HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

einpoklum

4,301 karma · joined August 24, 2016

https://eyalroz.github.io/

Software developer, researcher (well, sometimes), semi-retired union organizer and potpourri political activist, sucker for roller-coasters, Anarchist :-)

submissionscomments
einpoklum··on Claude reveals ECDSA curve origins
> This happens in academia all the time. You read a ton of papers, chat with tons of people about tons of ideas. > > Later you come up some idea, you do the experiment, write the paper, search for relevant citations when you write the intro.

And your search includes papers mentioning the various ideas you heard about from those other people. They almost always publish _something_ about it, and in the rare cases they do not, you put them in the "thanks" section, describing which ideas they contributed to (or in very rare cases, cite an unpublished result/claim as "personal communication" from an author).

I was in academic for a number of years (Theoretical Comp Sci, then DB management systems architecture), and what I just described seems to have been the practice. It is of course possible that people neglected to cite the sources of some of their ideas, but not that I know of. The worst I could say is that several authors' work exhibited a similar approach and a person preferred to cite one of them rather than another.

einpoklum··on Intuitive concurrent programming in any language
Title is incorrect of course, it is: "Intuitive concurrent programming in a separate language than the one you use for the actual work"

... which is not to say it's irrelevant, but still: Why is it worthwhile to have a separate language for this, rather than some library with bindings in various languages?

einpoklum··on Wayland desktop for Linux with skeuomorphic design
I am skeptical that a transition from X to Wayland is actually merited.

As for the post / the repo itself, this analysis:

https://www.salahadawi.com/hacker-news-ai-detector/50103338

suggests it is LLM-generated. Not sure what to make of it.

einpoklum··on Containment and monitoring failures are to blame for AI hacking reports: experts
I didn't say it was better, just that there was no "roguness" nor some magical surprise.
einpoklum··on Things to know when you get cancer
I broke my leg at the edge of the Fibula bone. 4 Orthopedic specialists gave me 3.5 different opinions with different and conflicting recommendations for treatment.

So, unless the first two opinions are completely identical - yeah, definitely get the third. Better to go for people with slightly different specializations if relevant.

einpoklum··on Things to know when you get cancer
Maybe change the title to mention it's about the US.

Also...

> You may need to push for comprehensive genetic testing.

Why?Cancer is not a condition that develops due to genes you inerited, after all, right? And also - for any cancer? Just some of them?

einpoklum··on Containment and monitoring failures are to blame for AI hacking reports: experts
The thing is, nothing "rogue" happened. It's more like: Frontier Lab: "Hey agent, try a bunch of network-related commands and actions to try and get access to server XYZ" Agent: Does that. Frontier Lab: 8-|
einpoklum··on Containment and monitoring failures are to blame for AI hacking reports: experts
They're skipping security basics, but they're not skipping PR basics. :-\
einpoklum··on Iosevka is an open-source, sans-serif and slab-serif monospace font
This set of fonts takes up 2.4 GB (yes, that's Giga, not Mega) bytes when you download the release. Each one is over 50 MB in size.
einpoklum··on Iosevka is an open-source, sans-serif and slab-serif monospace font
What does that setting do?
einpoklum··on Iosevka is an open-source, sans-serif and slab-serif monospace font
I guess I somehow skipped that, sorry T_T

But let's look at the font used here on HN. Sure, it's monospace, but it's not particularly thin. Mx ... the x-height is pretty close the em-width. So that quote should probably read "for our idea of typical serif fonts".

einpoklum··on Iosevka is an open-source, sans-serif and slab-serif monospace font
Yes. That is, for a given x-height, the width of an 'M' half of what it "should" be for that x-height. According to this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Em_(typography)

it seems the width of an M should be exactly equal to the x-height in points (IIUC).

einpoklum··on Iosevka is an open-source, sans-serif and slab-serif, monospace font
What does it mean for a font (or typeface) to be "quasi‑proportional"?

Also, whoever said that fonts intended for a terminal need to be narrower? Some terminals have narrower chars, some wider. And terminal emulators often allow for multiple char aspect ratios - e.g. via bitmap fonts of different aspect ratio.

Anyway, the typeface looks interesting, but I would have liked for the creators to compare and contrast it with existing (and popular) monospace / terminal-oriented typefaces.

einpoklum··on Hittite royal archive found in Turkey
I try to avoid conversion with LLMs. But I suppose they can always crawl my HN comments.
einpoklum··on Hittite royal archive found in Turkey
What artifacts are we leaving which will allow people in 3400 years to get a glimpse of daily events in our lives?

Digital information and toner/ink on paper will not last nearly that long.

Maybe humans of this age should be curating some etching on stone or even more durable materials, to record some of our history for posterity?

einpoklum··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI contributions
> I’ve mentored juniors and the common trait is that they rush to code without understanding, then they spend days trying to fix things.

As a senior (of sorts), even though I don't quite rush to code, I often find myself starting to code something 'naively', while my understanding is lacking (typically in a tangled, inconsistent and poorly documented codebase). But what probably sets me apart from juniors is how I handle getting stuck, or rather what it means for me to try to "fix things". I spend time thinking about what I've discovered that has gotten me stuck, what I must take into account, and how I should alter my approach (or refactor the existing code to be more accommodating).

Sometimes I manage to formulate ideas apriori that reduce the frequency of my getting stuck, and/or the extent to which I need to backtrack. But - not always.

einpoklum··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI contributions
> We’ve just moved the bottleneck from during writing the code to reviewing

Ah, that's only true if whoever is in charge is willing to _have_ a bottleneck in reviewing. In some software development groups, there is a strong pressure for reviews to pass, i.e. expectation that reviewers approve; and the notion of veto is not common, so that if some reviewer objects, the implementing developer can find others who would be willing to accept, bypassing the objections. Also, few people are willing to conduct long reviews of a lot of code, and even less people are willing to read multiple comments in a long review of a lot of code.

Now, in some projects, there are only one or two "owners" or "marshals" for some areas of the code, so they can apply a strict standard if they want to, but - their time is limited, meaning that long LLM vibe-pull-requests are likely to either be ignored for a long time or rejected off-hand.

I have many years of the experience of of raising concerns, criticism and objections in reviews

einpoklum··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI contributions
> The maintainer can then paste them in to an AI tool themselves and go back and forth faster than they could comment feedback to you and wait for changes.

My experience is that maintainers cannot do this. Or rather, that it is useless.

einpoklum··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
> the bottleneck is no longer writing code

The bottleneck has never been the writing of the code. It's all the rest that takes the majority of the time. Of course, it is often the writing which lets you expand your understanding or your awareness of challenges and pitfalls, which then puts you back on the drawing board.

einpoklum··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
Hasn't Israel repealed its signature at some point?
einpoklum··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> "President Trump will never allow the International Criminal Court to prosecute Americans"

... but his government does support the ICC prosecuting Russians, on behalf of Ukraine, even though none of the two states is a party to the Rome statute / member of the court.

einpoklum··on Show HN: Let your AI agents paint big arrows, boxes and text on your screen
More LLM-authored items about LLM slop.
einpoklum··on Meta and Microsoft take steps to reduce employee usage of Claude AI
That's a good start. Now they just need to limit use of CoPilot, OpenAI and MetaAI and they'll really be getting somewhere.
einpoklum··on Opus 5.5 agents discover two room-temperature magnetic semiconductor candidates
I would image it's the data the researchers fed the agents and in which a discovery was likely. Especially since it's "candidates", so it's not like a proper discovery.
einpoklum··on Opus 5.5 agents discover two room-temperature magnetic semiconductor candidates
This should probably read: "Researchers discover two room-temperature magnetic semiconductor candidates. They used Opus 5.5 agents to perform some checks."
einpoklum··on Getting the most out of Opus 5.5 in Claude and Claude Code
So, another anecdotal website extolling LLMs, written - so it seems [1] by an LLM. Typical far for HN these days I suppose.

[1] : https://www.salahadawi.com/hacker-news-ai-detector/49946567

einpoklum··on Reasons I didn't become an EMT, ranked
I like it when people are willing (and capable, writing-wise) to wear their hearts on their sleeve like that.

Also, I bet the whole blog post's worth would flash through the author's mind within all of 10 seconds whenever they were reminded of the possibility of taking the course. It takes both patience and self-discipline to put it all on paper like that.

Great blog post! Makes me want to take an EMT course :-)

einpoklum··on Commit description as a thinking tool
> Now we are in the era of agentic coding, where everything from code to commit descriptions is written by AI.

No, we are not. Sure, there is a lot of slop-coding/vibe-coding going on, but not much of it in serious code. In my experience and to my knowledge.

Of course, I encounter the opposite problem with humans: They often don't bother to write proper commit messages; and many tend to squash them in favor of giant single-commits which just say "Implemented feature #123".

einpoklum··on DraftKings Is Using AI to Behaviorally Target Chronic Gamblers
You're treating the state as "we". It certainly claims to be "us", but that claim is - for most world states - partially, or entirely, invalid.

Also, on a semi-related note - there is the legality of gambling, the legality of running a gambling operation, and the legality of doing so for pecuniary gain, and it is possible for just part of these three to be illegal.

einpoklum··on DraftKings Is Using AI to Behaviorally Target Chronic Gamblers
Ah, another boon of LLMs for mankind. Up there with the use of the 'Lavender' LLM to produce targets for the Israeli military to bomb in Gaza:

https://www.972mag.com/lavender-ai-israeli-army-gaza/

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →