1,436 karma · joined December 16, 2013
So we are supposed to give up on accuracy now? At least with humans (assuming good actors) I can assume an effort for accuracy and correctness. And I can build trust based on some resume and on former interaction.
With LLMs, this is more like a coin-flip with each prompt. And since the models are updated constantly, its hard to build some sort of resume. In the meantime, people - especially casual users - might just trust outputs, because its convenient. A single digit error is harder to find. The costs of validating outputs increases with increased accuracy of LLMs. And casual users tend to skip validation because "its a computer and computers are correct".
I fear an overall decrease in quality wherever LLMs are included. And any productivity gains are eaten by that.
Guess, people want to focus on this particular scenario. Does it confirm biases? How strong is the influence of Science Fiction in this urge to discuss this scenario and infer some sort of intelligence?
This AI bubble is far worse than the Blockchain hype.
Its not yet clear whether productivity gains are real and whether the gains are eaten by a decline in overall quality.
A lot of companies made Copilot available to their workforce. I doubt that the majority of users understand what a statistical model means. The casual, technically inexperienced user just assumes that a computer answer is always right.
The accuracy problem won't just go away. Increasing accuracy is only getting more expensive. This sets the limits for useful applications. And casual users might not even care and use LLMs anyway, without reasonable result verification. I fear a future where overall quality is reduced. Not sure how many people / companies would accept that. And AI companies are getting too big to fail. Apparently, the US administration does not seem to care when they use LLMs to define tariff policy....
Employers might believe that not using AI puts them and their investments at a disadvantage, while ignoring the overall quality issues.
Unless there are more fundamental changes in the technology, I only see us in the biggest bubble of the modern world.
This entire concept of city-states exists on a premise of peaceful coexistence and cooperation. Given our history, this is pure fiction. (And then these people shit on Communism.)
It was a time of wars and economic turmoil.
We expect computers to be right. Its a trust problem. Average users will simply trust the results of LLMs and move on without proper validation. And the way the LLMs are trained to mimic human interaction is not helping either. This will reduce overall quality in society.
Its a different thing to work with another human, because there is intention. A human wants to be correct or to mislead me. I am considering this without even thinking about it.
And I don't expect expert models to improve things, unless the problem space is really simple (like checking eggs for anomalies).
Its a different thing to sell Trump that LLMs should take over crucial decisions within a government than just using it for some prototyping, code completion at work or to create cat pictures at home.
Take Copilot for example. It was rolled out in different companies, I worked with. Aside of warnings and maybe trainings, I doubt the companies are really able to measure the impact that has. Students are already using the technology to do homework. Schools and universities are sending mixed signals about the results. And then those students enter the workforce with Copilot enabled by default.
At least with companies, its the "free market" that will regulate (unless some company is too big to fail...)
Now ask yourself why AI companies don't want to be regulated or scrutinized.
So many companies (users and providers) jump on the AI hype train because of FOMO. The end result might be just as destructive as this mythical "AGI".
Edit: I am not saying to not use the technology. I am just on the side of caution and constant validation. The technology has to serve society. But I fear this hype (and ideology) has it the other way around. Musk isn't destroying the US government for no reason...
That $9B is just a number. Whether it is reasonable or not can only be determined by looking into the details:
- What accounts as overhead?
- What were decisions that lead to that overhead?
- Were there alternatives that would have costs less?
- Why and how were those decisions made?
- Can we learn for future decisions?
- Was there actual fraud?
- When there was fraud, why wasn't it referred to DOJ to be investigated properly?
"Administrative overhead" is not bad by itself. Outside government, its simply called "Operating Expense" and "Cost of Revenue" (not a concern of government luckily). I am certain, if you look into SpaceX' or Tesla's expenses, you would find fraud too.
Because Musk and his brainwashed followers can claim stuff on Twitter doesn't make it true. And it certainly MUST NOT be basis to destroy Democracy and democratic processes.
Don't get me wrong. There is certainly fraud and overpayment happening in government operations. But just looking at receipts is not the smoking gun. If anyone suspects fraud, there are a processes. Inspectors Generals are (were) one way to have those payments investigated, DOJ and FBI would be another step. The IGs were fired last week. I wonder why...
Also, this "Ian Miles Cheong" guy is literally a Kremlin operative - really someone worth blocking. So that's important to know about his motivations to sow doubt in US Democracy.
- Calling payments to non-profit organizations fraudulent on a whim.
- The sweeping condemnation of what USAID was doing.
- His call for a blanket drop of regulations.
Either he knows better or he is totally lost in his sauce. Hard to say what's worse for where he is right now.
I believe, he does not care. He only cares about his conception of the world and how AI and Mars are more important than those tiny tiny human problems. Society has to serve him and his god complex. He was told to find his subsidies and tax cuts by himself. That's what he is doing.
Musk is neither competent nor efficient. He looks at line items and makes stuff up. He destroys a hundred useful things to destroy a bad one. Details don't matter to him. Its the same con man mentality that feeds off the works of his workforce. People who think he is a genius are gullible.
Regenerative energy already surpassed all other means of energy production in 2024: https://www.bdew.de/media/documents/2024_12_18_Die_Energieve...
Battery prices are declining for some time now: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-12-10/electric-...
And even larger storage capabilities are built: https://standort-sachsen.de/de/aktuelles/news/detail/n1474-g...
(I am actually working for a grid operator)
(Worked well throughout Trump's campaign. They even printed it on red caps.)