HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ejstronge

1,639 karma · joined December 17, 2012

Github: https://github.com/plantprelude
submissionscomments
ejstronge··on Why doctors in America earn so much
Do you have evidence of this lobbying? It does not stand to reason, since care provided by residents is quite cheap to hospitals from the perspective of labor.

Hospitals have no obligation to hire the residents they produce, so an optimal behavior would seem to be training many residents and not hiring them.

ejstronge··on Why doctors in America earn so much
You are precisely correct - this is not an AMA issue. Funding for this is tied to Medicare/Medicaid and thus a political issue that does not turn based on what the AMA may request. In searching for the below table, it seems that there is some effort to use funds from other sources to pay for targeted slots[1]

1. https://www.aha.org/news/headline/2023-07-27-hhs-awards-15-g...

Here's a breakdown for funding for one year in the recent past: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK248024/table/tab_3-1/?...

ejstronge··on 300K Damage from Airbnb Guest
Landlord property insurance policies do actually cover loss of rents - maybe the OP’s policy doesn’t have a landlord endorsement
ejstronge··on Trucking startup Convoy closes operations with no buyer
If one searches Reddit, there are brokers who will pass on wholesale car shipping prices which are lower than the prices of those one may find on Google.
ejstronge··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
Yes, we are on the same page the whole way.

My question is why we need to reframe our extant system as a 'land value tax.' This proposition suggests that we should give concessions to developers in areas where there is a need for more development. But this already happens!

I guess I don't know why we should avoid taxing the value of revenue-generating assets if they are fixed. Buying a truck for a landscaping business is an taxable purchase. Why should this be different when the asset is fixed?

ejstronge··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
Your argument ignores that changes to neighbors' property would then cause an increased burden to a land owner. This would not seem to be an improvement for freedom
ejstronge··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
> Land with a skyscraper already on it and land next to a skyscraper have related but not equal market values.

I agree! But in appraisals that I have seen, there is an effort to assess the highest and best use of a parcel as well as a break-out of the value of the land associated with a parcel.

If the highest and best use of a parcel is a skyscraper, a sale of the parcel should occur near the valuation of skyscrapers in that area. If there is no skyscraper on the parcel, the sale should occur near the valuation of land that has the possibility to be turned into a skyscraper.

> Switching from a tax on market value to a tax on land value rewards the the owner who developed their land and punishes the owner who didn't.

I agree that the owner who built the skyscraper is being penalized (but also, the owner would not have created a sksyscraper if the underwriting did not show the endeavor would be profitable).

However, both land owners are being taxed on land value; one is also being taxed on the improvements on the land. It would seem that the land value of both parcels should be the same.

ejstronge··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
> Property tax: The more of your money you invest into your property, the more you pay for taxes (punishing investment)

> Land value tax: Your tax is unchanged on how much you invest in your properties. A rundown parking lot pays the same amount of tax as the next door skyscraper (encouraging development of limited, high value land, and punishing lazy speculation).

The problem with this analysis of a land value tax is that the value of the lot next to the skyscraper depends on the improvements of the skyscraper lot. This is in addition to the 'inherent' value of being downtown.

If we assume the skyscraper is the highest and best use of the land, it would then appear that both the skyscraper land owner and the parking lot land owner are being charged based on the investments made on the skyscraper lot.

Now, how are market prices determined? Overall, investors and lenders wish to maximize a return on investment. Indeed, property appraisals explicitly consider the highest and best use of a property in determining its market value.

So I am unclear how the explicit taxation of land value and improvement value that exists currently causes differences in behavior from the land value tax system you outlined.

ejstronge··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
Perhaps someone who has thought about this more can explain how a 'land value tax' differs from existing property tax regimes that explicitly examine the value of improvements and the value of land...

This Detroit case is interesting because there are different rates of taxation on the land, but the difference in rate could also be obtained by increasing the land component of a parcel's value.

ejstronge··on D.C.'s ban on cashless businesses takes effect
It’s not absurd - the bank has to spend money to move depositors’ cash. This is a standard part of a commercial banking relationship
ejstronge··on Redfin Is Leaving the National Association of Realtors
I did read the post.

There is no monopoly because there is no single 'MLS'

ejstronge··on Redfin Is Leaving the National Association of Realtors
I don't think 'MLS' is a single entity - instead different areas have their own MLS, and these are interconnected based on contracts. Thus, there isn't a monopoly to disrupt in the first place.
ejstronge··on FCC aims to reinstate net neutrality after us Democrats gain control of panel
ISPs are offering 'Netflix-included' or discounted Disney+ plans. I don't know how they account for downloads from these services but the bundling is definitely happening.
ejstronge··on Gene-Engineered Mouth Bacteria
The added genetic factors may, themselves, be exogenous and genetically modified. Your argument does make sense over thousands of years, however.
ejstronge··on Show HN: ChatGPT for Med-School and Healthcare
> If this tool is even 1% lower on average, it's already better than a human.

Without diving into the source data behind the 'wiendlaw.com' article (are they authoritative sources? Can we believe their interpretation of a biomedical journal article?), it is facile and likely wrong to conclude, a priori, that one distribution of errors (that of humans) is indistinguishable from another distribution of errors (your hypothetical LLM with '1% lower on average' errors).

It is often said that 50% of biomedical facts are wrong. The trouble, of course, is determining which half of the textbook to disregard. While this trope is cute and also incorrect, it is difficult to imagine how an LLM trained on past knowledge will be able to create the new knowledge required to establish new facts

ejstronge··on We are retroactively dropping the iPhone’s repairability score
> , but it's important to realize that just because a specific security measure could not prevent what happened to you, that doesn't mean it's wholly ineffectual or not worth having.

I think you are missing the point of the comment. The GP says that Apple should allow parts to be unpaired to allow re-use of components; this example suggests that there is utility to keeping the existing security system.

ejstronge··on We are retroactively dropping the iPhone’s repairability score
> (If anyone at Apple is reading this: ffs, allow the legitimate owner of a device to "unpair" all components in their phone in iCloud so that legitimate second-hand shops can strip a broken device at least for its parts)

I was robbed at gunpoint (but not in a 'problematic' part of town) and the thief outlined all the steps he needed me to take to remove my phone from Find My and from iCloud. I think a lot of these mitigation measures could make sense but there's no perfect solution.

ejstronge··on Japan's Hometown Tax (2018)
Curiously, rural regions of the US have a fair amount of power due to how electoral seats are distributed. I'm not sure if this is also true in Canada, so it is possible that the GP's situation differs from your own experiences.
ejstronge··on Fixing the housing crisis is not rocket science. “Minneapolis has been build
Your and a sibling comment want to make the Floyd protests into an explanation for the data… while the trend both existed before the event and has continued afterwards
ejstronge··on Apple ditches the Lightning connector in favor of USB-C after 11 years
> So long and sooner into the landfill for a thermal camera, higher end environmental noise monitoring microphone, decent wrap around game controller pad, etc, and repurchasing all of the above. This must be some of that "reducing ewaste" and "saving us money" thing I've heard so much about on HN. Yay.

These peripherals had lightning ports in them? You can't use a USB-C - Lightning cable and continue using them??

ejstronge··on The complete sequence of a human Y chromosome
> That is if we transfer the DNA to an advanced alien civilization - would they be able to make a human.

You'd need a cell to start the process, with the various nucleic acids distributed correctly and proteins/energy with which to create further proteins using the information encoded by the DNA. Thus the civilization would need information about cells and a set of building blocks before being able to use the DNA.

ejstronge··on I am dying of squamous cell carcinoma, and potential treatments are out of reach
> The FDA could work with sponsors to come up with a range of risk profiles and expand access.

They indeed do this and have various avenues for treatments to be approved on expedited timelines.

ejstronge··on Terrible real estate agent photographs
Write-off is an accounting term that would seem not to have a meaning outside of taxes.
ejstronge··on A Student-Loan Payment Pause Led Borrowers to Take on More Debt
At the same time, your education costs were much lower - through no fault of your own. Why should younger borrowers be penalized for market forces they did not contribute to?
ejstronge··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
> to take computer science as an example: a 4 years bachelor degree only has about 500 hours of classroom instruction in comp sci subjects.

> a 9-5 vocational training program can provide 480 hours of classroom instruction in 3 months.

This feels like a disingenuous response - are you suggesting that solely 500 hours of a computer science degree confers utility to a graduate? Even then, 500 hours taken consecutively can hardly be compared to 500 hours spent over multiple years, interspersed with hands-on projects and internships.

ejstronge··on Sam Bankman-Fried Is Charged with Foreign Bribery
Can anyone comment on how necessary this sort of behavior might be to operate in middle economies / developing economies?
ejstronge··on Post-GPT Computing
Yes, this happened using GPT-4 and a coding plugin:

https://twitter.com/gdb/status/1638971232443076609

ejstronge··on “Healthy obesity” doesn’t exist. It is unequivocally bad for you
Supposedly the 10,000 calorie diet of Michael Phelps is marketing vs factual. I don’t have a source for this (but happy to search if requested) but humans are not likely to be able to absorb 10,000 calories daily; I believe the maximum is a function of one’s basal metabolism but would lie around 6,500 calories for an elite athlete.
ejstronge··on FDIC Takes over Silicon Valley Bank
Yes, but the OP comment conflated assets (cash and securities as you mention) with FDIC insurance which only concerns liabilities due to depositors who qualify for FDIC insurance.
ejstronge··on FDIC Takes over Silicon Valley Bank
> When someone opens a bank account and makes a cash deposit, he/she surrenders the legal title to the cash, and it becomes an asset of the bank.

I think this is Google's first hit when one searches this, but I do not believe this is correct. Here is a source saying the opposite, as an example.

A liability, in general terms, is something owed to another (e.g., a deposit)

https://courses.lumenlearning.com/wm-macroeconomics/chapter/...

And another more reputable source:

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/bank-deposits.asp

← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →