HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elangoc

197 karma · joined June 29, 2011

submissionscomments
elangoc··on Not Having A Real Job
Both travel and volunteering have to do with connecting with other people in the most quintessential ways.

Volunteering has to do with helping people in need. When you do that, you realize the scope of how much fellow humans are in need. As social creatures, we humans can't but feel humbled and feel that there is still something meaningful worth striving for -- a sense of purpose. Given that we are all tech people here, it's safe to assume that daily needs and 'creature comforts' are so easily secured that we easily don't feel that sense of purpose as it pertains to ourselves. Volunteering connects with others who inherently have a sense of purpose, since they struggle, and the act of volunteering is an act of committing yourself to the purpose of helping fellow humans in need.

Traveling opens your mind to new people and new cultures. And those ideas can get you to re-think what you believe, and you can grow as a person. You can also learn things to make the world around you better. What is the culture around education in Finland, and why is their ed. system so good? If Americans increasing want public transit, what does European rail transit have to each us? How could Bus Rapid Transit pioneered in S. America be even better? How can some cultures in Africa and India be a peek into human history 4000 years ago? Does South India's plant-based cuisines have the tastiest answer to current diet and environment movements in the US?

We tech people & entrepreneurs are taught to build things that people want, so talk to users to find out what they want. We are also taught to leverage other experiences and ideas to inspire solutions to our problems at hand. It should be obvious, now, that both of those ideas are directly related to volunteering and traveling, respectively.

elangoc··on A farewell to bioinformatics (2012)
Hrrm, I was in a genetics research lab myself and got annoyed at the inefficiencies myself. In particular, I got frustrating to write & use in-house scripts to run pipelines for compute clusters and then not know what the state of the execution is, where the files are, etc. It's sort of a meta-problem, but I decided to do a startup based on writing good software w/ a good UI to make the problem better (problem = running, monitoring, managing pipelines on clusters that have job schedulers like Grid Engine): http://www.palmyrasoftware.com/workflowcommander/

Maybe it's still in the early going, but I do see how it's going to be real difficult making a living doing this. OTOH, companies like CLC Bio seem like they're doing well for themselves...

elangoc··on Amazon Career Choice Program
Hmm, never heard of College of Albermarle. I don't disbelieve you -- most survey courses get taught in the 50-300 person seater rooms at UNC-CH. I just don't recall grad students teaching most of my courses, even the survey courses, whether they were in CS or Math (my majors) or the graduation requirements from social sciences, philosophy, etc. I had only one course taught by a grad student -- graphics. Which was your major at UNC-CH?
elangoc··on Sanskrit As A Language Of Science
minor correction, for the record: Max Müller did a lot of research into 'Aryan' culture via Sanskrit. Müller attempted to learn more about the origins of European religion and culture by reconstructing proto-Indo European language. Müller was opposed to Darwinism applied to people, and was very opposed to people using the term Aryan for racist purposes. He believed the shared history of different races should show we're all the same. The term 'Aryan' was coined for Western ears slightly before Müller. Robert Caldwell was the first one who came up with the term 'Dravidian' following his research into the matter. Prior to Caldwell, Dravidian languages and cultures were seen entirely through the lens of Sanskrit, although even today, as I mentioned before, this Sanskritic perspective to explain more than the evidence supports is kept alive by some people & interests.

On an interesting side note, according to Wikipedia, Müller also said, "the blackest Hindus represent an earlier stage of Aryan speech and thought than the fairest Scandinavians". That statement is true, even though Müller was not alive when the IVC was discovered -- swastika symbol clay seals have been found in the IVC, meaning that the swastika predates anything 'Aryan'. And there's similar irony with the red-and-black colors, in case you're wondering.

elangoc··on Sanskrit As A Language Of Science
Yes, some people propose that maybe the IVC writing isn't language at all. See this talk by one of the authors of a paper showing that it is, indeed, writing of a language: http://www.tedxsmu.org/events/tedxsmu-tuesday-7-5-11/ He used machine learning and the idea of entropy to prove his point, but as he says in the video, it's shocking how he got more menacing feedback -- to the level of death threats -- from saying that "the writing is a language" than saying "the language is Dravidian".

And as far as the Heras/Parpola Dravidian-based deciphering briefly mentioned in the talk, a much more expanded (and more compelling) deciphering is provided in the paper I linked above, called "The Indus Fish Swam in the Great Bath" by Iravatham Mahadevan. Ira. Mahadevan and Asko Parola are the the top 2 scholars of the IVC script. The paper also indicates several parallels to its other contemporary civilizations. That paper comes from the official website of the scholars involved in excavating and interpreting IVC sites.

elangoc··on Sanskrit As A Language Of Science
The Indus Valley Civilization is the indigenous civilization in the region of India, Pakistan, and parts of Afghanistan and Iran. It traded with Ancient Egypt, Sumeria, Greece, and Rome. For its time, it was the largest ancient civilization, and it was highly impressive (they had uniform brick buildings, perpendicular grid streets, covered sewers, a base-10 system of standardized weights, etc. : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilization#Matur...) The IVC collapsed before Greece and Rome reached their peaks, but in the absence of more research, we can only surmise its legacy (e.g., Indian sarees, white waistcloths and sandals may have been mimicked as togas). I think more research needs to be done to flesh out all of the loose ends of inquiry, and lots of interesting research is happening currently. I'm sure more facts will continue to emerge about the IVC that shift our understanding of the world's history.

The prevailing theory is that the IVC bequeathed culture (religion, customs, knowledge, architecture, etc.) to all parts of the region. It is believed that the IVC inhabitants spread east and southwards to fill all parts of India. The IVC collapsed (1900 BCE), and around 1000 years afterwards (1000 BCE), a branch of proto-Indo European language speakers is believed to have moved south from the Caucuses into Iran/India. The language they spoke (Sanskrit) is believed to have taken on influences by the indigenous language taken hold in the northern parts of India, but considering their much fewer numbers and nomadic lifestyle at the time of their arrival, their genetic contribution is thought to be minimal. After the British colonial scholar Robert Caldwell, a scholar in Sanskrit, noticed the difference between the languages of north India (Indo-European > Sanskrit derived) and southern India (a distinct language family, of which Tamil has the least influence of Sanskrit), he used the term "Aryan" to describe the northern languages and "Dravidian" to describe the southern languages. (side note: Caldwell was opposed to and upset with attempts by people to project the terms Aryan and Dravidian for the purposes of racism and hegemony; he personally believed in the opposite) It is also believed that at the time of arrival of the Sanskrit speakers to India from the north, the existing indigenous culture (i.e., of the people from IVC) heavily influenced that of the arriving people. Among the first writings in Sanskrit (Veda scriptures), the earliest shows the most indigenous influence (e.g., water-based imagery), and the later Veda writings show a diminishing influence towards a more Sanskritic one (e.g., fire-based imagery). In light of all of this, scholars say that pretty much the only evidence we have that "Aryans", as a distinct group, existed is their language.

It is widely believed that the language of the IVC is most closely related to Dravidian languages, and the best attempts to decipher their writing comes from using Tamil as the starting point. An interesting, recent paper from last year puts forward a very compelling advancement in interpreting the script, and in the process, it further fleshes out the relationship between IVC, the culture of Indian peoples, Sanskrit writings and Dravidian languages:

http://harappa.drupalgardens.com/content/indus-fish-swam-gre...

Because of Caldwell's linguistic analysis and the convenient role it played in political maneuvering for accruing power in British colonial India (by the British, and by people in India regionally and caste-wise), the division along "Aryan"/"Dravidian" lines became seen as a racial one. (If there is a difference genetically today, it may be from the occasional invasion by empires from the Middle East in the north of India over the millennia, from which the south was largely insulated by the Deccan Plateau). As the idea of this racial divide survives while India is now divided into states based on language (and the southern states are a minority), and given the roughly 90/10 split of Hindus and Muslims, chauvinism along religious, geographic, and linguistic lines has gradually coalesced. It's to the point where some Indians want to portray the IVC as Sanskritic/Aryan (and Sanskrit-speakers as the originators of Hinduism because the oldest known Hindu writings are in Sanskrit), even if they have to blatantly distort facts: http://safarmer.com/frontline/horseplay.pdf But more commonly, you'll find resistance among such people from accepting a proto-Dravidian language hypothesis of the IVC in favor of interpreting the IVC in a Sanskritic light: http://www.sanskrit.org/www/Hindu%20Primer/induscivilization...

elangoc··on Changing Your LinkedIn Password Still May Not Have Kept Your Account Safe
That's a good point. I'll keep that in mind.

I'm still hesitant to feel like it explains everything -- in 2007, LinkedIn still didn't seem that ubiquitous (after all, FB was then just opening itself up to non-college students, and LinkedIn's target demog. was still the pre-internet generation). So there weren't a whole lot of people I knew on the site to begin with, and there wasn't anybody I knew in common on LinkedIn connecting me to at least 2 of the vaguely familiar people I knew. And those 2 people started getting suggested to me by the site at the same time -- it seems too coincidental that these people (and others) provided their email contacts to LinkedIn at exactly the same time.

One good takeaway is, despite it taking me 5 more years to learn my lesson, and the really hard way :-(, I'm now using KeePass and creating difficult, unique passwords for each site, and using git to sync across computers. That helps.

elangoc··on Changing Your LinkedIn Password Still May Not Have Kept Your Account Safe
Although that might seem like a likely explanation, LinkedIn wasn't putting the "import email contacts" widget in your face like they do, now.

Of the two people I vividly remember as only vaguely familiar suggested people, neither was in my Gmail address book. I had a 2-sent-emails thread with one person, and no direct emails with the other. In 2007, Gmail might have already been auto-collecting contact info of people you email directly, but that can't explain the 2nd person.

elangoc··on Changing Your LinkedIn Password Still May Not Have Kept Your Account Safe
I'm fairly certain that LinkedIn has little or no regard for user privacy and security. Why do I say this? Even as early as 2007, I noticed that LinkedIn displayed 3 rotating links to people I might be 'interested' in connecting with. And among names of people I knew well, one or two names repeatedly popped up that were vaguely familiar, but they were neither friends nor friends of friends (as far as I knew). Then it dawned on me -- one of those vaguely familiar names is a person living halfway around the world whom I've never met except for the email inquiry he made to a mailing list and his followup to my response. The only way LinkedIn (or any real person) could think that we had any sort of affinity is if they read that singular email thread in my email. Yes, my email+password combo for LinkedIn was my email+password combo for my email.

So LinkedIn was snooping in my email, for which they would needed to have saved my password in plaintext (or equivalent) somewhere.

If I needed further proof, after my changing my email addr that I used to login to LinkedIn, I stopped getting those invasive people suggestions. I then googled (again, back in 2007) about LinkedIn and snooping in people's email accounts, and an interview with the CEO had a brief mention of it, where the CEO flatly denied any sort of privacy breach.

I think we need to supersede the commentary of LinkedIn's incompetent handling of security and privacy (which they spectacularly proved already) with the idea that not only do they not give a flip, but they want to keep it that way for their own maximum benefit.

elangoc··on Review: Clojure Programming
I'm slowly working my way through the book in order to write a review, myself. I've only gotten through the Chapter 1-Down the Rabbit Hole, but already, I'm pretty happy with how the book is fairly gradual and walks you through what it's presenting to you.
elangoc··on What good is experience?
I wonder about this style of thinking. In particular, the distinction between making it work and making it right.

I've read The Pragmatic Programmer, and early-on, it mentions "broken windows" principle -- fix errors as soon as you notice them, or else they'll get more difficult for you to fix as time goes by. And like broken windows are like a green-light for a neighborhood to decline, unfixed hacks similarly invite poor quality code.

In practice, do "working" and "working well" end up being sort of the same as suggested by the broken windows principle? Or Is "make it work" refer to making a quick prototype, and "make it right" refer to filling out substantial functionality?

elangoc··on The Newbie’s Guide to Learning Clojure
... aaand we're back, with more RAM. Thanks, great suggestions, will try them out!
elangoc··on The Newbie’s Guide to Learning Clojure
In my life, I've learned and used the following languages, in this order: Logo, Basic, Pascal, C++, Java, Python, Ruby, Clojure. Each time that I learned the next language, I thought it was a great improvement on the previous, and I wondered what I had been spending my life doing with the previous language.

My experience is that with Clojure is a testament to pretty much everything in "Beating the Averages" (http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html) It's hard to know for sure, but I have a feeling that I will end up using Clojure far much longer than the rest of those languages, combined.

If you are contemplating learning a language for one-off commands and sysadmin scripts, then I kind of prefer Ruby over Python and Perl for expressiveness and readability. Most Rubyists are of the Rails persuasion, but I still have never learned Rails.

elangoc··on The Newbie’s Guide to Learning Clojure
hehe. the load time is more like the stunned expression you get when you realize people picked up on something you said. :-P (I should have an upgraded amt of RAM in a matter of minutes, and hopefully it'll be up again.)

Interesting recommendation for Java programmers. I've noticed a lot of people smiling instinctively when they see the Seesaw project. Seesaw turns Java Swing GUI programming from a horror into a pleasure, so that's another idea.

About Seesaw, the GUI for the Clojure namespace browser was whipped up by Frank in the course of 1 week (https://github.com/franks42/clj-ns-browser). As Frank puts it, it's a testament to Seesaw, since he had no real experience in Java Swing, and he got the GUI working from the couple of hours a night he got each day after he put his kids to sleep in that one week.

elangoc··on The Newbie’s Guide to Learning Clojure
Sorry for the site loading so slow. I submitted this a week ago and thought it got ignored into Hacker News oblivion. Back then, I added a cache plugin, but I guess that's not enough.

I woke up this morning surprised to see it's on the front page a.t.m. I'm going to troublehshoot right now.

I also have the dirt-cheap lowest VPS option on Rackspace -- is that the problem? If anybody has immediate ideas on how to make my server not be so slow, pass them along (and thanks for reading!)

elangoc··on Why Reddit switched to Python (2005)
I came back to this PG essay on identity a couple of days ago. The essay discusses the points you mentioned and a compelling explanation for them: http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html
elangoc··on Why Reddit switched to Python (2005)
If there are any Lispers who lament the Lisp Curse, or some idiosyncracies of your favorite dialect of Lisp, and you have an open mind to give something new a shot, consider checking out Clojure.

I don't want to become one of those diehard __-advocates, but I'm pretty impressed with Clojure. Speaking from experience, I think it solves quite a few of the pitfalls mentioned in the OP. I wrote up an extensive post on how to learn Clojure, and veteran Lispers can jump to the end and catch the links of Clojure for Lispers:

http://www.elangocheran.com/blog/2012/03/the-newbies-guide-l...

elangoc··on How does Y Combinator scale Y Combinator?
for those interested, a nice explanation of the correlation of words to value / weaseliness in real estate is covered in a chapter of the book Freakonomics.
elangoc··on Paul Graham, it’s time to put your money where your mouth is
geez, what is up with this spate of snide/cynical posts about PG and/or YC? it's not necessary the content. I mean, I love almost all of what PG says in his essays, but there are at times genuine questions and doubts (e.g., I've heard schlep as a verb more than a noun). Sometimes, these questions of a larger, fundamental discussion (e.g., copyrights & property). questioning is fine, and is necessary in order to attain greater understanding.

what I'm getting annoyed at is the tone I'm sensing -- it's sometimes downright sneering. i know it's been brought up very recently as well, and PG has said it's been happening gradually as the site has grown. i've read the essay on trolls, but this seems like it's something different. jealousy is also something that increases as a function of success, and when jealousy crosses a threshold, it morphs into resentment. just sayin'...

elangoc··on Paul Graham Keynote at PyCon
I can relate to where you're coming from. When it comes to the motivations that drive some engineers (vs. the ideals that ought to drive them), you'll probably like the recent talk by Bret Victor, "Inventing on Principle" (vimeo.com/36579366).

You (correctly) point out the places where capitalism comes up empty, if capitalism is our implicit system of determining the worth of goods and services. Apart from the environment (which seems unaddressed by the major economic models of the world) or the other causes you mentioned (unaddressed by capitalism, at least), I suppose it's fine to rely on the adequacy of money as some measure of the wealth we add to the world (http://www.paulgraham.com/wealth.html).

Even if the world is being eaten by software (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405311190348090457651...), the transition to using software happens fastest through startups, I'm coming to believe. I used to work in a life-sci research lab, and there's just an exponentially growing divide between data growth and the tech resources to handle it. NGOs and government can be disorganized and unmotivated, so working for them is not necessarily going to be the best use of your engineering talents. But that might be aside your point, i.e., try to work towards noble goals.

Lastly, and most importantly, I find the model of the Aravind Eye Hospital as truly inspiring and business-model bending: a company set up to help the ones who are the _most_ in need. The ones who can least afford it. And yet in the process, generate income that goes back to serving and accelerating the mission. _This_ is what "social enterprises" ought to be: http://infinitevisionaries.com

elangoc··on JavaScript at Khan Academy
I totally agree. My statement about simple vs. easy is actually a weak attempt at restating some of the principles that guided the design of Clojure (from Rich Hickey's talk "Simple Made Easy": http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy) JS is approaching big apps with Node.js, and Clojure is approaching browser JS with ClojureScript... not sure how it will play out.

What are the current trends in language use? Are people moving away from Python, Java, and C++? and if so, to what?

elangoc··on JavaScript at Khan Academy
I'll go out on a limb to disagree with most of the comments here and say that I think JS seems like it could be very effective. The Stanford CS101 course page has already implemented decently well: http://www.stanford.edu/class/cs101/

The language you learn doesn't have to be the language you end up using, or using to learn CS. It just has to get you off the ground.

So many people get turned off from a subject when they "don't get it" at first, so really, the challenge is providing the least painful intro to programming. Personally, my first languages were Logo and Pascal, and since I almost wrote off programming before Pascal as being too hard, I'm glad I saw C++/Java only afterwards.

One thing that enamors me about the JS approach is that it reminds me a little of Logo -- not only are the results are very immediate, but the visual output gives us a constant second avenue of insight into what we're doing. I'm sure many have seen Bret Victor's talk "Inventing on Principle" (http://vimeo.com/36579366), and he underscores the benefits of direct feedback to what we're doing. I have a friend taking CS10 at Berkeley this semester, and the Scratch-based environment also seems equally cool.

That being said, I don't use JS much (haven't really touched in it 10 years), but I believe it when people say it's (still) horribly irregular. In that regard, it might be on par with some other scripting languages (e.g., Ruby). So the distinction to be made here is that JS might be easy, but (as we can see) not simple.

As people who program seriously, we need simplicity in a language in order to build up large apps that we can easily reason about and don't bite us in every corner. (Note: simplicity in a language doesn't necessarily mean it's going to be easy at first.) But I wonder if we've been so used to programming that we forget how it can be hard to learn at first, and we're just ruling out the easy approach, which would exclude just what some newbies need.

elangoc··on Clojure Programming
I imagine that Clojure Programming is going to be similar to Programming Clojure, when compared to the others (for a better rundown of others books: http://stackoverflow.com/a/2928998) Or as this answer from SO puts it, Clojure Programming probably teaches the "what" of Clojure: http://stackoverflow.com/a/2579877

Personally, I think Joy of Clojure is the "why" as well as "how to do it well". I learned the "what" mostly from Practical Clojure, which was good enough, but definitely not great. Programming Clojure (2nd ed. for clj v 1.3, still in progress) seems organized like a conversation in chapters, i.e., you'd have to read it entirely sequentially, and targeted random-access might be difficult for first-time learners. I don't how Clojure Programming will be, but I hope it raises the bar for teaching newbies.

elangoc··on It’s The Age of Big Data: That’s Why Math Counts
When I was in middle school (MathCounts' age range), math came naturally to me, and I was a competitive kid. For that reason, Mathcounts was fun for me, and it helped that I consistently did well. If you've never been to a math competition, it's an interesting environment. It's one of the few places that I thought you could gain respect for "academic prowess". Imagine that, in America!

I think that the act of creating a space for an alternative way of thinking / being is a powerful one, and MathCounts does create that for math. I wonder if I would have done a math major in undergrad if it weren't for the combination of math competitions and advanced math classes from middle school through high school.

A lot of MathCounts alumni (who self-select to report their current activities) have gone on in fields science, math, technology, programming, and business. Was it b/c of MC? Maybe not. And it is true that math competition-style math is not "real math". Instead, it requires a lot of problem-solving skills, and to a lesser extent, a knowledge of tricks. Upper-level math requires a little bit of that kind of "sideways thinking", too.

To me, it is apparent that math contest-style problem-solving is a lot like hacking together software. You have math tricks (known hacks) and you synthesize different domains (algebra, geometry, trig; hardware, networks, storage, etc.) with a little problem-solving (or programming) to get to the answer (or final version of code). I also think that hacking software is a lot like doing research (http://www.elangocheran.com/blog/2012/02/essence-of-producti...), so using the transitive property... I can see how MathCounts can help foster the analytical skills and math skills that we need as a society.

elangoc··on Garry's SF Guide to Where Your Startup Should Be
this is very cool! I came to the area recently and settled in Berkeley based on a PG essay, and I think it deserves the good review that it gets on the map. I thought being in the Gourmet Ghetto area would be too far away from the bustling student-y area with cheap food, but it's nice to see it got mentioned.

Travel to SV via public transit is a 2-2.5 hr trip door-to-door (maybe a little more, depending where, and if you need to walk). If commuting is only a once in a while thing, it's not too painful with a Clipper Card but maybe expensive.

elangoc··on Ask HN: small startups, what do you use for health insurance?
This is an important question, it's the kind of thing that needs to be on an FAQ somewhere. Here is the info that I've collected in the last couple of months (US-centric, sorry):

relevant YC posts/articles:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2247560

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2851224

links from the comments, or elsewhere:

https://be.freelancersunion.org/benefits/ (you probably want to look this up, since they provide discounted health insurance plans for people in and around NYC)

http://www.nase.org/Membership/OptionalBenefits.aspx (smaller benefits, not full covereage, for people across the US)

http://www.anthem.com (For people in California - a sufficiently high deductible introduces risk but can drop your deductible to around $150-200 or less; mine is $108)

If you have a pre-existing condition, then you might find a plan through your state: http://www.healthcare.gov/law/features/choices/pre-existing-... (is this an outcome of Obama's Affordable Care Act?)

deciding whether/how to claim this on taxes (I haven't quite fully understood this, though):

http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=220839,00.html

http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=223666,00.html

http://www.usatoday.com/money/perfi/columnist/block/2011-04-...

advice via Reuters, FWIW: http://blogs.reuters.com/small-business/2010/12/06/health-in...

elangoc··on Amazon.com begins rolling out new homepage design
It's done randomly. They do a controlled test of a feature by turning the feature "on" for a window of time, and measure users' reactions in the control vs. experimental groups in real time. Experimental bias is minimized by the traffic being simultaneous, having a large sample size (visitors), and randomly deciding who gets put in which group.
elangoc··on Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator
I just had an idea: is it possible to move the voting arrow(s) down to the end of the post, e.g. next to the "reply" link? From a user UI flow standpoint, it would be nice to be able to read a long post and then think, "After reading through such an insightful post, that deserves an up-vote" and not have to break the-flow-of-scrolling-down to do so.

Now, the current position of the voting arrow is nice demarcation of the beginning of a post, and it also serves to indicate the nesting depth of a comment. Something serving that purpose is still useful. But maybe this more conveniently-located voting option can be implemented with an onhover so that it's visible at the end of only the post that the mouse is hovering on (a few other sites have comment boards like this).

elangoc··on How to learn Clojure effectively
i was also thinking about using Google Code Jam problems to practice from. anyone else tried this or has thoughts?
elangoc··on The Future of Light is the LED
Ever since I heard about "dirty energy" emitted from CFL bulbs, I've become wary of fluorescent bulbs and pro-LCD bulbs. Especially because I'm an asthmatic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VS5ogZxoZ2Y http://www.magdahavas.com/2009/12/05/gs-units-explained/

Can anyone with more knowledge on the subject verify if the dirty energy info about CFL bulbs is true, and if LCD bulbs will be free from that?

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →