HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elbrodeur

899 karma · joined June 17, 2010

Designer & Front end developer
submissionscomments
elbrodeur··on Ask HN: Why are YC startups so secretive in Job postings?
There's more to planning your press and media attention than your product, though. Here are couple of benefits from a good PR strategy:

- Investors can hear about you

- Showing relevant press from a reputable source is a great way to overcome objections to your product

- It attracts excellent talent that is more risk averse than, say, someone who is willing to join early stage/pre money or when the startup is in stealth mode

- You get to set the tone of your brand in the public eye

- You can get a critical amount of press momentum with a lot of planning and a little bit of luck. The idea being that if you can get a few big -- or relevant -- publications to write about you at the same time, it will get the attention of secondary publications and down onto humble bloggers.

PR might not always be a good strategy for product awareness. But planning and guiding how the public sees you is a great strategy for any company.

elbrodeur··on Twitter Raises $200 Million at $3.7 Billion Valuation; Adds New Board Members
MySpace's exit was $580MM. They had an estimated revenue of $300-$400MM in 2009. They might not be Facebook, and may never have a very high valuation, but the exit was very profitable for those involved.

Twitter can just as easily be great for it's stakeholders and fizzle out as a service.

elbrodeur··on [dead]
I think the link title misses the point of the article. The article is about getting unstuck -- something very difficult to do in any relationship. People get disengaged; routines become habits. The question she's struggling with is; how do you reengage?

This is easily applied to startups -- I'm at my third startup and after the initial push, rush and execution, when you're entering your 3rd or 4th year... It's hard to get really amped about work. It's hard to get excited about working from home. It's hard to keep focused and motivated. It's hard to break what has become routine. So how do you do it?

If her solution for her marriage was parlayed into startups it would be to ... act a little more unemployed. Get hungry.

elbrodeur··on Further Freedom Attacks
Again, there's no way to contact you personally regarding this really off-topic thread, so I'll reply here.

I'll agree with you that there is an unfortunate rise in the amount of politically charged rhetoric lately, but I really don't care for navel gazing (which I think is a far more unfortunate result of online communities in their adolescence). However, I don't really think that this article "in no way piqued anyone's intellectual curiosity, but instead triggered political feelings." ... I'm not quite sure how "intellectual" curiosity differs from normal curiosity, but can you honestly say that there wasn't a single person who didn't find the article interesting enough to say, 'Hey, what this guy said was interesting! I'd like to investigate this issue further.'

>>Things that are there for the purpose of intellectual intrigue do not have rallying cries for redistribution in bold as their first sentence, for example.

Intellectual intrigue? Was there a thought crime committed here? Joking aside, you can't fault any author for trying to promote their work. Self promotion -- and the prominence of the self promotion -- doesn't say anything about the quality of the content.

>> Also, I've observed the upvote vs. flag mechanism working for several years now. I agree that it does work in general. I posted this because I believe it is somewhat breaking down lately, in the form of political rallying cries reaching the front page.

Again, this is a conversation you and I should be having. It's a great reason to add some sort of way to contact you personally -- there's no reason anyone else should have to read our meta-HN conversation.

That being said -- what does a comment that essentially amounts to a downvote + flag add to the discussion?

- You obviously don't care for the article

- You didn't add anything constructive OR critical

I mean, honestly, I can't believe I've been typing for two minutes about this.

elbrodeur··on Gizmodo Goes Crazy, Reality Isn't What It Seems
Sorry, trying to get a handle on the barrage of headlines after thanksgiving and, previously, two weeks out of the country (and offline). "ICE's total cost" is what? Meaning the breakdown of their budget as it relates to the takedown of the sites?
elbrodeur··on Further Freedom Attacks
I'm not an expert but it seems to be legal and even constitutional. It's offensive, but if you mad-libbed the story, I'm betting it would seem less offensive.

The US Government siezed __number__ of __noun plural__ because of suspected __illegal verb__.

I was upset when I read the headlines as well. Mostly because of what I inferred -- not because of what happened.

My only worry is that one sad effect of this precedent might be people having their domains taken from them because a small number of users use the service for illegal activity.

EDIT: There's another post on the front page right now which says what I wanted to say much more eloquently: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1946154

elbrodeur··on Further Freedom Attacks
Putting this here because you don't have an email address:

- Upvoting an article is the group's way of saying, "This article has something interesting in it."

- Bad articles, spam, linkbait or things that don't fit in the guidelines or don't follow common sense usually get flagged and filtered out.

The post doesn't really seem to be outside of the guidelines. It may not meet your personal standard of quality, but the group likes it so it's on the front page. The best way to combat content that you think is spammy, irrelevant or wrong is to flag it.

elbrodeur··on Why The Shortage Of UI Engineers Is Going To Get Worse
I would say it's the same thing that makes anyone good at anything: The ability to take the body of knowledge associated with the field and not only synthesize it, but to riff on it and make new -- or at least -- compelling things.

That might be too broad. Specific to UX, I would say that many companies only consider what a user experiences and the stories they accumulate when their brand is mature -- usually much too late to pivot.

A good UX designer in an early stage venture is usually also an interface designer, to some degree, and taps into the following:

1) Deep understanding of the market and demographic

2) A solid grasp on what people expect

3) A great appreciation for the things that compel people to action

UX designers and engineers make things that cause people to accomplish goals in a way that is unobtrusive (except when it needs to be) unoffensive (except when it needs to be) and not confusing (ever). That's my take, at least.

elbrodeur··on Why The Shortage Of UI Engineers Is Going To Get Worse
I think HCI -- even though it's a relatively new program in most schools -- is a response to a problem a decade late. For reasons good and bad, Academia can't keep up with Moore's Law.

First, you don't want to build a major for every new technology; the half life of most technologies is very short. Second, sifting the cruft from the stuff that will outlive the specific technology (think personal updates vs. friendster -> myspace -> facebook -> twitter) is difficult.

So you end up with a compromise: A school of thought that teaches (or tries to) timeless principles of interaction. This is an incredible advancement in education, but unfortunately means less to someone looking for employment right out of college.

The problem is that UI and UX are a mix of science -- something taught at universities and colleges -- and what is traditionally relegated to vocational schools. It's not an applied science; it's more like being a mechanic or someone who makes those really fancy import cars even fancier.

The solution, I think, is going to be a long way off; universities will have to hire people that teach more about the history of design, what people are accustomed to and expect, what interfaces work and why and how to design for people whose aesthetic changes once every couple years. Art schools will have to hire hardcore CS people to teach rock solid foundations of logic, how languages work, etc etc...

elbrodeur··on Why The Shortage Of UI Engineers Is Going To Get Worse
Can I ask why you prefer this? I think that prefacing the word engineer with the type of engineering is much more preferable than redefining the word to mean something to do with physical engineering.
elbrodeur··on Why The Shortage Of UI Engineers Is Going To Get Worse
Sorry about the confusion. We call our developers engineers.
elbrodeur··on Why The Shortage Of UI Engineers Is Going To Get Worse
While I agree with the central theme ("UI/UX Designers and developers are going to get harder to find") I don't agree with a lot of his reasons.

He's obviously not an engineer and doesn't really understand AJAX, jQuery or HTML5.

Personally, I believe the shortage is going to get worse because there is going to be an increase in demand and there are VERY few paths through traditional educational outlets that will produce a good UI/UX designer/engineer. HCI at Stanford is the closest I've seen recently while interviewing candidates, and even then it has less to do with web technologies than interaction principles.

elbrodeur··on Is this a joke? New Service, AdKeeper, Lets Consumers "Click to Save" Online Ads
Longest. Press release. Ever. It would be nice to read a review of the service rather than a press release.

That being said, I think one of the main hurdles a service like this will be user banner blindness. Many people have banner blindness and interactive advertisements don't seem to perform better than passive advertisements.

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
I'm having trouble understanding why it should. The main thing that is difficult for me to accept is that the fire department was there, within rock-throwing distance of a fire, and did nothing except make sure the neighbors who were covered were protected.
elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
>>People who sustain life-threatening injuries when uninsured do not pay "at cost". They don't pay at all. The hospital bankrupts them, and then the rest of society pays nominally increased premiums to cover them.

I should have said that people are provided services and given a bill. Recouping that cost is, as you point out, difficult or impossible in many cases.

>> But none of this has anything to do with what the fire department did. The fire happened outside their service area. They simply weren't obligated to respond to it.

I can't argue with that. But it's still irksome that there is no other recourse for someone confronting an extremely slow moving fire while people with high pressure hoses look on.

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
I did gloss over your main point, sorry.

Insurance does work. It worked in this case: The neighbors houses were saved. But when insurance is the ONLY means by which a burning house can be saved we should rethink how we treat emergencies.

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
You're ignoring that in almost every other instance where you could have had insurance, you receive assistance and pay the price.

This is not insurance, this is a protection racket.

EDIT: By protection racket I mean this: I think in this scenario there is little distinction in letting something bad happen when it is well within your ability to stop it and making something bad happen.

"If you don't pay up I'm not going to be able to stop Vito over here from breaking your legs if he tries to break your legs..."

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
Already, for the uninsured, if you break a leg and need an ambulance ride you get one. It costs an arm (in addition to your wounded leg) but you get it.

Would you say this creates an incentive for EMTs and paramedics to break people's legs?

Again, systems are in place to already collect from people who can't afford lump sum payments. Amortized scheduling occurs in pretty much every industry.

Yes, a certain number of people cannot and perhaps will not pay. But the net benefit to society is manifest when your neighbor's house isn't burnt to the ground.

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
It's demonstrated in the article and elsewhere that they weren't expecting a free ride.

Again, there are numerous examples of systems working where uninsured people pay AT COST. Uninsured? An ambulance ride is really expensive. Uninsured? A broken leg is really expensive.

But you will still get treatment and you will eventually pay the price.

elbrodeur··on What life is like in a state where firefighters are paid voluntarily
>> Insurance doesn't work if you only pay it -after- you have a problem.

It's been said in several other places but this sort of intellectual dishonesty can't be left alone.

There are a plethora of examples currently in place in society that work well where if an uninsured person requires assistance they pay AT COST. If they can't afford out of pocket they set up a payment schedule.

elbrodeur··on InDinero (YC S10) seeking lead frontend engineer
I feel like for myself and the front end engineers I know it's just a begrudged reality of developing consumer facing products.

I envy my friends who can stand to lose IE6 traffic, but my company can't and besides -- it's always a point of pride when the site looks almost perfect the first time you check it in a legacy browser like IE6.

That being said, I hope they don't mean 5.5. :)

elbrodeur··on [dead]
Thanks! I should have searched before submitting. Sorry. Great discussion in the last thread you linked.
elbrodeur··on Ask HN: Recommend some good books for a dev with no design background?
The principles of great design are pretty timeless and are rooted in psychology, how our brain works and history.

You're right that you can learn a lot by intuition, but it's more likely that you're learning what you prefer, not what good design principles are.

elbrodeur··on Ask HN: Recommend some good books for a dev with no design background?
Don't Make Me Think: A Common Sense Approach to Web Usability http://www.amazon.com/Think-Common-Sense-Approach-Usability/...

It's a quick read that will give you tons of "A ha!" moments.

elbrodeur··on Ask HN: Do you think nature loves pomegranates more than apples?
Additionally, the pomegranate is native to an extremely arid environment; more seeds are necessary to ensure reproduction.
elbrodeur··on [dead]
Every time someone declares something dead, I die a little inside.
elbrodeur··on The Genius and Tragedy of Patrick McKenzie (patio11)
I couldn't agree more. This article was extremely uncomfortable to read; if it was me being written about I would be embarrassed and probably more than a little angry.
elbrodeur··on Ask HN: "Interesting" Job Contract
Do not accept this offer. Do you really want to work with someone who A) Doesn't trust you to work hard and B) Doesn't believe their work environment or product is good/fun/exciting enough to keep you around for only one year?

We all have to start somewhere, but this sounds like a situation that will leave you feeling deflated, powerless and bored.

elbrodeur··on Ask HN: What do you want to tell Microsoft?
I would like to tell Microsoft to stop being so risk averse. Stop relying so heavily on market research. Stop acquiring talent with proven track records and stifling them with your rubric.

If you want to survive the next 20 years, you're going to have to innovate. But innovation comes with significant risks, and at the earliest sign of failure or possible failure, you pull out instead of pivot, adapt or wait.

Stop worrying about marketshare. Start worrying that your products are not considered thought leaders; your flagship products are (until several innovations recently, like IE9 and 7) considered buggy, not secure and it's your fault. You've let the competition paint you into that corner.

Stop playing catch up. Start innovating.

elbrodeur··on Code for open-source Facebook riddled with landmines
It's pre-alpha. I've yet to take a look at the repo, but any software that isn't full of security holes, bugs and flaws at the pre-alpha stage is probably ready for an alpha release. In other words: No duh.

It would actually be surprising to read the headline: "4 students develop bug free, totally secure social networking platform in 3 months"

That being said, I'm excited to see how the project develops -- it's the kind of project that I wish I had the time to contribute to.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →