HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elefanten

3,113 karma · joined October 7, 2016

submissionscomments
elefanten··on Lemming Suicide Myth: Disney Film Faked Bogus Behavior
Are you referring to the original fairy tales that Disney content is based on? Even there, no example comes to mind.

Which stories are you referencing?

elefanten··on The world needs computational social science
A more charitable interpretation would be that the author is being tactical in addressing a discipline where the dominant fashion has been to critique or dismiss scientific methods. By packaging “let’s be more scientific” in an argument that sounds like “let’s not be narrowly prescriptive about epistemologies”, they may have a better chance at getting through to the most relevant target audience.
elefanten··on FindMyCat – Open-Source Pet Tracker
It’s not as “simple” as gp suggests, nor is it “the right thing”. We really don’t know what psychological and qol differences there are between the two… we’ve never been able to ask the cats. There are trade-offs, life expectancy being only one dimension of it. And in both cases (like the play you mention) there are mitigations to the downsides.

Source: I’ve had both indoor and outdoor cats, including cats that transitioned to outdoor after being raised indoor. Lost one outdoor cat tragically in middle of his lifespan. But his equally-outdoor brother lived to 19, and all the outdoor cats hands down seemed happier on average (less lethargic, less neurotic, less obsessive, less overeating).

elefanten··on Cisco Systems and Financialization
Yes, that’s the primary meaning of “arbitrarily”.

Party elites ban companies and competition at their whim for purely their own selfish ends, rather than according to principle.

They act as the arbiters of the matter.

elefanten··on ‘Baldur’s Gate 3’ Prepared for 100k Concurrent Players, They’ve Gotten 700K
Fair observations broadly, but gp’s points are fair too. It’s hard to predict hits but the points listed are all factors that helped the title out. Larian got the contract precisely because they proved themselves to be what you describe in your last sentence through the Divinity releases gp mentions. And even that was no guarantee here.
elefanten··on Google’s Plan to DRM the Web Goes Against Everything Google Once Stood For
I don’t follow this logic. For one… the other 50% is Google. But Google has equal or better market share of many other key product/service areas… and significantly higher share in the web advertising ecosystem central to the discussion.
elefanten··on Marijuana addiction: those struggling often face skepticism
That’s a significant oversimplification. These days, most of humanity has access to many types of powerful potential addictions. For many of them, trauma suppression is not a necessary condition. Reward chasing can exert enormous influence on its own.
elefanten··on Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard
Yeah, this is the real danger of the deal.

Most likely, it will: 1. First, be good for consumers short-term as MS floods the market with high quality cheap content. 2. Next, be bad for the games industry medium term as their product gets devalued and only the biggest winner-take-all free to play games can compete vs. the value of bundled content 3. Next, be bad for gaming employees and entrepreneurs as the value of their roles gets squeezed and the nature of working in the industry become more constrained and formulaic 4. Finally, end up bad for consumers when the quality and variety of viable gaming products declines.

Sadly, the FTC and CMA chose to base their cases on a bunch of abject nonsense, so I'm grateful that the FTC has rightfully lost the crummy case that it made. And the CMA is also about to rightfully lose / surrender next.

But the key words of my take are "most likely". Games market changes too much to make long term predictions about. The countervailing forces are increasingly cheaper and easier creator tools, as well as the rising difficulty of maintaining a meaningful hardware edge.

From the public policy perspective, it's much more urgent to come up with meaningful and sound legal doctrines against excessive market power than it is to litigate speculative crap based on the optics of resisting big price tags. Lina Khan's performative career boosterism has been a huge failure because she's just as greedy and anti-social as every stereotype about corporate management. But I have faith that a framework which doesn't rely on spectacle and punditry can be found. The EU is trailblazing in that area where the US and UK are still completely primitive.

elefanten··on Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard
All market segments have subsets and supersets. Why should the line be drawn where you imply?

Is Sony monopolizing the God of War market because God of War fans understand how those games are differentiated to appeal to their preferences?

The FTC's case that PS and Xbox exist in their own "high-performance console" market is the contrived argument. Honestly, it's dated to even consider consoles their own market. Product planning practice in the games industry these days pretty much looks at 2 markets: the mobile market and the "HD market" (PC + console).

elefanten··on Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard
Oh, I shared plenty specific to the case that you've glossed right over. Why does your observation matter more than any of mine?

Do you have a theory of how the tenuous connection you state might induce a district court judge to risk harming her career by making a flimsy decision that can be overturned or, worse, risk criminal prosecution if she was found to be conspiring in illegal dereliction of her duty?

What's the scenario you're implying? You haven't even made an argument. The deal expands a business segment that accounts for less than 10% of Microsoft's revenue, it's not going to make her son rich in stock options. He's 3-4 years into his career and has held an entry-level role at Microsoft less than a year, it's not going to rocket him to the top of the org chart. What's the incentive to induce whatever crimes or corruption you leave unspoken?

You conveniently ignored the argument a sibling poster made that the FTC chose their venue. Why choose this one?

Your take is tabloid pundit banter. Extending such disproportionate knee-jerk prescriptions upon such thin logic would grind any activity to a halt.

elefanten··on Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard
There are laws and case law that set standards of varying degrees of precedent that both parties and the judge need to form their arguments around. The losing side can appeal to other courts and, in this case, the FTC can continue their own internal trial that has been scheduled for over a year and a half (surely, purely coincidentally scheduled for a month after the deal would contractually fall through). The same FTC that was extensively prepped and assisted in this trial by Sony and Google. The same Sony that has European Playstation headquarters in the UK, where it employs a lot of locals and where it announced a new modern office build shortly before the UK’s CMA announced it would block the Microsoft deal. All of the above whom own plenty of index funds that include copious amounts of Microsoft stock.

Go searching for connections and you’ll find them every which way. I suppose we should declare everything illegitimate and corrupt, go back to atomized subsistence farming.

elefanten··on Red flags in the Threads privacy policy
Can you elaborate a full argument here? Or link somewhere that does?
elefanten··on Why Nvidia Keeps Winning
Historically, it was typically quite a bit smaller than consoles. Recently, they’re pretty similar in size but both significantly smaller than mobile.
elefanten··on Why Nvidia Keeps Winning
Can you elaborate about the Shield? Seems like a perpetual flop.
elefanten··on Why I started (and stopped) making games
Circling back late here, but thank you.. and thank you to all the sibling commenters as well!
elefanten··on Has Xbox lost the console wars?
I’m saying it made those companies more competitive (as in “better equipped to compete”), not that it made the various markets more competitive (as in “characterized by competition by multiple actors”).

“Big Tech” tends to refer to the companies.

Edit: To clarify further, I’m not casting those claims about older Big Tech acquisitions as wrong or misinformed. Nor am I trying to make any specific argument about the Democrats’ strategy / Neo-Brandeisian thought here. Just directly answering the question I replied to. I’m quite confident that this particular case against Microsoft, as argued by the regulators, is quite weak and that the political tail is wagging the dog here.

elefanten··on Has Xbox lost the console wars?
The real answer is that the FTC is pursuing the currently canonical Democrat party regulatory agenda of trying to stop big companies from getting bigger (search terms “Neo-Brandeisian” and “market power”). This goes along with the general optics / narrative that regulators “failed” to stop big acquisitions that, in hindsight, made Big Tech more competitive (the most common examples are Google acquiring DoubleClick and YouTube, and Facebook acquiring WhatsApp and Instagram). This deal had a large headline price ($70B / “biggest gaming acquisition ever”), so the FTC opposed it knee-jerk and has tried to justify it post-hoc.

Most of the comments here are uninformed on the law and the underlying market dynamics. My job involves analyzing the games market and there is no reasonable support to the claim that this deal will significantly harm competition in itself. Various parties might not like it for various reasons, but it would be pretty bog-standard, business-as-usual in video games. Activision is big but its portfolio isn’t big enough to single-handedly sew up the market for long. Huge swings happen every decade and no content or IP is guaranteed to keep its influence for very long. Xbox is in a distant third among consoles and MS would lose more money by pulling their biggest titles from the biggest console platform (PlayStation) than they’d gain by muscling more device share. They’d also degrade the value of the product because cross-platform play is basically table stakes and gamers would move towards games they can play together. MS is proving all this by offering all other platforms access to said content (which Nintendo and most others have accepted, but Sony has performatively refused). Some smaller content will be held exclusive, but that’s the running standard in the industry and has been for all time.

So, the FTC really doesn’t have shit here. They’re going to lose the ongoing injunction case and by all likelihood MS will close the deal before the July 18th deadline.

The UK’s Competitive Markets Authority is also holding it up (but notably, no other major regulator has objected, including the EU which has the most regulatory credibility). Playstation has a huge corporate presence and its European HQ in the UK, so the CMA is likely driven by local lobbying strength combined with similar political motivations (further bolstered by pressure from the current FTC commissioners, which has been reported). The CMA’s objection is (amazingly) even more poorly constructed, based on the argument that this will make future “cloud gaming” markets uncompetitive. I’ll spare you the details, but that is even more comically ridiculous than the FTC case. Once the FTC loses this injunction, the CMA will have to fold or else they will be embarrassed as a regulatory body by Microsoft closing the deal over their objections and showing them to have no teeth (and no clue).

elefanten··on Creating and Playing Games (2022)
Meandering and muddled bit of content marketing here. For one, their self-placement at the top of the hierarchy of undisruptible learning tools is rich, especially while dismissively putting Khan Academy at the bottom. KA isn’t “just” for rote memorization… it goes way up the pyramid with really deep and thoughtful instruction to foster understanding, application and analysis (at a minimum). I dont think this educational memegen product is doing as much heavy lifting as they want to believe.

But mainly, its central point that students should be critiquing and correcting AI output is only feasible if students have learned enough to effectively do so in the first place! So, yes, there are still appropriate concerns about students using ChatGPT to do their homework for them — if they do that upstream of having learned the subject matter, they’ll never have a chance to effectively learn from the methods endorsed here.

elefanten··on Email proves Microsoft's Activision bid is designed to eliminate Playstation
This is old news among the trial watchers.

The article author has clarified (and updated the article near the end) that he was informed the email is from 2019 and doesn’t pertain to the Activision acquisition. https://twitter.com/stephentotilo/status/1671304215006773257

And legal commentators have shared precedent that competitive expressions by management are not necessarily “anticompetitive” per the law. https://twitter.com/hoeglaw/status/1671267277700755460

Also, this filing is from the private case against the deal (not the FTC case) which was already denied a preliminary injunction given this email.

elefanten··on We Have Discovered Spherules from the Path of the First Interstellar Meteor, IM1
“Ryan Weed, Jeff Wynn, Charles Hoskinson, J.J. Siler and Amir Siraj are all engaged in this effort.”

The founder of Cardano is on the team? Weird. I thought maybe just a coincidence of two people with the same name, but appears confirmed on his twitter. [0]

[0] https://twitter.com/iohk_charles/status/1671496735267467264

elefanten··on Textbooks are all you need
Because it’d either be expensive or illegal, and all content owners are paying attention now
elefanten··on Why I started (and stopped) making games
Can you share any references for finding the top quality or best known games made using Godot? I haven’t looked in a while.
elefanten··on The WFH future is destroying bosses' brains (2021)
Both salary and hourly roles ultimately have expectations around both time spent and work contributed. On average, in both cases, the time spent portion is tracked more closely while the worked performed portion is functionally given more leeway.

That’s why the original comment nails it in the first two paragraphs. It may not be intended this way, but effectively people are paid for their time much moreso than their output.

elefanten··on The WFH future is destroying bosses' brains (2021)
Is that why its measured and paid in time-based increments while output is only measured in arbitrary ways and at fuzzy granularity?
elefanten··on Mark Zuckerberg on Apple’s Vision Pro headset
Oculus wands would make a barely more compelling experience of a butterfly landing on your finger.

When Apple’s ready they’ll release haptic gloves that smash that experience out of the park.

elefanten··on Mark Zuckerberg on Apple’s Vision Pro headset
The open secret is that the units they’ve sold get very little use. The typical user plays around with it for a few weeks and then it sits on the shelf.
elefanten··on Google doesn’t want employees working remotely anymore
I buy that... but real talk, there's gotta be a ton of bloat in the engineering org, no?

I've never worked at Google but I know shitloads of Googlers. And listening to their work problems... it sounds like engineers outnumber the other functions like 10:1 (at a minimum) but still produce mind-bogglingly slow estimates for the simplest shit. Like... 9 months to create a settings page. 6 months to change a few pages cumulatively simpler than a CRUD app.

Is it the systems they have to work with? The approvals to connect to this or that? Is everything within Eng bureaucratized to fucking hell and back? Or are >50% of them completely faking it and utterly useless? What the hell's going on there?

Edit: for context... yes, the abstracted examples I'm giving are coming for the perspective of PM / Design / Marketing folks. And when I ask my Eng Googler friends they get awkward and cagey and seem to not want to say anything mean about anyone.

elefanten··on Google doesn’t want employees working remotely anymore
It's fun to observe the difference in framing and word choice here. NY "cynicism" vs CA "toxic positivity".

As a Bay native, a younger version of me would've produced the mirror image to that rant along the lines of: "why are New Yorkers so angry and aggressive about everything? are they just miserable because they're all packed like sardines into that shabby concrete prison? why can't they just be chill like Californians?"

No accounting for taste!

elefanten··on US urged to reveal UFO evidence after claim that it has intact alien vehicles
Seems reasonable that even an intersolar civilization would be subject to bugs, errors, degradation and bad luck. An intersolar trip could’ve damaged a craft far more advanced than what we can make.

Could be (perhaps even likely to be) an unpiloted craft. It could be a craft no more technologically advanced than human tech; maybe it’s an alien Voyager 1.

elefanten··on Hypersonic missiles are misunderstood
What’s your take on the directed energy assessment in the article? Seems the author is ultimately advocating that route
← PreviousPage 4 of 28Next →