HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ergo98

3,484 karma · joined October 9, 2009

http://blog.yafla.com/
submissionscomments
ergo98··on Android Isn’t About Building a Mobile Platform
I see little that is unique or insightful in this essay.

"Google builds services like Google Maps, Gmail and Docs and gives them away for free"...

...because they entered a market where maps, email, and "docs" were free. Google didn't blaze a trail of free services, but they were bound to continue it.

Nonetheless, they've managed to get lots of businesses to subscribe to the pay services though.

"This is important for Google because while Google isn’t licensing Android"

Aside from the fact that while the core Android image -- which is GPLd btw -- is free, Google's premium applications are not. Note that many low end devices don't have Google's applications. Google is also trying to monetize their leading edge advantage with the Nexus One originally, and now the Nexus S.

"And Google conveniently owns one of the largest mobile advertising providers, Admob. "

Yeah, so does Apple. How do you like them Apples? Apple is very heavily invested and involved in the advertising and the media sales market. Any illusion that Apple is a pure player just trying to honestly sell an electronic device and that's the conclusion of the transaction should be demolished the moment you hook it up to iTunes. The original purchase is merely the first of many monetizations of the customer.

"Google is building Android not so they can make great mobile devices"

Oh well if you say so.

"For example, Android’s market may not be terrible in comparison to Apple’s App Store for paid applications just because Google hasn’t yet finished it; rather, discouraging paid applications on the Android platform is in Google’s interest. "

Conspiracy theory. Google is simply really bad at some things. See Google Checkout -- which was actually a major contributor to the Market's problems -- and Google's retail efforts with the Nexus One. The Android Market is not great, but neither is it particularly terrible, and it has been rapidly improving.

"This would squeeze out space for Apple in the mass market, forcing them into the high-end of the market, where people are willing to pay higher prices for a better device and experience."

This is my favorite bit. Apple is a mass consumer electronics company, with products at every price point, usually representing the value option. This sort of casual allusion that it is the premium option is utter bunk, and instantly reveals the bias of the speaker. If Android succeeds, via competition, in putting price pressure on smartphones, you can be certain that Apple will be pushing down to the lower options just as quickly. Anyone who thinks otherwise has absolutely no business sense.

Android is really a story about Linux. When people miss the Linux part of the equation -- and the decisions that are bound by it -- they instantly lose focus on some of the givens of the platform.

ergo98··on I Paid a Bribe
Is this a serious question?

The correlation between wealth and class is almost 1.0. How can you seriously argue otherwise? This discussion has taken a turn to the bizarre.

ergo98··on I Paid a Bribe
>Tipping low-wage customer service workers for unadvertised services and favours is now some sort of evil "class" issue that indicates greed and corruption?

It is absolutely corruption. There is no question about it.

Sure, the corruption is from a less powerful position, but the morals and outcomes are largely the same: Someone is selling privileges they have no right to sell, and the same mentality is the mentality that allows corruption in public office.

"Do you get mad when other diners at your favourite restaurant tip better than you and get friendlier service for their trouble?"

What a terrible example. Tipping occurs at the end of the transaction, and is intended as a reward for good service. If you had to pay the server before getting served, and it decided the level of care and concern you would get, I am quite confident that it would be forcefully abolished by every restaurant immediately.

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
Says some boring internet goblin that has almost certainly never touched an Android device, much less in any real world situation. You're another bore with your tired talking points pushing forward the iPhone religion.

Get a grip.

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
This is fantastic to hear.
ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
If you notice a lag is not minor any more: it is one of the most irritating aspect of any UI.

The people who complain about minor, incidental interface lag are the people who don't use Android. To people who use it day to day it just doesn't matter. It really doesn't.

But please, tell me again what's important to some iPhone users who don't use Android, repeat talking points, and live with a system missing basic functionality.

Complaining about iTunes dependency, but silent about Google services dependency?

Actually I'm complaining about the archaic, Windows Mobile like "Hook it up to a real computer" nonsense. Again, there is nothing good about that.

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
They're engineering fixes, but the complaints are due to UX, and UX guys wouldn't have let those problems leave the lab.

The lack of GPU usage is an engineering and time restriction: Android is available on many devices, not all of which have GPUs supporting two surfaces at once. Android made a completely reasonable compromise of not using the GPU for the surface which in practice works perfectly fine. With enough time and engineering effort they could, and should, create divergent codepaths for higher-end and lower-end devices, which is exactly what they are doing with Honeycomb.

I have no doubt they'll resolve it as the platform matures and the hardware base improves. It just isn't as important of an issue as many seem to believe it is: Again, I use Android as my primary smartphone device. Minor interface stuttering just isn't a big issue, or any issue at all for that matter.

What I did have a problem with was games that, due to GC pauses, stuttered (a problem that kills it as a gaming platform pre-2.3). That has been largely resolved in 2.3 with the concurrent GC (which also improves the base UI).

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
"They need to stop hiring engineers and start hiring UX guys."

The two complaints you just aired are engineering complaints -- GPU usage by the core UI, and as a related complaint that the zoom speed of the browser isn't great (which again is GPU usage -- on the iPhone it is simply zooming in on a surface skin).

If I had to compare minor interface lag against the completely broken notification system on the iPhone, the latter absolutely eclipses the former. If you want to call one "not ready", I would say broken fundamental functionality is quite a bit higher on the complaint scale. Or at least it should be...yet we always hear about minor scroll stuttering.

Just as is the case with the iTunes dependency (no thanks), and previously the complete lack of reasonable multitasking.

Those egregious usage issues, however, always take a backseat to frivolous "you will never notice it when you actually use the device in real practice" trivialities.

Windows Phone 7 is providing a better UX than Android on version 1, and it doesn't strongly emulate iOS like Android does.

Wrong on all counts.

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
Twitter, Facebook, and Amazon MP3 are "built-in" apps in many Android images (e.g. Nexus One 2.2), at most allowing you to uninstall updates to them.

It's a major irritation, really. Google needs to stop that nonsense.

ergo98··on An iPhone Lover’s Take On The Nexus S
Google sent out phones to both Gruber and Siegler. What were they thinking? Neither are fair actors, and neither have any credibility outside of the core Apple base.

They are lost causes. There is no value in courting them: Let the product diminish their relevance, which is exactly what has already happened.

Siegler's review pretends that he gave it a fair shake, yet like all Apple reviews it only notes where Android fails, in his opinion, relative to the iPhone. Where, for instance, is any comment on the superior Android notification system (which to me is a dealbreaker of the iPhone), the power of widgets, the granular app permissions, etc.

As much as he doth protest, his conclusion was predetermined. There is no scenario where he would consider it a superior device.

ergo98··on Hotlinking to jquery.com will be disabled on January 31, 2011
Pretend to take the high road. Misrepresent what I've said in reply after reply (now you're onto the "don't get angry!" screed which is one of my favorites). Pull the "I'm done!" card just as you've declared me a troll. I see that you've mastered this technique, and your black belt awaits.

I'm not done because I've debated with this ridiculous tactic enough to see it for what it is.

Copy-pasting code that you don't understand is pretty much the definition of laziness.

And just to be clear, it's "trivial" for jQuery to do this, in your mind, because you're not the one having to do it. Probably thousands of tiny sites that are doing this (I doubt it's any big numbers sites), each requiring you to go through the whois process to find a webmaster. Not as trivial as you proclaim.

ergo98··on Hotlinking to jquery.com will be disabled on January 31, 2011
"I guarantee that some people are using the wrong URLs because they received bad advice, or copied from code they shouldn't have, or were simply told by somebody that they could link to the version on jquery.com, so did."

Is that not precisely what I said? Laziness.

I feel like I'm debating with a tired Hallmark card. Yes, high road and all that. We get it.

Just as you misplaced the malice quote (you were a little too eager to play that one), now you're on about punishment: Who said anything about punishment? Saying "Don't hotlink, but we're giving you 30 days grace" is not remotely "punishment". That you portray it as such is, honestly, outrageous.

ergo98··on Hotlinking to jquery.com will be disabled on January 31, 2011
Malice? As quaint as that saying is, malice plays no part in this discussion.

I'm attributing laziness, which is quite removed from malice. People using jquery should be evolved enough to know what CDNs are, and the dangers of hotlinking (which is as simple as "jQuery decided to reorganize their site, and now a thousand sites are broken").

ergo98··on Hotlinking to jquery.com will be disabled on January 31, 2011
They are already going way above and beyond by extending their deadline to the end of January. They have the capacity to be much ruder about it.

Hotlinking like this has been a well known web evil for well over a decade. That people still do it and just hope for the best is indicative of extraordinary laziness and selfishness.

ergo98··on Software Patents Have Got to Go
Very unlikely. He targeted everyone but Gates. His attack is legitimate.

However Allen can feel just, I guess, given that he has dedicated most his wealth to charity after he dies. So he's essentially playing Robin Hood.

ergo98··on Tim Bray: Year-end View of the Mobile Market
>I keep hearing this argument that Google simply has to assemble a crack team of UI experts and they'll inevitably match or surpass Apple's offerings.

Android is already matching iOS in many areas, exceeding it in some (a superior, and more functional, notification system, and a much better messaging system, though that is subjective). With each iteration it keeps improving and improving, not by changing actual function but mostly just by decorating in a manner that iPhone users are more accustomed.

ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
No. I'm suggesting that the media manipulation is a negative. That Apple customers actually haven't caught onto this is yet another negative.

The modern world is amazingly capable of huge feats of fulfillment without demanding that the hordes line up for the cameras at 5am. That practice is a ridiculous anachronism.

ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
Android already does flow based layout by default, taking its cue from the web itself. Web apps have been dealing with this problem space for many years, and in some ways have conquered it.
ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
I actually said "My comment was specifically and only about essentially spurious, extraneous chrome", which you extrapolated, and got upvotes, for misrepresenting as "animations have nothing to do with usability or design". Kudos on your misdirection.
ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
Plus, linking to a Nexus S "line" that the photographer admits was posed?

The long lines for the latest Apple release are an indictment of the Apple fanbase. They should never been seen as a benefit of the platform.

I see the same thing about the endless gloating about Apple profit. "Hey everybody, look at how much I overpaid! I surely picked the right horse to back!" It's a bit incredible.

ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
>Looking only at the functionality and completely ignoring the design is superficial.

Who is completely ignoring the design? My comment was specifically and only about essentially spurious, extraneous chrome -- literally interface bedazzling. It has nothing whatsoever to do with usability, and actually little to do with design.

You know I still marvel that Apple is held as the gold standard of design. The iPhones notification system is truly terrible. The messaging system is a god awful sin of design (for the longest time I simply could not believe that the screenshots posted were actually from the esteemed iPhone). Many of the transition effects stink of excess.

ergo98··on Emotional Rescue
>If Android were serious about their developers, they would bake in standard animations.

Why do you presume that they haven't? Every View has intrinsic full animation support, and of course there's a full simile of CoreAnimation in android.view.animation.

So why don't Android apps make use of it? Generally as a function of time, care, and craftsmanship. Too often Android apps were second tier, and many Android app writers were doing it to scratch an itch (versus for the iPhone where it is typically productized).

Android apps have the potential to be just as slick, just as polished, and just as nuanced and emotional as any iphone app. The state today is that they aren't, but that isn't any intrinsic failure of the platform.

Honestly, though, I find that sort of observation superficial and just incredibly boring. Every iphone user when they touch an Android device will immediately comment on the lack of slickness of the non-GPU using transitions. As a day to day Android user, using my phone for virtually everything and anything, this has absolutely ZERO impact on my enjoyment of the device. To say it is unnoticed is still giving it too much credit. It's superficial bedazzling that differentiates based upon the utterly irrelevant.

ergo98··on 2011: The Year Android Explodes
http://blog.yafla.com/The_Biggest_Lie_That_Ever_Was_Told/
ergo98··on Where Is Awarded "The Mother of All Geofencing Patents"
Agreed. This patent is not the mother of all geofencing patents: They seemed to have made it specific enough that it is actually not the egregious sort of patent abuse that we so commonly see.

A patent can have multiple independent claims, independently enforceable. In this case, however, there are only a few independent claims, each a simple rewrite that only marginally changes scope. The reset are dependent claims that are specializations.

ergo98··on Pandora, Angry Birds, other apps selling private info to advertisers
Angry Birds only requests the following two permissions on Android-

-Network Communications

-System tools (prevent phone from sleeping)

This doesn't include even coarse location, much less a fine GPS position. Unless they're cracking your system, they can't get more than a guessed geolocation of the IP address you're at.

Nor can they access your contacts, read your personal details, steal your emails, read your phones identifier, etc.

Looking at the WSJ story, they don't even include Angry Birds under Android in their analysis. It is, I think, fascinating that there were so many stories on here about Android apps "stealing your data", yet the iPhone market remained opaque, with so many holding some unsupported notion that a high level curation guaranteed good app behavior.

In this case, despite the Android version being only ad supported, I have comfort that it can't possibly be doing what the iPhone app is doing.

ergo98··on Apple v Google
XServ? Apple TV that has iterated through various terrible iterations? Ping?

The article is yet another Apple love-in. The comparison is "viewing one company with a critical eye, and the other with rose coloured glasses."

ergo98··on Android 2.2 FroYo Offers Huge Performance Gains: Dell Streak Tests
Indeed. I said questionable. Go to any review of the release of Android 2.2 and you can see the performance improvements that are pretty much universal across devices. This simply conflates the two and implies something that isn't true.

With 2.2 the Streak is competitive with other 2.2 devices. There is no surprise there, given that it runs essentially the same processor as the Nexus One.

ergo98··on Android 2.2 FroYo Offers Huge Performance Gains: Dell Streak Tests
2.2 offers big theoretical performance improvements over <2.2. We all know that.

The graphs on this, however, are ludicrous. It's putting the 2.2 device up against 2.1 devices, adding questionable statements like "Even Samsung's 1GHz Cortex A8 Hummingbird chip can't compete versus the 1GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon chip in the Streak, when the Epic 4G is running Android 2.1 -- but over a 3X improvement from Android 1.6 to 2.2 on the Streak?"

Yes, JIT offers big performance improvements. It doesn't somehow make the Snapdragon a better chip, however.

ergo98··on Netflix: Lessons We’ve Learned Using AWS
Analogies merely confuse (they always have that superficial "aha!" moment, yet never bear scrutiny). If it must be, however, in this case it's more synonymous with a restaurant that farmed out their kitchen and their wait staff, but they carefully crafted the menu, chose the silverware, and did all of the marketing.
ergo98··on Netflix: Lessons We’ve Learned Using AWS
Reading both this entry and the one that explained why they went with AWS, I'm left confused about why they ever went to AWS in the first place.
← PreviousPage 5 of 26Next →