HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ergo98

3,484 karma · joined October 9, 2009

http://blog.yafla.com/
submissionscomments
ergo98··on 7M Downloads: Why Angry Birds Is Free on Android
What is your Android phone? I've played the game on my Nexus One and on an iPhone 4, and I find the experience close to identical. The iPhone 4 without argue has a GPU that absolutely trounces the Nexus One -- though it is matched in the Galaxy S, Desire Z, and close to matched in the Moto Droid 2 variations -- however Angry Birds doesn't really exercise the limits of it so that doesn't come into play.

So presuming that you're talking about the "Full" version, and considering that there is no lite version, I'm curious how such a difference of perceptions could possibly be.

ergo98··on Apple bans Android magazine app
You have pretty much all of the pro-Apple talking points covered in your various posts in this discussion. I urge you not to simply accept them because you read them elsewhere, however, because they're largely baseless.
ergo98··on Chevy Volt rated at 93/37mpg
It was a trolling title. The EPA has been working out how they would rate electric vehicles, and by the original criteria the LEAF would have been rated at something like 367 mpg. The Volt hasn't suddenly become less efficient -- the rating criteria changed.
ergo98··on Chevy Volt rated at 93/37mpg
While an early adopter vehicle like this isn't about saving money at all (there are extremely few hybrid vehicles that economically pay off), a Volt with come with a lot of cachet. Sure there'll be the contrarians (seriously, the griping about the 37 mpg borders on the ridiculous. That is a very decent worst-scenario mixed-use value for a vehicle in the class of the Volt. But contrarians gotta hate), but overall most people will perceive it as a higher esteem vehicle.

People pay a lot of money for higher esteem vehicles. It funds most hybrids (which by themselves are seldom a net return).

ergo98··on Google and Microsoft Cheat on Slow-Start. Should You?
Very interesting. Is such a thing configurable in Apache or nginx? It seems to be a rather rude behavior, but I'm curious how accessible it is.
ergo98··on Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures arms HTC with big patent trove
Fisticuffs at high noon!
ergo98··on Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures arms HTC with big patent trove
As downtrodden and abused as you might pretend to feel, claiming that I resorted to an ad hominem is quite fallacious: My comment was specifically and only about the argument (which was a variation of the "Apple is always the inventor" theme that is so popular among a few), not about the speaker. It is, quite literally, the exact opposite of which you claim.

Though the image of you putting on your top hat and adjusting your monocle was delightful. I pray that you haven't succumbed to the vapors.

Patents (which trace back to Venice circa 1474) were always were protections for individual inventors and creators. The "everyone churn out patents for the company to lay a monster landclaim --- just take what you find and add "with a computer" or "with a touchscreen" and we're golden", with patent ownership reverting to the corporate entity, is an altogether recent concept.

ergo98··on Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures arms HTC with big patent trove
Out of curiosity, why does the 1700s timeframe preclude such a purpose? That was an era when incredible individual invention occurred, largely in machines and chemistry. It was seldom the R&D division of a large manufacturer (those robber barons), but was often individual inventors.

Virtually all invention was a individual or small group pursuit.

ergo98··on Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures arms HTC with big patent trove
>but Apple at least is playing the game in the exact spirit in which the laws were conceived

The patent system was conceived to allow the little guy (or little business) to invent, and profit from those inventions, even when he lacked the means or scale of manufacture to reliably profit from that invention.

Without such protection obviously there was no way that someone who invented a new method to harness energy from gasoline, for instance, could avoid getting crushed by an established car company: He would have close to zero leverage in such a transaction, and there was little to prevent them from simply saying "thanks".

Honestly I suspect that if companies above some threshold were barred from filing patents, it would have no impact at all on their R&D spend. It might even improve efficiencies as they stop focusing on trying to land grab with hundreds of trivial patents (which is sadly what most patents are now, where offenders accidentally offend simply in the course of building things because overlap is unavoidable).

There is nothing, whatsoever, morally different between patent trolls and a company like Apple. They are both playing the same game to enrich themselves at the cost of everyone else. As the old saying goes, however, don't hate the players, hate the game, so kudos to Apple for doing what they can to ensure that $4 billion + of profit enriches their account every quarter.

ergo98··on RIM kicks Kik off Blackberries: Revokes keys, disables push
Android seems to have the same problem with Skype

The oddity of Skype is entirely Skype's making -- they saw a revenue model negotiating with carriers (the idea being "Get a Verizon Android phone because then you can get Skype"), so that's what they did. They control their own product, so there it is.

ergo98··on Apple Poaching Enterprise Sales Staff From Research in Motion
Look, I don't mean to go all John Gruber here, but a good portion of iPhone users wouldn't want anything changed...until it's actually changed at which point it's the most obvious, most important thing in the world.

If Apple came out with a slider version of the iPhone tomorrow, I suspect there would be a rapid, but remarkably quiet, appreciation of hardware keyboards among many iPhone faithful.

Mileage will definitely vary. I know people who absolutely love their onscreen keyboard. They do tend to be people who actually type very little though, so it's perfect for them.

It's interesting that you mentioned onscreen keyboards giving you a increase in screen space -- yeah, when you don't need to type anything. When you do, suddenly 80% of your screen is all keyboard.

ergo98··on Apple Poaching Enterprise Sales Staff From Research in Motion
While it might be a problem for some for most it hasn't been one.

iPhone users live on with a touchscreen keyboard because they have no choice. Most Blackberry users never migrated to the iPhone for that reason. Android users were caught in a temporary world where every Android maker tried to be like the iPhone, with the terrible choice of the onscreen keyboard, but thankfully that period is quickly passing, with great devices like the G2 / Desire Z and the Galaxy S Pro.

ergo98··on Apple Poaching Enterprise Sales Staff From Research in Motion
Do you post HN comments using your touchscreen? If not, why not?

I've done the keyboard smartphone thing, and the touchscreen smartphone thing (incl. swype with the latter). I prefer a real keyboard overwhelmingly -- even a miserable keyboard like on the HTC Dream -- and I know I'm far from alone.

When someone sends me an email or a text requiring a response, honestly it is a sad, defeated feeling when I have to respond on the touchscreen keyboard.

I know I'm hardly alone with this: iPhone toting friends and peers tend not to author any content on their device beyond the occasional "lol" or "brb" type response (you know instantly that they're hacking it on the screen), whereas others with Blackberry devices or physical keyboards...I often can't tell from their response whether they are at their desk or remote because they don't artificially abbreviate their comments.

I'm sure there are non-typists or those of few words who are completely satisfied without a keyboard. Most others simply accept it.

ergo98··on I Quit Hacker News
I think he's just upset about the TSA articles

The TSA articles are annoying noise that undermine HN. Unless it's discussing the technology of the devices or heuristics of algorithms used to analyze it, it's pop political garbage that belongs on Reddit.

Though I'll disagree with him on one thing: HN should be more elitist, not less. HN's distinction was once that it really was where the smart technology people were. Of course once it gets that rep the hanger ons follow, and soon they're the ones stamping their feet and yapping about the TSA or even North and South Korea -- those are nice, calming, accessible topics, and it's how every community driven site, without oversight, eventually drifts to the mean.

ergo98··on Safari on iOS 4.2: Accelerometer, WebSockets, SVG, AJAX2 & better HTML5 support
Not sure why Android gets pulled into this, however in addition to the fact that Android 2.2 has far and away class leading canvas and JavaScript performance -- the poor performance on iOS is why so many apps go native on that platform for trivial needs -- and brings virtually all of the Google Gears functionality that became the foundation of "HTML5" to Android (web databases, web workers, geolocation), the next version of Android is going to feature optional javascript access to the camera, among other improvements.

Android is innovating heavily, and your comment is way off base.

ergo98··on John Carmack talks about Rage SD and HD, iOS, and what's next for iOS gaming
The personal example was anecdotal. The same thought process applies to many people.

The GP opines that the Jobsian "he'll choose what's right for you" model is, as you quoted, right for most people most of the time. I would say that is absolutely not correct, and the iPhone has succeeded despite that model, not because of it: Great integration, software, and branding has overcome an incredible lack of diversity and choice.

It isn't a good long-term strategy though.

ergo98··on Where Are the Android Killer Apps?
I have no disagreement with Gruber here -- he is generally on the mark.

However I think it is a short-sighted perspective. The products that are in the market today often had many months to years of incubation end evolution time on them. A mere four months ago, iOS was still overwhelmingly where it was at, and on sites of the people making the apps -- like HN -- it had the dominant mindspace.

That has profoundly changed. On my Android I've noticed the pace of iterations of the top tier apps is reaching an incredible pace, as obviously what was an afterthought is starting to get equal billing to their iOS product.

Gruber is unquestionably right today. In three months, or six months, I think the equation will have dramatically changed.

Though it will never be about "killer apps" (where exclusivity is the definition). That antiquated notion has no place in modern computing. Note that Google makes all of their "killer apps" available on iOS as well, which is exactly how it should be. In an ideal every top tier app exists on multiple platforms.

ergo98··on John Carmack talks about Rage SD and HD, iOS, and what's next for iOS gaming
As much as some chafe against the "Jobsian" world of Apple products, Steve makes many choices for you and most of those choices are right for most people most of the time. That's about the best you can do.

Couldn't disagree more. I like keyboards on my smartphones, and GPUs fall low on the scale of needs: I use it mostly for productive or professional use. For a lot of smartphone buyers, Rage graphics just don't matter.

I would go so far as to say as people buying an iPhone are buying an iPhone; people buying an Android phone are buying a phone (or, in some cases, they're not buying an iPhone).

People buying an Android are buying a Smartphone. No they aren't buying a brand or some sort of ridiculous personal identity. As a smartphone the Android devices are a bang up option.

My personal belief is that Android handset manufacturers are participating in seppuku.

You mean the makers who have seen the platform's sales increase 1200%+ since January? I would say the metrics would say that you are completely off the mark.

ergo98··on John Carmack talks about Rage SD and HD, iOS, and what's next for iOS gaming
The low end of Android -- particularly in the GPU realm -- is much lower on low-end Android devices. An iPhone 3 decimates a Dream/Magic, for instance. There are new Android devices coming out that still don't hold a match to the original iPhone.

That isn't fragmentation. It's disturbing hearing it described as that. It's consumer choice.

Really Android needs a "gaming index", similar to the reality that some PCs -- just like some Macs -- are really shitty for gameplay, whereas others are high-end superstars, the devices in the Android market should have clear rankings. The Nexus One, for instance, has a terrible GPU. The Galaxy S is a good 3X faster or more.

ergo98··on W3C Working Group Just Killed Web SQL Database
Hi there, nl.

"As far as the NoSQL thing is concerned, I think it's interesting to note that IndexDB's semantics closely match those of BerkeleyDB, which started life in 1991. Work first started on IndexDB in 2006 [2], long before the term NoSQL was invented."

I don't think anyone believes that NoSQL is a new concept, regardless of the lineage of the current name (just as "AJAX" existed years before someone called it AJAX).

ergo98··on W3C Working Group Just Killed Web SQL Database
The most complex part of Web SQL effectively amounted to "Whatever SQLite implemented"

Which is one of the most tested, most utilized, most known pieces of code used among modern software. Saying "reference it" is entirely rational. And really the ludicrous notion that documenting its behaviors is unfathomably difficult is so asinine that it demolishes that line of argument.

neither Mozilla nor Microsoft supported it

Microsoft doesn't REALLY support either: Does IE9 have IndexedDB? Not that I'm aware of.

Microsoft's angle regarding Web Databases was nothing more than "I don't know...that looks mighty uppity for a web app..."

Mozilla is taking a very myopic, "high-road" approach that is similar to, and less justifiable, the whole h.264 debacle: Everyone loses, but someone gets to hold their head up high.

Further, Chrome, Safari, Opera, other...none of them support IndexedDB, so as a standard it is effectively irrelevant.

Presumably the W3C have decided to favour IndexedDB instead, which solves many of the same problems in a much more elegant, simple and well-specified fashion.

Ha ha ha!

The IndexedDB spec right now has incredible gaps that make it close to useless. The braintrust at Mozilla that are responsible for it can't stop themselves from saying "CouchDB" long enough to actually work on it, it seems.

I think they got caught up in the whole NoSQL thing. So much so that they now seriously advocate that libraries should pop up inefficiently implementing SQL on top of IndexedDB, which is just saddening.

But aside from that, rah!

ergo98··on Woz misquoted 'Almost every app that I have is better on the iPhone'
I'm sorry but I'd rather take Woz opinion...

That's nice, but a false dichotomy. I questioned the relevance of the Woz's opinion, but that doesn't in any way come at the benefit of someone else's opinion, much less some arbitrary ".NET wunderkind".

In this case, after Android has already taken a pretty strong sales lead, the Woz tells us that Android is probably going to take the lead some day. Prophetic.

But yeah whatever you have a bone to pick with Woz...regardless of what dislike you might have with the man's persona.

Lame.

ergo98··on Woz misquoted 'Almost every app that I have is better on the iPhone'
This is the soppy romanticized garbage that is so boring to debate with.

Yes, if you want to talk to someone about 1970s era personal computer innovations, the Woz is almost certainly the goto guy. Granted.

Is he important? Sure, he is important to a certain era in Apple's history. The part before the company would have dissolved as an ongoing enterprise if it wasn't for some strategic rescuing by Microsoft.

Are his comments about pretty much anything in the modern era even insightful or of particular relevance, beyond "this guy worked on the Apple I" colour commentary? I don't think so. I suspect that the Woz's primary reason for appearing in Apple lines and giving "grate on Steve Jobs" quotes is so the reporter can bring up that he works for FusionIO.

But yeah, your Dyed in the Wool Woz fanclub membership card is in the mail.

ergo98··on Did Google Arm Its Own Enemies With Android?
There's a context to this thread that you disregarded.
ergo98··on Woz misquoted 'Almost every app that I have is better on the iPhone'
No it isn't. 23 years ago Woz was a "motivational factor" at Apple for the preceding 4 years. The prior two+ years he was off after an accident. Before that he worked with Jobs for 4 years.

His real contribution to Apple was for four years of the company's 34 year history.

ergo98··on Woz misquoted 'Almost every app that I have is better on the iPhone'
Ending 23 years ago (and saying "12 years" is grossly overgenerous). Of zero relevance to the modern Apple computers (edit: Sorry, it isn't even called Apple Computers anymore)
ergo98··on Woz misquoted 'Almost every app that I have is better on the iPhone'
Actually in this case it sounds like the reporter wasn't to blame at all. Woz is simply saying "What I really meant was..."

Personally I don't get why his thoughts on things are given such importance. Each Apple release he appears at some fan line to go "Hey, everyone remember me! I'm the guy who was involved with Apple for a short period!". Not trying to be cynical, but seriously I suspect he's a major irritation for Jobs.

ergo98··on Did Google Arm Its Own Enemies With Android?
Just as you can use an Android device without ever seeing a single Google ad.

However Apple's media strategy is a big part of their iDevice push. Simply selling you a piece of hardware is only a small part of their plans for you.

ergo98··on Did Google Arm Its Own Enemies With Android?
I believe their intention was to make sure that they get a piece of the mobile ads pie

Well sure -- the reason they want you using Google search is so they can advertise to you. And they can get you using Google Voice, and Google Maps, etc. They are less likely to have their products -- which are largely sponsored by ads -- cut out.

I'd rather use products from someone who's in the business to make money from products: Apple, Nokia, RIM, MS

Apple is a terrible example of that. Aside from the fact that they have a very big advertising initiative, a big part of the iPhone experience is lock-in with various other Apple products and conduits. Want some music? Oh well look, Apple is your conduit, taking their piece of the pie. How about a movie, or a book, or a newspaper? Hi, Apple here, ready to tax you.

Nokia...sure. Apple -- absolutely not.

ergo98··on Did Google Arm Its Own Enemies With Android?
YES! YES THEY DID!

This was a no-so-directly stated purpose and intention of Android since day one. That any late to the party analyst looks at the situation and thinks they've discovered a hole in the plot speaks more to how ill informed the field of analysts are than to Google's strategy.

Google's intention with Android -- they haven't been quiet about this -- was to create an open, competitive ecosystem that isn't controlled by any one vendor (incl. themselves). If Apple dominated and decided to cut Google out (and smartphones continued their path to dominance), that single point could decimate Google. However if 20 handset makers make Android, and one of them decided to cut Google out, the damage is limited. If Google provides an experience that customers want, they would vote with their wallets because they could.

(see the negative reception of Bing on some Verizon handsets)

← PreviousPage 8 of 26Next →