HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eropple

27,070 karma · joined April 12, 2011

Lead architect of Verizon's next-generation API platform. I know--I'm as surprised as you are.

https://bsky.app/profile/ed3d.net

Favorite follows: toomuchtodo, JumpCrisscross, woodruffw, tptacek, pjmlp

Given the rate at which Hacker News sprouts green-text commenters who tend to really, really like bigotry, I read HN with a plugin that automatically folds all green-text comments. I apologize if you're a new user acting in good faith and I don't read your post. Please feel free to get in touch with me via the above email.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/eropple; my proof: https://keybase.io/eropple/sigs/o9U8phHSrpBd_HL4r_Fb_hutO3mrRucKWwIFL7dquhI ]

submissionscomments
eropple··on Old vs. new growth trees and the wood products they make
> Yeah, maybe some of these materials are not as "sturdy" to the touch and maybe they have a shorter life-span, but I am positive they work better and are cheaper/easier to replace.

They are cheaper, they are easier to replace, and at the moment (wood nerd hat on) we genuinely do not know if they have a shorter lifespan. But it's very likely that they do not, in part because of the construction around them. These concerns are not, in my experience, something that you really hear people who spend much time around structural work bring up. It's mostly a "back in the day" thing.

For furniture, on the other hand--things are different. But dimensional lumber as practiced today is a modern miracle.

eropple··on You've just inherited a legacy C++ codebase, now what?
I get where you're coming from, but frankly: nah. If you are so in-the-rut that you can't switch, say, text editors or IDEs and are compelled to have an Incredibly Normal Day about it, you're probably not actually possessed of the plasticity to be somebody I want to work with.

I use vim, IntelliJ, Visual Studio, and VSCode at least once every two weeks apiece, and it's no skin off my back to switch. Do thou likewise.

eropple··on The lithium-ion battery may not be the best bet for EVs
It's not even true in the United States. In the Boston area, there are still plenty of those "strong towns" the bloggists go on about. I live in one. My car gets used to go to Home Depot, to drive to visit my parents four hours away, and if I need to go to my doctor who's just a little too far off the beaten path to drive to. The rest of the time, I walk, and I'm within a mile of a commuter rail station to get to Boston proper.

Of course, we have not here decided that Government Is The Problem, so we tend to wield it a little better. A number of my neighbors want to change that, being as afraid as they are of "Transit-Oriented Development" (you can guess what that means), but hey--democracy isn't free, we need to push that nonsense back.

eropple··on Money bubble
I know you're goofing on it, and tbh I give more credence to MMT than most folks do, but most folks I know who think about MMT still acknowledge that if people believe they're being taxed to pay for things, they still kinda are. MMT is a guiding principle for policy, not something to tell individuals how their relationship with the state actually works (because most folks don't care).
eropple··on You've just inherited a legacy C++ codebase, now what?
> neither does the organization have to deal with the endless yak shaving over brace style and tool choice

I hear you, but an organization that fears this, instead of Just Pick Something And Deal With It, is an organization that probably doesn't have the right people in it to succeed at any task more arduous than that.

eropple··on Bluesky is rolling out Hashtags
Are you going to pay the freight for videos you consume, or for videos you post? Which one? (There is no third option.)
eropple··on Sky High Sabotage: Major Airlines Are Using TSA to Shut Down Competitor
> Is it possible the metal detectors are actually working and not just security theater?

The results have been consistently poor over a long period of time. Just one example: https://web.archive.org/web/20181009074941/http:/oversight.h...

It's possible that they are doing something for sure, but also possible they're just a tiger rock.

eropple··on Ryzen Z1's Tiny iGPU
AMD does seem to be trying new stuff with Strix Point Halo, but in-package RAM seems like it'd add new physical challenges that probably need a defined market before they swing for the fences?

Because it's not just the memory chip, also the interposer it's stacked on top of, which now needs to be bigger, which means you need to find more room in the PCB (today) or a bigger silicon interposer (likely in the near future) which reduces yields, and so on and so forth. If you wanted to have more than the very limited SoC RAM, you'd also then be looking at having multiple DRAM controllers, which also adds to surface area, and so on and so forth.

eropple··on I Spent a Week with Gemini Pro 1.5–It's Fantastic
You know that somebody can hold two thoughts in their head at once, yeah?

Green power is great! But there'll be limits to how much of that there is, too, and asking if pictures of hypothetical cats is a good use of that is also reasonable.

eropple··on Thanks FedEx, this is why we keep getting phished
It can, and I tried this, but in practice we have to change our passwords at my current employer so frequently that I got more irked changing it on the Yubikey (not the least hassle-free of processes, as I couldn't install the Yubikey software on the work machine) than just typing the thing.
eropple··on Thanks FedEx, this is why we keep getting phished
UPS is up there, too. I still get text messages about an old address on an account I can't log into for...reasons. (Special characters sound plausible! And of course the password reset flow doesn't work.)

Wonder if they share a vendor.

eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
Because it's funny.
eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
In such a case you absolutely should! At the same time, it makes sense that bsky, as the protocol stewards, might not want to make that pit too easy to fall into.
eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
Sure, but that's Scary(tm), because an unexpected viral skeet is going to cost you a lot of money. In this case I'd expect almost all video to be fraudulent--either in terms of pirated egress or in terms of disinfomation scams.
eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
By externalizing costs onto server owners, the same way they do everything.

It's not a good way to do it, though, and it's worse for Bluesky because it implies that in order to move your PDS (one of the best features of the design), you'd have to pick up the freight for video that already exists. If PDS mobility is important, attaching large economic strings to that is a big disincentive.

eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
I agree with this--and also, again, you have video, if you upload it to YouTube. Or stream via Twitch. Like, you don't need on-platform video. Google makes more money than God; let them pay for the perturbed bits.
eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
It's not storage, it's bandwidth. Most system providers, for Bad Reasons, charge a lot for egress; even relatively good ones like Cloudflare have particular payment shenanigans around video. Size uploads could help in that situation, but it's a bandaid on a bullet wound when the video still gets played a million times, y'know?
eropple··on Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters
Video is also prohibitively expensive outside of Google-scale endeavors and will likely crush both third-party BGSes and PDSes. Everyone doing video is either selling you ads (whether it's in that video or around it), selling you the video itself, or is losing money. Possibly all three.

As it is, og-embeds do work for video and audio from a few different providers.

eropple··on A Plea for Lean Software (1995)
> So one thing you could say is, well, every generation says that there were less strikeouts in third day. But there's actually data on this and..... it's true! Almost every decade, from the 1800s through every decade of the 1900s through now, strikeouts really have been going up year to year. And so that intergenerational commentary, well, it's describing a real thing that really is happening.

I agree with the factual observations in your post, but there's an additional bit here, and that there's qualitative value being assigned to what The Youths don't mind and The Olds protest. In baseball, the guys who strike out a lot but hit a ton of home runs create more runs, and therefore create more wins, than most base-hit machines (obvious outliers exist, but you get the idea). On my computer, VS Code does more things that benefit me than vim does (and the outlier here, I guess, would be "a lovingly crafted vim monstrosity that uses all the LSPs etc. designed for VS Code et al in the first place"--doable but not the happy path, etc.).

There's also (and IMO this is more in code than baseball) some kind of bizarre moral valence assigned, and that I don't even pretend to understand, but that's a different story.

eropple··on Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional
> If Roe was an actual law, it wouldn't have been overturned.

Nonsense and worse words. They aren't originalists, they don't care about the executive/legislative distinction. It's embarrassing farce to pretend that there is constitutional principle behind achieving their desired political goals. Roe would've been gutted were it law and the general incoherence of Alito and Thomas would have led the way.

eropple··on Amazon argues that national labor board is unconstitutional
> You don't lose your right not to be subject to arbitrary fines just because you incorporated.

One: NLRB rulings are "arbitrary" only if you somehow believe that a regulatory body, whose rulings can be appealed to an Article III court for redress, are intrinsically "arbitrary". Which is a quiet little hide-the-ball attempt at rhetoric.

Two: your fictive person provides the real people who've bought into it limited liability, which actual humans cannot avail themselves of. This is a superpower of your fictive person exists at the literal beneficience of the society that granted its charter; its bad behavior should be more readily addressed than the due process afforded to actual humans.

eropple··on We Have to Start Over: From Atom to Zed
The line between "IDE" and "text editor" has blurred to the point where I'm not sure they're super useful terms anymore. When I used vim up till about 2019, I had it configured with all the toys to the point where it wasn't all that far off of where my VSCode setup is today.

Also, you know, insert Emacs joke here assuming if you still have enough RAM to post, etc.

eropple··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
Thanks for the link! Maybe less thanks for the attitude, though--I'm well-versed in how these tools fail and nothing goes out the door without me evaluating it. (And, for my use cases? Generally pretty solid results, with failures being obvious ones that fail in my local and never even get to the deployed dev environment.)
eropple··on Our next-generation model: Gemini 1.5
Mindshare is part of enterprise sales, yes.

I work at a very large company and everyone knows about ChatGPT and Gemini (in part because we for our sins have a good chunk of GCP stuff), but I doubt anyone here not doing some LLM-flavored development has ever even heard of Anthropic, let alone Claude.

eropple··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
For just blasting a config out, I'm sure there are tons of problems. But (and I have not been to your forums, because...the project just works for me, it's great!) I've had a lot of success having GPT4 do the first-pass translation from nginx to Caddy. It's not perfect, but I do also know how to write a Caddyfile myself, I'm just getting myself out of the line-by-line business.
eropple··on Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescue Metals chairman
I'm not saying that the grandparent poster has the right of it, but this is a bizarre objection. Brazil had about a million more square miles of rainforest just four years ago. I'm sure that across the entire planet we could, yanno. Scrounge something up.
eropple··on Cousins are disappearing. Is this reshaping the experience of childhood?
It absolutely is worse than it has been in the "good places", though. Because we have more people, but not more good places.
eropple··on US rail safety legislation stalled one year after East Palestine Ohio disaster
So we're talking about transportation, and I guess I have to ask exactly what transportation infrastructure you then mean? Because the only serious, broad, federally-managed transportation infrastructure I can think of are like, military airbases. Which tend to be pretty good!

That's assuming, of course, you mean the US government--which does not own things like highways, for those unclear; it does have a controlling stake in Amtrak, but aside from the NEC (which is great IMO) Amtrak does not own the railways that actually serve as rail infrastructure. Because, of course, country governments elsewhere regularly own or have majority stakes in both railroads and railways, to pretty good success.

Or, on the other other hand, maybe you mean non-transporation infrastructure? 'Cause frankly, the US Postal Service was pretty great 'til "the government doesn't work and we're going to prove it by ripping out big chunks of it" politicians got their hands on it.

eropple··on Cousins are disappearing. Is this reshaping the experience of childhood?
Yes, of course! And it's reasonable to think that living in both modest precarity and isolation is worse than living in somewhat more severe precarity; "affordable" places to live are inferior goods!

The problem, fundamentally, is that we, collectively and as a country, need to create more good places, rather than to exile people to the bad but affordable ones. We need a concerted effort to have strong towns and to put cars at the edge and not the center of those towns in order to have a healthy community future, and just sneering that you can buy a house in the hinterlands is both non-responsive and cruel to boot.

eropple··on Cousins are disappearing. Is this reshaping the experience of childhood?
I've seen it but don't have it on hand. Urban prices certainly seem to have disconnected quite hard from suburban/rural ones, but even suburban/rural might not capture it. I grew up in a not-all-that-wealthy town in Maine about the same size as Watertown, NY--a little smaller actually; an empty half-acre lot there costs more than $120K. (I'd love to move back there, but a house the size of my Boston-area house costs the same as my Boston-area house...)
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →