HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

esonderegger

425 karma · joined December 25, 2011

personal site: https://rpy.xyz

twitter: @esonderegger

email: evan.sonderegger@gmail.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/esonderegger; my proof: https://keybase.io/esonderegger/sigs/HQt3aUZE4DakwdMinsXGfV5AIJfTb2uxi05grG956JI ]

submissionscomments
esonderegger··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (January 2015)
Location: Washington D.C.

Remote: Yes

Willing to relocate: Yes

Technologies:

    - Python:
        WebApps: Flask
        ORMs: SQLAlchemy
        Scripting: Subprocess
    - Javascript:
        DOM: jQuery
        Visualization: D3
        Experimental: Web Audio API
    - StyleSheets:
        Less: Bootstrap
        Sass: Bourbon/Neat/Bitters
    - AudioVideo:
        - Live Production
        - Streaming
        - Metadata Management
    - Robotics:
        - ROS
        - SLAM
        - OMPL
Résumé/CV: https://rpy.xyz/about.html

Email: evan.sonderegger@gmail.com

esonderegger··on Spreading a little Christmas job-hunting hope
Congratulations! It sounds like you've landed somewhere really good.

Thank you for reminding us not to give up. A lot of your story sounded familiar, although you were way more persistent than I was. I'm 33, and recently got rejected from two different bay area "dream job" companies after making it through several phone rounds in order to fly out for in-person interviews. The more recent of which, I got nervous the night before and only got three hours of sleep. The hardest part of that rejection was wondering "what if" I had been just a little bit sharper.

After the second rejection, I accepted a position with a small defense contractor near my home in Washington DC. The bureaucracy and mindless restriction are sources of endless frustration. The combination of billing by the hour and a long commute leave very little time and energy for keeping up the job search.

Reading your story reminds me I have very little to complain about. Thank you for posting. I'll use some of this time off to send out some more applications. Hope you have a great Christmas and good luck once the new job starts!

esonderegger··on SecureDrop
If anyone from WaPo visits here, you've got some typos on that page:

"Download and install the Tor browser bundle from Download and install the Tor browser bundle from https://www.torproject.org/" should be "Download and install the Tor browser bundle from https://www.torproject.org/"

"You will be provided with a codename that you will use it to log in to check for replies from The Post." should not have the word "it".

Otherwise, great work! I'm really glad that you're doing this and featuring it prominently on your home page.

esonderegger··on Show HN: Codementor Office Hours
Scrolling is completely broken for me on ios devices (both an ipad and an iphone 5c). Why is there so much temptation to mess with how the user scrolls?
esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
I didn't start working here until 2006, so I don't really know how they were purchased, but they didn't standardize on Mitsui MAM-A until 2002 or so. Before then, there was an assortment of gold media from different brands. The masters have been stored in standard jewel cases in drawers in our office.

I've also had great luck with the Taiyo Yuden CD-Rs. We go through about a thousand discs a year for people who prefer to have a CD copy of their music to being able to download a file, and I can't remember the last time I had a failure. However, now that our master copies are 24-bit wav files on network storage, I haven't been as concerned with how those discs have been aging.

I suppose we probably have enough samples for an interesting study on the longevity of optical media, but unfortunately I just don't see us having the time to devote to something like that.

esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
Yes, of course. However, backups != preservation. You could have a textbook backup strategy with restore drills and fixity checks making sure that your integrity is 100%. If your audio is stored in Sound Designer II files and your print documents are Word Perfect files, you are probably not being a good steward of your data.
esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
I didn't start working here until 2006, so I don't really know the details of what the process was like back then for testing discs after they had been burned. I assume at least a verification step was involved.

Now, when I want to see how bad a disc has gotten, I use PlexTools to do a Q-Check. However, we haven't considered anything on optical media to be a master copy for a while (at least five years). CDs only get burned when someone wants to listen to something in their car.

esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
Interesting. I hadn't heard of M-Disc. Thanks for the link!

The worry of not being able to find a device to read/play back your media is a common one for all storage types, analog and digital. For example, we have hundreds of reels of quarter inch tape from the fifties and sixties down in our library. The tapes themselves are safe (some may need a day in an easy-bake oven), but otherwise they still sound great. We recently had our Studer A-820 refurbished and it's probably in better than new condition, but I worry there won't be any people to do the service, or parts to do the service with if it needs attention in ten years.

The more obscure, the medium, the trickier it gets. We have a bunch of early digital recordings stored on Betamax tapes, that need both a working Betamax deck and a PCM encoder-decoder box in order to be read. Fortunately, those have all been transferred now.

This is why I'm a believer in thinking of maintaining an archive as being an active rather than static process. It's important to be periodically re-evaluating your digital assets to make sure they can be losslessly transferred to current file formats and modern storage media. It was probably never a good idea to simply "put it on a shelf and forget about it", but thankfully with digital assets, these migrations can be lossless, automated, and tested.

esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
I just went to the drawer to check - It appears as though most of the earliest CD-R discs were HHB gold archival discs. Some of them came from external mastering facilities, so would be on something else. Around 2002, they standardized on Mitsui MAM-A for the archival copies. Interesting enough, those discs have had very few issues.

It appears as though the early DVD-R discs were Mitsui MAM-A, with us switching over to Taiyo Yuden in early 2007. Since we have all that stuff on network storage, I haven't gone back to check how the Taiyo Yuden discs have fared over time.

esonderegger··on Amazon’s Glacier secret: BDXL?
Do BDXL discs have greater longevity than other types of optical media?

Back in 2000, our studio switched from archiving our audio recordings on DAT to CD-R. Thinking the greatest threats were loss and scratches, they made three copies of every disc and stored them in different locations. Around 2007, all of those CD-R discs started becoming unreadable around the same time.

Video recordings were archived to DVD-R starting in 2003 with the same three copy approach. In 2009, after having successfully rescued all our audio recordings on to RAID5 network attached storage, we weren't so lucky with saving our early DVD-R data.

I always assumed the reason DVD-R discs lasted less time than CD-R discs before chemical decomposition was because of the greater density, but I never looked into it enough to know for sure.

I have to imagine if Amazon is indeed doing this, they have some sort of plan in place to write all data to fresh optical media every five years or so. If so, that would create a very different cost equation.

esonderegger··on Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check
Thanks for suggesting DLNA! (Stuff like this is why I keep coming back to HN)

I spent the afternoon trying various different approaches with my Sony Blu-Ray player that has DLNA support. It appears to only want to play files, not live streams. That said, I haven't exhausted all options yet and will have more tools to test with at the office. And from a video engineering perspective, RTSP/RTMP or even HLS as native formats would be way easier.

esonderegger··on Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check
I tend to agree with you, with one minor exception. If you're going to put an ethernet jack on a TV anyway because people seem to like having Netflix apps on their tv, I'd love it if there were some basic "dumb" software as well, like an RTSP/RTMP client.

At work, we have five of these Samsung Smart TVs and if I want to get a video signal from my control room on to one of them, I have to send it via HD-SDI into the main video router, then run coax from the router to the tv, then use an SDI to HDMI adapter (the cheapest of which is the monoprice $100 one). The picture ends up looking great, but it doesn't exactly feel like 2014.

esonderegger··on Good laptops for Linux
I dual boot Ubuntu 13.04 and OSX on my 13" rMBP. The hi-dpi issue really doesn't bother me at all. (I run the display at 1680x1050 - the only thing that shows up really tiny is the splash screen)

The install was easy enough. Setting up refit was pretty easy. The only slightly complicated issue was putting the wifi and other proprietary drivers on a thumb drive because the rMBP doesn't have an ethernet port.

My only gripe with this setup is, because I run it about 60% OSX/40% Ubuntu, is that I'm really only happy in Ubuntu when I have a USB mouse plugged in. I haven't figured out how to make ctrl-click equal right click and I'm one of those who likes to two finger scroll inverted (like an iPad), but use the scroll wheel on a mouse in the traditional direction. If anyone has figured out a magic solution to MBP trackpads in Linux, I'd love to hear it.

esonderegger··on Confessions of an Intermediate Programmer
I'm sure I'm not the only one who got down the road to overscoped features by saying "gee, wouldn't it be cool if my users could access this info that's living in a mysql table" and threw something together with a little php mysql_query(SELECT...), and it worked! except for some edge cases with non-ascii characters and the fact that you knew you were opening yourself up to SQL injection attacks, but you weren't really concerned because you only have 100 users and they're already authenticated by a more robust system. Anyway, you decide to do it the "right way" and rewrite it using SQLAlchemy. In the mean time, your coworkers wonder why you've burned half a day rewriting a feature that worked just fine after you had only been spending 30 minutes on it.

Sorry, that was a long way of pointing out that us novice programmers often don't have good methods of determining how long something should take because we've never done it before.

esonderegger··on Confessions of an Intermediate Programmer
What's worked for you all for making the leap from lone programmer to working on a team with a mentor/people who are smarter than you?

I ask this as someone somewhere between "beginner" and "intermediate". I've used git on a bunch of projects, but normally get hung up with branches or with trying to undo changes. Even harder than version control, I think, is getting a lone beginner programmer to write tests. When I'm writing something, it's always tricky figuring out exactly what it is I should be testing. When time is a limiting factor, it's hard to get from "I know I should be doing this" to actually doing this.

When you are good enough to make your own projects work the way you want them to work, but not good enough to contribute to the open source projects you actually use, how do you break out of your bad habits that you know you will need to break when part of a team/large project?

esonderegger··on Apple is shutting down OpenNI
This is when I'm especially thankful for open source licenses. The OpenNI2 repository on github currently has 148 forks:

https://github.com/OpenNI/OpenNI2

I've been using OpenNI2 with ROS and an ASUS Xtion Pro Live for object detection and avoidance. What I think the community is missing is missing right now isn't really on the software side, but is good, cheap, hardware. I'd be thrilled if I could buy a Carmine or something like it from Apple, but I don't see how it makes any business sense.

esonderegger··on Google Acquires Boston Dynamics
I highly recommend watching a talk given by Erik Nieves from Motoman at the most recent RosCon because he talks about the state of the robotics industry and why this "gap" exists in a very accessible way.

http://vimeo.com/67044628

Two reasons why I think the gap between getting started and being able to build something useful exists is that robot parts are still much more expensive than we expect them to be and the fundamentals of robot movement are much more difficult to learn than we expect them to be. Unfortunately, I think those two factors discourage a lot of engineers early on and is why the size of this community is so small.

I feel very fortunate that I have a Kuka YouBot to hack on. The company I'm trying to get started with two friends wrote a proposal that got accepted into the sponsored track of a competition Kuka is running. (http://www.kuka-labs.com/en/network/innovationaward/) After setting it up, it's clear why this is a 20,000€ robot. But before you can actually DO anything useful with it, you have to be able to understand kinematics and dynamics as well as how to get path planners to talk to controllers. And then the really powerful stuff becomes possible once you incorporate computer vision, which is also not an easy topic to understand. It not surprising that most of this work is being done at universities by grad students.

The state of ROS today feels a lot like what Linux felt like to me back in the late 90's. There are lots of issues with dependencies and programs not compiling correctly. Documentation is severely lacking. But there's lots of enthusiasm from very friendly people to help each other work to make things better.

What makes me worry is that many of the advances in ROS came from Willow Garage and Google is buying up many of the companies that spun out of Willow whereas a lot was made possible in computer vision due to the sensors made by PrimeSense, which was just acquired by Apple. I hope the Google vs Apple rivalry doesn't slow the pace of progress in open source robotics that was making the dawn of non-industrial robotics seem not so far away.

esonderegger··on Ask HN: So what's the job market like for generalists, really?
Thank you! When my Marine Corps contract expires in about ten months I'm going to be looking and both the advice to try AngelList and the confidence that it will be alright will be a huge help.
esonderegger··on Poll: Do you use antivirus software?
I have a HTPC running Windows 7 that has Microsoft Security Essentials installed (mostly to stop it from bugging me). My audio/video editing machine is a Mac without any antivirus software installed. And my development machine is running Ubuntu LTS without any antivirus. What's awkward is I don't even know which option to upvote.
esonderegger··on Storage for Photographers
I really wish we as a developer community would better differentiate between "backup" and "preservation". They are both related to storage, but are fundamentally different problems. The article touches on the desire to have photos safe for decades, but doesn't really get into the strategy necessary to make that happen.

If we care about decades, storing the raw NEF or CR2 file is almost certainly the wrong approach. Those files could easily be as difficult to open in fifteen years as a ClarisWorks document is today (just to choose one example - proprietary formats for professional software from the late 90's are all pretty hard to open today). Also, important metadata is kept in the lrcat file. Unless we expect to always be able to open our copies of Lightroom, we need to migrate that data too.

We used to think of "archiving" as putting something on a shelf and forgetting about it, sometimes taking environmental factors like humidity into account. With our digital data, we need a plan for periodically checking it, both for fixity and to make sure at risk file formats are migrated to current best practices. This will require greater awareness for the complexities involved (and the need for open file formats) from everyone from creatives to storage and service providers.

By the way, every creative industry is struggling with this right now. Recording studios have session files created in ProTools 4. Designers have really old Quark files, even though they've been working in InDesign for the past five years. Composers have Finale files. A lot of these file formats depend on plugins to be able to display properly. I don't mean to sound discouraging, I think there's plenty of opportunities for viable businesses here. We just need to start using the right terms.

esonderegger··on Netflix no longer issuing new API keys
Agreed! I wasn't aware of canistream.it until reading this thread and I'm very impressed with it.

I think if I was aware of that site when I started moviepresto, I wouldn't have built it. But, then again, I wouldn't have learned the things I learned in the process.

esonderegger··on Netflix no longer issuing new API keys
This doesn't surprise me, but it does make me sad because I think it's a short-sighted move that will hurt Netflix in the long run.

Full disclosure: my side-project (which I have woefully neglected of late: http://moviepresto.com) uses the Netflix API to determine if a movie is available on Netflix Instant or as a disc rental and then links accordingly. The title, description, basic info, and background image come from themoviedb.org. Personally, I'd prefer for my "what do I want to watch tonight?" decision start with the set of everything that's been released and then follow to "where is that available?", instead of starting with "what is available to watch on platform X?". My cynical side tells me that Netflix doesn't just want to be the center of the online streaming universe; they want to BE the universe.

Even more sadly, I think Netflix won't even realize what they are missing out on: potential user interface improvements that they could incorporate into their own products, ideas for integration they never would've thought of, potential great hires, etc.

esonderegger··on Introducing Roku 3
Has anyone here done any app developing for the Roku? Does this open up new avenues for that, or is it the same SDK as before?

I remember taking a brief look at the SDK a few years ago and deciding that it was too much of a mess for me to work with it and keep my sanity.

esonderegger··on Steal These Freelance Business Ideas
For those of you that hire video producers, how do you go about selecting who you work with?

Since I'm coming from a career as an audio and video engineer into the startup world, this would seem like an obvious area to do some freelancing, but it also seems like a chicken and egg problem with finding work and having demos/references.

esonderegger··on Disney announces Wreck-It Ralph will arrive for download before DVD, Blu-ray
I'm a little confused. This community (myself included) often complains about how we wish Hollywood would release their movies as DRM-free files. But then some of us say that the "purchase" price is too high and we want a "rental" option.

How exactly would this work? Would the movie studios ask you nicely to remove the file from your computer after three days? I'd love to hear a technical answer that contradicts this, but don't see how a DRM-free rental could ever be possible.

esonderegger··on Google Play comes to Google Apps: Enterprises can distribute apps internally
This is perfect timing for a video streaming solution I've been working on.

I'm trying to build a video capture program and a google tv app that talk to each other so I can stream video around our LAN. The video capture box would probably be in the $1000 range. Then each tv that wants to see that stream would only need a $100 Vizio Google TV box and the private android app. Now that I know I can build an app that won't be in the public Play store, but will be accessible easily to accounts on our domain, I can make that app much more specific.

I could see this being really popular with companies who use a lot of TVs for signage. The first thing that comes to mind for me is all the TVs in airports showing departure and arrival information.

esonderegger··on Git over FTP
That would make way too much sense.

The server hosting the public-facing site is across town (where the sysadmin works). The RDP step is for getting from our network to a non-public-facing machine that is physically right next to the public-facing machine.

Then, at two or three pre-appointed times during the week, the sysadmin transfers the contents of a folder onto a usb hard drive, and then eventually where it needs to go.

I suppose it's time to start reading the "Who is hiring" threads a little more closely.

esonderegger··on Git over FTP
My organization's public-facing website is on a .mil domain.

Our sysadmins tell us that for compliance reasons, any server-side processing is prohibited and right now the only way to update the site is a combination of RDP and sneakernet. But, until recently, we could update it via ftp. (they got in trouble for it during our last inspection, hence the sneakernet)

I've been playing with the idea of building a new site for our public affairs folks (the ones who are responsible for content) based on pelican or jekyll. Using a static site generator will get us around the no server-side problem, but there is still the problem of needing to transfer an entire site's worth of data avery time there is a small edit made. If we still had ftp access to our server, this would solve that problem.

esonderegger··on Show HN: Simple BitTorrent Magnet Link search
For those interested in a legit variation on this theme, check out http://www.moviepresto.com

Pretty much every movie out on video is available via one of the online platforms (currently iTunes, Amazon Instant, Netflix, and Redbox), but availability outside the US is still frustrating.

esonderegger··on The Pirate Bay - 9 years and still bloody runnin
I actually really like your idea of comparing the choice of DRM-encumbered vs DRM-free files to choices we make with respect to how our food is produced.

I think many Americans have a general idea that the food they eat is the product of a corporate farming system that can be pretty sketchy. We expect the government to get involved when the practices of food producers create a food safety issue, but otherwise we leave it up to consumers to choose. And some consumers do choose to buy grass-fed beef, free-range chickens, and organic produce, and pay extra for it.

There are probably some parallels to be drawn with respect to product labeling. (Should Amazon and iTunes be forced to warn consumers that the movie they're about to buy includes some type of DRM?)

More importantly, though, both of these situations require consumers to be educated in order to make informed decisions about which product to buy. If we as a culture want our farming system to be more humane to animals and better stewards of the earth, we need to teach our peers how to read food labels and understand what they mean. If we as a technical community want DRM to not be forced into the files we buy, we need to educate our peers on the drawbacks of DRM and persuade them to make it an issue.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →