HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

etiennemarcel

107 karma · joined June 15, 2018

submissionscomments
etiennemarcel··on Startup Nation? Entrepreneurs Still Toil in Macron's France
Bureaucracy is not an issue in my opinion. I've ran a successful business in France and if you have a good accountant (and lawyer for some particular issues), it's not anymore difficult than in the US. As an individual, compare how hard it is to make your tax return in the US and in France...
etiennemarcel··on CLIP OS – France’s cybersecurity agency’s open source, secured operating system
"in the pocket"? as in the literal translation of "c'est dans la poche" (meaning "I got this, it's easy")
etiennemarcel··on French bookshops revolt after prize selects novel self-published on Amazon
Well we have Carrefour (second largest retail store chain after Walmart).

I understand your position from an American point of view but I don't agree with it. What you see as unnecessary regulation we see as the right way of governing, and what you see as protecting dying industries we see as preserving a way of life.

Since 1981 (or so) the price of books has been fixed by law. Nobody can sell them lower than that price. If you walk through Paris (or most cities) you'll see a number of small library shops that contribute to local economy and culture. I find that very nice!

Other retail industries have not been so lucky. Many smaller towns (10-50k inhabitants) have seen their city centers die out because of large outlets opening outside of town, and because of Amazon. I guess you could the say that the free market has decided what was the future. But these cities have become dead towns, people have moved to the suburbs, contributing to sprawl and car pollution. Social life has been reduced, and a recent study showed that the far right/protest vote was higher there. Today the political opinion is starting to shift and there's talk of more regulation to try and preserve smaller cities.

Anyway, there's a lot more that could be said in this eternal debate between the "American" and "European" point of view. But I mean we're not Soviet Russia. We may not have Facebook (I can live with that) or Apple (that would be nicer), but regulations are only part of the issue. And we're not clinging to some antiquated world view, we're just trying to make sure change doesn't crush people too fast.

etiennemarcel··on Life in the Spanish city that banned cars
What Paris could have looked like if Pompidou had his way in the 70s: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plan_autoroutier_pour_Paris
etiennemarcel··on EU to stop changing the clocks in 2019
"Funny" story about that... We switched to Berlin time when Paris was occupied in 1940. We didn't go back to GMT after the war.
etiennemarcel··on Why Is College in America So Expensive?
The French system is fairly complex, it's not single payer. To sum up, for "everyday" health issues the public health insurance reimburses 70%. For grave long-term illnesses, you're covered 100%.

You're supposed to have a private health insurance (it's now mandatory for all employees) that reimburses the remaining 30% and all extra costs. That includes some dental and optical work, but also stuff like single-bed rooms in the hospital. Your additional private insurance also covers doctors charging more than the "official" price.

etiennemarcel··on Why Is College in America So Expensive?
At least in France, it's both. The cost for the patient is usually low thanks to the health insurance, but also because of price control. A GP visit is 25 euros by law, covered from 70 to 100% depending on your insurance. Doctors can choose to charge more but then patients need better private insurances to be reimbursed.

You can find the price lists here:

* https://www.ameli.fr/paris/medecin/exercice-liberal/facturat... * https://www.ameli.fr/paris/medecin/exercice-liberal/facturat...

etiennemarcel··on Why Is College in America So Expensive?
From a European point of view I have a hard time understanding your opinion.

In other countries, regulated/public healthcare works better and is more efficient than your system, it's hard to deny it... I don't see how doubling down on cutting regulations would solve anything.

In a way it reminds me of the gun control issue: the idea that deregulating gun ownership and carrying will make everybody safer seems so absurd from abroad... I guess it's cultural.

etiennemarcel··on I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d like to pass on
The number is actually pretty high (around 1800 soldiers deserting every year): https://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2018/04/17/le-temps-d...
etiennemarcel··on I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d like to pass on
The "opération Sentinelle" (the soldiers patrolling in France) is mostly for the show... It's currently the most expensive military operation run in France, and is one of the main factors in the rise of desertion in the army. The only time these soldiers had to fire was to protect themselves, since they are magnets for wannabe terrorists or crazy people...
etiennemarcel··on EU copyright reform: the facts
Ethnic statistics are not totally forbidden, they're very strongly regulated. http://www.liberation.fr/checknews/2018/01/16/est-ce-que-les...

Yet if tomorrow these statistics were allowed and were to show (for example) that 50% of people in jail are Muslim, what would be the use of that number? The far left would use it as proof of discrimination and the far right that muslims are a danger to society.

Societies like the US where there's a "race" checkbox on forms and where ethnic statistics are legal, are far from being less racist or discriminatory...

etiennemarcel··on India court legalises gay sex in landmark ruling
In 81 homosexuality was taken off the mental illnesses list, that's probably what you're thinking of.
etiennemarcel··on Why Technology Favors Tyranny
The 1830 revolution is also missing, or the revolt against the 1851 coup... Yet minor incidents from last year protests are on the list.
etiennemarcel··on Naked Europe covers up
The de Funès movies (gendarme) are still on French TV at least once a year and nobody cares about the nudity. We don't really have the same puritanism when it comes to nudity or profanity on TV.
etiennemarcel··on How America Killed Transit
That's a very American point of view.

Here in Paris, public transit is run by the state since the war and works really well. It's going to be open to private concessions in a few years (buses first, subway in 20 or 30 years) because of European regulations, I'm not sure it will change for the better...

etiennemarcel··on Air-conditioners do great good, but at a high environmental cost
2003 was a wake up call. The heat wave this year was the second hottest since 2003 and there have been a lot fewer deaths (at least in France). People are better informed and the health professionals are better prepared.
etiennemarcel··on Insured, but Still Owing $109K for a Heart Attack
Yet the administrative costs of Medicare or the French healthcare system are much lower than private insurances. I'm not sure the government is that inefficient...
etiennemarcel··on The First Photo of a Human Being, and How the Scene's Changed from 180 Years Ago
A better before/after taken from the same location: http://www.niepce-daguerre.com/boulevard_du_Temple_de_dag.ht...
etiennemarcel··on What makes Paris look like Paris? (2012)
ZAC rive gauche, Batignolles, Chapelle International, Bercy-Charenton, Rosa Parks... That's quite a lot of room for experimentation and new neighborhoods.
etiennemarcel··on What makes Paris look like Paris? (2012)
Actually, the whole point of the new subway lines (especially line 15, which will go around the city through close suburbs) is densification. City planners want to avoid the city going further and further in the countryside and want to have denser hubs (around new stations) closer to the city.
etiennemarcel··on What makes Paris look like Paris? (2012)
And yet most arrondissements have densities similar or greater than Manhattan (28k / km2): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrondissements_of_Paris#Arron...
etiennemarcel··on What makes Paris look like Paris? (2012)
What's interesting about your examples (Place d'Italie, Montparnasse, Berges de Seine) is that these neighborhoods are considered as the ugliest and seen as mistakes from the 1960/70s. They were part of projects to rebuild the whole city, along with highways that would cut through Paris. I'm pretty sure everybody today is happy those plans were cancelled.

It's no wonder we're kind of vaccinated against towers... I could add to the list: place des fêtes, Olympiades, les Orgues de Flandres...

etiennemarcel··on What makes Paris look like Paris? (2012)
It's not true at all. The central arrondissements are (for some part) well preserved, but once you go a little further you'll see that most buildings have been destroyed and replaced since the 50s. There are few highrise, but Paris is already very dense and it wouldn't really be able to support these buildings.

Since a few years there's a construction boom in and around the city. With the new subway lines to come (greater Paris), new neighborhoods are built everywhere.

Your vision of Paris is at least 50 years old...

etiennemarcel··on How air-conditioning created the modern city
Upper floor apartments were cheaper because they were meant for working-class people. The ground level and first floor were for shops and shopkeepers. The 2nd floor (that would be the 3rd flood in American terms) was the "noble" floor for rich people, with high ceilings and big balconies. The last floor under the roof was for housekeepers and cooks of the rich people below.

Obviously there were no elevators.

etiennemarcel··on The Ascetic Beauty of Brancusi
When Brancusi died, he left his workshop to the French state. It has been rebuilt right in front of the Centre Pompidou and can be visited for free, it's very interesting!
etiennemarcel··on World’s longest palindrome?
Georges Perec in 1969: http://homepage.urbanet.ch/cruci.com/lexique/palindrome.htm (1247 words)
etiennemarcel··on Uber Hit with Cap as New York City Takes Lead in Crackdown
I'm not saying one model (national companies) is always better than the other (private ventures). But I was trying to show that it's mostly a management issue, the MTA seems to be terribly mismanaged, while its French counterpart is not that bad. Even though it has its own challenges.
etiennemarcel··on Uber Hit with Cap as New York City Takes Lead in Crackdown
It was the same in Paris (CMP and Nord-Sud), until the subway was nationalized after the war. And yet there are still major investments...

You could say the same for the national railway network, it's a state company and it didn't prevent investments and improvements (high speed trains).

etiennemarcel··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
We've had a subway for more than a hundred years, it's not exactly a new development.
etiennemarcel··on It took a long time for de Gaulle to become ‘de Gaulle’
Why is that surprising? Until the 90s France had a nuclear triad, but the land component was dropped. We used to have more warheads, but still need quite a few to keep global coverage through submarines and aircrafts...
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →