HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewjordan

2,337 karma · joined July 7, 2008

submissionscomments
ewjordan··on “For Rent” signs are popping up all over Portland
The median family income in Portland (the city proper, not the metro area) was $77k in 2015 according to http://www.deptofnumbers.com/income/oregon/portland/. $1500/month is totally within the bounds of the typical 40:1 income to rent ratio, so it's unsurprising that available rents tend to be in that range. If you want something cheaper than that, then yes, it's going to be low-end.

I'm not really sure what you're hoping for. Rents were creeping further upwards until building started to catch up with people moving in, and now they're coming down.

Are you really trying to argue that the best move, in light of this evidence, is to build less?

ewjordan··on “For Rent” signs are popping up all over Portland
Yes, but a lot of people, for various reasons, either believe that econ 101 arguments don't apply in this situation or that even if they do, the effects of building market rate housing are still undesirable.

Their actual stated arguments tend to be delivered in unconvincing ways, but Julia Galef (who I gather does believe in the econ 101 take) took a stab at steelmanning that side in https://juliagalef.com/2017/07/13/should-we-build-lots-more-..., and it's definitely worth a read.

What I'd add to her points is a fourth, that while some people believe that either overall affordability or total number of below market rate units are the right metrics to measure success by, some people care more about the percentage of affordable units than the number. An extreme version of the argument says that having 100 affordable units out of 200 total is better than having 200 affordable units out of 1000 total, because the second scenario will mean a strong demographic shift in the neighborhood (a "whitening"), not to mention an increase in density that will change the feel of the area. This is not an economic argument, but one about values, so it's not going to be resolved by numbers.

ewjordan··on Why Does the Neocortex Have Columns? A Theory of Learning Structure of the World [pdf]
Not sure whether that was a jab at Numenta or not, but I do think the combination of these two comments cuts to the heart of the PR problem for Numenta: they're neither trying to do 0.1% better on the classic perception benchmarks than other algorithms do, nor trying to publish accurate, testable descriptions of the true details of meatspace neuroscience.

To me, exploring alternative network architectures and algorithms seems an extremely worthwhile goal even if it's only loosely tethered to actual biology, but from a PR perspective they really need to be better about priming the conversation if they want people to care.

Bad (neuroscience-focused): "We're doing a lot of research on neuroscience, and finding some really interesting stuff, so we built a model that doesn't exactly match the way the brain works but is still interesting. No, we haven't tried to make it work to classify ImageNet test cases, that's not our goal. But look, it's closer to biology, and we have working code that we're playing with!"

Better (ML-focused): "We're developing a novel neural network architecture that performs online unsupervised learning using only local update rules. Though it performs competently at classic benchmarks X, Y, and Z when a small WTA layer is thrown on top, it can also tackle problems A, B, and C that classical deep learning networks can't make any progress on."

To be fair, I'm not even sure if Numenta's networks could perform competently at any classic benchmarks (I'm guessing that if they could, it would take some work to get them to do so), and I have no idea what new problems it could work on. But they really do need to reframe the conversation and emphasize that sort of innovation if they want to be taken more seriously - focusing on neuroscience underpinnings is not a great move if they're not engaged in research that can actually win over neuroscientists, and just pointing out that they're focusing on those things is not a way to win over industry ML folks if they don't have any results to point at.

ewjordan··on Newfound Wormhole Allows Information to Escape Black Holes
Only in strict GR - when quantum effects are taken into account, the entire black hole will evaporate into Hawking radiation in a finite time.
ewjordan··on A Theory of Sequence Memory in Neocortex
In this article they're using the word "dendrite" to mean a bit more than just an input to a neuron (which does exist in NN models) - one of the often criticized simplifications of most neural net models is that they don't account for the structure and function of the entire dendritic tree. Specifically, in the image you're referencing in the article they point out that synapses very near the soma directly cause action potentials, whereas further out they will cause some depolarization but not actually cause the cell to fire.

The way some authors explain it is that you can think of a neuron as really having an entire neural net embedded inside of it (based on the structure and function of the dendritic tree), that does some non-trivial amount of information processing even before you consider the connectivity of neurons to each other. Exactly how non-trivial that is is a deeper question, but it's worth noting that these structures are extremely plastic, and change over timescales of seconds to minutes, so it's not hard to imagine that these details are significant.

ewjordan··on Uber is charging drivers to work
Do you think removing the option of working for Uber would make things better for the steamrolled?

If so, then why are they choosing to work for Uber instead of doing whatever they'd be doing if Uber wasn't around? Are you saying that they're stupid or being tricked?

If not, then isn't the world a better place for those people with Uber as an option?

ewjordan··on Keyboard latency
"the most ergonomic keyboards are those that require the least amount of repetitive motion"

Not sure I can agree with that. I was using one of the Apple keyboards for quite a long time while running liveops on an online game (which meant rapid response whenever incidents happened, jumping into shells and constantly typing like my life depended on it), and developed fairly severe wrist problems within a couple months. To the point where I almost had to leave the job on disability, per my doctor's orders.

On the recommendation of a friend, before taking that step I tried switching to a Kinesis Advantage for the better wrist alignment and less "hard" keystroke bottom as compared to the chiclets on the Apple keyboard. It was a bit of a learning curve (~2 weeks to get up to full typing speed when using it every day, a couple more to push past it), but at the end of it my wrists got better almost instantly, and I never had problems again. My typing speed went up as well.

I'm not sure how much of that improvement is due to the better alignment of keys (there's almost no hand movement when typing, and your wrists are always neutral) and how much is due to the bigger key action and softer bottom, to be fair.

Edit: it's worth mentioning that I'm also a boxer and a piano player, so my wrists take a lot of abuse on a regular basis. YMMV and if you're not having problems, I definitely found the Apple keyboards to be very easy and fast to use.

ewjordan··on Handmade Hero – A complete game live-coded from scratch
I'd recommend making at least three games and shipping them on existing engines before trying to write your own. That's the best way to figure out what is and isn't a must-have feature.

Beyond that, if you're interested in physics look up everything Erin Catto has written about the design and implementation of Box2d.

ewjordan··on The Depression Thing
Is there actual research that shows that the sleep/eat/exercise approach works by itself for everyone that is compliant? Most of the psychiatric community would absolutely agree that it helps, or couldn't hurt, but (anecdotally) I know athletes that control all of that stuff like a science because they have to in order to compete, but still suffer from depression, so I have trouble believing that's all there is to it.
ewjordan··on Brain vs. Deep Learning (2015)
No, that's a misunderstanding of what hypercomputation is.

If you can write down or talk yourself through a proof of why a program will halt, you have solved a computable problem. By definition. When you say "we can decide a whole lot of programs halt", you're talking about plain Jane computation.

If you have knowledge that any program that I give you will or will not halt, then you're a hypercomputing oracle for the halting problem, and you can do magic, basically.

There's a world of difference between the two situations. And I'm fairly sure (but not positive) that there's no way for you to prove in finite space and time that you are an oracle for the halting problem.

Edit: for more on that last bit, see https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/19f9/0c34cdda43efdcf0831b2f...

ewjordan··on Brain vs. Deep Learning (2015)
I think I tend to agree (and actually, the author does, as well), the interesting question is whether we've been underestimating the number of artificial "neurons" we'll need. If each biological neuron is actually essentially implementing an entire neural net internally, then we might be a lot further from achieving that amount of computation than we expected.

We absolutely need to start doing what you're suggesting, and figuring out how to derive useful basic structures, represent them, and construct networks using those as the building blocks. My prediction is that's where the field will go over the next 5-10 years, a much deeper dive into how to specify connectivity and usefully control it than has been done so far (we're still using fully connected layers, for the most part, which we know is not a scalable approach as we go from thousands to millions of nodes).

ewjordan··on Brain vs. Deep Learning (2015)
Please at least read the Wikipedia articles on computability (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computability) and hypercomputation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercomputation) before making arguments like this. There is literally zero evidence that anything in our known universe can perform hypercomputation - and that includes all quantum mechanical effects that we've been able to measure. So the Bayesian prior for human intelligence being computable is somewhere near 100%, and it would take very, very extreme evidence to contradict that.

"Is it true there is no truth?" is not even close to a compelling argument, there are rigorously defined notions of truth within any of the eminently computable logical frameworks that we use.

ewjordan··on Brain vs. Deep Learning (2015)
Nobody has ever established that human intelligence is not computable. Human intelligence can't solve any of the well-defined problems you mention, or transcend the limitations of any of those theorems. Don't mistake the idea of an idealized perfect intelligence with the very limited and finite ones that we actually possess. Asking what God could do always leads to madness.

Some of what you mention are what I consider non-well-defined philosophical problems, which really have no bearing on the ability to create algorithms that could pass the Turing test and are outside of the scope of a discussion on the practicality of creating AGI.

ewjordan··on Brain vs. Deep Learning (2015)
The key to the claim that other computational estimates are way off is essentially that there's a lot of data crunching happening within a single neuron, rather than it being something we can model as collecting a bunch of inputs and either firing or not. He's arguing that each neuron does a ton of internal computation that can itself be modeled as a (sometimes very large) convolutional network.

I think in a sense this is well-established when looking at real neurons, but several times in the article he uses phrases like "shown to be important for information processing", and that's where I get off the boat a bit. When you're saying that it's so important for information processing that it warrants a 1000x or more increase in the computational power necessary to implement an algorithm, I think it's necessary to dig into what the actual work being done there is, not just that there's some non-trivial transformation. A lot of interesting and extremely tough to model fluid and chemical dynamics are in play when I drink too much water and have to pee, but that doesn't mean that we need to understand them to build a waste disposal system using pipes.

In particular, does the within-neuron processing actively tune itself based on the data it processes to an extent on-par with inter-neuron connections (in which case the argument that it's fundamental to the learning process would hold a lot more weight), or is it mostly static? I think a lot of us consider "important for information processing" to mean "is a meaningfully dynamic parameter involved in a learning algorithm", rather than an accidental shmearing of data.

I'd really love more info on what the actual processing that's happening is.

ewjordan··on Apple does right by users and advertisers are displeased
We all just click through cookie popups, the specific text doesn't make any difference to 99% of users, if not more.

The only thing legislation like that does is make companies pay people like me a little more to implement popups that annoy their users.

ewjordan··on What, exactly, do philosophers do?
The scientific misunderstandings are extremely offensive at times, too: a philosophy professor teaching metaphysics at Yale a long while back once offered a completely serious argument against relativity of simultaneity by snapping his right fingers, then snapping his left, and saying "whatever the physicists want to say, one of those snaps obviously happened before the other". When I objected that physicists would agree with him, because light cones yadda yadda, he cut me off because I was "getting into the weeds" (isn't that the point?!!?). The next topic was one vs many, where he cherry picked just enough offhand quantum mechanical commentary from Wheeler and Feynman to argue that maybe it was all just one electron going back and forth through time, and that was about when I lost all faith in the field.

That said, metaphysics is pretty much the worst of philosophy, because it has been so thoroughly rendered useless by all that we've actually learned about the physical world. Other subfields are substantially more interesting and less underinformed.

ewjordan··on Tell Google: Stop Killing Monopoly Research
So...it's evil for Google to not want to fund a group that has people actively working towards hurting Google's business interests?

Meh.

Find a hand to feed you that's not the one you're currently trying to bite. There are plenty out there, you'll be fine.

ewjordan··on Let’s Use Hard Science to Help Tech Companies Advance Women
That we don't acknowledge every drug addict that we walk by does not mean that we don't care or are not acting in many ways to attempt to help them. It just means that stopping and giving cash every time we pass them is not a helpful approach; giving money to good charities and advocacy for better city policies does much more.

I'd also mention that interacting with some homeless people can be dangerous and deadly. I've been attacked a few times while living in SF because I used to have a rule of engaging the homeless as normal people if they approached me, back when I had naive principles; I don't do that anymore, after being assaulted twice, once with a knife. While only a small percentage of the homeless are dangerous, that small percentage really do kill people (3 murders via homeless-on-local violence within a block of my place over the past few years), so anyone can go fuck themselves if you think I'm being heartless for not engaging anymore. Self preservation trumps compassion.

ewjordan··on Let’s Use Hard Science to Help Tech Companies Advance Women
I actually think the next comment is more meaningful as an explanation:

One other key factor that hasn't been mentioned yet: Harvey Mudd requires all first-year students to take their intro CS course

I've been arguing for a long time that simply forcing everyone to try CS (the way we force everyone to try math, English, history, etc) would go a long way towards closing these gaps. I think it's fantastic that they're doing that.

ewjordan··on 83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey
When a good is in limited supply, yes, it's trivially true that increasing supply will allow more people to use that good. That is not the same as saying that more supply will drive up demand or prices, merely that more of the existing demand will be met.

The difference between housing and cars-on-the-road is that housing is generally seen as a positive thing that people get real value out of, whereas cars-on-the-road are an unfortunate side effect of people not having housing near where they live. We explicitly want fewer people to drive into our cities; on the contrary we want more people living in housing near where they want to be.

To put it another way, if you really think that building more housing will make things worse, then why not argue for the destruction of existing housing stock to make things better?

Or do you think we're at a peak, where we have built just the right amount of housing and we should just leave it alone? I guess there probably is some amount that's just right for each city, though I have no idea what we'd have to look at to figure out that number.

ewjordan··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
Google's hiring rate between men and women does seem to match the relative rates that men and women graduate with CS degrees, which suggests that they're at least not discriminating at that level.

There are still arguments to be made that either more aggressively recruiting women (fattening their pipeline, even if it's zero-sum versus other players in the field) or accepting a higher rate (yes, "lowering the bar", which most colleges do quite aggressively and people seem mostly okay with) could be positive moves on many axes.

More productive overall measures involve equalizing the educational pipeline, which IMO is the real solution. Google invests heavily in that, too, though, so I'm pretty happy with their multi-pronged approach.

ewjordan··on We need to document macOS
Documentation effort towards OSX would help vastly more people than similar efforts for any flavor of Linux, which nobody plus epsilon uses (except amongst devs).

Impact is a big factor in how useful an activity is, even if it's tied to a big company.

ewjordan··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
Just to clarify, my comment is not meant to defend poor hiring practices in any way, I'm very much in favor of agressive efforts to improve diversity numbers (including heavy affirmative action). I just get bothered by the use of the term "white" to refer to groups with heavy Asian representation; these groups have vastly different experiences than whites do, and lumping them all together just because they're present in tech and tend to be financially successful is a dangerous oversimplification. The systematic problems go much deeper than people just hiring people that look like they do, if that was the whole problem we'd have achieved parity a long time ago.
ewjordan··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
Without digging too deep into the rest of this issue, do you consider Asian men white? Or is the situation a little more complicated than white men only choosing their own?
ewjordan··on The first Bitcoin Cash block has been mined
I don't follow this stuff closely, so I'm clearly missing an important detail here: how can several different entities simultaneously have the ability to "easily" control 51% of the hashrate?
ewjordan··on Judge rules Utah law banning undercover farm filming is unconstitutional
Given that you're all over this thread, do you have any connections in the farm industry? Or is this just an issue that you randomly feel strongly about?
ewjordan··on Oral sex producing unstoppable bacteria
There's a ton of overlap with the people that stop taking antibiotics once they feel better rather than finishing the course (and thus have them sitting around, and decide to take them the next time anything at all is wrong). In some cases doctors will also relent and just write a "get out of my face" prescription to shut a hypochondriac up, but that's more rare these days because most realize how bad an idea that is (in the past, it was considered fairly harmless to prescribe a course of antibiotics even if someone didn't need it, but now we mostly know better).
ewjordan··on Edge cases to keep in mind when working with text
FWIW I'm totally with you here: this particular family was who I was aiming the "scum" comment at, not the entire culture.

I'm never going to do a song and dance in favor of that culture, though, because it is pretty messed up if it encourages that kind of behavior. That doesn't mean that everyone in the fold is a bad actor, so I'd hesitate to paint so many people with the same brush. Some or most are probably decent folk that would never support shit like this.

I do stand behind my word choice as written and clarified here, though.

ewjordan··on Edge cases to keep in mind when working with text
The Turkish situation referenced (http://gizmodo.com/382026/a-cellphones-missing-dot-kills-two...) is not an indictment of bad tech, but of a fucked up honor-based patriarchal culture.

"Ramazan went to the family's home to apologize, only to be greeted by the father, Emine, two sisters and a lot of very sharp knives."

There's no technological way to fix people that would try to kill someone over a text misunderstanding without figuring out the truth first. People like this are garbage-people murderers, let's not blame tech mistakes for the fact that some people are scum. Everyone involved knew damn well that a couple characters would make the difference between a benign text and an offensive one, and frankly, even if the text was offensive, murder was not justified. Scum.

ewjordan··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
Fair enough, I'm very sorry about the crisis and hope it works out okay.

I 100% agree with your calling out constant sexualization of women as a major problem that permeates the industry, so I don't think we're really that far apart. At least on my end any disagreement mostly centers on the role that education will play in mitigating the side effects, which is fine; even if it doesn't help as much as I hope it will, I'm still happy to see the progress that students make as a result of my work, and I can't blame anyone for being skeptical about the ultimate impact.

So no hard feelings, and I apologise if I came across as argumentative. It does occur to me in hindsight that especially in the context of this article, my comments could be construed as defensive of the industry status quo, since "it's the pipeline!" is too often used in that way. That's not what I intended at all, I'm sorry I failed to make that clear. I think we really are on the same side here in terms of goals, if not tactics.

← PreviousPage 4 of 18Next →