Not sure whether that was a jab at Numenta or not, but I do think the combination of these two comments cuts to the heart of the PR problem for Numenta: they're
neither trying to do 0.1% better on the classic perception benchmarks than other algorithms do, nor trying to publish accurate, testable descriptions of the true details of meatspace neuroscience.
To me, exploring alternative network architectures and algorithms seems an extremely worthwhile goal even if it's only loosely tethered to actual biology, but from a PR perspective they really need to be better about priming the conversation if they want people to care.
Bad (neuroscience-focused): "We're doing a lot of research on neuroscience, and finding some really interesting stuff, so we built a model that doesn't exactly match the way the brain works but is still interesting. No, we haven't tried to make it work to classify ImageNet test cases, that's not our goal. But look, it's closer to biology, and we have working code that we're playing with!"
Better (ML-focused): "We're developing a novel neural network architecture that performs online unsupervised learning using only local update rules. Though it performs competently at classic benchmarks X, Y, and Z when a small WTA layer is thrown on top, it can also tackle problems A, B, and C that classical deep learning networks can't make any progress on."
To be fair, I'm not even sure if Numenta's networks could perform competently at any classic benchmarks (I'm guessing that if they could, it would take some work to get them to do so), and I have no idea what new problems it could work on. But they really do need to reframe the conversation and emphasize that sort of innovation if they want to be taken more seriously - focusing on neuroscience underpinnings is not a great move if they're not engaged in research that can actually win over neuroscientists, and just pointing out that they're focusing on those things is not a way to win over industry ML folks if they don't have any results to point at.