HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewjordan

2,337 karma · joined July 7, 2008

submissionscomments
ewjordan··on Some fun mathematical puzzles
Path On The Surface Of The Earth is a neat one, took a while to realize why there were multiple answers.

SPOILER: Obviously the North Pole is one answer, because if you're 1 km south of the pole then it doesn't matter what longitude you're at, if you go 1 km north you'll be back at the pole.

The other answers are more interesting, though, and involve the south pole. The key observation is that at certain locations fairly close to the south pole, going east by 1 km will bring you back exactly where you started because the longitude circles are very small, so there's a set of latitudes where your 1 km journey will wrap you around the world any number of times. From that observation you can figure out the rest if you care to flex your trig...

ewjordan··on Some fun mathematical puzzles
Cutting cheese (start with a 3x3x3 cube of cheese and a knife, how many straight cuts at minimum are needed to turn it into 27 1x1x1 cubes?):

The obvious answer is 6, by cutting it the obvious way (2 parallel slices along each dimension at the appropriate locations), so that seems almost certainly wrong.

If the cheese remains convex, any straight cut can at most double the number of pieces of cheese, so it would be impossible to do in less than 5 cuts (2^4 = 16, which just can't give us enough pieces, whereas 2^5 = 32 does). That holds only if we can assume convexity, but for the purposes of the problem, I assume the cheese isn't bendable or anything like that, in which case any set of straight slices you could do to make cheese non-convex would be "wasting" cuts (to maximize cheese-block count, you should always cut all the way through along a plane, and you'll only end up with convex pieces that way).

We might be tempted to go out on a limb and say that it must take 5 cuts, otherwise the problem isn't very interesting.

Unfortunately, we'd be wrong.

Think about the center piece of cheese in the 3x3x3 block. None of its faces are exposed in the original block, and there are six faces, none of which are coplanar. Unless we cheat pretty seriously (bending cheese), we cannot expose more than one of those faces with each cut, so there's no way to do it in less than six slices.

ewjordan··on [dead]
Huh, interesting - looks like HN's dupe detection considers a trailing slashes in the URL enough for the two URLs to be different.

Should be easy enough to fix, and I doubt it would flag many, if any, incorrect dupes.

ewjordan··on Internet blacklist bill COICA one step closer to becoming law
One thing I was wondering was whether or not, for instance, Google would be prohibited from returning a direct IP address link to (say) the Pirate Bay in response to a search for "pirate bay".

The text in the bill says:

`(i) a service provider, as that term is defined in section 512(k)(1) of title 17, United States Code, or other operator of a domain name system server shall take reasonable steps that will prevent a domain name from resolving to that domain name's Internet protocol address;

...and the definition of "service provider" as referenced is:

(1) Service provider. — (A) As used in subsection (a), the term “service provider” means an entity offering the transmission, routing, or providing of connections for digital online communications, between or among points specified by a user, of material of the user's choosing, without modification to the content of the material as sent or received.

(B) As used in this section, other than subsection (a), the term “service provider” means a provider of online services or network access, or the operator of facilities therefor, and includes an entity described in subparagraph (A).

It looks like Google would probably fall under (B) there, so if they received a court order, they couldn't specifically do DNS routing; it's probably questionable whether returning a link as the first result to the IP address that the domain name would resolve to if it wasn't blocked counts as resolving a domain name, I'd imagine the government would make an argument that it does.

But there's still a gaping loophole here: the bill says that a service provider must "prevent a domain name from resolving to that domain name's Internet protocol address", so fine, maybe Google couldn't return a link to 194.71.107.15 in response to "thepiratebay.org", but there's absolutely nothing in the bill that says they couldn't return a link to 194.71.107.15 in response to "Pirate Bay", "piratebay", "thepiratebay", etc. There's also nothing in the bill that prohibits them from responding to a "thepiratebay.org" query with a message telling the user that the link they were looking for was filtered out, and suggesting that they strip the suffix off of the search term to get around the domain name resolution restriction.

I realize this doesn't solve the problems of broken links on the net or anything like that, but it's an indication of the fact that this bill, horrible as it is, will likely just be routed around like many other problems on the Internet, with a lot of effort wasted in order to do so.

ewjordan··on Generating code from natural language is closer than you think
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=draw+a+red+filled+circl...
ewjordan··on Facebook’s Modern Messaging System: Seamless, History, And A Social Inbox
From what I understand they're not targeting die hard email users, they are targeting a much younger demographic, probably ideally around age 17 and heading off to University.

This is a dangerous game, targeting the youth - they're not very sticky, and it's hard to lure the next generation in when the last generation is sitting there making your service look uncool. If anything, I'd say going after the kids is most effective for a new service, because it will pull the adults in later; going the other way is tough.

My generation saw the cycle play out twice already, with AOL and MySpace: "Wow this is cool, check it out!" to "Sweet, everyone's on here!" to "Hmm, my sixty year old aunt twice removed just sent me a message...that's kind of strange" to "Really, you still have an account there?".

Now, maybe Facebook will be stickier because it's reached such critical mass, but I wouldn't necessarily bet the farm on it - the behind-the-times folks are almost all signed up and spamming friend requests to everyone they know, parents are insisting that their kids friend them, and a lot of the early adopters of my generation are getting disgruntled, wishing that they weren't forced to use Facebook just because everyone else does.

I can't help but wonder if there might just be a natural ebb and flow from one new social network juggernaut to the next, as the last winner begins to suck more and more due to its unchecked growth...

ewjordan··on Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting contacts to Facebook)
Right; there are practical usability problems with allowing willy-nilly access to your contact list. Some of your contacts have now given your email address to a company with which you never wanted to have a relationship.

This is a red herring. Facebook lets me choose whether my friends can give away literally anything else that's part of my Facebook presence to third party apps. In fact, there's a strong recommendation that I allow as much access to apps as possible, in the name of a "more social" experience. They let apps that I've never used spam me daily, I don't really get the sense that they care whether they force me into relationships with companies I have no interest in, as long as it happens within Facebook.

Why should I not get to decide whether to expose my e-mail address? If I want to, I'm allowed to set my e-mail address to "Everyone" visibility in my profile, literally the only thing I'm not allowed to do is expose it via the API.

That's a very deliberate choice, and maybe I'm a cynic, but it strikes me as mighty telling that the lack of API access to the e-mail part of the social graph is just about the only barrier in the way of Google being able to reconstitute the entire Gmail intersection of Facebook's social graph (Facebook UIDs don't suffice, because Google can't match these to e-mail addresses without the users explicitly doing so for them).

ewjordan··on Give Us Our Data, Facebook
Every other piece of information that Facebook has on me is allowed to be exposed to my friends' apps without me personally connecting with the app.

The motivation here is crystal clear: e-mail addresses function as (essentially) UIDs on the web as a whole, and someone like Google has billions of these e-mail addresses laying around. But since people started managing parts of their social graphs on Facebook instead of through (say) Gmail, Google's edge graph is starting to get stale. Facebook is terrified of the idea that Google could connect all the Gmail-to-Gmail edges without finding every one of those users.

In order for Google to refresh that graph without e-mail addresses, they'd need every involved user to export their Facebook UID out of Facebook - if I didn't do this myself, then despite the fact that (say) 30 of my Facebook friends are on Gmail, even if every one of them exported from Facebook to Google, Google could never match my Facebook UID to my Google account.

If they were able to match e-mail addresses, they could probably reconstruct a very healthy proportion of the edges (almost every edge that has a Gmail user at both vertices) even if only a small proportion of initial users seeded the graph by exporting their own data; further, when Google got an edge (suppose my friend exported his data, and my Gmail address matched), they could follow up with that edge, knowing that they are also Facebook users, and suggest that they export their data as well, which would lead to blisteringly fast filling out of that tree.

To anyone that doesn't already have a huge userbase, this is not a big deal, but to anyone that does, it's the difference between having effectively zero access to the social graph and being able to reconstruct your users intersection with it with almost perfect resolution.

ewjordan··on Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting contacts to Facebook)
What does Facebook's motives have to do with anything? The question under discussion is whether a random stranger who can convince one of my friends to sign up for a virtual pet should suddenly be able to spam me.

That is, indeed, the question under discussion.

But the question that should be under discussion is whether I should have the ability to toggle an "e-mail" field alongside the 18 other fields of information that Facebook allows me to expose to apps when a friend decides to sign up for a virtual pet. Facebook encourages me to share my pictures, my status updates, my location, my birthday, etc., with apps that my friends use, yet doesn't even allow me to choose whether to share my e-mail address.

For my protection, my ass. If that ability didn't go against their business interests, you can bet there'd be an option to allow that.

ewjordan··on Give Us Our Data, Facebook
User choice is the problem here - I should be able to choose whether or not apps that my friends use can access my contact information, not Facebook.

And in fact, there already is an extremely fine grained control panel managing what kind of information the apps my friends use can access (18 different toggles), from my bio to my location to the content of my status updates.

The one thing that I'm not allowed to expose to those apps? My contact information.

For my protection my ass. I just can't believe that's about protecting my privacy, considering they encourage me at every step to pass every other piece of my Facebook presence around like the village bicycle.

ewjordan··on ⌘Q is too damn close to ⌘W
Huh. I guess that's true, for some reason I've never noticed it before.

I usually keep my left hand on my "home keys" when browsing (Firefox user here), in order from pinky to thumb, q-w-e-f-⌘, of which I use w, f, and ⌘ on a regular basis, and I guess that usually keeps me from mis-hitting q when I mean w, I'd actually have to push the wrong finger, which is pretty rare.

Right thumb goes on the trackpad for mouse interactions (much easier now that the MBP trackpad presses in rather than having a button), other four fingers on that hand go on j-k-l-; (⌘+j/k/l I use all the time for downloads/search/address bar, ; is wasted, of course). Scrolling is the only thing that sucks, but you can get pretty far with space/shift+space (hit space with left thumb, shift with right pinky).

If I had a problem with this, I'd probably go with the WoW shortcut for quitting, alt+command+Q, which is pretty hard to do accidentally (Double-thumb keypress? Expert move...) and doesn't tend to be bound to anything else. Command+1 seems like a bad idea because some of us are very used to Command+(number) to switch to tabs.

ewjordan··on First Impressions of Python from a Java Developer
I think speed has a lot to do with it, last time I checked Groovy was more than an order of magnitude slower than Java, whereas Scala (which has many of the same benefits as Groovy) was much closer.

A 2x speed hit might not be a problem, but for a lot of people (myself included), 50x is way too much of a penalty when you've got options that offer effectively the same benefits with vastly better performance. Maybe things have improved since I last checked it out, but I'm not sure.

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
That makes no sense at all. Arguments are meaningless because they are used too much? Utterly illogical, have I misunderstood something here?

Maybe I didn't make my point very clearly, and you're right, as stated that's not really what I mean.

What I was trying to get at is that topical debates where one side disagrees with the scientific consensus typically degenerate rather quickly into complaints about the scientific establishment itself, and about how its barely-permeable idea membrane has a tendency to shut down a lot of criticism without fully addressing it.

And this is a valid point; unfortunately, it doesn't tell us anything at all about whatever specific claim is at hand, it just tells us that science puts up some pretty strong barriers to new ideas. Which, I might add, is the main reason that science continues to work, because for every scientific theory out there, even the ones with the most solid evidence, there are dozens of vocal lunatics that have their own pet theories that "aren't being taken seriously" or "have been silenced". In most scientific fields, apart from a few edge cases where data is weak or theory is spotty, there usually is a very strong consensus on most issues, and they're settled well enough that criticisms will usually be dismissed out of hand unless there's a very strong reason to take them seriously.

That doesn't mean that if someone is being "silenced" or shouted down they're necessarily wrong, but it does mean that they won't score any points by complaining about it. That treatment is leveled equally on all new ideas, and even in the best case scenario it usually takes new ideas (if correct) a generation or so to make their way through the barrier (mostly because the new generation thrives on tearing down as many ideas from the old generation as it can, whereas the old generation fights to preserve the status quo).

A big part of the problem is both sides assuming the other is disingenuous.

I absolutely 100% agree. Whenever someone shouts "Fraud!" in these arguments, I cringe, because it's rare that someone will spend a lot of time and effort pursuing scientific ideas that they actually think are wrong.

FWIW, I'm not taking any stand on AGW here, I really don't know enough about it to comment intelligently on the science. But the argument surrounding it, politicized as it's become, has a very similar tone to the arguments about evolution, right down to many of the same meta-critiques about the scientific process. Those talking points were not helpful when applied to evolution, so I'd rather they fell out of the lexicon, their presence in an argument immediately rings several alarm bells due to the similarities. The similar argument style would typically make me assume that the deniers/skeptics are just wrong (if it walks like a duck and talks like a duck...), though in this case I'm reserving judgment because a few of their other points seem like they might have some merit.

Not being convinced is always valid unless there is concrete irrefutable proof.

Hmm, I suspect a lot of Less Wrong-ers would disagree with you there, the entire philosophy of that site is based around the idea (one that I find very defensible) that we should usually be thinking statistically instead of right/wrong, and even if we can't know something for sure in the face of uncertainty, any pair of people that are thinking rationally and honestly should, in time, be able to at least agree on likelihood ratios between different possible outcomes by recursing through all the relevant priors and settling discrepancies that way. "Agree to disagree" is merely a way of cutting off that recursive settling of priors, and will sometimes have to happen in the interest of having finite length discussions, but the goal should always be to avoid that, or at the very least, pin down the lowest level disagreement about prior probabilities so that we at least know that both sides have updated their beliefs based on the same evidence.

For instance, if someone was honestly arguing that special relativity was wrong with an X% probability, that's not valid at all unless and until they can go through the various evidences in favor of it (which scientists claim puts its likelihood of being right at, say, 99.9% (we really should be talking likelihood ratios, not percentages, but you get the point)) and justify a set of priors that would lead to that X% probability. Similarly, scientists should be able to go through the evidences against special relativity and and justify granting them less authority, by showing their priors. Then we can look into those lower level assumptions, and do the same thing. Obviously this process can balloon, which is why scientists hate to do this kind of thing when they could be doing real work instead. :)

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
Here is someone providing no thought and adding nothing to the discussion, by definition, he is providing noise.

No. In theory, he's responding to noise by providing signal that addresses it.

There's a big difference there, though whether it's justified depends quite crucially on the quality of the signal that he's spewing in response to the noise...

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
Replacing yourself with a chat bot is just like arguing in person, except that it doesn't try your patience or waste your time, only the other guy's, and it doesn't give you any opportunity to learn or be exposed to novel ideas.

I don't see any problem with this, as long as you're actually right when you do it. It's never a waste of time to truthfully tell someone that they're wrong, as long as you give them the information that's necessary for them to realize why.

And in my experience, most of the "novel ideas" that the anti-evolution folks have to offer while discussing evolution are very much worth skipping.

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
Works great -- as long as you're omniscient.

Not at all - to set people straight on common talking points doesn't require omniscience, it merely requires that those specific talking points have been satisfactorily refuted before, clearly enough so that almost anyone would agree that they're squashed.

If someone on Twitter said "evolution is just a theory", I'd be perfectly happy to see someone respond-spam them with the Merriam-Webster definition of "theory" as it relates to science - that's an unambiguous refutation of the argument, verifiable by pretty much any onlooker as valid (in my experience, when confronted with that response, creationists usually don't acknowledge that they're wrong, but they quickly leave the topic, realizing that they won't score any points there). Similarly, if someone said "Darwin recanted on his deathbed", a simple link to http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/2009/03/31/darwins-... (the first Google result for that phrase) would be fully justifiable, regardless of the qualifications of the responder.

As a rule, I think if someone utters/posts/writes something that can be 100% debunked, beyond any reasonable doubt, by typing the phrase into Google and reading the first three results, it's fair to call them out on it, even in an automated way. Omniscience not required.

Then again, I'm more used to arguing evolution than global warming, and evolution is a much more solid theory. I don't know how soundly most of the anti-global warming claims have been refuted, it may very well be the case that this guy is just parroting back talking points rather than properly shooting wrong ideas down. In which case that's Bad(tm).

But as an abstract idea? Go ahead, shoot down the idiot masses, as long as you're damn sure that you're right about what you're putting them down over. A lot of stuff that people say really does deserve a rude smackdown, it's so offensively wrong - this is Twitter we're talking about, after all!

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
Here's the problem: while I would tend to agree with you if your claim was that global warming is not as clear cut an issue as the mainstream makes it out to be, that's not how your post comes across.

The real problem with the way you're arguing is that most of the meta-critiques that you've offered about the way mainstream climate change scientists act read almost exactly the same as the anti-evolution arguments that biologists have been assaulted with for decades. "Consensus is not how science is done?" Check. "The evidence goes against prevailing opinion?" Check. "Proponents won't argue the science and just parrot talking points?" Check. "They just shout people down as 'anti-science' when they disagree?" Check.

And all these claims may be true, hell, they probably are. The problem is, that's how scientists act when they're right, just as much as when they're wrong.

This doesn't bear on your claim at all, of course, and I have no intention of getting into a specific global warming dispute (I don't have the expertise or the interest, and frankly, I doubt there are many people here that do); but those arguments mean absolutely nothing, because they are always offered whenever people disagree with the prevailing consensus in a field, whether it's correct or not.

I've only met a couple climate scientists, but my impression was most definitely not that they were ideologically driven morons that simply want to push their preconceived notions on the world. I've always gotten the sense that they really felt that the data supported their claims. Now, that doesn't make them right, but be careful about assuming that they're just perpetrating a fraud for some reason. One of the most common mistakes people make when arguing issues like this is to assume that the other side actually knows (or secretly suspects) that it's wrong, and it's playing dirty to trick everyone else. This is rarely the case, if someone is wrong it's typically more likely that the evidence they've seen strongly suggests their hypothesis, which ends up blinding them to later evidence that might weaken it.

ewjordan··on Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense
Furthermore, the totality of all nuclear accidents in the world has caused less deaths than coal soot alone.

This is where the current environmentalist movement has really failed: "Don't burn shit, it's bad for the environment and it's bad for us" was a compelling story, because it's pretty obviously true and hard to fight back against. When environmentalism was all about smog, coal burning, and all that nasty stuff, it was hard to find much fault with it.

But now it's all about carbon. And global warming involves a lot more analysis to evaluate, to the point that even the most scientifically minded non-experts can't claim to fully understand the evidence for or against it (if they even have access to that raw evidence), not to mention all the possibilities of fudged data, which turn this more into a guessing game about who's telling the truth than a matter of science.

ewjordan··on Facebook knows when you'll break up
Is it possible they really meant "over 10,000 status updates" that include one of the phrases in question? Broken down yearly, 10,000 samples is an average of somewhere around 25 samples a day, and I'd imagine that on average far less than 1/25 of Facebook status updates are about breakups, so there would be only a handful of days with any hits, let alone enough to pick out a "Monday effect" or anything like that.

If it's 10,000 that match the query, then that's a more reasonable amount of data. Of course, the interpretation is still pretty shallow, and mere regex-matching for those phrases could be getting a lot of other crap, but at least it's a (just barely, given that they want to break it down day-by-day) decent sample size.

ewjordan··on Using genetic algorithms to find Starcraft 2 build orders
Again, it might work very well, I just think that some sort of tree-based approach might be faster and more efficient.

While this is true in general, sometimes the nice thing about genetic methods is that pretty much all you have to do is write the fitness function, cross your fingers that the problem is a good fit for the method and go do some real work on another computer for a while.

Oftentimes other methods require more in the way of setup or planning, not the least of which is actually picking an appropriate method and mapping its implementation onto the problem space.

Some of the nastiest problems I've ever worked on have gotten that way because I went with a domain specific approach that was "optimized for the problem"; while the end results are usually very good (and, to be fair, run on the computer from zero-to-solved in no time flat), in a couple cases I've gone back and tried the "brute force" genetic programming approach, and though it took quite a bit more computer time, the programming effort was substantially smaller to end up with similarly good results.

The real problem, though, is that many of the problems people apply GA/GP to aren't well suited to the genetic approach, usually because the problem itself doesn't lend itself to incrementally improving solutions (problems like function regression can be tricky, because getting close to the correct functional form symbolically usually leaves you very far away from the correct form numerically, and sometimes the correct result is actually surrounded by a "wall" of completely and utterly unfit solutions that's very hard to break through). Genetic methods work well when the fitness landscape has lots of solutions that work fairly well, and quite a few that work great, not when there's literally one needle in some super-multi-dimensional haystack.

To be fair, the Starcraft optimization problem is probably somewhere in the middle, there are probably many good solutions to the problem, and many of these will be minor variations on other good solutions, so it's pretty likely that a GA will get to some good ones. But the search space is small enough that you're probably right, a heuristic-guided direct search would be more likely to pick out the best solutions faster.

ewjordan··on U.S. Says Genes Should Not Be Eligible for Patents
Gene patents have not been a "problem" in the same way as software patents.

I'd argue that the "problem" is that the entire idea that ownership, even temporary, can be claimed on a pre-existing string of bits (and not just some particular method of extracting or using that information) that exists inside all of our bodies, is downright offensive. Moreso because the techniques to isolate and exploit these bit strings have now become commonplace and all but trivial.

And, unlike software patents, they are more likely to represent a significant R&D investment by the applicant.

But the patent system is not a subsidy for R&D costs, it's supposed to protect innovative inventions. I'm appalled at the idea that a research group might be prevented from researching novel therapies that target a particular gene just because some other company happened to successfully isolate it using standard techniques ten years ago.

ewjordan··on U.S. Says Genes Should Not Be Eligible for Patents
Do I understand correctly that just physically extracting a certain piece of DNA from a cell ("purifying" it) makes it patentable? That seems silly.

Yeah, it's ludicrous - imagine that I tried to file for a patent on using a random (but useful!) phrase in English on the basis that I was able to write a Perl regex to pull it out of a web page.

And I won't even qualify that with the usual "poor analogy" disclaimer - it's almost exactly what the current law allows for, just replace "random phrase in English" with "snippet of DNA", and "Perl regex" with "biochemical reaction".

ewjordan··on "Calling oneself a C Programmer is like saying you're a Hammer Carpenter"
Bah. Long division is a rather unenlightening algorithm that doesn't teach most people anything at all about how numbers interact.

That's assuming they even remember how the algorithm works. Which they don't, as a rule.

ROI-wise, there are far better places to spend time learning the relationships between numbers than long division.

ewjordan··on Ask HN: Show me your Half Baked project
One of my first programming projects, a physics game done with Processing: http://www.ewjordan.com/RGBApplet/ (warning, that link is a Java applet, don't blame me if your browser crashes!)

Buggy as hell (won't work if you reload the page, I think the applet viewer doesn't reset statics?), and really rough. Probably one of the toughest control schemes imaginable.

ewjordan··on On a New Road : James Gosling on Apple and Java
Poker Copilot (http://pokercopilot.com/ - a hand history database/HUD for online poker) is one example, and actually a good example of a business approach that many people here would doubtless love to follow (one guy, making a reasonable salary off of a medium-high-priced niche product, with no delusions of future massive growth).

Steve McLeod knew that he'd never be able to compete with Pokertracker on Windows (it doesn't run on OS X), so he decided to focus 100% on the OS X side of it and add features as he was able, and I think that was an excellent decision. The product is quite good there and doesn't feel like an afterthought like many OS X products. It's a small market, but he's pretty much the only player in town, so...

ewjordan··on Should Kids Be Paid to Do Well in School?
First off, I think it's worth noting that the current system of motivation, based on grades, is hardly better than straight up bribery, it's just that the theoretical rewards of the "bribe" (good college, great career, etc.) are so far in the future that they're pretty much invisible to most of the people in the system, except for the truly pathetic worry-wart-weiner-dogs that actually change their actions based on potential ten-year-hence consequences as high school students (which, I realize, is a category that many of us fall into, and there's probably something wrong with that, but now's not the time or the place...I was one of them, so I'm not going to cast stones).

I think rather than trying to bribe children to go to school because they hate it they should instead concentrate on making school actually interesting.

And I think rather than trying to bribe adults into doing work because they hate it it would be fantastic if we could try to make it interesting instead, so they would want to do it without compensation.

Of course, failing that, we have to pay them, because it's more useful to have a person do a dollar's worth of work for a "cheap" reason such as money than it is to keep the dollar in our pocket. Doesn't matter how nice it would be if the person really desired to do that work of their own accord, it's worth more to us to pay them than it is not to, so we do it.

Where's that analysis here?

From my interactions tutoring the hideously under-interested youth of America, at least the rich parents that care about such things would almost certainly be far better off (dollars and cents-wise) paying their kids a nominal wage to do their f-ing homework than they are paying me $80/hr to sit with them and force them to do it - even if I am there to answer the occasional question and review the material in a (hopefully?) more comprehensible way than the teachers might at school, in my experience the real gains are simply achieved by forcing kids to think about the topic for a certain amount of extra time every week, which they typically would never do on their own.

Basic reading, writing and arithmetic should be compulsory but let kids choose whatever they want to learn after that.

I'm all in favor of that idea. But you may underestimate the extent to which we're not even covering reading, writing, and arithmetic the way things stand. As educated people we tend to assume that everyone else is at least in the same ballpark as us, but look...those comments that you see all the time on YouTube, and chuckle at, assuming they're written by non-native English speakers? They are, in fact, pretty close to the average quality of the prose you'll get if you ask an average classroom of American students to write an essay.

ewjordan··on The Math Problem That A/B Tests Should Be Trying To Solve
Just to be clear: I'm not necessarily suggesting that full multivariate A/B testing is the best thing to shoot for, I realize very well that especially in site design, different splits cannot be composed together.

However, related to a discussion this past week where it became clear that periodically checking confidence intervals until they "hit" was a terrible way to test because of the high likelihood of picking the wrong result, I am suggesting that the two-armed bandit problem should be considered mandatory knowledge for anyone working on A/B testing frameworks. That problem is literally what A/B testing tries to solve (try to make choices between two options to maximize payoff when you don't know the payoffs of either choice beforehand, taking into account the fact that trials spent building up certainty by testing the payoffs are sometimes wasted on the least valuable option).

I'd have linked to the two-armed bandit problem if there was a page on that, but it just redirects...

ewjordan··on Poor People Should Probably Gamble More
Fully in agreement here. And actually, I agree with the moral of what you've said almost elsewhere else on this thread; I meant this post to be a bit more tongue-in-cheek than I suspect it came across, I definitely should have made it more clear that I don't really think poor people should be heading to the casino every time they come up short when rent's due. :)
ewjordan··on Poor People Should Probably Gamble More
By that same interest rate argument, the marginal utility of money should increase on both ends the further you get from zero, since interest earned on the money you have compounds, too. That said, the interest rate is much larger when you're in debt than when you have money (actually, in this case that's not 100% true, because DMV suspension fees don't accrue interest, nor do tickets or court costs after the late fees max out, but in general, you're right), so this could be a real concern.

Even in the face of marginal utility differences, though, if you were to accept (unreasonably, of course; thought experiment disclaimer goes here) that you only had the two options given (do nothing and owe another $100 to the state, or take the bet, coming out $130 ahead or $230 behind), would you really suggest that doing nothing is the better option? How good would the odds need to be (and how little variance) for you to take the bet, if so?

If I laid out this payoff structure without placing it in a real world context where there are many other obvious potential solutions, I think you'd probably argue in favor of taking the bet - the expected loss is so much lower that I think it's difficult to make a marginal utility argument against it. I suspect that what's really making you argue against it in this example is that there are so many better ways to deal with the situation in real life that it's hard to even imagine having to make a choice between the two alternatives on the table.

ewjordan··on Poor People Should Probably Gamble More
Tangent:

Not at all. In fact, I wrote this up because of a conversation I had a while back with a man buying a lottery ticket at the gas station. I was talking with him about how bad the odds were, and he fully admitted that he was getting terrible odds on that dollar.

But he figured that on the one in a million chance that he hit the jackpot, even if he only saw a quarter of that amount he could actually get out of debt and start making the power of compound interest work for him instead of against him, and after enough time with that money in the bank, the scales would tip in favor of spending the dollar on the lottery ticket.

Now, I don't think that argument really holds water, and I told him so (for several reasons, even apart from my skepticism that he'd actually put any cash he won into a properly managed account without spending a huge chunk of it first; the odds at the lottery are so hideous and the doubling time for a quarter million that you're also drawing money out of to live off of is very long, so it would be tough to make those numbers work out), but it got me started thinking about whether there might actually be situations where a losing gamble could be worthwhile, depending on the current situation of indebtedness.

← PreviousPage 8 of 18Next →