HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewoodrich

2,349 karma · joined October 23, 2011

submissionscomments
ewoodrich··on Ireland’s Diarmuid Early wins world Microsoft Excel title
Nice, that makes sense. I'm always curious when I hear about other giant Excel monoliths still in use if they're truly a huge tangled web of formulas, or more like a VB6 program stapled to some worksheets that can be distributed as a single .xlsm file like ours.

You're definitely right that 99% of Excel users have no idea that an entire IDE is lurking in the background with Alt-F11 and wouldn't even know where to begin to do a simple fix/tweak. Whereas even a complex formula can at least be mentally parsed as a math equation with some strange ALLCAPS() names scattered throughout, or copy/pasted into Google/an LLM to get started, so much more discoverable than VBA.

Not to mention that the VBA IDE is a horrible dev experience in pretty much every way and frozen in time while regular Excel is actively maintained.

I've explored pulling out all the critical business logic currently in VBA and having Claude Code rewrite to VB.NET that can be called from Excel to gradually phase out VBA for maintainability. But unfortunately despite VBA essentially driving everything, it's tightly coupled to the Excel spreadsheet data model. So I'd have to use a .NET library to emulate the Excel worksheet functions, or pretty much do a full rewrite to use modern .NET methods for the in-memory data manipulation stuff.

Without good visibility into the Excel side of the VBA, Claude Code/Gemini CLI were just flailing so I abandoned that idea for now until I can find a solid conversion path.

ewoodrich··on Ireland’s Diarmuid Early wins world Microsoft Excel title
Any VBA? I help out with an extremely complex 15+ yr old Excel workbook designed for managing school debate tournaments that's still in active use in the PNW debate world but the complexity is 90% from VBA.

It does inject Excel formulas when creating worksheets but also heavily uses UI controls/dialogs made with the VB6 era WYSIWYG designer built into Excel, plus some COM extensions for SMTP emails, with spreadsheets used both as a pseudo database mostly hidden from the user and as the output for rendering data but the actual logic is mostly VBA.

Excel's VBA IDE feels like a time capsule from 2002, and not in a good way (with some of the most comically unhelpful error messages I've ever seen and extremely aggressive syntax checking that constantly interrupts typing in code). Microsoft increasingly makes it very clear they don't want people using VBA but it still works fine in the latest PC versions from O365 after turning off a few security features/approving some prompts.

ewoodrich··on Believe the Checkbook
My company (and others in the same sector) depends on certain proprietary enterprise software that has literally no publicly available API documentation online, anywhere.

There is barely anything that qualifies as documentation that they are willing to provide under NDA for lock-in reasons/laziness (ERPish sort of thing narrowly designed for the specific sector, and more or less in a duopoly).

The difficulty in developing solutions is 95% understanding business processes/requirements. I suspect this kind of thing becomes more common the further you get from a "software company” into specific industry niches.

ewoodrich··on 2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity in search results
Aurora Store is a nearly perfect 1:1 replacement for the Play Store. I just wish they had slightly more clear error messages when downloads don't work (but typically just means the Play Store wouldn't have shown as available for the device for whatever reason).
ewoodrich··on Systemd v259
Yeah, I've been using Claude and Codex to create bespoke systemd services for my random tools and automation stuff and have been really impressed by how easy it is and how rock solid they are once setup. It's really nice not living in constant terror that a reboot, network connectivity loss or gentle breeze will cause my duct taped scripts to collapse under their own weight.
ewoodrich··on Gemini 3 Flash: Frontier intelligence built for speed
Yeah my parents never really cared enough to explore ChatGPT despite hearing about it 10 times a day in news/media for the last few years. But recently my mom started using Google's AI Search mode after first trying it while doing research for house hunting and my dad uses the Gemini app for occasional questions/identifying parts and stuff (he has always loved Google Lens so those sort of interactive multimedia features are the main pull vs plain text chatbot conversations).

They are both Android/Google Search users so all it really took was "sure I guess I'll try that" in response to a nudge from Google. For me personally I have subscriptions to Claude/ChatGPT/Gemini for coding but use Gemini for 90% of chatbot questions. Eventually I'll cancel some of them but will probably keep Gemini regardless because I like having the extra storage with my Google One plan bundle. Google having a pre-existing platform/ecosystem is a huge advantage imo.

ewoodrich··on Gemini 3 Flash: Frontier intelligence built for speed
Gemini CLI via a Google One plan is the regular consumer billing flow which is pretty straightforward.
ewoodrich··on GPT Image 1.5
Sure, you can always remove it, but an average person posting AI images on Facebook or whatever probably won't bother. I was skeptical of Google's SynthID when I first heard about it but I've been seeing it used to identify suspected AI images on Reddit recently (the example I saw today was cropped and lightly edited with a filter but still got flagged correctly) and it's cool to have a hard data point when present. It won't help with bad/manipulative actors but a decent mitigation for the low effort slop scenario since it can survive the kind of basic editing a regular person knows how to do on their phone and typical compression when uploading/serving.
ewoodrich··on Vibe coding creates fatigue?
I also get confused when I see it taken for granted that "vibe coding" removes all the drudgery/chores from programming. When my own experience heavily using Claude Code/etc every day routinely involves a lot of unpleasant clean up of accumulated LLM slop and "WTF" decisions.

I still think it saves me time on net and yes, it typically can handle a lot on its own, but whenever it starts to fuck up the same request repeatedly in different ways, all I can really do is sigh/roll my eyes and then it's on me alone to dig in and figure it out/fix it to keep making progress.

And usually that consists of incredibly ungratifying, unpleasant work I'm very much not happy to be doing.

I definitely have been able to do more side projects for ideas that pop into my head thanks to CC and similar, and that part is super cool! But other times I hit a wall where a project suddenly goes from breezy and fun to me spending hours reading through diffs/chat history trying to untangle a pile of garbage code I barely understand 10% of and have to remind myself I was supposed to be doing this for "fun"/learning, and accomplishing neither while not getting paid for it.

ewoodrich··on Thin desires are eating life
IMHO your comment would have been far more constructive if you actually explained what "copium factory" is supposed to mean in this context.

As it stands I literally have no idea what you are trying to say except for the broad dismissal of the post as pop psychology. (And yes I'm familiar with the word, it still just doesn't make any sense to me).

ewoodrich··on Fix HDMI-CEC weirdness with a Raspberry Pi and a $7 cable
Yep, I have a bunch of those audio extractors, they're awesome. In my home office setup I even have an HDMI output that's mirrored to several screens and extract audio at various points along the same path (two using the dedicated mini extractor boxes, one just using the headphone out on a monitor).
ewoodrich··on Mistral releases Devstral2 and Mistral Vibe CLI
Every link in the "Legal" tree is a dead end redirecting back to the home page... strange thing to put together without any acknowledgement, unless they spam it on LLM adjacent subreddits for clout/karma?
ewoodrich··on Agentic AI Foundation
I use OpenCode as my main CLI tool at this point, falling back to Claude Code and Codex as needed. It's really solid these days, highly recommend.

I use Claude Sonnet 4.5, Gemini 3 Pro Preview, and GPT 5/5-mini with great results on OC. I initially tried it so I could decouple from VS Code extensions while still using my Github Copilot plan like I had been with Roo Code/Kilo Code, but have branched out to also using it with the Claude Code backend and their free models as they come and go.

Definitely worth trying if you haven't picked it up recently.

ewoodrich··on Apple's slow AI pace becomes a strength as market grows weary of spending
They're being sued over an Apple Intelligence gimmick in an ad campaign that turned out to be vaporware at this very moment!

https://www.axios.com/2025/03/20/apple-suit-false-advertisin...

ewoodrich··on Show HN: Gemini Pro 3 imagines the HN front page 10 years from now
I wouldn't describe most of Claude's predictions as better, they seem to skew towards wildly over optimistic futurism/science-fantasy:

  "SpaceX announces Mars City Alpha is now self-sustaining (spacex.com)" 

  Show HN: I built an IDE for direct neural programming (thoughtexchange.io)
Gemini's SpaceX post is at least in the ballpark of plausibility 10 yrs from now:

  First successful telemetry from Starship HLS-9 on the Sea of Tranquility (spacex.com)
ewoodrich··on Show HN: Gemini Pro 3 imagines the HN front page 10 years from now
At least in my case, the "pinpoint accuracy" of that roast made for a pretty uninspired result, it seemed to be based on like 4 or 5 specific comments seemingly chosen at random.

Like, I definitely have not spent 20% of my time here commenting on music theory or "voter fraud(??)" (that one seems to be based on a single thread I responsed to a decade ago)? ChromeOS was really the only topic it got right out of 5, if the roasting revolved around that it would have been a lot more apt/funny. Maybe it works better with an account that isn't as old as mine?

I find the front page parody much better done. Gemini 2.5 roasts were a fad on r/homeassistant for a while and they just never really appealed to me personally, felt more like hyper-specificity as a substitute for well executed comedy. Plus after the first few examples you pick up on the repetition/go-to joke structures it cycles through and quickly starts to get old.

ewoodrich··on Has the cost of building software dropped 90%?
Fully agreed, aligns perfectly with my experience hitting the 95% done wall on a solo contract project recently. I still do the majority of work using agentic tools but the multiplier effect feeling evaporated at a certain point as the accumulated tech debt, complexity and scope creep enabled by how “easy” features felt with Claude Code/Codex early on finally caught up to me.

I (probably) still would have used CC heavily with benefit of hindsight but with a view that every seemingly “trivial” feature CC adds in the greenfield stage to be radioactive tech debt as the pile grows over time. Until reaching the point where CC starts being unable to comprehend its own work and I have to plan out tedious large scale refactors to get the codebase into a state approaching long term maintainability.

ewoodrich··on Let's put Tailscale on a jailbroken Kindle
Android on an e-reader unlocks so much potential. I've owned four or five Kindles over the years but recently switched to an Onyx Boox page 7" as my main e-reader. Expensive (relative to Kindles) but runs full Android 11 and has physical page turn buttons. I use an app called BookFusion to sync my library including reading position across all platforms. Battery life isn't Kindle grade but I can get by charging once a week which is a good enough tradeoff for the convenience of being able to run Android apps.
ewoodrich··on Anthropic taps IPO lawyers as it races OpenAI to go public
Am I? I'm just comparing the relative degree of enshittification, implicit in that is nothing will last forever, Gemini freebies included once they get their fill of training data. But I was surprised to see Anthropic used as an example of something that hasn't enshittified, considering how in less than 6 months my Claude plan went from fantastic value to constant rate limiting.
ewoodrich··on Anthropic taps IPO lawyers as it races OpenAI to go public
Anthropic's incessant cuts to CC rate limits/quota on the Claude Pro plan have nearly pushed me to cancel.

If anything they're far ahead of Google on the enshittification schedule (who still give out API keys for free Gemini usage and a free tier on Gemini CLI, although CLI is still pretty shaky unfortunately but that's a different issue).

It also doesn't help that CC will stop working literally in the middle of a task with zero heads up, or at best I get the 90% warning and then 30 seconds later have it stop working claiming I hit 100% after about two additional messages during the same task. I'm truly baffled by how they've managed to make the warnings as useless and aggravating as possible in CC and routinely shutdown while the repo is in a broken state, so I have to ask Codex to read the logs and piece things back together to continue working.

ewoodrich··on Anthropic taps IPO lawyers as it races OpenAI to go public
I went from:

  1. using Claude Code exclusively (back when it really was on another level from the competition) to

  2. switching back and forth with CC using the Z.ai GLM 4.6 backend (very close to a drop-in replacement these days) due to CC massively cutting down the quota on the Claude Pro plan to

  3. now primarily using OpenCode with the Claude Code backend, or Sonnet 4.5 Github Copilot backend, or Z.ai GLM 4.6 backend (in that order of priority)
OpenCode is so much faster than CC even when using Claude Sonnet as the model (at least on the cheap Claude Pro plan, can't speak for Max). But it can't be entirely due to the Claude plan rate limiting because it's way faster than CC even when using Claude Code itself as the backend in OC.

I became so ridiculously sick of waiting around for CC just to like move a text field or something, it was like watching paint dry. OpenCode isn't perfect but very close these days and as previously stated, crazy fast in comparison to CC.

Now that I'm no longer afraid of losing the unique value proposition of CC my brand loyalty to Anthropic is incredibly tenuous, if they cut rate limits again or hurt my experience in the slightest way again it will be an insta-cancel.

So the market situation is much different than the early days of CC as a cutting edge novel tool, and relying on that first mover status forever is increasingly untenable in my opinion. The competition has had a long time to catch up and both the proprietary options like Codex and open source model-agnostic FOSS tools are in a very strong position now (except Gemini CLI is still frustrating to use as much as I wish it wasn't, hopefully Google will fix the weird looping and other bugs ... eventually, because I really do like Gemini 3 and pay for it already via AI Pro plan).

ewoodrich··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
I largely agree with this advice but in practice using Claude Code / Codex 4+ hours a day, it's not always that simple. I have a .NET/React/Vite webapp that despite the typical stack has a lot of very specific business logic for a real world niche. (Plus some poor early architectural decisions that are being gradually refactored with well documented rules).

I frequently see (both) agents make wrong assumptions that inevitably take multiple turns of needing it to fail to recognize the correct solution.

There can be like a magnetic pull where no matter how you craft the initial instructions, they will both independently have a (wrong) epiphany and ignore half of the requirements during implementation. It takes messing up once or twice for them to accept that their deep intuition from training data is wrong and pivot. In those cases I find it takes less time to let that process play out vs recrafting the perfect one shot prompt over and over. Of course once we've moved to a different problem I would definitely dump that context ASAP.

(However, what is cool working with LLMs, to counterbalance the petty frustrations that sometimes make it feel like a slog, is that they have extremely high familiarity with the jargon/conventions of that niche. I was expecting to have to explain a lot of the weird, too clever by half abbreviations in the legacy VBA code from 2004 it has to integrate with, but it pretty much picks up on every little detail without explanation. It's always a fun reminder that they were created to be super translaters, even within the same language but from jargon -> business logic -> code that kinda works).

ewoodrich··on Claude 4.5 Opus’ Soul Document
It kept feeling like I was reading an advertisement, personally...

  Think about what it would mean for everyone to have access to a knowledgeable, thoughtful friend

  Claude can be the great equalizer

  We believe Claude can be like a brilliant expert friend everyone deserves but few currently have access to
ewoodrich··on Claude 4.5 Opus' Soul Document
What is special/unusual that makes this so significant? (Not trying to be dismissive, legitimately asking in case I'm missing something)

I understand it's not a system prompt so there's some novelty there I suppose. Is it because someone was able to get Claude to regurgitate a (very large) document from its training data? Or is it the content of the document itself?

I've only skimmed it and there's probably some unique nuggets here and there, but at a high level the rules/guidelines didn't really jump out at me as being much different than the various system prompts for proprietary models made public over the last couple years. Except much longer (and a bit ramble-y in some sections vs the directness of typical system prompt).

ewoodrich··on DeepSeek-v3.2: Pushing the frontier of open large language models [pdf]
Yes, if you try using Kilo Code/Cline via Openrouter the cost will be much cheaper using Deepseek/Kimi vs Claude Sonnet 4.5.
ewoodrich··on SmartTube Compromised
That's refering to Play Protect (virus scan-ish thing on Google branded Android) and whatever Amazon's equivalent is, not an app requested force uninstall of some kind.
ewoodrich··on An update on the Farphone's battery
I've been using an old Pixelbook for 3 years that I had laying around for an always on Home Assistant control panel (but with adaptive dimming that defaults so extremely low brightness to reduce heat until approaching it).

I noticed a few months ago that the battery has started to significantly swell pushing the back panel apart, but I haven't worked up the motivation to try removing it yet. From what I can ascertain from user experiences, it actually does boot sans battery but haven't confirmed, it would be awesome if that worked and would probably give me 5+ more years of usage.

So in my case, data point is that 3 years of 24/7 use/charging of an old laptop/tablet was enough to push it over the edge and finally swell. It's really a shame how so many otherwise usable devices that could be wall mounted turn into e-waste because they won't run without a battery. With USB-C PD a well-designed device should be able to get whatever power is needed on demand but manufacturers don't really have any incentive to future proof for the .01% of users like me who would benefit.

ewoodrich··on Leak confirms OpenAI is preparing ads on ChatGPT for public roll out
I also wouldn't underestimate Google's ability to nudge regular users towards whichever AI surface they want to promote. My highly non-technical mom recently told me she started using Google's "AI Mode" or whatever it's called for most of her searches (she says she likes how it can search/compare multiple sites for browsing house listings and stuff).

She doesn't really install apps and never felt a need to learn a new tool like "ChatGPT" but the transition from regular Google search to "AI Search" felt really natural and also made it easy to switch back to regular search if it wasn't useful for specific types of searches.

It definitely reduces cognitive load for an average user not needing to switch between multiple apps/websites to lookup hours/reviews via Google Maps, search for "facebook.com" to navigate to a site and now run AI searches all in the same familiar places on her phone. So I think Google is still pretty "sticky" despite ChatGPT being a buzzword everyone hears now that they caught up to OpenAI in terms of model capability/features.

ewoodrich··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
Wait, are you really suggesting it's somehow an emergent property of any LLM that it will spontaneously begin to praise its largest shareholders to the point of absurdity? Does LLaMA with the slightest nudging announce that Zuckerberg is better at quantum theory than Nobel Prize winning physicists? Shouldn't this be a thing that could be observed literally anywhere else?
ewoodrich··on Claude Advanced Tool Use
I really need something like this up for tasks I want Claude to run before handing off a task to me as "complete". It routinely ignores my instructions of checklist items that need to be satisfied to be considered successful. I have a helper script documented in CLAUDE.md that lets Claude or me get specific build/log outputs with a few one liner commands yet Claude can't be bothered to remember running them half the time.

Way too frequently Claude goes, "The task is fully implemented, error free with tests passing and no bugs or issues!" and I have to reply "did you verify server build/log outputs with run-dev per CLAUDE.md". It immediately knows the command I am referencing from the instructions buried in its context already, notices an issue and then goes back and fixes it correctly the second time. Whenever it happens it instantly makes an agentic coding session go from feeling like breezy, effortless fun to pulling teeth.

I've started to design a subagent to handle chores after every task to avoid context pollution but it sounds like hooks are the missing piece I need to deterministically guarantee it will run every time instead of just when Claude feels the vibes are right.

← PreviousPage 3 of 24Next →