2,349 karma · joined October 23, 2011
Particularly when it's in response to pointing out a big screw up that needs correcting and CC utterly unfazed just merrily continues on like I praised it.
"You have fundamentally misunderstood the problems with the layout, before attempting another fix, think deeply and re-read the example text in the PLAN.md line by line and compare with each line in the generated output to identify the out of order items in the list."
"Perfect!...."
It would be great to be able to check in on Claude on a walk or something to make sure it hasn't gone off the rails or send it a quick "LGTM" to keep moving down a large PLAN.md file without being tethered to a keyboard and monitor. I can SSH from my phone but the CLI ergonomics are ... not great with an on screen keyboard, when all it really needs is just needs a simple threaded chat UI.
I've seen a couple Github projects and "Happy Coder" on a Show HN which I haven't got around to setting up yet which seem in the ballpark of what I want, but a first party integration would always be cool.
Then I do a double take and re-read the summary message and realize that it pulled a "and then draw the rest of the owl", seemingly arbitrarily picking and choosing what it felt like doing in that session and what it punted over to "next steps to actually get it running".
Claude is more prone to occasional "cheating" with mocked data or "tbd: make this an actual conditional instead of hardcoded If True" stuff when it gets overwhelmed which is annoying and bad. But it at least has strong task adherence for the user's prompt and doesn't make me write a lawyer-esque contract to avoid any loopholes Codex will use to avoid doing work.
Which is why I think the parent post had a great observation about human problem solving having evolved in a universe inherently formed by the additive effect of every previous decision you've ever made made in your life.
There's a lot of variance in humans, sure, but inescapable stakes/skin in the game from an instinctual understanding that you can't just revert to a previous checkpoint any time you screw up. That world model of decisions and consequences helps ground abstract problem solving ability with a healthy amount of risk aversion and caution that LLMs lack.
Either with the web UI a la OpenAI Playground where you can see all the knobs and buttons the model offers, or by generating an API Key with a couple clicks that you can just copy paste into a Python script or whatever.
It would be much less convenient if they abandoned it and forced you to work in the dense Google Cloud jungle with IAM etc for the sake of forced “simplicity” of offering models in one place.
Which eventually forces you to take a step back and start questioning basic assumptions until (hopefully) you get a spark of realization of the flaws in your original plan, and then recalibrate based on that new understanding and tackle it totally differently.
But instead I watch Claude struggling to find a directory it expects to see and running random npm commands until it comes to the conclusion that, somehow, node_modules was corrupted mysteriously and therefore it needs to wipe everything node related and manually rebuild the project config by vague memory.
Because no big deal, if it’s wrong it’s the human's problem to untangle and Anthropic gets paid either way so why not try?
I made some charts/dashboards in HA and was watching it in the background for a few minutes and then realized that none of the data was changing, at all.
So I went and looked at the code and the entire block that was supposed to pull the data from the device was just a stub generating test data based on my exact mock up of what I wanted the data it generated to look like.
Claude was like, “That’s exactly right, it’s a stub so you can replace it with the real data easily, let me know if you need help with that!” And to its credit, it did fix it to use actual data but I re-read my original prompt was somewhat baffling to think it could have been interpreted as wanting fake data given I explicitly asked it to use real data from the device.
I was running into this constantly on one project with a repo split between a Vite/React front end and .NET backend (with well documented structure). It would sometimes go into panic mode after some npm command didn’t work repeatedly and do all sorts of pointless troubleshooting over and over, sometimes veering into destructive attempts to rebuild whatever it thought was missing/broken.
I kept trying to rewrite the section in CLAUDE.md to effectively instruct it to always first check the current directory to verify it was in the correct $CLIENT or $SERVER directory. But it would still sometimes forget randomly which was aggravating.
I ended up creating some aliases like “run-dev server restart” “run-dev client npm install” for common operations on both server/client that worked in any directory. Then added the base dotnet/npm/etc commands to the deny list which forced its thinking to go “Hmm it looks like I’m not allowed to run npm, so I’ll review the project instructions. I see, I can use the ‘run-dev’ helper to do $NPM_COMMAND…”
It’s been working pretty reliably now but definitely wasted a lot of time with a lot of aggravation getting to that solution.
I also landed on “agentic coding” FWIW. It’s a bit clunky but didn’t feel like an embarrassment to the entire software industry typing it so I’ll happily use it over the alternative.
It worked fine until recently where I will ask it to tweak some behavior of a command with a flag and it does a diff with like hundreds of lines. So now it's struggling to catch every place it needs to change some hardcoded duplicate values it decided to copy/paste into two dozen random places in the code.
To be fair it is doing a decent job unfucking it now that I noticed and started explicitly showing it how ridiculously cumbersome and unmaintainable it made things with specific examples and refactoring. But if I hadn't bothered to finally sit down and read through it thoroughly it would have just become more broken and inconsistent as it grew exponentially.
If xAI in particular is in the mood to light cash on fire promoting their new model, you'll see it everywhere during the promo period, so not surprised that heavily boosts xAI stats. The mystery codename models of the week are a bit easier to miss.
I've lost count of how many times I've asked whether some command line tool has an option or config available for some niche case and ChatGPT or Gemini shouts "Yes! Absolutely! just use '--use-external-mode' to get the behavior you want, it's that simple!" and it's 100% hallucination created by mangling together my intent with a real option in the docs but which in reality does not actually exist nor has it ever existed. It's even worse with GUI/menu navigation questions I'm guessing because it's even less grounded by text-based docs and trivially easy to bullshit that an option is buried in Preferences, the External tab maybe, somewhere, probably.
The desperate personality tuning to please the user at all costs combined with LLMs inherently fuzzy averaging of reality produces negative value whenever I truly need a binary yes/no "Does X exist in Y or not?" answer to a technical question. Then I waste a bunch of time falling back to Google trying to definitively prove or disprove whether "--use-external-mode" is a real thing and sure enough, it's not.
It does occasionally lead to hilariously absurd exchanges where when challenged instead of admitting its mistake the LLM goes on to invent an elaborate entirely fabricated backstory about the implementation of the "--use-external-mode" command to explain why despite appearing to not exist, it actually does but due to conflicts with X and Y it isn't supported on my environment, etc, etc.
I use Claude Code, Roo Code, Codex and Gemini CLI constantly so I'm no kneejerk LLM hater to be clear. But for all the talk about being "a better version of Google" I have had so much of my time wasted by sending me down endless rabbit holes where I ignored my sneaking suspicion I was being lied to because the answer sounded just so plausibly perfect. I've had the most success by far as a code generation tool vs. a Google replacement.
And then I waste 20 minutes bashing my head against the wall trying to write three paragraphs meticulously documenting all the key gotchas and lessons from the "good" context window with the magic combination of words needed to get Claude back in the right head space to one-shot again.
At least if I pull that off I can usually ask Claude to use it as documentation for the project CLAUDE.md with a pretty good success rate. But man it leaves a bad taste in my mouth and makes me question whether I'm actually saving time or well into sunk cost territory...
So despite the meme that stolen iPhones are "worthless" while locked, the presence of large buyers with demand for unlimited quantities of locked iPhones means that the fence value at the lowest level of the food chain is still more than enough to incentivize rampant theft (even if it were only like $50 to a thief for a $1200 phone, that is worth $200 to a Shehnzen buyer).
I'm making the numbers up, but the point is that even if iCloud activation lock and serialization destroys the vast majority of the phone's value it's not enough to truly discourage theft rings selling to wholesale buyers overseas. It just put the humble local neighborhood thief or opportunist reselling on eBay out of business, with the vacuum quickly filled by organized crime.
In a world where most people don't carry around cash or valuables that's the best a street level thief is going to do unless you run into the odd person with a Rolex or jewelry with rare actual pawnable value, and it's a bottomless crime of opportunity in a big city or festival/concert/etc so adds up quickly.
I also catch it on B roll footage in movies or shows from the 90s/2000s a lot. It’s a specific type of visual blight I rarely ever see after those ultra flimsy single use bags that could be carried dozens of miles on a gentle breeze were eliminated.
(This children's book was written basically at the tail end of the era where seeing a bag flying could conjure the imagination)
https://www.amazon.com/Bag-Wind-Ted-Kooser/dp/0763630012#ave...