HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewzimm

2,294 karma · joined June 14, 2013

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/ewzimm; my proof: https://keybase.io/ewzimm/sigs/_HzNdSjZAgFuWUj-RPvgavSOK_wkOiGNlC1dVJx5-Nc ]
submissionscomments
ewzimm··on Why Would Anyone Use Another Centralised Social Media Service?
HN is still my favorite social media site. All the best online communities I've kept up with since the 90's have been community-driven BBS derivatives attached to a centralized entity where the community discussion is only tangenially related to the hosting organization. A lot of them attracted people who didn't even engage with the host's content much at all. The hosting organization just acted more like a host at a good party, attracting the right kinds of people to connect with each other.

I think there's some kind of a Goldilocks zone that happens when the organization that hosts the social media site engages in good content moderation but doesn't try to heavy-handedly control the conversation according to its own goals, allowing the community to direct itself in a balanced way. This type of attitude could help the fediverse grow too.

ewzimm··on Why Meta is tanking and how Zuckerberg can fix it
It would be interesting to know why Mark didn't choose this option because Alphabet had already structured their company exaclty like this, separating Google from Other Bets, and so there was a clear precedent from a peer. Did Mark ever explain why he thought this was the wrong path for the company?
ewzimm··on iCepa: iOS system-wide VPN based Tor client
This should definitely be fixed, but this applies only to network connections that are established before the VPN is run. Since you can't connect to .onion services before running the VPN, this is less of an issue for this type. Apple services are the most common ones run before the VPN connection is established, but these will be secured between the device and Apple and difficult to intercept.
ewzimm··on The mysticism of Alan Watts (2018)
This is specifically mentioned in Buddhism as one of the ten hindrances, "sīlabbata-parāmāso," attachment to rules and rituals. In Christianity, this is similar to the idea of works-righteousness which was the basis of Martin Luther's Protestant Reformation. In either case, spiritual practice would be meaningless without passing through the messiness of life and learning from mistakes rather than dwelling on them.
ewzimm··on PayPal restores to its TOS $2,500 charge for any post they don't like
This might be true, but I wonder if there's really anyone so unlikable that they couldn't find an audience in the long tail. Extremism unfortunately seems to be able to find a way despite deplatforming. See examples like Nick Fuentes who recently attracted some of the most prominent politicians to his conference.
ewzimm··on PayPal restores to its TOS $2,500 charge for any post they don't like
The first person who gets charged this fine could make a lot of money from publicity if they're smart about it. It's nice that this has been so widely circulated.
ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
Personification is a special case of reification, but it is the underlying issue. We reify signifiers based on memories.
ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
Evolution depends on multiple minds coordinating. A virus’ fate will be decided by thinking people eventually. It’s not fair to talk about something as broad as evolution if you only focus on the early period where determinism is easy to represent with math. The process involves intentions as much as anything.
ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
I like this explanation, but I might say abstractions are mutually translatable in a society. People having similar ideas is convenient but not necessary. I could imagine a society where everyone thought differently but used AI as a universal translator to make their ideas and personalities compatible.

Maybe you wouldn’t consider it a real society if they depended on machine translation, but we’re partially there already. It would still be a collection of minds with their own identities and intentions coordinating through an abstraction.

ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
I’m talking about how the framing makes people think and how we can drift toward abstraction over reality. When we talk about the police or the state being created to do something, we’re implying that the intention involved in its creation might be the most important thing about it. At least it still expresses the will of it’s creator. For something involving as many people as police or states, I think this undervalues the importance of individual intentions over abstract insitutional goals.

For specific examples here like, “the police are not there to help you, only the rich,” you can easily find counterexamples, but let’s be a little more generous and imagine it means that the individual intentions of officers are negated by something else. That something else is more likely to be the interests of real living people and not abstract institutional purposes for which the police were created. The institution might provide them an opportunity to pursue their goals because of the power it presents, but any misalignment of goals with public interest is because of the intentions of people in the system, not the will of the system itself.

Maybe that seems too obvious, but I think it’s established that people tend to anthropomorphize things, and when we talk about the will of the police or the state or a corporation, it’s easy to slip into thinking of an abstract entity as a person with thoughts and desires, which only hides the problem.

ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
Every individual makes this judgment all the time. When people notice a problem with their ideologies, sometimes they will just ignore the issues, and other times they will decide to rebel. When enough people make that choice not to follow the tune, there's a revolution. That's why power is so precarious. It's hard to get people to dance to the same tune forever.
ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
I'm not upset in either case, but that's another good example of the problems in attributing personified intelligence to an abstraction. Especially in the early days, people tended to substitute "God" with "evolution" and shoehorn evolutionary processes into areas where they didn't apply because they used to attribute them to God. This still happens! Sometimes, it's just "the universe."

This was usually based on the further misunderstanding that evolution represents a progression from lower to higher life forms. For example, Engels was especially influenced by the idea that political processes followed Darwinian principles and that societies inevitably move from lower to higher forms, leading toward perfection in communism. In the U.S.S.R., science fiction assumed that aliens would all be Marxists because it was a fundamental law of the universe.

Even in the case of evolution, there are minds with intentions. Our ancestors wanted certain things, and the ones who were able to get them passed on their programming to the next generations.

ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
My answer would be that individual intentions are ultimately the only thing that matters, but they are shaped by cultures which use abstractions to communicate and connect. Social control means learning which abstractions will stick, like finding a catchy tune, but the most memorable ideas aren't always the best. When an internalized abstraction leads to negative consequences, people tend to rebel against it and find another one.

The goals of abstract institutions are abstractions of intentions. They exist in both the minds of those who write them down and those who carry them out, and a perfect translation between those two groups will never happen. If we want to get down reality, we have to talk about the intentions of the actual people involved.

ewzimm··on People Staring at Computers (2021)
In these discussions, there's always an implicit assumption of certain intentions being the "real" ones. Statements like "police were created to..." first imply that there was a creator whose intentions define the police through incarnations, a kind of "god of police," and, more likely, if it was not a single individual, it is a "pantheon of police" composed of its creators and sustainers. And then we have the image of the state as a composite entity which exerts control over the pantheon without being corporeal itself, maybe as the composite will of a class of people.

To me, this idea of the personification of state power into an all-powerful driving force seems more mythological than the importance of individual decisions being made by those who carry out the work of the state. An individual officer may have a similar belief in the intentions of the state, but their actions are ultimately their own.

It seems ironic that the more we tend to be critical of state power, the more we tend to mythologize it into a kind of personification. You might not fall into this trap, but many do. But why should the intentions of the composite pseudo-entity matter more than the intentions of the real individuals who carry out the work? Isn't each police officer a person who has different goals and ideas about who they are and who they serve? Is this really so insignificant, or is it so overwhelmed by institutional goals that it becomes irellevant? Or could the real people and not their abstractions be the real bedrock of civilization?

ewzimm··on Yen slips past ¥150 against the dollar to lowest level since 1990
The Federal Reserve sets interest rates for banks. To slow rising prices, they have been increasing interest rates, which makes people want to buy more bonds because they have better returns. As more money moves into U.S. dollar-based investments, the value of the dollar rises, and the investments based in other currencies that were sold to buy them decrease in value.
ewzimm··on The Rise of ‘Luxury Surveillance’
I had those “Pullman Towns” in mind. This type of system opens up obvious opportunities for exploitation, but so do our existing prison systems. If we ever did replace prisons, I think it would involve something like this.

Since Amazon Prison is so close to life already, we might all benefit from thinking about how to solve its issues. As the legal system necessitates lawyers, a digital prison might need digital advocates programmed by the prisoner‘s representatives. Could we design a digital jail that could both monitor the prisoner and share privileges?

As software introduces more restrictions on our lives, we could benefit from something like an AI “Freedom Box” that represented us while interfacing with proprietary services. People have already made AI lawyers to suggest options. Maybe these could merge with security software to allow us to navigate whatever future prisons we build.

ewzimm··on The Rise of ‘Luxury Surveillance’
If there were an Amazon Prison option, I wonder how many people would choose it. Need to serve time? Skip the cell and stay home with a robust suite of real-time behavior analytics to ensure compliance. Conversations are processed locally and scanned for restricted subjects with advanced AI. A special Amazon Prison store offers a full suite of approved products with automatic payments, accessible with Alexa, and customized meal plans are optimized by biometrics. Need money? Work is available on Mechanical Turk at reduced rates for store credit only. Now available for undocumented immigrants awaiting processing!
ewzimm··on Intel and the $1.5T chip industry meltdown
This is a terrible truth, but the situation has changed in this war because everyone is contributing in organized volunteer centers. The amount of coordination is orders of magnitude greater than was possible a hundred years ago. I don’t think such a large society has ever been so fully engaged in a single purpose in history. Because the strategy is so new, it would be a mistake to assume that old tactics will work against it in the same way they have in the past. Nothing is guaranteed, but I wouldn’t bet against the Ukrainian people even in the worst circumstances.
ewzimm··on Intel and the $1.5T chip industry meltdown
Not everyone would be involved in directly fighting, but there are intelligence networks, supply networks, opportunities for discreet sabotage and falsifying critical data, and many other ways that people can support a resistance movement that would continue even in a fully occupied Ukraine.
ewzimm··on Intel and the $1.5T chip industry meltdown
This is a good comment, but rather than tens of millions of new citizens, they would get tens of millions of new insurgents. Nearly the whole population of Ukraine is involved in the war effort in some way, and it would be impossible to break this completely. The only thing that could be given to Russia with the conquest of Ukraine is the option to turn into Afghanistan instead of North Korea.
ewzimm··on Software and Anarchy (2021) [pdf]
Constantly renegotiating definitions comes with the territory, so I wouldn’t expect this to go away. The name is meant to be provocative, so it fits.

Defining it outside theory is an interesting take. But doesn’t praxis eventually require considering theory when a decision has to be made?

ewzimm··on Software and Anarchy (2021) [pdf]
From the article you linked, “the Zapatistas have rejected and defied political classification.” I think they main issue is that they have a deep indigenous tradition outside of socialist anarchism, although they have clear intersections of thought.

Intentional community development is one of my projects right now, so I appreciate the reference!

I think what you’re describing is something better than anarchism because it has a lot less historical violent baggage associated with it and probably deserves a new name. It might get one if it grew enough. It would probably still involve hierarchies based on consensus and clear limits on scope and time. More arrangements like these would do a lot of good, and I hope we get more of them!

ewzimm··on Software and Anarchy (2021) [pdf]
If you exclude organizations like the PKK, which ones would you consider to be the true anarchists? How about the Industrial Workers of the World, one of the most prominent international anarchist organizations? You can read the constitution at iww.org, and it mainly defines the organizational hierarchy.

I'm curious about your perspective, because when I've seen this argument before, it seems to be based on a personal literal interpretation of the world anarchism as the negation of hierarchy, as if the etymology of the term is more important of the history of the movement. If you have a deeper insight beyond that, it's worth explaining!

Another definition that might be helpful comes from Noam Chomsky's "What is Anarchism?"

"...anarchism is a tendency in human development that seeks to identify structures of hierarchy, domination, authority, and others that constrain human development. And then it seeks to subject them to a very reasonable challenge: Justify yourself, demonstrate that you're legitimate, and maybe in some special circumstances or conceivably in principle. And if you can't meet that challenge, which is the usual case, the structures should be dismantled, not just dismantled but reconstructed from below."

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/noam-chomsky-what-is...

ewzimm··on Software and Anarchy (2021) [pdf]
You can define anarchism to mean the abolishment of hierarchy, but you would be distancing yourself from most anarchist movements. One prominent counter-example would be the Kurdish Workers' Party based on the philosophy of Abdullah Ocalan. It is an anarchist organization with a strict hierarchy. By anarchism, we usually mean the movement that started in early European socialism, developed through Marxism but split with state socialists and distanced themselves from Lenninism, along with all the related movements that developed from it. It has a particular culture and history that has always stood against enforced hierarchies because they get in the way of natural hierarchies that develop through social processes as people make collective decisions and assign temporary leadership roles through defined processes.
ewzimm··on Startup Builds Houses by Pumping Concrete into Inflatable Forms
Earthquake resistance is increased by strengthening the concrete, but it mainly depends on how the structure is built, not just the shape but additoinal measures used to strengthen the structure. We've been stuck on rebar for so long that research on alternatives has stalled, but there are interesting opportunities and developments in that area. For example, basalt fiber and bamboo have potential.

Sustainable, innovative building structures that don't require energy-intensive and corrosive steel will depend on a convergence of strengthening technologies and archtectural techniques, maybe even including ones like described in the original article.

Considering all the environmental and social problems we have with modern housing and construction, this is a prime area for innovation!

https://www.architectmagazine.com/technology/two-natural-reb...

ewzimm··on Startup Builds Houses by Pumping Concrete into Inflatable Forms
Modern uses of Roman concrete go beyond what the Romans did. We can create completely different types of structures using the same principles. Here's an example of recent developments in research:

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/01/210113090920.h...

ewzimm··on Startup Builds Houses by Pumping Concrete into Inflatable Forms
Concrete construction without rebar is more durable and worth bringing back.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_concrete

ewzimm··on NVIDIA and nouveau
I bought a Kepler GPU in 2012, and it's been my most valuable technology purchase ever. It can even handle 3D game development in Godot. I only run free software on my desktop, including firmware, and nouveau works really well. Now I see that Kepler is even in-scope for the potential next-generation drivers, which is really considerate of the developers toward all the people who have stuck with it to avoid signed firmware.
ewzimm··on You can't buy a Raspberry Pi right now
For my project, I could get most of the functionality I needed from an Arduino board by attaching some additional modules, but for more powerful SBCs, I’ve been impressed by Olimex products, although they may have limited quantities available.
ewzimm··on Bruce Willis denies selling rights to his face
Although obvious, I think it’s worth mentioning plenty of great examples of this even beyond the modern media. For example, “less than 1% of people become addicted to OxyContin” (Purdue Pharma) or “AIDS was created by the CIA” (Da Baby, also the KGB), or “Thomas Jefferson had a child with Sally Hemmings” (James Callender).

You can likely find similar stories carved into Sumerian tablets somewhere.

I do think it’s gotten worse in some areas, but the identification of the issue as a modern product of the Internet echo chamber also seems a bit misleading, as it might cause someone to misidentify the problem as a uniquely modern one that we could fix with changes to rules of publishing platforms alone. I’m not sure that the echo chambers in the modern media are worse than they were in Europe during the Hundred Years’ War, for example.

← PreviousPage 4 of 28Next →