1,260 karma · joined November 30, 2018
But pack animals? Maybe. We don't have an answer to how our own self awareness works, so we're largely working in the dark.
As such, this is spam for a vague mailing list.
A more effective approach for anti-CCP activists would be to spam a short, compelling sentence regarding one of CCP's questionable activities, followed by, "Read more here: <multilingual article with citations>".
If that lucid and informative spam got taken down, I'd also be up in arms. I myself invested time in online activism regarding Hong Kong. "Communist bandits", however, is worse than useless. Censor/filter away the low effort and unproductive stupidity, not the substantiative information.
Treating the developer with suspicion, after they clumsily and callously trampled over him. Insult to injury.
That spokesman needs to be fired, and we need to stay angry until Google gives us developers a real pathway of appeal/communication concerning our apps being taken down, so we're not talking to a cold machine when our livelihood is suddenly yanked out from under us. We shouldn't have to make a public fuss to get our apps reinstated.
It's precisely that, because it is driven by hate -- you will understand this if you talk to people who deeply hate communism, such as in my experience Czech people who suffered under it -- and it's a meme, something repeated for social reasons, not to cultivate understanding.
If you can understand what's driving the kids to spam "communist bandits", you will see its ugliness. If you can't, then it's like a curse word in a foreign language: of course you don't mind. It remains, however, a foul little turd to all the people who do understand the context and the language, and who have adequate taste and intellect to prefer higher minded discourse.
To directly address your mischaracterization, this is not crybaby-ism; it's taste and the desire for substance. Nobody is crying about kids posting the hateful meme "communist bandits." I have no affinity for communism myself. I would take equal disgust in kids spamming "capitalist pigs". It's just dumb and ugly.
Give me a thesis with supporting evidence and citations. Meanwhile, delete (indeed, censor!) all the childish and simpleminded spam, so I don't have to be immersed in stupidity and hate when endeavoring to broaden my understanding.
You seem to not mind wading through filth, but most highly verbal adults share my preferences. We leave forums when the filth piles up, and the "discourse" that remains after we're gone reflects this reality.
And now we get to you. Some of us try to be bigger than calling each other crybabies, and calling their positions bullshit. What you wrote violates Hacker News rules. I'm not going to report you, because despite your unflattering model of me, I can pluck out a fly that lands in my whiskey glass without crying about it. This thread should be dead enough that you should be safe, but I'll regret my decision if you go on to attack other people.
I instead hope whatever is broken inside you gets healed, so that you can more effectively tackle what I agree is a problem: a government that forces citizens to literally watch their backs after they voice their mind is influencing countries and companies abroad. Right now, with your hostility, you're just poisoning the well.
* Accept suppression of intelligent dissent.
* Allow all speech, including unintelligent and hateful speech.
This is evidently false, given:
1) Intelligent, well-reasoned dissent against a platform is permitted on virtually all large platforms on the internet, and this has been the case for decades.
2) Virtually all large platforms censor unintelligent, hateful speech.
Your nightmare scenario of intelligent speech disappearing due to censorship of small-minded vulgarity simply hasn't happened.
Quite the opposite, intelligent speech does disappear when small-minded vulgarity isn't censored. See voat or 4chan or the thousands of other poorly censored, poorly moderated places on the internet. Productive, intelligent communication does not happen in public forums without censorship.
Concerning what-ifs and slippery slopes, call me when someone with a well-reasoned argument is being suppressed by a large platform. All I've ever seen is hate and misinformation being pushed down the drain, and good riddance.
Censoring kids spamming "communist bandit" isn't a problem, not in this universe.
Censoring a professor critiquing communism as a viable form of government would be a problem, but that's neither here nor there.
Meanwhile, legitimate problems in the free speech domain are draconian copyright laws, suppressing science and creativity, and espionage laws, suppressing whistleblowers such as Snowden.
If we've decided that free speech shall be our crusade, and we're in the US, our limited time and resources should be focused on these real, ongoing, and broad-reaching problems.
The first party is the owner(s) of a platform. For any owner, there is incentive to preserve power, but there is also incentive to not act as an oppressive villain.
The owner sometimes has ideals beyond power, such as cultivating free communication to build ideas for a better world.
But even the most callous, iron-fisted dictator can sniff the danger in being overly oppressive. They also sometimes recognize that unstifled communication serves as a competitive advantage.
As a consequence, free speech is less fragile than it seems. There are even whiffs of it in China itself: https://www.cecc.gov/freedom-of-expression-in-china-a-privil...
The second party that decides what constitutes an intelligent, well-reasoned critique are the viewers of and contributors to a platform.
We have pitchforks, and pitchforks have sharp ends, but they can be dulled by overuse. Furthermore, the citizen's militia grows weary when called upon too often.
And thus, when the rallying cry is sounded for the non-event of a crude slur being censored, we're eroding our own power. We're jumping the gun, which should fire only when we think an intelligent, well-reasoned critique has been suppressed.
Making a slippery slope argument is betraying a lack of understanding about the above complex dynamic.
They would target anything that gets spammed and reduces the quality of discourse (such as it is on YouTube).
I see no evidence that China is getting any special treatment here. It was the subject of hateful spam, so now it gets a filter. Same would apply to any other country or topic.
From my perspective, the absolutist "freedom of speech"/anti-censorship belief is naive. There would be no havens for intelligent communication online without censorship.
When an intelligent, well-reasoned critique is deliberately suppressed, protest is warranted.
Until then, it's shrill and spammy and divisive and ascribes nefarious intent to people simply trying to keep the room clean and is, ironically, best moderated away to preserve the quality of discourse elsewhere.
The fear is induced by calling electromagnetic waves "radiation," a scary word. If you accurately called these waves "high spectrum light", the fear would evaporate.
The pedantic scientific caution is that our model of electromagnetism may be wrong. Indeed, light may be small demons seeking to enslave us, and only coincidentally behaving in accordance with the Schrödinger equation, but this is unlikely.
And so it is just as reasonable to outlaw rain dances from subsistence farmers in Africa (Our model of cloud formation could be wrong! Who knows what effect these dances could have?), as it is to be worried about 5G.
Myself, I'm looking forward to high resolution, negligible latency VR, as well as no longer having to buy computer hardware: VM's will perform just as well as your tricked out local computer, so it won't make sense to buy computer (or even a smartphone) anymore. The smarts will live in the cloud, and you'll just need a screen, an input device, and a connection to work or game. 5G is coming, so you might as well be excited about it!