HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

falserum

250 karma · joined October 21, 2023

submissionscomments
falserum··on Abnormal brain structure seen in children with developmental language issues
How extensive safety testing of a hammer should be?

Should there be double blind clinical trials for it’s health impact when caried daily on a tool belt?

For most people, answer will differ depending on what the hammer is made of (iron vs uranium vs radium).

My point here would be that a) we must choose appropriate set of tests as they cost in money/time/opportunities, b) the choice of tests must be influenced by what we know and/or suspect.

If unknown is unknown, then we don’t know that we need a test for it.

falserum··on Swedish composer becomes Spotify's most-famous musician you've never heard of
Can’t argue on that. More transparency is always good for end user.
falserum··on Swedish composer becomes Spotify's most-famous musician you've never heard of
I think what parent meant was, all poplar art tries to sarisfy some “algorithm”. (Algorithm of what will masses listen to)

20 years ago that was trying to pick good ratios of bass, haircut, and marketing to get into mtv top ten.

falserum··on Swedish composer becomes Spotify's most-famous musician you've never heard of
Does art need to “make a statement”?

I think:

- It is subjective.

- if you enjoy it, then it is art.

Doing music for profit is not a new concept, just look at pop music (and especially “boy bands”)

But if end result sounds good to a lot of people, how is that not an art?

falserum··on Swedish composer becomes Spotify's most-famous musician you've never heard of
Is that actually sketchy though?

- Each artist has different royalties, some are more expensive than others.

- appearantly people do listen to ”cheaper” artists, in right circumstances

- consumers prefer that cost of subscription would be lower

- I assume scenario in the article saves money for spotify, and in turn allows to remain profitable without increasing subscription prices.

Seems it aligns well with interest of consumers in the long run.

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Nice.

Are these numbers the same: “0.5 in base10” and “0.1 in base2”?

falserum··on 8 years later: A world Go champion's reflections on AlphaGo
I have a further nitpick regarding terminology.

Wording like “game is more complex” overal seems incorrect. Game is not complex by itself (for example go rules are extreemly simple), all the difficulty and challenge depends on the skill of your oponent. Game only allows the opponent to demonstrate the skill.

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Is 1/10 (also known as 0.1) a valid number in base 10?

What about same number expressed in base 3? (I think in base 3 that would be written as 1/31)

And what about number 0.1 in base 3? (Which is equivalent to 1/3 in base 10)

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
In neibhouring thread that deeper difference appeared to be: “PI is not actually a number.”
falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
> 1/3 is also a special kind of procedure.

Important to note: When ggp asked for a recursive procedure to generate real numbers, they wanted that exactly same proceedure would generate all reals (not special procedure for each number)

If we have special procedure for each number, then procedure to generate 1/3 is just 1/3. …of course naively assuming notation of 1/3 is as valid as 0.33333…, and that base 10 is not the only possible base.

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Fun.

What about 1/3, 1/7, …? Previously outlines recursive procedure doesn’t generate those.

But yeah, if you deny existance of irrational numbers, and redefine Real:=Rational, then you can generate these “real” numbers recursively and it does follow that all infinities have same cardinality here.

Btw. what is the diagonal of a unit square formed by 4 objects at the corners? I assume it is a rational number. Btw2. If you take that answer and multiply by itself, what do you get?

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Thanks for reply.

When will this reach PI or e or sqrt(2)?

(There are infinitely many numbers that will not be reached by this procedure)

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
1, 1.1, 1.01, 1.001, …

This will never reach 2, so it will not generate all real numbers. (Which was what parent was asking for, to recusively generate all R)

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
> proof of infinity

This combination of words seems strange.

Like: proof of ‘zero’ or proof of ‘left’.

All of them have definitions, not proofs.

(Qualitative distinction of different infinity types has a proof though)

falserum··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
> I'm happy to accept that I have two apples of my desk if all my friends and the guy I bought them from agree with that definition.

That’s useful, but very vague, and very movable criteria for “exists”. (Approx. Must be based in physical reality + enough people subjectively agree on it)

Do following finite numbers exist: -1, 0, 0.5, PI, 2^300 (more than particles in observable universe), sqrt(-1)? Do individual digits exist? If PI exist, how many digits does it have? Do models and algorithms in general exist? Do model existance depend on limits of your/somebodies capacity to understand them?

I would propose alternative, but useful way to look at this. “Two” and “infinity” are models. Both these models are useful, but “two” is just more common one. (Still, various infinities are useful for bunch of people)

falserum··on Abnormal brain structure seen in children with developmental language issues
Problem is that unknown unknows are not actionable.

You dont even know what or where to look for them.

(Though I agree regarding hubris part)

falserum··on Abnormal brain structure seen in children with developmental language issues
Are audiobooks much easier for you than physical books? (I’m just comparing notes)
falserum··on YX Problem
Might be abit too dramatic regarding consequences.

Mentoring is force multiplier in virtualy all scenarios, but there is a fraction of people who are self starting eager readers, that will manage to get out of the newbie stage on their own (as long as they are not actively sabotaged).

Btw. You sound overburned. Btw2. I find being selective of whom to help, very healthy for me.

falserum··on I summarized my understanding of Linux systems
I found it useful. Allowed me to compare if I have similar idea to the author.
falserum··on YX Problem
Thanks.

Good to know that there was no repealment for Cunningham’s law.

falserum··on YX Problem
Duplicates could be useful if they are properly linked with earlier question/answer. (Something like “import answer” could be useful)
falserum··on YX Problem
> but it's unfair to the dozens of people who follow in their footsteps and find their question years later.

Exactly.

In similar fashion: duplicate questions are alternative ways how people can find the question. (I.e. Useful for later searchers)

falserum··on YX Problem
I bet that problem was not the answer but how you did it.
falserum··on YX Problem
> The X answer is a lecture on language theory including the construction and inversion of finite state automata.

To be helpful and educational, one must describe/illustrate the failure mode of X. For example just demonstrate how unwieldy pure regex is for more constrained question like “regex to check if there is no ‘ab’ within 3 char string”. “a[^ab].|.a[^b]|[^a][^a].”. (Solution complexity grows with length of the string within which we are searching)

falserum··on Mass timber is great, but it will not solve the housing shortage
Some of those reason might be change by government policy.
falserum··on Amid explosive demand, America is running out of power
This point seems to be overlooked very often.
falserum··on Amid explosive demand, America is running out of power
I guess dictionary is a good start.

> noun 1. an act or instance of using or expending something carelessly, extravagantly, or to no purpose.

falserum··on Amid explosive demand, America is running out of power
https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/nuclear-constructi...

> It takes around 6 to 8 years to build a nuclear reactor.

(Note: There is no data on planning part though; not so easy to methodically measure probably)

Point still valid, but 20 years seems excessively pessimistic.

falserum··on The Law of Leaky Abstractions (2002)
Seems like you missed the point of the article.

Yes, most of the article is dedicated to describe the “leak”, but there was no call to abolish abstractions. Just the insight that one needs to understand implementation of those.

falserum··on The Law of Leaky Abstractions (2002)
Thats the first part.

The second part is that you must acknowledge that it is JUST an abstraction, and learn&understand what actually happens.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →