HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

falserum

250 karma · joined October 21, 2023

submissionscomments
falserum··on The Law of Leaky Abstractions (2002)
> Writing your program to use UDP instead of TCP won't make it …

There was no proposal to use UDP, so this comment is not about the article.

The point of the article is near the end:

> the only way to deal with the leaks competently is to learn about how the abstractions work and what they are abstracting. So the abstractions save us time working, but they don’t save us time learning.

I.e. To competently use an abstraction, one needs to understand what happens under the hood.

falserum··on Array languages vs. the curse of the spreadsheet
Relevant part of the comment

> the English keywords used in programming languages are thus just abstract (mathematical) symbols that are incidentally also English words

Explanation: People learn python without understanding meaning of keywords used. One must understand what ‘for’ means in python (i.e. repeated execution), but there is absolutly no necessity to understand what it means in English ( https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/for )

falserum··on Could Modified Gravity Kill Planet Nine?
Process is (laymans understanding):

1. you observe a galaxy doing something strange

2. whatever it does, you add just enough dark matter to account for that behaviour.

Such process seems fishy, because it can explain ANY observation.

If we would go back 130 years ago where GM was not a thing yet, and GM would be competing with DM theory, occams razor would point to DM, because it is simpler one - it fits with newton nicely.

(not an expert though, just repeating stuff I heard on youtube; I’m happy that experts work on all kinds of angles)

falserum··on A 45 year engineer clears up electric sauna ventilation
Where I live, saunas have the stove’s inlet outside the sauna itself.
falserum··on Elon Musk sues Sam Altman, Greg Brockman, and OpenAI [pdf]
Thing to keep in mind. That Musk even might force to open up GPT4.

That would be nice outcome, regardless of original intention. (Revenge or charity)

Edit: after a but of thinking, more realistically, threat to open sourcing gpt4 is a leverage, that musk will use for other purposes (e.g. Shares in for profit part)

falserum··on Elon Musk sues Sam Altman, Greg Brockman, and OpenAI [pdf]
> included generations that were deemed unsafe

How was it unsafe? How was those generations causing harm? (Curious, Just in case somebody read the report)

falserum··on Nokia is replacing Huawei at Deutsche Telekom sites in Germany
What is 996 (short googling gave only a model of a sports car)
falserum··on Money bubble
Oh, how nice it would be to have AI give medical advice.

(From time to time I have some trivial questions, but not enough hundred valued bills, to ask actual doctor)

I agree with your point though, before starting on chemotherapy I would definitely shell out some money for opinion of a live doctor.

falserum··on It's that most wonderful time of the year when tech cannot handle the date
I liked how author wrote it. Especially this line :)

> fast-tracked to insanity

falserum··on Pql, a pipelined query language that compiles to SQL
Because SQL is a nightmare. (Standard is in thousands of pages; nobody fully implements it; not actually a single language as usually each db has deviations and extensions; nonmodular, composability is hard - an afterthought)

And the worst part: nothing better exist; single’ish bad language is better than dozens of new shortlived ones that have quirks in various other places.

But somebody needs to be idealist and keep trying.

falserum··on Boeing missing key elements of safety culture: FAA report
Most people are only mildly greedy, but that accumulates as a silt in a river, and eventually gives opportunity for more serious greed to manifest in full glory. Corporations, while are not democratic in nature, still get nudged in various direction by all the people around it, not only execs, but (even if differently weighted) also employees, customers, voters. As it is the environment where corporation operates in. Btw. I know it’s a bit of a stretch, but I would call turning a blind eye to minor infractions done by others as manifestation of minor greed. (acting would cost my time/energy without benefit to me)

> that specific companies that are found systematically guilty of some sort of crime should be forcibly disbanded.

There are limitations what can be actually done to boeing, even if a lot of people agree that boeing is faulty.

It is not feasible to just nuke it from the orbit. (As in, “there was boeing a minute ago, and now there is vacuum”) For example, somehow supply/services to Us military MUST be kept. Maybe restructuring, maybe some execs investigated, maybe penalty, but military must be supplied. (Not disagreeing with the sentiment regarding accountability per se, but implementation must be compatible with current reality)

> You're on Hacker News, so I have no doubt at all that you're living your life in good faith.

Thanks for that, but I would caution you to adjust this heuristic. As I see it, HN is a good filter for tech curiuosity, but it is orthogonal to a lots of things. I’ve read that suicide bombers frequently were engineers.

falserum··on Boeing missing key elements of safety culture: FAA report
No, we can not solve corruption, because people are greedyand organization needs hierarchy.

Regarding climate change I have hope, but again, same greed, kind of would dictate that at best we will slow it down.

Whatever you will decide to do with boeing, you will have to make employees, shareholders and numerous clients (incl. Us military) content.

Btw. I own a share of a fund which has shares of boeing. Should I go to jail?

falserum··on When Apple takes the European Commission for fools: An initial overview
Yes, I agree, the line is blury, because it’s hard (impossible) to define objectively what market it operates in.
falserum··on When Apple takes the European Commission for fools: An initial overview
It can be argued that it is not monopolistic, because it dies not have 50% of market share.

At the same time, it is a clever technique. Create a walled garden, and subvert free market (act anticompetitively) only there. As long as your garden does not exeed 50% of the land, your golden.

falserum··on CRE vet says 30% of office buildings are 'basically worth nothing'
Since we need both, appartments and farms, let’s extend that to: convert office building into appartment and have horizontal farm vs convert office building into vertical farm and build new appartment.
falserum··on Efficient recovery and recycling of cobalt from spent lithium-ion batteries
> it effectively replaces fire and chemicals with clean, cheap renewable electricity

Does it mean it can work on intermittent electricity? (Cheapest renewable is intermittent)

falserum··on Parasite infection is associated with entrepreneurship (2020)
Not everybody has access to it. Somebody needs to deliver it to the masses.
falserum··on TSMC is having more luck building in Japan than in America
They dont need to conquer the country, they just need to damage the factory.

(Only tiny bit relevant Russia allegedly blew up ammo depo in Czech republic in 2014 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Vrbětice_ammunition_war...)

falserum··on Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution
Id we are being charitable to firepeople, I assume, that bikelane will reduce width of auto part of the road, thus making difficult: for firetruck to drive on it or make turns, other cars can not allow through the firetruck.

(Maybe amsterdam bikelanes were not an afterthought and took all this into the design)

Diclaimer: I have no idea, just speculting

falserum··on A former Gizmodo writer changed name to 'Slackbot', stayed undetected for months
I assume op’s system was to allow A to ssh to B, but not to C. (With lot of different As and Cs)

Where “but not to C” is the reason for existence.

How certificates simplify that part?

(Never used them, but my understanding they are usefull when you want x1,x2,… ssh’ing into y1,y2,…; two uniform sets; if set sizes approach 1, then cert usefullness aproach zero)

falserum··on A former Gizmodo writer changed name to 'Slackbot', stayed undetected for months
> cloaking your account

This seems like a bit of strech for “cloaking”. (Like wearing vaguely similar colored t-shirt as employees do)

> continuing to access them when you know you're not allowed to

This part is rock solid.

falserum··on Satoshi – Sirius emails 2009-2011
s/thinks/decides/
falserum··on Satoshi – Sirius emails 2009-2011
Quantum superposition
falserum··on Satoshi – Sirius emails 2009-2011
> Did the inventor of Bitcoin do something wrong to allow for a judge to violate their privacy in a court case? That's the only way I see the info getting out, but is there a crime to allow that situation to arise?

This feels like wrong framework/approach. Fundamentaly question here: “is it worth it for somebody?” Economists path to an answer: If for somebody[3], profit[1] of identifying satoshi outweighs the cost[2], it will be done.

[1] profit in very abstract sense. E.g. elimination of (perceived?) threat, aquisition of credible threat to other enemies, political points, money, making an example for others, showing off skills.

[2] “cost” is also used in very abstract sense. E.g. Favor from a known(or compromised) judge, man hours dedicated by FBI/MI6, money, negative press budget after “bending” some rules, risk of getting caught by supriors/underlinglins/press/constituents.

[3] “somebody” - to no surprise - can be anybody/anything. E.g. A corporation, a government, maybe single branch or department, maybe sole individual able to use his government position for personal gain, an employee of ISP, a blockchain historian, most likely Satoshi’s ex.

Important to note: both individuals and governments do break the law when they think it is necessary.

I find at least two credible incentives to find satoshi:

- bitcoin can be used to lounder money, circumvent financial sanctions, so governments want to stop that and make example of it.

- Satoshi, has 1 000 000 bitcoins. That’s a lot of money. a) banal roberies are done for far less. b) CIA or similar might want to know who wields this much resource, friend or foe (especially if its value would grow even more)

How Satoshi can be uncovered I have no idea, but the story of Silkroad owner shows, that minor slipups can be revealed after number of years.

falserum··on Private company landing on the moon today
If it’s waterproof your legs will be wet anyway (sweat will accumulate)
falserum··on Python datetime pitfalls, and what libraries are (not) doing about it
Mist likely it was: It’s a low effort proxy for “this comment is most probably written only after only reading the title”
falserum··on Python datetime pitfalls, and what libraries are (not) doing about it
For educationary purposes: TFA=The Fucking Article

(I’m voting for not being afraid of curse words; if they are relevant)

falserum··on Python datetime pitfalls, and what libraries are (not) doing about it
Instant in history -> GMT+0/UTC

Future shedule for humans to coordinate (contracts, meetings) -> ZonedDateTime

Personal alarm that should be kept in sync with the sun (e.g. go to sleep) -> LocalDateTime

What’s good example/purpose for OffsetDateTime?

falserum··on Python datetime pitfalls, and what libraries are (not) doing about it
1. Contract says that goods must be delivered at 4pm.

2. Government suddenly changes the law and moves the offset of whole country.

3. Contract is still valid, goods have to be delivered still at 4pm, but with new offset (so at different utc time).

(I guess timezoned time would still be better than local time, but UTC would not work here)

falserum··on Python datetime pitfalls, and what libraries are (not) doing about it
> how do we represent the 2am in "clock changes forwards at 2am".

If we are willing to adjust a tiny bit, there are options:

Option1: “01:59 is followed by 03:00”.

Option2: “clock changes forwards at 2am GMT+2” (GMT+2 is offset before the hour jump)

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →