HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fargle

1,337 karma · joined August 28, 2019

submissionscomments
fargle··on The Physics Trick That Makes These New Super Cars So Insanely Fast
please, if your article is behind a paywall, post a version that everyone can read.

https://archive.is/2P9Z2

fargle··on The Lenna Story
the artificial outrage over what is a simple beautiful photo lead me to actually go and find the original magazine and purchased it.

should we ban it because someone knows the "dirty" secret of scanlines 600+? does it make some new engineers uncomfortable or feel negative? is it erasing history to bury it for future publication? are we truly being puritanical enough? and only for just the right causes?

who knows? i don't. i just bought it to read the articles.

fargle··on World conker champion found with steel chestnut, cleared of cheating
roshambo. southpark style.
fargle··on Bridge to Nowhere
> practitioners’ general and typical inability to separate fantasy from reality.

i don't think that is proven, nor true. simply begging the question.

to hear you debate, it's as if you believe that generally anyone in the role of chaplain, minister, priest is obviously a schizophrenic nut job (general and typical inability to separate fantasy from reality). one of these days, i hope, you will find out that there are people, of all religions, that live for nothing except to help others. why insult them?

fargle··on Tesla Motors Linux Kernel
> The proper way to do a vulnerability audit is by building and running code under test in sandboxed environment, and running each CVE-indicative sploit against it.

that doesn't work if there isn't an exploit

the other problem with both "clipboard audits" and your suggestion is that neither take into account the full context of the system. in general, a potential vulnerability might be significant, but in the context of your system, or tesla's, it might often be completely irrelevant. the converse is also true, and more problematic. it is very common for a potential vulnerability to be masked by other system characteristics.

the only way to do an audit is to do a comprehensive review of known potential vulnerabilities in the full context of your entire system stack and a well defined threat model requirement. otherwise, you will both underestimate some and overestimate many others. and you can't assume this is static; it must be repeated continuously because inputs and assumptions are constantly changing.

patch-and-pray is worse than a waste of time.

fargle··on An exoskeleton let a paralyzed man walk, then its maker refused repairs
> "Straight’s path to paralysis started in the 1990s at the Saratoga Race Course".

why is that ridiculous? seems tragic to me; not to mention the horse broke his neck as well.

fargle··on FEMA spent nearly half its disaster budget in just 8 days
it's almost like, some kind of a disaster happened. i do hope they will be ok (i'm imagining severely blistered fingers in the check writing division)
fargle··on The Atlantic Did Me Dirty
indeed. somewhere the world's tiniest violin must be playing a very sad song for her

perhaps, and maybe i'm just spitballing here, the author of the article didn't agree with her take on things does she really think that if you are interviewed by a journalist, that they are compelled to agree with you and take your side? and if they don't they "did you dirty"?

ugh. this is the kind of self-important english teacher i'm very happy to despise.

having eagerly digested all those great literary works and wisdom of the ages, and trendy modern ones too, i wonder how long it will be before she discovers the source of her feelings of "demoralization" (and it's not some hack journalist at the atlantic)

fargle··on Palmer Luckey: Every country needs a 'warrior class' to enact violence on others
contrary to a sibling comment, your last few sentences are 100% right.

military service-men are special because of their sacrifices they all make, whether it be health, freedom, separation, adversity, injury (mental or physical), or ultimately even death. they do this out of respect and service and to protect their families, loved ones and communities.

every society does, in fact, need those who sacrifice for the good of others.

very, very, few military people get off on killing - these are also called psychopaths. the rest of the servicemen that have been put in that position to kill, even in war, will always carry scars.

clearly Palmer does not speak from experience - he's a naive autistic, imagining that simply being part of Anduril makes him a party to the "violence" while in reality he's a healthy billion dollars away from it - of course he can sleep at night!

fargle··on Boy named after Star Wars character denied passport due t copyright infringement
why in heck would you want to go there when you could just go to Oakland, CA

https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/traveladvisories/...

    Exercise increased caution in the Dominican Republic due to crime.

    Country Summary: Violent crime, including armed robbery, homicide, and sexual assault, is a concern throughout the Dominican Republic. The development of a professional tourist police corps, institution of a 911 system in many parts of the country, and a concentration of resources in resort areas means these tend to be better policed than urban areas like Santo Domingo. The wide availability of weapons, the use and trade of illicit drugs, and a weak criminal justice system contribute to the high level of criminality on the broader scale.
fargle··on Torvalds weighs in on 'nasty' Rust vs. C for Linux debate
bingo. i think that is the best read on the situation.
fargle··on Windows NT vs. Unix: A design comparison
this is a lovely and well written article, but i have to quibble with the conclusion. i agree that "it’s not clear to me that NT is truly more advanced". i also agree with the statement "It is true that NT had more solid design principles at the onset and more features that its contemporary operating systems"

but i don't agree with is that it was ever more advanced or "better" (in some hypothetical single-dimensional metric). the problem is that all that high minded architectural art gets in the way of practical things:

    - performance, project: (m$ shipping product, maintenance, adding features, designs, agility, fixing bugs)

    - performance, execution (anyone's code running fast)

    - performance, market (users adopting it, building new unpredictable things)
it's like minix vs. linux again. sure minux was at the time in all theoretical ways superior to the massive hack of linux. except that, of course, in practice theory is not the same as practice.

in the mid 2000-2010s my workplace had a source license for the entire Windows codebase (view only). when the API docs and the KB articles don't explain it, we could dive deeper. i have to say i was blown away and very surprised by "NT" - given it's abysmal reliability i was expecting MS-DOS/Win 3.x level hackery everywhere. instead i got a good idea of Dave Cutler and VMS - it was positively uniformly solid, pedestrian, uniform and explicit. to a highly disgusting degree: 20-30 lines of code to call a function to create something that would be 1-2 lines of code in a UNIX (sure we cheat and overload the return with error codes and status and successful object id being returned - i mean they shouldn't overlap, right? probably? yolo!).

in NT you create a structure containing the options, maybe call a helper function to default that option structure, call the actual function, if it fails because of limits, it reports how much you need then you go back and re-allocate what you need and call it again. if you need the new API, you call someReallyLongFunctionEx, making sure to remember to set the version flag in the options struct to the correct size of the new updated option version. nobody is sure what happens if getSomeMinorObjectEx() takes a getSomeMinorObjectParamEx option strucure that is the same size as the original getSomeMinorObjectParam struct but it would probably involve calling setSomeMinorObjectParamExParamVersion() or getObjectParamStructVersionManager()->SelectVersionEx(versionSelectParameterEx). every one is slightly different, but they are all the same vibe.

if NT was actual architecture, it would definitely be "brutalist" [1]

the core of NT is the antithesis of the New Jersey (Berkeley/BSD) [2] style.

the problem is that all companies, both micro$oft and commercial companies trying to use it, have finite resources. the high-architect brutalist style works for VMS and NT, but only at extreme cost. the fact that it's tricky to get signals right doesn't slow most UNIX developers down, most of the time, except for when it does. and when it does, a buggy, but 80%, solution is but a wrong stackoverlflow answer away. the fact that creating a single object takes a page of code and doing anything real takes an architecture committee and a half-dozen objects that each take a page of (very boring) code, does slow everyone down, all the time.

it's clear to me, just reading the code, that the MBA's running micro$oft eventually figured that out and decided, outside the really core kernel, not to adopt either the MIT/Stanford or the New Jersey/Berkeley style - instead they would go with "offshore low bidder" style for the rest of whatever else was bolted on since 1995. dave cutler probably now spends the rest of his life really irritated whenever his laptop keeps crashing because of this crap. it's not even good crap code. it's absolutely terrible; the contrast is striking.

then another lesson (pay attention systemd people), is that buggy, over-complicated, user mode stuff and ancillary services like control-panel, gui, update system, etc. can sink even the best most reliable kernel.

then you get to sockets, and realize that the internet was a "BIG DEAL" in the 1990s.

ooof, microsoft. winsock.

then you have the other, other, really giant failure. openness. open to share the actual code with the users is #1. #2 is letting them show the way and contribute. the micro$oft way was violent hatred to both ideas. oh, well. you could still be a commercial company that owns the copyright and not hide the, good or bad, code from your developers. MBAAs (MBA Assholes) strike again.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worse_is_better

fargle··on Yosys and slang: A match made in heaven
yosys [1] is the the open-source synthesis tool and also supports formal verification and other analysis.

however, it's Verilog front-end is basically Verilog-2005 with a hodge-podge of newer features added on but it is unfortunately very buggy and incomplete.

Mike Poploski's slang [2] is an absolutely top-notch System Verilog parser and elaborator that already supports nearly all System-Verilog 2023 features already.

why not adapt the slang front-end to yosys so we can have a proper modern System Verilog HDL entry with yosys's excellent synthesis and analysis engines?

Martin Povišer just did it! Thank you Martin.

[1] https://github.com/YosysHQ/yosys [2] https://github.com/MikePopoloski/slang

fargle··on LwIP – Lightweight IP Stack
the stack itself is extremely solid and works perfectly with reasonable performance. the codebase is extremely stable and has not had major changes, nor significant bugs in ages.

the biggest problem with lwip is the documentation. you have doxygen API docs that tell you exactly what the interfaces are (and not much more than the reading the header filed does), you have a few pages of "how to ..." and higher level background. but often it's slightly bit rotted, subtly hasn't kept up with design changes. so it's difficult to learn - you effectively have to thoroughly read the code to get the big picture. and if you make a mistake in handling your application callbacks, you can easily leak buffers or create other problems. it's not "awful to use", it's actually very simple - once you understand it, which is seriously hampered by truly lacking documentation.

the second issue is that the SoC vendors inevitably pay some overseas contractor to do the port and MAC/PHY drivers and example code, just like another [1] comment describes. that's where a lot of the instability and bugs come in. it's not lwip, it's the port that sucks.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41462602

fargle··on Why So Many People Are Going "No Contact" with Their Parents
agree with that. it's just interesting as the story expands to see in the Amy case, there's definitely two sides to that one.

btw. too late to edit, but i think i mixed up 'former' and 'later' in my comment. anyhow the point there was i don't like the article spending soo much time on the Amy's of the world and equating and brushing off estrangement due to the real abuse. probably more common than anyone thinks.

fargle··on On the direction of baggage claim belts
due in part to the practical application of an eponymous law of nature discovered by Dr. Murphy, the carousels are designed to always turn in the direction that takes your luggage away from wherever you are standing.

over 97% of the time, it is found to require more than 540 degrees of carousel rotation for your luggage to reach you, regardless of where you stand or move. this fact remains true for all passengers simultaneously. except for that one damn guy who got upgraded to 1st class and now his suitcases were first to come out right in front of him too (we collectively hate him).

note: this is statistically impossible, but airport bureaucracies and Dr. Murphy are clearly not subordinate to mathematics.

fargle··on Why So Many People Are Going "No Contact" with Their Parents
spent the 1/2 half of the article reading about "Amy". Her story is sympathetic, but so also is her families'.

Then we get the the abrupt turn: "One woman had spent much of her twenties coming to terms with sexual abuse from her father" and "Several described a family member as a classic narcissist or as toxic."

wait. wtf? are you comparing flat out sexual and mental abuse with "i'm liberal and my parents/siblings are super religious conservative"?

in the former case, sympathetic or not, you have selfishness and egos on both sides.

by the end of the article, "Amy" begins to appear to me to be about the most self-centered narcissist herself.

in the case of actual toxicity, abuse, etc. it's easy. short of that it would seem to be more a case of "it takes two to tango".

also, how many more parents reject/abandon their kids for similar or lessor reasons? plenty for sure. doesn't make that right either.

fargle··on Why So Many People Are Going "No Contact" with Their Parents
please, if you must post a paywalled article, add a link so we can read it

https://archive.is/JAJnU

fargle··on Brazil judge blocks Starlink accounts as X suspension deadline looms
i was thinking the same thing or maybe his boss or another higher judge!
fargle··on You are not dumb, you just lack the prerequisites
> Do some people's brains "just not like reading?

yes, certainly. pretty common - outside of a disability, we can all learn to read, but it's hard and not enjoyable for many.

> Do some people's brains "just not like music?

yes. (when i say "like" btw. i meant roughly "natural ability", not "enjoy") of course most people love to listen to music, but many people do not have much of a musical ability - and you can't work, learn, or practice your way into it beyond a certain point, either.

> There's nothing special about math here

yes.

some people are terrible at dealing with socialization and others are brilliant. we are NOT all wired the same way. we all have different abilities. what justifies that claim is several billion examples.

fargle··on You are not dumb, you just lack the prerequisites
not untrue, but only part of the story.

certainly your math skill level neither makes you "smart" or "dumb" (which really aren't opposites, either).

prerequisites are (ahem) required. not having them does imply having a bad time.

what's missing is that different people's brains work differently and people have different talents.

if you learn differently, that can factor into that lack of prerequisite knowledge - perhaps the way it was taught didn't work for you.

but some people's brains just don't like math. other's are gifted at it. you can have all the prerequisite knowledge needed, be the best most diligent student, be wildly intelligent in general, and still not just "get" math.

so this article was about someone who actually did have a decent proclivity to math, but was robbed of it because of some missing foundation. and then said "ah ha!" there's the problem! but that doesn't mean that's the case for everyone else - far from it.

it smacks of the "affirming the consequent" fallacy:

    ("dumb" => !math) !=> (!math => "dumb")
    (!prereq => !math) !=> (prereq => math)
fargle··on Python’s Preprocessor
confused why coc is okay, dong is not okay.
fargle··on US judge throws out FTC's ban on non-compete agreements
agree! they should be banned, but the FTC was clearly (over)-reaching here. the correct way to do it is via law. even though it is the right thing to do, it's just the wrong way to do it. blocking and de-incentivizing monopolistic behavior like this is one of the most useful things a government should do.
fargle··on X ordered to pay €550k to Irish employee fired after yes-or-resign ultimatum
this is a good point. there really used to be two major items that were part of this asymmetric leverage. one of them, retirement plans, have started to disappear, and that's a good thing.

- as you mentioned health insurance (and to some extent life insurance, cheap when young, but not so cheap as you get older)

- retirement. this seems to be steadily changing to 401K type schemes. the 85 point (age + years of service = 85) pensions are solidly in the rear view mirror, and i for one, applaud that. you can take your 401K where-ever you want and decide for yourself what age and how much money you need.

but i have other problems with "universal" health care though; the VA has something like this and it's not better. must it be that way? maybe not, but is it likely be that way? yeah...

then you have the free-rider problem vs. basic human rights. i'd just be happy if everybody could purchase the same insurance at the same price employed or not if they wished to do so. it's not quite there yet, although i have received quotes from Kaiser in CA for equivalent individual policies are that are nearly the same price to what just my parole deduction portion is from $$big$$corp - not counting their ~40-50% portion. which implies, as usual, big companies are being not very efficient. billing is a disaster; why is my insurance charged $50,000 for something i can buy out-of-pocket for $5,000? patents and drug companies are a disaster; problem: drugs are too expensive - solution: give artificial monopolies...

so what we've done so far in this country manages is a half-measure that manages to be worse than what we had before and just as bad or worse than some ideal universal health care would be. i acknowledge that health care is a thorny problem, nothing seems to be a good answer and we're highly unlikely to be fixing it (by fix, i mean make it better, not just doing more stupid stuff).

fargle··on X ordered to pay €550k to Irish employee fired after yes-or-resign ultimatum
all of that is fine, but my point and what i was responding to is that comparing the US system to "indentured servitude" is completely the opposite of a good analogy to what it is.

you prefer "guarantees". that's fine. i prefer more freedom and i don't want or trust those guarantees. nothing keeps a company from going out of business and then it doesn't matter what the law says or what they owed you - piff - you're screwed right then and there. you can also be run over by a bus tomorrow through no fault of your own in spite of any number of laws to keep that from happening.

> You may prefer living in a world where corporations can wreak havoc with employees lives without consequence (like Vader) but I don’t.

i don't like that either. but realize we both already do live in that world. unfortunately it is a fundamental universal fact of life that enough power and money can be, and usually will be, wielded to do bad things. since you can't fundamentally change that, most "fixes" are just trading one thing for another, or shifting costs to someone else, who is probably poorer and less powerful. every safety net is also a set of handcuffs. every benefit has a cost somewhere else. to move more toward more employment guarantees makes you more of a slave, not less. ironically, more regulation strongly favors the larger bureaucracies and bigger companies at the expense of the individuals and small companies. so now you just encouraged more economic asymmetry.

i'm not telling you what you prefer or what's best for you or what to believe. just realize that everyone does not have the same viewpoint or needs at all. and it's not simply evil vs. good as portrayed in the movies.

i'm sorry to hear about your wife. the quality of healthcare in this country can be highly variable, it's certainly not always bad. i've heard that UK sometimes has different issues. use your intelligence to make the wisest and best decisions you can and be as proactive as possible, that's all you can do, anywhere, anytime.

fargle··on X ordered to pay €550k to Irish employee fired after yes-or-resign ultimatum
> are employees actually at the level of indentured servants (which I would expect to be a contract between TWO parties)

no, it's actually the polar opposite of that. either party is free to end the relationship at any time. there is essentially what is a long term contract (may not be called a contract), but one which either of the two parties can terminate. it's halfway between being a european style employee and being a truly independent contractor. an indentured servant is certainly not free at all to end a bad relationship or to seek a better job or more pay - totally the opposite thing.

and i don't think there's anything wrong with it. in fact, i personally strongly want to move more toward becoming a true independent contractor someday, but the culture of engineering strongly favors employees for what i prefer to do. i'd rather pay my own taxes and handle my own retirement and medical insurance and other "benefits", many of which do not benefit me at all.

when you say "click-or-be-fired" it seems shocking. rephrase it into "agree to our new terms going forward, or we will not renew". i have zero problem with that if that was the situation that was originally agreed to.

now, i don't know what those new terms are or whether they were fair, and that might have been a problem. but simply the at-will employment system isn't wrong on it's own. but in our jurisdiction, not ireland (which is how X appears to have got itself in trouble).

fargle··on Burners eat big losses in desperate race to sell unwanted Burning Man tickets
ooof. finding out that market forces are real must really suck when you "don't have the disposable income to spare" but bought those, now, 50% worthless tickets anyhow.
fargle··on Limits to running speed in dogs, horses and human
well, i never said, nor do i believe that a human's will and intelligence is not a good thing in general. we're probably the pinnacle of evolution, around this galaxy at least. what i solidly do not believe is that "willpower" is an advantage in the much more narrow realm of simply going fast, especially for horses. i think it even slightly works against it. it makes sense - same reason we're naked and have bad teeth - there's no evolutionary push to fix what thumbs and brains can overcome.

> dogged persistence, not any genius

i saw or read that interview and agree. 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration as they say. or maybe 1% inspiration, 50% perspiration, and 49% luck as i sometimes feel.

> If the trainer doesn't show up one day, does the horse train itself?

1. well, yes, they do. they have a strong desire to stay fit and every day we turn them out and they run. it's awesome because they are so fast and good at running. pure joy as they run just as fast as they can. there are plenty of videos of barrel race horses running the pattern by themselves when let loose in an arena, just because they love to do it.

> I've never seen two riderless horses race each other. Does this ever happen?

2. oh absolutely! they love to race each other just for fun and it's probably as fast as they ever go, without a riders weight. we limit how often we turn two young ones out together because they might overdo it and hurt themselves. it's sometimes a show of dominance, but mostly its buddies playing. horses form very close "buddy" relationships and they legitimately play with each other. and play means "run" for horses. they'll run along the fence line, just as fast as they can go until they are totally winded. tails in the air, loving life. not worried at all about your vet bills.

my perspective is this: quarter horses (which are what i have) are the 5th fastest land animal. they are basically evolutionarily perfect for what they do: sprinting. some sources say 55mph but all sources say north of 44mph.

unlike humans they do not need external motivation because they were just built for running. they do not care about the short term, long term, or any other things like that. they do very much like alfalfa. and carrots, and neck scritches. that's basically it.

as with all specialists, however, they are also relatively fragile and while good at a few pretty specific things, they are poorly adapted at other things. like not dying when a plastic bag floats by on the wind, or by forgetting to drink. their digestive system is primitive and rather poorly "designed". if they get stressed out because a you moved something in their environment, they might die of a stomach ache. horses actually invented aspergers and they all have a serious case of it.

more motivations, more intelligence, more will would not improve the speed of a horse, even if it had a human-like concept of that. just as this article implied, racing horses have likely achieved their penultimate performance potential.

willpower is important to human performance, sure. but horses are not human.

horses aren't overall "better" than us, generalist, thumb wielding, humans. but they are indisputably: much bigger, much faster, eat a lot more, and are truer friends.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fastest_animals

fargle··on Limits to running speed in dogs, horses and human
>"data suggest" isn't a strong argument

not my argument, not my words, quoted from from TFA.

> has that been applied to animals?

yes 100% it has.

> Does a dog communicate with his trainer with the depth and accuracy that an athlete does?

yes. i'm more familiar with horses, but the connection between rider/trainer and horse is very deep and precise. people build walls.

your points 1 - 4 are 100% applicable to animals just as well

in my opinion, point 5 is solidly won by the animal athletes

> Human minds are far more capable than horse minds, and so can have goals and make tradeoffs that horse minds are incapable of.

precisely. mind, and will, is not an advantage for raw performance. that's why for example donkeys and mules don't perform like horses - they are technically smarter.

> Do horses make plans for the future?

nope. not at all. they 100% live in the moment. they just like to run and love to do what they're asked to. do you see how, for an athlete, that is the almost perfect thing? it takes humans a lot of training to let their minds blank and get "in the zone". we fight against our minds sometimes.

i'm not saying human smarts or will is not an "advantage" overall. but for going fast? not necessarily. it's just not a "A huge advantage" to running.

Walter, i've enjoyed the back/forth. i also really appreciate the things you have done and created, btw. i'm not trying to be argumentative, but i am trying to expose you to how awesome these animal athletes are. really they are extraordinary. they are, in fact, the real-life dragons and mythical creatures we romanticize, and for once it's not an exageration. perhaps it's difficult to convey, but if you ever can, find a good horse to hang out with. they blow people away. even a bog average horse (or a dog) is 1000% the friend and has at least 1000% the heart of anyone you'll know.

fargle··on Limits to running speed in dogs, horses and human
a man isn't going to run himself to death either. unless you have better friends than me, it'd take a lot more than a little ask or pushing for one of your friends to run themselves to collapse or to death just because you kept asked him to. would you "will" yourself to run yourself to death? few would argue they would or could.

further, from the conclusion: "The case for defined limits in horses and dogs is particularly strong" and "... race speeds in these animals have not increased in the last 40–60 years. Thus, for horses and dogs, a limit appears to have been reached"

"The situation is less clear cut for humans, in particular for men" and "data suggest that a limit to male human speed exists, and that this speed is only a few per cent greater than that observed to date. But unlike speeds in horses and dogs, and sprint speeds for women, speeds for men have not yet reached a plateau"

So if human men have this "will power" advantage, why have they not yet improved to their plateau? (which is still far below the horse)? they certainly have plenty of coaches asking and "pushing" them, and many other strong incentives to go faster.

to me it suggests that is not will power that is an advantage at all, it's instead a willingness to do what is asked just for the sake of it. great horses just have a really big heart and they do love to run. that's their advantage.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →