HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Welders set off Beirut blast while securing explosives
Its not that its going to manipulate me into donating. Its that this sort of action does not ring true. Even if raising funds via 'go fund me' etc is what is purported to happen in many of these events.

If you were involved in an accident of some sort say a car crash, would you say that people should donate to some-cause on account of having heard your story? Would you leverage this event in that way? And if you did, wouldn't you provide some actual evidence that you were there, rather than a couple of links to generic news clips? Surely the bar needs to be a little higher for us to buy into this stuff....

feralimal··on I Tried to Live Without the Tech Giants. It Was Impossible
Well, you are clearly an optimist, which I genuinely appreciate!

I agree, technology is neutral in itself, its just a tool. But, who runs all of it? Is it you? No. Is it comparable to other tools such as a shovel? No, again. The question I ask myself, is 'who owns the algorithm and its parameters?'. Do you? Or do you only have the impression of that?

If you are only 'leasing' the tools as you continue to use them, you are providing corporations the opportunity to learn all about everyone at scale. This confers huge advantages to whoever owns that data, they measure, store and analyse everything they can. But don't share it. There are many examples of this, but how about that amazon doesn't even release data on which books sell best? It simply provides a best seller list.

With that level of knowledge, much of which can be automated, and which you do not have access to, you have a massively asymmetric balance of power. I don't see how you shake off that yoke.

Like I say, I would prefer to move away from the archaic social and political order. But stepping into a highly monitored and supervised cage, no matter how gilded it is, isn't the answer for me!

feralimal··on I Tried to Live Without the Tech Giants. It Was Impossible
After so many years (perhaps starting with the East India Company), the result is that these mega-corporations have finally reached a point where they have had both the power and control of the reins for so long, that life as we know it is not possible without them. We will demand that our ineffective government step aside and that our corporations step up - we will choose to have them technocratically manage us. And the boot up of governance 2.0 will be complete.

My own PoV, is that I wanted governance 1.0 rolled back!

feralimal··on Stanford cancels plans to bring half of undergrads back to campus
I think we're not demanding technological, remote learning enough yet! We will have to go through this charade a couple of times more.

IMO, all teaching as we know/knew it is gone. And those controlling the governance will be happy about that as it removes unnecessary costs.

feralimal··on NSA Owns Everything (2015)
I don't even see the geo-political situation in terms of US or non-US. Or rather, its not a meaningful distinction to make. They are really just administrative regions for a One World Order administered by supra-national bodies such as the UN, WHO. Ie a bunch or organisations that no one voted for yet seem to have the hands on the levers of power. And it seems that "they" are shifting focus to the Chinese autocratic-technocratic model. And that it is planned for the US to take on that model too, at least the technocratic part. Hence we see things such as the roll out of UBI v1 as part of the current drama.
feralimal··on NSA Owns Everything (2015)
PS - here's a link I posted in another comment about the disappearing glasses: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QqxLalvh-4
feralimal··on NSA Owns Everything (2015)
My background is a technologist who observed the Snowden story. I followed some of the details and was genuinely shocked at the revelations therein. I was looking at HN for more info at the time. But I also followed main stream media. The gulf between the technical details that were reported on HN and mainstream news sites was so large, it was clear to me that a damage limitation exercise was being undertaken. That in itself raised loads more questions for me.

Here's a link to a video on Snowden's disappearing glasses: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QqxLalvh-4

Cutting to the chase, if it is as I suggest it is - that most media is there as part of the governance structure to beam a particular type of messaging to us - you then have a few options.

You can refuse what I say, and accept the media as is presented. This is surely the path of least resistance.

If you care about the truth, you can look more deeply and research all ideas before accepting them as true. Just because you see something on TV does not make it true. My thesis is that news media is just production of a show, like a film or cartoon. You don't trust films or cartoons - so don't trust the news. Here's a fun example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5cDYKXMkSRs - check the folder change colour live on the news! Is it fair enough to manipulate what we see on account of a "green" budget?

My bottom line nowadays, philosophically speaking, is that I am only prepared to accept as true that which I can confirm for myself via my own experience. This may sound a weak position, and it is perhaps. But I stand on solid ground as I am personally able to verify whatever I claim.

With regards to events that are presented in the media, I take an aggressive deconstructive position, and ask questions such as: have I been provided evidence, am I being emotionally manipulated, is the story coherent, etc. I find my questioning frequently provides evidence that the story is not coherent, and can be dismissed. That again may sound weak, but the thing with truth is that it is resilient and not incoherent - when you are presented with an incoherent story then you can dismiss and ignore _all_ of it.

So, my default position with media stories is to autohoax them and to lend far greater weight to personal experience.

feralimal··on NSA Owns Everything (2015)
I'm saying that media outlets are an arm of the governance structure that are there to corroborate and promote the story. The only one that researches anything you can trust is you - and that doesn't mean reading the Guardian.
feralimal··on NSA Owns Everything (2015)
The Snowden stuff was the event that shook me to my core. I was a happy technologist till then, thinking that such was the nature of life and progress simply was unfolding in front of me.

However, the way the event was covered by the media - told a different story. The media focussed on the man rather than the info he provided, so the conversation was 'where was he?', 'where was his girlfriend?', etc - that told me everything. They hardly touched on what was provided and what that meant (that we were being spied on 24/7). And what was provided took years to come out...... So, the media are complicit - just another arm of the governance structure we find. The intercept, the MSM, all are just playing a role in mis-informing the people.

Since then, I have even come to change my views on the Snowden event itself. I think this was an intentional release of data, an orchestrated event. Snowden is probably a character created by some agency. He may not be a real person - things like bits of his glasses disappearing indicate that he could be CGI. Perhaps this sounds crazy - but if you are in the business of governance, you want to manage everything, even the opposition. (Think 1984 and the way that the opposition is created and controlled in that book).

Why would "they" create Snowden and the release of apparently top secret files?

Well, if you know what is coming you do not respond with shock, you do not reject it out of hand. You acclimatise to the new reality. There was little we could do with the Snowden event, except watch it play out. We were put on notice and informed of what was/is coming. And what's coming is a technocratic system with very fine grained control in the hands of the technocrats.

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
The article itself presents an ideological position. So, this was ideological from the start.

I am presenting an alternative ideological position that better frames the original one. It is a better framing, because the original is backed on racial grounds, whereas I am making a point based on taking personal responsibility or not (being governed).

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
PS Thanks for clarifying.
feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
Plainly these must be seditious ideas...
feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
I'm fine to carry on this conversation, but I'm surprised to find that its been flagged. Why?

Whether you agree with what I say or not, I think I am expressing a valid viewpoint. I don't think I have been rude or abusive. Do you?

Frankly, I don't even know what being flagged means. How does one do it? Will I be banned for my comments?

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
I have an argument, a hypothesis. I have tested it and I don't find it wanting. You have an opinion. You don't have an argument.

4 or 5 years, I won't quibble.

And oh, how else do you participate in democracy, except for voting? Does one stand for election?

And for me, if I am settled in my thinking that no one represents me and I don't want a part of the extortion system that is in place, do I have to do whatever some group of people say is right to do because they can force me, even though I am doing no harm to another?

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
:) Funny

Of course we don't know what might or might not occur, if the situation were different. But the fact is that neither you nor I decided on roads. The government decided. I don't see what's weak about that.

The government is 'they', its not 'we' (though you may identify with its actions). I want no part of it, but despite my lack of agreement with anything that it does, it is inflicted on me anyway. I am coerced to pay taxes. You are in agreement with a system where a big gang can use their superior numbers to force another person to do what they say, despite that other person having done them no wrong.

So, seriously, if you have a counter argument, please go ahead and make it. Please explain what number or percentage of people makes it ok to force another person to part with 40% of their income against their will. I'd like to hear your argument. Be sure to explain the difference between government tax and mafia protection money too.

Cheers.

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
You participate once every 5 years in voting for one of 2 meaningful options on a list of ~5-15 issues. No one is happy with that choice.

Then, say 50% of the populace vote, 25% get the person who they voted for in. So the 25% (who do not feel fully represented) get to rule over the other 75% who know they are not represented. Basically we all pay taxes into a system that no one feels happy about. And when you think about it, it isn't about what's right - it comes down to who has the force. Its a mafioso monetary extraction system, that indoctrinates its victims. 'Stockholm Syndrome' is the psychological term for when you love your captor; most people who support the government system suffer with this.

As a group of people our views are diverse. That's good, right? Large groups of people are hard to manage. So don't manage them. I don't seek to manage other people's affairs. Government is the solution to a problem that doesn't exist - managing lots of people. People should be self-managing.

PS There's a difference between jumping to the defence of a system that no one is happy with, and finding a way to survive in a system that is collectivising and dehumanising. In supporting the system as you do, you are literally a turkey voting for Christmas. Sorry if that's harsh, but that's really how I see it.

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
I didn't say that schools, roads and hospitals are not necessities. I would say schools, roads and hospitals are necessities for the government to run a modern society. They decided and they did it. You and I paid for it.

Just on the roads point, without a government, we might all be flying personal helicopters, no roads required.

feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
You don't have a choice about being a part of civilisation and whether you pay taxes or not. No choice. But congratulations, you have made yourself feel as if you did and you're happy to go with it. I guess you walk out the door, satisfied at the way your money is spent, the roads, armies, education, etc, etc - just as you would have chosen for yourself!
feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
Great - can you pay me some money too? I'll call it a tax if it will help..
feralimal··on Not all the facts fit the anti-colonialist narrative
Yes.... maybe that stuff wasn't as helpful as you think.

Maybe it ensured that you were trained in a way that you would accept and conform to the world that you were presented with.

feralimal··on What should you do if you come across an unconscious person?
You and me, both :) All the best.
feralimal··on What should you do if you come across an unconscious person?
I'm very glad you took this in the way I intended it! And that you took the time to respond :)

I agree - when I read the original source, you do easily read 'him'; it doesn't jar.

But, like you, I always wonder why they do that. I wouldn't. You can easily use 'they', or say something like, presuming this is a man/woman you would check him/her... etc.

But thanks for replying and taking the critique on the chin!

feralimal··on What should you do if you come across an unconscious person?
A quote in the article, from the Wall Street Journal: "A: Emergency physicians say the first step is to verify that the person really is unconscious. Shout, shake her, or dig your knuckles into her collarbone. That may revive her."

Lol. Who said it was a 'her'? That jumped out at me.

Just checking at the original article though: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB120277331164160573 .. and you can see that in the WSJ, it was 'him'!

So this bookofjoe character, says they are quoting the WSJ but actually changes the quote, making a low level politically correct adjustment.

And I'm the chap (or idiot) who spends my time checking sources, and uncovering this scandal! Lol.

feralimal··on An important part of science is admitting when we’re wrong
Yes. Its not clear cut. But they are all being counted as coronavirus.

The statistics are gamed to prove the case.

feralimal··on An important part of science is admitting when we’re wrong
And the statistics are a mess.

With regards to coronavirus, people who die "with" coronavirus and die of say, a heart attack, are being counted as coronavirus deaths. They aren't dying "of" the virus, they just happen to have it. But this doesn't count as a heart attack statistic.

Not to forget, that there are financial incentives for doctors and hospitals to mark deaths as coronavirus deaths.

feralimal··on An important part of science is admitting when we’re wrong
Who funds them?
feralimal··on An important part of science is admitting when we’re wrong
Well, you don't really know how many deaths were prevented. You have what is effectively public relations arm of the industry computing those numbers.

However, iatrogenic causes are said to be the third largest cause of death in the US. There are various values bandied about, but I think this is in the order of 225,000 deaths per annum. So, this is to say, doctors taking an incorrect action eg prescribing the wrong drug, wrong amount, catching MRSA in hospital, etc, is the third largest cause of death.

I think, but cannot be sure, that this was the case for someone in my family. An elderly relative who had been on the same medication for 40 years, had their medicine changed. Within a month, that person had a stroke, and was dead a year later. Obviously this is anecdotal, and I actually don't think this would even have counted as a iatrogenic death statistic, but it does indicate how this could be the case. And that the actual iatrogenic death numbers could be higher, if it were possible to get accurate breakdowns of causes of death.

feralimal··on An important part of science is admitting when we’re wrong
This is absolutely the case - we need to be happy to admit we're wrong. I think everyone would agree.

But what if your whole paradigm is wrong? What if the entire idea you are labouring under, is mistaken? Can we even consider this and change tack? Can the Verge consider this idea?

No.

I'm indifferent to vaccinations - I don't know if they cause more good than harm. If pushed, I tend to think that the human body is a better handler of disease than doctors, given the right food, water, and general environment.

I do see that the medical industry does stand to benefit from selling vaccines. This is to say that as for a man with a hammer every problem looks like a nail, for the medical industry every problem requires medical intervention. They cannot in good conscience to their shareholders recommend that people eat a better diet, not go to hospital to give birth, nor gain natural immunity. Such answers cannot be leveraged for profit.

I think its fair to say that we have a sickness industry, where all the incentives are to treat sick people. We do not have a health industry - where someone gets paid for ensuring that we live as long and as well as possible. The incentives are all wrong. Perhaps the industry is happy to have a large pipeline of sick people, or people that they can 'treat'. Of course companies think mostly of profit - but would they even go so far as to create (fake) opportunities to open new markets to the world? Do vaccines that needs to be taken annually, by a global population, perhaps mandated by law, constitute a big enough market to make it worth it? Could such an industry admit a mistake?

feralimal··on Google speakers are listening to more than just voice commands
It might not be as high as you think, if they are processing the data and sending a summary over, rather than the raw sound file.
feralimal··on Covid-19 is one of Wikipedia's biggest challenges ever
"With so many Wikipedia editors (and bots) constantly monitoring the mountain of information, misinformation tends to be quickly weeded out."

Sorry - but this is a joke. Wikipedia is a pretty biased and unreliable source of information.

← PreviousPage 13 of 14Next →