HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Zoom lied to users about end-to-end encryption for years, FTC says
No! Corporations lie?!

At least their feet will held to the fire!

/s

Tbh though, they will only be held to account, if another big player wants to cripple them and take their market.

feralimal··on Have Fruits and Vegetables Become Less Nutritious? (2011)
That's all a bit harsh! My gold standard is fair surely! I don't eat like that often, but I can dream!

Agriculture is absolutely a boon to humanity. But that doesn't mean that I need to go along with big agra, does it? I don't agree with oil based fertilisers being used. And monocrops.

It is absolutely the system we have, but its not a good one. Smaller farming, locally sourced food would be a better way to go. I am a fan of permaculture - I'm itching to try this when circumstances permit. This is a way of densely growing food.

feralimal··on Have Fruits and Vegetables Become Less Nutritious? (2011)
I agree. I actually don't think organic is as good as whatever natural methods were used. I would prefer wild or food grown on less 'managed' land - that would be the gold standard for me.
feralimal··on Have Fruits and Vegetables Become Less Nutritious? (2011)
Well, colour me shocked!!

Modern farming doesn't produce as nutritious fruit and vegetables as that of the past. (Where everything was organic, and the land was managed sensibly.)

Maybe we need to 'fortify' our veg, by adding calcium (chalk), and iron (fine iron filings) to it!

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
If I know something about the scientific process its because I try to use it in my personal life. This is to say, I try to be aware of my assumptions, to be clear about the distinction over what I know and what I believe. For myself, I am trying to uncover the truth of our experience in this life.

I think we will probably agree that there are all sorts of problems with science and the scientific process. And that's fine. If should be about putting the best hypothesis forward, trying to edge closer to the truth.

But, the system we have cannot do that. It is funded by corporate interests, that cannot in good faith to their shareholders, present information that may be to the benefit of mankind, if its not in their financial interests. I think that's pretty clear.

Given all that, it does rile me that there are so man science fan boys, that scoff at religion, while acting as if science has the answers. As if they aren't in a state of religious belief! And that they feel they dismiss a piece of anecdotal experience from a real individual, as it wasn't proper science!

Anyway, I'm sorry this wasn't fun, nor eye-opening for you. But at least it was real!

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
> Edit: Now I agree drug companies would not make a big deal about advertising that result, but that’s a different story.

Well, its only a different story for drug companies.

For you and I, as individuals, what value is science, if it will provide you with drug options to imperfectly manage your diabetes, but not tell you how to avoid it completely.

Would you say that science is progressing towards truth and greater knowledge, or towards truth and greater knowledge of how to extract more money from those it is purporting to serve?

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
The bible is a bunch of stories that people believe in. They listen to the priest, read it for themselves. It has value at an allegorical level though. Believers believe it has the truth.

Science has its articles of faith. They pay lipservice to the scientific method and truth. In reality it is executing mathematics or some defined process. It might find the truth in that process, but this is a siloed truth. It is not true to say it is arriving or will ever arrive at the greater truth, if it does not align with corporate or governmental interests.

You yourself may testify to this, given that you say you were hunting for grants. Did you feel that this was about discovery and understanding the world or something else?

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
> For the record, I don't like being used in this manner to further your agenda. I consider it malicious behavior.

How am I abusing you or being malicious? It certainly wasn't intended! I'm talking about you in the third person in the comment you quote me from, but then I was replying to someone else. I'm not misrepresenting what you said, or how I feel about it. That is all honest. I'm not sure what to make of you seeing malice there.

We agree that people are well intentioned but that their data and inferences are wrong.

I would describe myself as a hardcore skeptic, I don't accept data or information on trust. I actively distrust corporate/governmental information. From my perspective, when I hear the opinions on hn, many are simply parroting some consensus opinion that they have not verified. This is to say most are living their lives on the basis of unverified beliefs masquerading as knowledge. This is to say, ignorance.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
> Square these two sentences, because you can't accidentally "only pay lip service to the scientific method". Are you or aren't you claiming that scientists feign their rigor?

You can do everything right, follow the scientific method, but be answering the wrong question.

Eg, asking which of these 3 drugs is best for such and such a disease. Ie you are excluding fasting or other alternatives. You will build up a load of data on those 3 drugs perhaps, but fasting might be best of all. You just don't know.

But a scientist will say that there is no evidence to support fasting. So the scientific method has studiously ignored inconvenient (unmarketable) options.

So is the scientist giving the best information here? Are his/her answers biased?

> > And, be honest, you don't even need them to provide evidence for you to accept whatever they state.

> I suggest that you stop such insinuation.

If you skim articles, watch TV, and don't do research to satisfy yourself, you don't have evidence. You don't know. You may think you know. And thinking you know, when you don't, is dangerous. This is a point worth considering - in my opinion it covers 99.99% of what passes for knowledge.

You may find that you have lots of belief and very little actual knowledge just a compound and rigid set of mutually reinforcing beliefs. (This is akin to religion in fact). Which is at least an honest assessment of what most 'scientists' are practising! They believe that there is a body of evidence that supports what they think, and can take that for granted. No one is checking that the foundations are as solid as they believe!

And that is the point of education.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
I'll try to post an update here in 11 years! I may well have changed my mind! :)
feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Thanks. But are you doing all that personally? Do you have time?

Probably not - I certainly I'm not polling hundreds of people over each minutaie in my life. So, it is likely that neither of us have done the work personally.

The difference is that I distrust the output of science by default. I understand that it is an industry and I'm deeply suspicious of all its pronouncements. I'm on the lookout for the monetary upside, and what isn't being discussed. I love the scientific method, but it is not the be all and end all. What q

Could a drug company ever say:

"Guys, we've done the testing, and the best thing if you have XXX disease is NOT a drug. No, the best thing is to go on a juice diet and prolonged fasting."?

It could not.

With individuals, I am more open. If you can speak to someone, eg Doreen in this case has offered her perspective, that counts for far more with me. I know most individuals are happy to offer help and their perspective out of natural good will. Mostly individuals are trustworthy.

The system that individuals are forced to engage with however is degenerative, and system/corporate/governmental outputs are propagandistic and in the service of the system itself.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Yes - I think I knew what n=1 is/was.

There were 2 reasons I asked the question.

Firstly, I don't like 'inside baseball' talk. In fact we are not at a science convention - it is a public forum.

Secondly, I want to know what the poster means by it. The last sentence where they say:

"those where not tested because again N=1"

- that doesn't make sense.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
While doctors do distinguish between different types of diabetes, my anecdotal experience is that they do not in practise distinguish between the two types. They do not tell type II patients that they will not have the condition if they don't eat carbs.

So which is worse or more harmful? Me, some clown on the internet, bringing this to people's attention? Or 1000s of doctors failing to provide full information to their patients, thereby dooming them to a degenerative life experience, taking ever greater drugs?

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
I'm glad you agree with the gist of my points. I also absolutely understand that you would cringe at my comments. Whatever, I may say though, is no reflection on you.

If you were to meet me in person I don't think you would cringe if we were to talk. But on a forum, you only have a short amount of time to make an impression, catch people's attention, and try to get them to consider what I think is truth. People are so indoctrinated, they can barely recognise it.

Here, on HN, there are many people who love science - it is their religion. They don't think its a religion, but it is - they believe in it, they don't know it. They don't even know what knowing is. The accept the pronouncements from the priest-scientists, as if they were gospel. A cursory review of some science study is all it takes. But the point of science is that it should be verifiable, not based on belief. No one is verifying anything, and when studies are peer reviewed 70% cannot be replicated. 70%!!

In fact, I love science done properly too, but that is nowhere to be found. I hold to application of the scientific method personally. In all areas of my life.

If I have any ambitions in my interactions on HN, it is that I wish for others to engage their rational thinking, not just when tackling a gnarly coding issue, but also in other parts of their lives. I wish that people would think more individually, rather than just going along with the herd, what they have been taught, etc.

Questions people should be asking include: Why is it so medicine so expensive? Has the 'health' system been captured? When was it captured? Why don't we know what the right food for humans is? Why were we taught the food pyramid? Is food medicine? Is pregnancy an issue that requires medical intervention? Etc. If you really start to find answers to those questions, the reality of this existence takes on an entirely different perspective.

I appreciate that you are looking into this stuff for yourself. I appreciate that you are sharing your understanding and anecdotal results. I'm glad that you clarified that it is not n=1 but n=2 or 3. Given what I understand about science, I genuinely value the anecdotal points you raise highly. I have gained much more useful information anecdotally than from 'science'.

Finally, I would say, that along with fasting, I understand that the Gerson method is excellent more providing you with nutrition and along your body the space to repair itself. And in repairing itself, I understand there will be a healing crisis, where the build up of toxins etc may be expelled and that that can mean that one feels worse than ever. But that this is an essential step on the path to wellness.

All the best.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Absolutely, replication repetition does help understand and draw out a hypothesis. But why does that mean that anecdotal evidence is invalid?
feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Had I better not ask what something means?
feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
What does N=1 mean?
feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
> This is a gross insult to the vast majority of scientists.

Its not an insult. I'm happy to accept that most scientists are acting in good faith. As I'm happy to accept most google, apple, facebook developers do not think they are building the prison technology of the future. They simply don't have the bigger picture. Mind you, their jobs depend on not knowing that picture either.

> Whatever problems scientists have with reproducibility, there can be zero expectation of reproducibility with anecdotes.

Why? That's insane. If someone, in person, testifies to their personal experience, that it had an impact on their life, you would ignore that? Corporations pay billions for people to create any old crap if they think there's a market in it. That individual is offering up some personal information for no gain, just as a simple expression of the truth they have found. And you would ignore it?

With the best intent, you need to take a look in the mirror and question whether you are a part of the problem. If you take the word of 'science' over an individual's open expression, you don't have authority over yourself as an individual. Science has authority over you. And, be honest, you don't even need them to provide evidence for you to accept whatever they state.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Thanks for NOT taking the time to explain to me how I'm wrong. I just am wrong, right? So says the voice of science! (I couldn't have asked for a better example of how science pays lip service to the scientific method only!)

I link to wiki, not because I think it is authoritative, far from it. Like the NYT, CNN, Guardian or BBC which deliver us our daily propaganda messages, wikipedia delivers us the historical narrative we are meant to accept. When they themselves say 70% science studies are unreproducible (ie lies) you know that we're in a world of BS!

Science is busted, but I find that individuals are able to relay the truth more fairly and accurately.

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
No problem. The reality is that the medical industry is a sickness industry. Not a wellness industry. There is no incentive for them to make people well, but every incentive to keep people unwell for a prolonged period.
feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
I couldn't disagree more.

With science so utterly serving corporate interests, the only information that has a possibility of being true, IMO, is anecdotal evidence.

This person is applying the scientific method personally, and cautiously. And he is sharing his experience with you. Whereas science only pays lip service to the scientific method. Its only there to make money.

If you are interested in what I'm saying, you want to look into how science is as I say, take a look at the following:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Most_Published_Research_Fi...

feralimal··on Impact of fasting and calorie restriction on cancer cells
Don't worry about not being a doctor - that's a good thing!

Doctors would NOT advise anyone to cut calories by 80% even if, as in your case, it improves your health. Nor would they advise a diabetic to abstain from carbs, and so take away the trigger for their condition. (Ie - you don't have diabetes if you don't eat carbs.) 99.9% of doctors will only prescribe drugs.

The medical industry is not about well - its about maximising illness for profit. And improving diet and eating behaviour is the last thing they will do - there's no money in that!

feralimal··on A68 iceberg on collision path with South Georgia
They worry, because they are told to. They are told that humanity is a plague on the planet. The consequence of this (lie) is lots of hand wringing and self blame.

But there is nothing to be done about one's existence. Though surely some will have killed themselves and many have not had the families they wanted in account of this misplaced belief.

feralimal··on South Park creators have new political satire series with AI-generated deepfakes
Well, personally I think deep fakes are a good thing.

The reality is that 'we' were too trusting of what is presented on screens as true. Its the main piece that is used to manage and govern us.

So, I welcome distrust on what we see on screens - that trust was always misplaced, and all about manipulation rather than information.

feralimal··on Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally?
And before that the predictions were for a mini ice age.

Frankly I have very little faith in these 'projections', whether it is for global warming, or presidential races. I think these are better thought of management techniques in the here and now, intended to achieve a present-day objective, eg increase fear, get consent to take more taxes, stuff like that.

feralimal··on Poll: 62% of Americans Say They Have Political Views They’re Afraid to Share
Win some, lose some! I cracked a couple of sarcastic 'jokes' in previous threads which got upvoted, so I've got points to burn!
feralimal··on Poll: 62% of Americans Say They Have Political Views They’re Afraid to Share
That's an interesting stat, though its political in nature.

I suspect that the disconnect is far wider in scope. Most people are totally perplexed by the disparity between their own reality and what is portrayed in the news. For 3 years we had evidence-free but unrelenting Russia/Trump hate. This seemed insane, but it turns out that was just the warm up act to coronavirus!

The reality of what people see around them is sooooo far away from what is portrayed on the MSM. It amazes me that anyone pays any notice to the MSM at. But what it really shows, is that most individuals are not their own authority in their life. They defer to what is the consensus opinion that is blasted at them 24/7 from the MSM, rather than acting according to what they actually experience.

Imagine, somehow a person was frozen in time, and seeing how the majority live now - scared of living because someone said something on TV!

But that is the power of the media, and why it is such an effective control. The majority disagree with what is portrayed, but feel pressured enough to keep quiet and therefore acquiesce to whatever is being shouted out.

feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
There is always an edge case to justify the loss of freedoms. In the fullness of time, it is revealed that case was just a pretext that doesn't really occur. But the genie is out of the bottle then.

The means is that TV/media play up edge case as if it was important. Once the justification is accepted, the freedom is taken and does NOT come back.

(Media, in case you haven't been paying attention is part of the governance system - driving what is acceptable to think about on a daily basis. No, propaganda is not to be found in China, Russia only - in fact the Western societies are far worse; we are propagandised from cradle to grave.)

Have any of the pre-9/11 freedoms we lost, come back? Travel restrictions, water bottles on planes, etc? They have not. So, an event occurs, this is played up to the n-th degree to justify the loss of control in our lives, and slowly slowly we tip-toe into overt control and domination by the system. In a way you can say that humanity's well-meaning nature - the wanting to do the right thing - leaves us open to these sorts of attacks - ie our good natures are weaponised against us.

feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
> Under this line of reasoning, any level of societal participation is tantamount to slavery. I understand the what you're angling at and I agree to some extent; however, can you provide a viable alternative?

I understand why you ask this. I will respond in a way that I know will be unsatisfactory to you.

The way I see it, is all the actions that we are expected to take that are in service to self (i.e. getting yours). Society is geared up to make that seem perfectly natural. In fact, you/we all need to get acquainted with morality. The first step of that is to understand the world for oneself, to take no one's word for it but instead to apply the scientific method personally. Accept that you do not 'know' much, very little is proven. What you have are beliefs masquerading as knowledge - this is to say you have negative knowledge (aka crap).

What I'm really trying to get at, is that social change is an effect of the actions of all of us in aggregate. To make the world better, one can only attempt to makes oneself better. Be the change you want to see. And that is done by following one's heart/conscience/spirit or whatever you want to term it.

> Society in and of itself is a hierarchy. Anything that contributes to society is therefore something that enforces the 'hierarchical system.'

> You don't have to participate in society if you wish otherwise. The world could always use more mountaintop hermits.

Its not as easy as you might think to not participate in society! To get away from it completely is impossible. People I have never voted for, or agree with, demand, by force if necessary, that I contribute to and support their system.

Right now, you can see the next generation system that has been in design for us. Citizen scores, UBI (carrot), access (or not) to 'social' goods eg public transport, loans (stick), free movement, limited use of energy, water, etc without the 'administrators' say so. Smart water meters, electricity, 5g is the backbone to that.

Still, I don't discount the mountaintop - but I don't think there will be peace there either!

feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
If you haven't worked out that governance is more than the political class by now, we don't have much hope! Educational institutions are as much a part of the problem as media institutions, as politicians, as we are ourselves. In fact, they are probably the worst - taking children and teaching them that the government is good, it loves them, that they are not slaves.

When government is slavery.

And it takes a lot for an individual to turn around and point the finger at themselves, accept some of the blame and make a change.

Most will take the ethic-free paycheck, rather than start to consider how their effort is creating a dystopian future for us all.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →