HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
Is that a joke? I don't care what Harvard has to say about Ethics! Harvard!! The educators of the master administrative class. That ethically outsourced all of the jobs to the rest of the world.

It says:

Code of Ethics As an ACM member I will .... Contribute to society and human well-being. Avoid harm to others. Be honest and trustworthy. Be fair and take action not to discriminate. Honor property rights including copyrights and patent. Give proper credit for intellectual property. Respect the privacy of others. Honor confidentiality.

Fine words! But take a look at the first - "Contribute to society and human well-being." Contribute to 'society'. 'Society' is a fiction. Its not a real thing - its an idea in people's heads. You could just as easily say contribute to stones.

People are the only thing doing the experiencing. Individuals. You can say 'society', but this just a way of avoiding talking about and to individuals.

Ethics questions are for the individual to work out. And it takes work! And the worst thing is that everyone thinks they know what they mean. That they are ethical. That its others that need the educating!

feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
Agreed. The internet, computer and chips though can be (more) neutral with care. They can serve you.
feralimal··on New nuclear plant at Sizewell set for green light
We needed more steam!
feralimal··on Foundations of Software Engineering
More 'ethics-free' guidance, thanks! /s

Yes, we should care about writing good software, what is a good process, how to best satisfy requirements, etc.

But I really would like to see ethical considerations play a role. Sometimes (surprisingly often I think) people should not do the work they are being requested to do. Just because one's boss (and one's paycheck) depends on following a set of instructions, if it goes against one's conscience, what is the point?

I mean, someone wrote these 'track and trace' apps. This is to say, they are explicitly enabling the government to track every single move of its citizens. Is that ok? Not to me. They should have resigned rather than play their part in increasing governmental control.

Unfortunately, technologists are building the dystopia of tomorrow. 'Smart' cities, anything that encourages use of a 'smart' phone, more data in the hands of FAANG, etc, etc.

smart == spy

If you are under the panopticon, you are not you any longer. You respond to please others, not yourself. You are in fact a slave.

Anything that enforces the hierarchical system, making it ever more restrictive, has blood on their hands in my view. We are designing a future that is less free, less accepting, more rigid. No one wants it. But all those doing the work, are selling out their fellows and even their own future rights, for a paycheck today.

feralimal··on Xbox creator Seamus Blackley baked a 4,500-year-old Egyptian sourdough
Atlas Obscura know which side their bread is buttered. Its a (yeasty) puff piece.
feralimal··on Xbox creator Seamus Blackley baked a 4,500-year-old Egyptian sourdough
"4,500-year-old dormant yeast samples"

You have got to be joking.....

It must be that this guy (or his son/daughter) are about to start a 'Ancient Egyptian Bakery' franchise, and needed something to drum up some interest.

feralimal··on Hackers hijack and publish mental health data of hundreds of people
I appreciate your being honest about how the system works, and that part of its function is to aggregate data.

I don't think the system can work in the ideal way I would like - the system's priority is the system itself, regardless of the wishes of the individual. As you say, doctors would be sued. I would say that suing, etc relates to the culture that has grown up around the system. And perhaps the medical system was always this way - ie system-centric, rather than patient-centric. With the onset of the 'IT age', we get to see that system-centric fruit fully 'ripen' such that everyone's data can be seen by anyone.

You might say - as I do - that it is for the person who is being treated to be the collector of their information. A different culture would have grown had we had the patient at the center of our considerations.

I'm sure people have been warning all the way down the line, about the issues over privacy. It is frustrating that at every turn the expediency over the system overrides all other concerns. After, what 100 years(?) we find ourselves where we are no, with the patient having no control (and often no knowledge) of the issues that relate to them, while the system has it all. I would go further and say that this outcome is by design, as those running the system - those who govern us - would prefer that we were ignorant while they are informed. Its pretty dystopian anyway.

feralimal··on Hackers hijack and publish mental health data of hundreds of people
> This is a classic "Damoclean sword" conundrum.

Is it though?

Its only a conundrum because of the way we have organised data, with NO regard for the people the data comes from. We could have had data collected WITH consent only.

The privacy boat left the port long ago - personal privacy was intentionally eroded, and this is just one example.

Personally, on ethical grounds, I could never have designed a system like that, with so little regard for others, externalising private information so that a permanent record is kept. Once private data is exteralised, who knows where it ends up, even if it is in the name of some good cause (eg an improvement in therapy). Plenty of people warned of these sorts of outcomes.

At this point, if you care about your privacy, you really only have the option of not engaging with the system. Or engaging as little as possible.

feralimal··on The Last Ent of Affric (2019)
Great that there's an old, original tree there - it should do well if they use it to grow more trees in the area, as they apparently plan to.

My question is something denuded the hills in Scotland - you can see them in the background behind the tree. What happened?

feralimal··on Be prolific
I agree absolutely.

I would also say that this applies more broadly - that busy work is required in all parts of one's life. Deconstruct everything. Accept nothing. You will still learn, but you will recognise the assumptions and beliefs that you hold, and having recognised them you will also test for their truth.

I see 'busy work' as the root to a more valid personal epistemology; one that is based on personal use of the scientific method.

feralimal··on Writing Is Thinking (2014)
I have to agree that writing is thinking. In fact, in my opinion it gets to the root of why humanity is what it is.

This lady is writing about writing. This is recursive. Humanity has the ability to think conceptually and recursively about things - this is thinking about thinking. This act opens the world to creativity in a way that is not possible for other creatures.

Eg we can think about a table as a concept - it brings to mind something like "Four legs, a flat solid top". As a concept though, we can take those bits out it and ask things like 'What would a table be with no legs?' or 'what would a table be without a solid top'.

This is how easy it is for us to play with concepts - thinking about thinking. And then write about it.

feralimal··on The physiological effects of slow breathing in the healthy human
> > Are you able to prove that there are no deleterious effects?

> That's not how it works - the side making a claim has to provide evidence.

Lol! Who is making the claim? Is it me who's saying that we should be able to breath as nature intended (without masks)? Or you who's saying that we should wear masks? Who has to prove their case do you think?!?

And a breaking story - "Covid-19 study on mask-wearing efficacy rejected by journals"

https://www.rt.com/news/504219-danish-mask-study-rejected-co...

No one will publish the study...

feralimal··on The physiological effects of slow breathing in the healthy human
If it was neutral or positive to your health you would choose to wear it by choice. Did you wear masks last year for fun and pleasure? Do you think re-breathing your exhaled is a good idea? From my personal experience, I can only report minor negative effects. I certainly don't think anyone operating machinery (eg drivers) should be wearing one.

Surgeons wearing masks for a period of time during an operation is not the same thing. But I would expect that those surgeons that wear masks the most would suffer with dental issues, sores, and breathing issues. Are you able to prove that there are no deleterious effects?

Its not proven that masks prevents particulate transmission. Can you provide reliable evidence for your claim?

And to governments now, can you provide that evidence before you start enforcing mandates please? And, why the evidence is so patchy - no distancing or masks in Sweden. Sometimes masks are mandatory and advised, then sometimes not. Its mixed messaging because there is no evidence.

feralimal··on The physiological effects of slow breathing in the healthy human
Seriously though, I'm in total agreement with the breathing techniques mentioned above. I wouldn't sit in traffic fumes, I do think pranayama breathing, Wim Hof, etc are excellent. I try to go outdoors, in nature daily, breathing deeply as I go.

The mandatory mask wearing is anti-peace, anti-life, anti-'all the good stuff mentioned above'. And governments have made this mandatory in many places. I can't think of something more anti-life than restricting free breathing.

Governments are mandating anti-life activity, and this is accepted!

This has been rolled out and is encouraged by most. Its even actually considered ok to shame and snitch on others who don't accept it.

For me, the mask 'cure' is worse than the disease. How many people will suffer known health effects from wearing masks, for the sake of the unproven hypothesis that they mitigate something?

I don't understand those on this thread who are happy to upvote the nice comments, while overlooking the elephant in the room. Perhaps you didn't recognise it as the mask is covering its whole trunk!!

feralimal··on Mood and cognition after low LSD doses: A placebo controlled dose-effect study
I'm very suspicious of the advocating of any sorts of drugs, hallucinogens included. Each to their own, but for myself, these are surely not something to be taking like a coffee or tea. And even then I don't think coffee, tea or processed sugar is something we should take regularly either! But I'm a bit hardcore.

Pretty much the only circumstance that I think it is ok to take hallucinogens is when you believe you have adopted a negative approach in viewing reality, when you've gone down a cul de sac of sorts. If this is a day in day out experience perhaps a 'pattern interupt' is a good thing.

Hallucinogens can be a way appraise the world and enjoy its many manifest glories - daily I look at trees or clouds and am in admiration of the wonder of nature in this experience. So, in the right circumstances, if LSD et al help you break out and get closer to one's more natural, feral state, then great :)

feralimal··on The physiological effects of slow breathing in the healthy human
Compare and contrast with mandatory face mask wearing.

Re-breathing your own expelled air is provably bad for health.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
This is a difficult question - which is why this line is always provided as a justification for greater authoritarianism.

I would ask, where is the crime here? Is it that you saw something terrible, or that something terrible occurred? Should we be focused on the prevention of immoral acts, or the representation of those immoral acts on video?

Does your not knowing about certain immoral acts make it better or worse in reality for those suffering by them? If the reality is that there are racists and pedophiles, is better to address the issue openly, or behind closed doors?

In my opinion, it is better to enshrine freedom of speech, and to address issues openly. Having things 'managed' privately may mean that it is ok, as long as no one finds out about it. Its definitely a difficult one, but I am not for hiding reality.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
Yes. But do you mean to use conspiracy in a pejorative sense?

I think its pretty obvious that people 'breathe together' and formulate plans that work best for them. So with us, at the individual level, and so with those who have all the money and operate at the macro level. Are you saying that conspiracies don't happen? What is your method of finding the true ones?

The answer is that we require unfiltered information, and open communication with others. We need to personally engage in verifying claims. We can only confirm or deny whatever claims are made, if we have the information. If that is unavailable because of censorship we can only verify very little. This is where we are today.

As we can only verify very little, the problem is that we are not getting the information. Who is restricting information then? Is the world's leading, corporate-sponsored, search indexer (google), preventing the free flow of information? Well, yes it is. So we can say google is part of the problem, not the solution.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
Yes - corporates, media, education AND government form the governance system we have.
feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
But it does. Its public knowledge that google was partially funded by inqtel. The government subsidises corporations.

I think you and I must have different ideas on what governance is. You probably think education, corporations, government and media are separate. I don't. I think they are part of the same governance apparatus.

Hence you have a search company providing email, content, etc in google. And you have Bezos who supplies your online request and media. And Elon who supplies a car service (that he can shut down), space, and neural laces. Microsoft who provide the world's operating systems, family planning and viruses. Etc.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
Well, you are saying it is a good thing that certain information is unavailable to you, and that you trust google, the government to do the job for you. I couldn't disagree more!

My response would be, don't you think you can judge for yourself what is ok, and to not watch things that are nonsense? Also, aren't you concerned that you could be manipulated as you may be trusting authorities who - out of self-interest - could fail to disclose information to you; ie that you will be unable to reach an informed opinion as you will be in ignorance?

Personally, I have zero trust in any other parties judging what is ok or not for me to know about. I am happy to judge for myself, without parental guidance.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
It is hard to get a handle on what disappears; at least I haven't seen a straightforward breakdown.

Certainly things that talks about 911 not being an act of terrorism, Sandy Hook and other school shooting being a govt sponsored hoax, the Las Vegas shooting hoax, things relating to space being hoaxed, etc. I'm not going to provide an opinion on these things.

Whatever your perspective, the thing I would argue, is that if you want to be informed you need access to all the information and evidence, not a subset selected for you by the governing class.

It used to be a popular thing to say: "I hate what you're saying, but I'll fight for your right to say it". I agree with this. But we have been educated to think that so called 'hate speech' is a problem, whereas the real issue is the prolonged infantilisation of adults - in that we don't trust our own judgement, and would prefer an authority to do it for us.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
'Society' is not a real thing, even if people treat it as one. Society does not like or dislike, cannot be informed or uninformed. It is just a collective term. Like government. Its a figment in people's imagination, a term, or an idea - brought to life only because we in aggregate believe it to be true and act as if it is. Personally, I don't consider these ideas to have substance in the way they are presented.

The reality, is that 'society' is made up of individuals. Individuals are substantially real. Individuals need to choose for themselves whether they want to be informed or not, according to their conscience.

Individuals should also step out of other people's business, ie stop trying to manage 'society'! But that's another story.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
Centralised platforms have utterly failed us though, and have become a way to manage information centrally - someone decides what you can or can't see/read/know about.

Decentralised is really the only option for an informed humanity. In the long run, this has to be the answer.

feralimal··on Debian donation for Peertube development
This is so heart warming.

Thanks to Debian and wow - Framasoft (who I'd never heard of) has a page that is so on point!! Amazing.

Someone doing something to stop the book burning (comment deletion in the billions) and censorship at youtube.

I wish there was more of this.

feralimal··on Escaping Science's Paradox
Yes. I think we're agreeing... The costs are prohibitive, so why do check? And if you know you aren't likely to get checked and you're running a study that would be very nice to have a particular outcome, well, wouldn't it be nice to get that outcome? Only, that's not how science is meant to work.
feralimal··on Escaping Science's Paradox
This is interesting.

I have a couple of points. It says:

"To be sure, the problem seems much less acute in harder sciences – e.g., physics, chemistry, cosmology – that have an established tradition of skepticism, replication, or even blinding researchers to their own conclusions."

Of is this because there are very few people who are trying to replicate the studies? The equipment is a barrier. Its not clear...

My second point regards innovation, is that surely replicability is essential. If studies aren't reliably replicated, what exactly can the innovation be? So I see replication as a core issue.

Replicability is also only one of the problems science faces. The other issue that isn't well discussed, is that funding comes from 3 sources by and large - the government, the military and corporations. We, as individuals, cannot assume that this method of funding will serve our interests. Why would studies on 'good food' receive funding over a new type of medication. When the funding is tied to profit, or vested interests, there is only so much inclination to 'rock the boat'.

But in general, I'm certainly glad this very major issue is being discussed. I'm not holding my breath for any solutions. And I only wish there was greater awareness of how much trust, or faith, goes into un-skeptical acceptance of scientific pronouncements.

feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
I'm not in the military, I've no interest in it. I mis-spoke and said army instead of navy and you think I'm writing falsehoods. When I realised my mistake, I came back to correct it! That's ethics! I eat my dogfood.

Yes, I also expressed a bit of distaste at the way you had missed the main point of what I was saying. You want to nitpick and call me a liar.

So, judge yourself. You want to critique an error of mine, but will swallow whatever BS some random online publication puts out.

Whatevs.

feralimal··on U.S. Accuses Google of Illegally Protecting Monopoly
This is surely theatrics, given that Google has always been a quasi-governmental/military corporation:

"In-Q-Tel sold 5,636 shares of Google, worth over $2.2 million, on November 15, 2005.[9] The shares were a result of Google's acquisition of Keyhole, Inc, the CIA-funded satellite mapping software now known as Google Earth.[10]"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel

feralimal··on How long can you survive without water
You might also remember this series from classics such as:

* The man who ran out of air

* What happens when the food runs out

* The city running out of water

lol

← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →