HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

forgetfreeman

2,334 karma · joined September 7, 2022

submissionscomments
forgetfreeman··on New York Times adds more AI features to its Cooking app. Users aren't thrilled
Why should they engage with something they didnt ask for and clearly don't want? The burden of proof is on new technology, not its skeptics.
forgetfreeman··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
1. Not my job to do your homework for you. You advance claims, you provide proof or gtfo.

2. (and this is really the most important part) literally every claim in your list was later refuted by... wait for it... better data. So, again for the cheap seats, data plz.

forgetfreeman··on Software may be getting worse, but it used to be horrible
Yeah, that's me. I played Lemonade Stand on an apple some software salesman hustled the local school board into buying, and understand that's the only market that "game" sold into, so it's got more in common with spreadsheet software than PacMan, and certainly isn't relevant to a discussion of popular games and gaming in the 80s. Edit: I wish I'd checked your username before I bothered engaging.
forgetfreeman··on Software may be getting worse, but it used to be horrible
Fair, a lot has changed in the space over the last 45 years. Take the proliferation of titles that are basically just you having a job as an example. That shit absolutely would not scan with older gaming audiences. Why it became popular is a complete mystery to me. Audience expectations for their entertainment dollar spent have definitely declined sharply.
forgetfreeman··on Software may be getting worse, but it used to be horrible
This is a relatively recent attitude. OG gamers expected to have their hair blown back through some combination of novel game mechanics, setting, and storyline pretty much every title every time, and if a game didn't deliver it didn't sell.
forgetfreeman··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
Showing up with your feels is now how one counters claims backed with data. Where is your data?
forgetfreeman··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
Research has shown there isn't any ambiguity here. Stuff like this isn't good for adults, and is even worse for kids. So yeah, obvious child abuse.
forgetfreeman··on US Wages Share of GDI at 75 Year Low
Is it though? Self-employed individuals who've set up an umbrella business entity aren't particularly common.
forgetfreeman··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
Film acquisition time? You tossed it in the shopping cart while walking through the grocery store along with batteries and other random household essentials. In extremis you'd grab a few rolls off the display in the closest gas station. People literally spend more time a year getting off their phone lock screen to take a photo than you'd spend in the act of buying film. You're talking about a task with seconds-per-year levels of overhead for normal households. Professional photographers ordered theirs in bulk shipments so again the unit cost in time was functionally nil. Same with albums. Labeling and sorting were optional and at most happened one time (1) per pack of proofs and this was typically a group recreational activity for families. Dust gathers at a set rate regardless of what is occupying a given space, so it's not obvious how having a photo album increases cleaning time.

As to the claim that retention isn't insoluble, that's at best a baseless statement of faith not terribly dissimilar to someone praying a rosary. With other religious pieties there's at least some evidence (someone built a cathedral, there's a book, etc.) to support the faith. There is no evidence to date to support the idea that basic file formats are a settled matter on archival timeframes, much less retention services or storage hardware.

forgetfreeman··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
More accessible? Barely. Kodak disposables and Polaroid cameras were so common they were frequently used as toys by children. Also you can't claim zero marginal cost. If anything continuous data retention headaches make it more expensive (in terms of time) to take and keep photographs than any point in prior history. The costs just moved from the camera to the photo album.
forgetfreeman··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
I mean they're an excellent example, but this is just as true for the overwhelming majority of B2B productivity suites I've encountered. Hell, digital cameras didn't improve photography, they just killed three industries and saddled just about everyone with data retention and migration problems and that's without even getting into the social effects of ubiquitous cameras combined with social media or the surveillance state they've made possible.
forgetfreeman··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
One major obstacle is developers have either encountered or created entire ecosystems of problems they can't solve that get inherited whenever and wherever software is introduced. Proposing to add evergreen issues around security, data entry and retention, connectivity, vendor lock-in, and update cycles is frequently a shitty trade for whatever notional (often fictional) productivity improvement is being proposed by injecting software into a workflow.
forgetfreeman··on Drupal is now light-years ahead of its reputation
A web accessible runtime, regardless of language of origin, is a giant security vulnerability and always has been. Despite language purists insistence to the contrary there isn't a secure language ecosystem, never has been, and all current evidence suggests there never will be.
forgetfreeman··on Drupal is now light-years ahead of its reputation
I am shocked Dries has the gall to post anything to a public forum. Dude presided over ramming every aspect of Drupal into the ground. Out of spite I checked D.O.'s reported usage metrics the other day and it's an eyewatering 450k sites, down from ~18M individual sites at the project's peak. The entire arc of the project is a perfect case study in how to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

Full Disclosure: I was a core and module contributor, DUG organizer, and left the project out of disgust during the aftermath of the smallcore community implosion.

forgetfreeman··on Steam Users Beg for "No AI" Filter as Vibecoders Flood Next Fest
Get rid of the thing that's causing problems is both thoughtful and intelligent when the alternative is either ignore the problem or some as of yet undefined activity that is entirely outside the current scope of business. Steam isn't obligated to accommodate AI-generated games or participate in whatever currently undefined process would be required to make them palatable. That's the studios' responsibility.
forgetfreeman··on Steam Users Beg for "No AI" Filter as Vibecoders Flood Next Fest
Every major gaming outlet and studio has at one time or another decided to try to play chicken with their customers. This never goes well. Historically Steam has been pretty skilled at not finding a hill to die on so one would assume they'll avoid the obvious blunder of ignoring users preferences here.
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
"A smart person with the right access can see that", so like a store employee glancing at your choice of an analog temperature display or a telltale light? A perfectly workable solution that persists for the vast majority of the restaurant industry and every independent grocery store in the country, and has done for roughly the last century. Adding the kind of aggressively stupid failure modes that software drags into the discussion (eg. russian bot networks are attacking the ice cream) to avoid having to occasionally inspect equipment doesn't seem particularly bright.
forgetfreeman··on Retired Penn professor arrested for blocking Uber Eats robot
So medically urgent the slowest delivery option available is selected? I mean, I kinda get the idea of trying to win an argument online but have some dignity yeah?
forgetfreeman··on Desire to Move Permanently to U.S. at New Low
If true then y'all have something in common.
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
I'm pretty confident there is no failure mode industrial cooling equipment can experience that can be solved remotely. Remote monitoring and control systems on the other hand...
forgetfreeman··on I built a tool to track what AI leaders say and how their views change on video
You noticed that too, eh?
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
Routine service and maintenance doesn't require net connectivity to schedule.
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
Marketing. The restaurant industry doesn't have less skin in the game than grocery retailers re avoiding spoilage and net connected walk-in coolers and freezers are not a thing.
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
There's a marketing issue here that would need to be addressed first, namely the phrase "dumb appliance". That's a marketing slur that was intentionally propagated by manufacturers and it's bullshit. Few things seem more obviously stupid than the added complexity, expense, and security concerns associated with "smart appliances" especially given none of the features touted are critical to the appliance performing it's stated function.
forgetfreeman··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
Given the perfectly workable alternative of not having remote monitoring and simply having the store manager contact a repair tech on the exceedingly rare occasion that there is an issue, yeah I think actually you do need to justify the added complexity and expense of making this kind of mundane equipment internet accessible.
forgetfreeman··on Has the Autonomous Trucking Revolution Arrived?
That one of us doesn't understand FSD's capabilities isn't in question. Tesla has proven record of hyping their tech's capabilities well in excess of what would in decades past resulted in career-ending lawsuits for some combination of false advertising and outright fraud. Wake me when hostile 3rd parties have confirmed L5 parity.
forgetfreeman··on Has the Autonomous Trucking Revolution Arrived?
Heh I-95 has a few thoughts on what is and isn't "viable" that it's absolutely going to share with the "highway autonomous" touts and I'm betting they won't enjoy the lesson.
forgetfreeman··on Has the Autonomous Trucking Revolution Arrived?
By the industry's own admission absolutely. Nobody's claiming to even be close to meeting L5 criteria which is parity with the average human driver.
forgetfreeman··on Across the Globe, People Increasingly Say Social Media Is Harming Democracy
Yes BUT nobody took anything on any of those platforms seriously. It was commonly agreed on at the time that the internet was for bullshit and bullshitting, and people reacted accordingly. The problems online didn't start in earnest until a bunch of people were convinced to pretend, in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, that online spaces were a real thing where Important Stuff happened.
forgetfreeman··on Improper redaction reveals Google Data Center water and electricity usage
Absolutely. That shouldn't even be legally possible outside of very narrowly scoped defense contracts.
Page 1 of 34Next →