HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

forthedayrate

6 karma · joined December 9, 2021

submissionscomments
forthedayrate··on We do not break userspace (2012)
Linus had a reputation for doing this, back in the day. He took some time off a few years ago, and while he's still very strict on quality, his tone has changed.

I've run a lot of dev teams, and I see two side to this.

On the one side, the worse thing you can do is build an environment where folks are scared to raise new ideas, or think of new solutions, for fear of being publicly humiliated. At best, you will get teams that do very average work. At worse, you'll loose all your good people.

On the other side, I've had devs who thought they were god's gift for code, and made everyone's life around them, a misery. e.g. one guy spent months failing to implement an API with the front end he was writing, but despite that, he'd comment on PR's "This code is shit and needs to be rewritten."

Folks like that need to be part of, what we call in the UK, a frank and open conversation, which I had one to one. This particular dev refused to back down, and left without working his notice. Going somewhere where they would, in his view, thank him for his feedback. Good luck with that. They guy that replaced him had the API working inside of a week.

tbf, the API was terrible, but that's a whole other story involving IBM and SaleForce...

forthedayrate··on I made my first web0 website today. It's so cool it just works
Does it have to be that hard though?

From a user point of view, RSS readers are easy to come by.

From a server point of view, I think a raspberry pi build that scripted most of the setup, is an achievable goal. Not an easy one, but doable.

Sadly, even if you made it super easy, most folks would stick with the big names. Still, it could be nice to start a little community of self hosted sites...

forthedayrate··on Ask HN: Am I the only “unlucky” software engineer?
"Why hire a senior person as a poster, if you're not willing to be challenged and listen to different ideas?"

Lots of people do this. I find the STARS framework a good way of assessing what's expected of me in a senior role: https://hbr.org/2009/01/picking-the-right-transition-strateg...

As senior people, we're usually pretty opinionated. There are different outcomes from sharing those opinions at different times, depending on the context (see the framework above).

If you are looking for a role that values strong opinions early on, then roles that require a start-up or turnaround approach, are the ones that will match this. They are also the roles where the org is most open to change.

Outside of these situations (I'm talking role types, not whether a company is a start-up or not), orgs are resistant to change, and unlikely to hire someone that challenges things before they are even through the door.

From what you've said, it sounds like these are not the roles you're looking for, in which case, the process is working. There are very few start-up or turnaround roles that go to unknown candidates. In my experience, these roles go to folks that have been personally recommended, as the price of failure is so high, and people want a known quantity. (Whether that is what they get is beyond the scope of this comment).

Network, get to know people and get known as someone who can bring these types of changes to an org, and one might come your way.

Of course, if this isn't the type of role you're looking it for, then you are simply rocking the boat way too early.While most places would benefit from some level of change, they will still resist it.

If you challenge things before you've started in a role, a hiring manager will probably speculate that if you are this much trouble before you've even started, you will be even more trouble once hired. And they will reach for the next candidate, because there's always the next candidate.