HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fpgeek

6,372 karma · joined September 27, 2009

submissionscomments
fpgeek··on Aiming to Ease App Discovery, Apple Pairs With Pinterest
If you have to use iTunes, that doesn't sound similar at all. There's a huge gap between virtually any browser you're willing to log into and a computer that you can run iTunes on.
fpgeek··on Apple's New Market
It probably doesn't hurt that some of Apple's design choices reinforce that conveyed status: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150211/05455029985/green...
fpgeek··on Starting today, wireless carriers have to unlock your phone
Also true in Singapore.

Some contracts can be nastier (e.g. no early termination, just pay the rest), but that may just be an unrelated local difference (I've seen the same thing with residential ISP contracts, where there isn't a SIM-locking equivalent).

fpgeek··on Defending GCC considered futile
I think the real point is there's defending GCC and there's "defending" GCC. Actually defending GCC means making it as useful and usable you can in the context of a robust, interoperable GNU ecosystem. "Defending" GCC includes creating pointless interoperability barriers and weakening other GNU tools in the guide of "protecting" copylefted crown jewels that no one wants to steal any more (those people have long since moved on to clang).
fpgeek··on Google Play Store: Browsing with Firefox is no longer supported on Android
In other words, more of a SafariFox than a Firefox.
fpgeek··on Google Play Store: Browsing with Firefox is no longer supported on Android
Degrade gracefully?

BTW, for those playing at home, the Play Store website loads just fine if you claim to be running Firefox OS instead. If there actually are features the Play Store site uses that work in Firefox OS and not in Firefox for Android, I'm sure Mozilla would like to hear about them (probably via Bugzilla).

fpgeek··on Google Play Store: Browsing with Firefox is no longer supported on Android
This isn't true. As I mention in a comment below, Firefox gives you two nicer ways to switch from the web to an app:

1. The droid in the URL bar once the page has loaded.

2. The "Open in an app" alternative in a link's long-press menu, which often tells you which app when the destination is clear.

fpgeek··on Google Play Store: Browsing with Firefox is no longer supported on Android
There's some irony here. Chrome unpredictably punts you to the app when browsing the Play Store (actually I think it has to do with whether the link to the store involved a redirect, but that looks unpredictable from the outside). This is a mess.

Firefox, OTOH, lets you reliably browse the website and easily switch to the app (via the Android in the URL or via the Open in an app option in a link's long-press menu) whenever you want. This is much cleaner, but...

At least we have Phony.

fpgeek··on We Need to Break the Mobile Duopoly
Think about the type of deep integration that Apple-owned Siri has on iPhones, or Google-owned Gmail has on stock Android phones, for instance. Those apps operate much more contextually and fluidly, and far more powerfully, on those phones than 3rd-party apps downloaded from an app store would.

While I understand the point about Siri, Gmail (of all the Google apps) seems like a terrible example of the same thing on the Android side (Maps and its incestuous relationship with Play Services might be a better fit). What does Gmail do that Microsoft's Outlook app couldn't do if Microsoft were willing to invest the effort? Maybe I'm missing a feature I don't use, but the best I can come up with is being bundled with the device, but even there if Microsoft struck a deal with, say, Verizon, I don't think there's much Google could do about it.

fpgeek··on Tail-call optimization added to 6to5 compiler
The standard Lisp use for generated symbols is to provide a way to reliably avoid name clashes during macro expansion.

I'm not sure if that qualifies as a practical use in the out in the wild or just a practical way to fix pain (e.g. CPP nonsense) that you can see out in the wild.

fpgeek··on Twitter Confirms New Google Firehose Deal
I don't follow your logic. I didn't see anything in the story that indicated that the deal was exclusive.

Twitter certainly wouldn't want it to be - they're trying to increase reach. In theory, I can see how Google might want the advantage of an exclusive data source. However, in practice I suspect Google thinks they can get enough of an advantage from using Twitter's firehose better than their competitors do, especially since paying extra to get Twitter to lock out competitors would invite even more antitrust scrutiny.

With the Google/Twitter firehose deal, Google's competitors have lost a potential advantage, but that doesn't mean they've picked up a corresponding disadvantage.

fpgeek··on Microsoft Acquires Calendar App Sunrise for North of $100M
Their development roadmap could easily change after the acquisition. More importantly, Microsoft already has plenty of people who have a lot of experience adding enterprise features to products. It makes far more sense for them to buy the calendar company that is best at the things they don't have, rather than the one that has more of the features they can straightforwardly add.
fpgeek··on Jobs at Apple-Search
The Apple Maps experience is evidence against that, though. We know that they were working on maps for years and things like PoI search were among the biggest issues. I find it hard to believe they would have done that badly if they had an in-house search team (if only because such a team would have been good at flagging problems and suggesting solutions).
fpgeek··on F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as a Utility
> People who recognize that the internet has been a free market for most of its existence

Really? ARPANET and NSFNET were big free market bastions, were they?

fpgeek··on Microsoft Makes Clever Moves
Exactly. That demonstrates the fundamentally unstable foundation of Chinese non-Google Android. China might decide to interfere with the non-Google services being used (I suspect that's more if they come from a foreign company like Microsoft), Google might negotiate a new agreement or something else might scramble the playing field (China taking a hard line on device encryption?).
fpgeek··on Microsoft Makes Clever Moves
For popular devices, the bottleneck with Android updates isn't really the resources to develop them, it's the carrier certification process. You can see that when the same device gets updates on some countries/carriers and not others. CyanogenMod doesn't address that, it just evades it via unlocked bootloaders and flashing. The more official they try to be, the more they will run into the same problems.
fpgeek··on Microsoft Makes Clever Moves
As you note, inside China is an important special case, but outside China, Xiaomi includes Google apps. For that matter, even plenty of people in China want Google. There's a practically a cottage industry of hacks to get the Play Store on Chinese devices (including a shady app in the Mi Market, I believe).
fpgeek··on Never trust a corporation to do a library’s job
> Deja News could have ended up anywhere, including at the Internet Archive.

This is exactly what I'm talking about. The idea that a company that is falling apart and selling itself off in pieces was going to donate one of its last major assets to charity... I don't even know where to start.

That was the whole problem. Running the archive wasn't a business (at least deja.com never figured out how to make it one and eventually gave up trying), but the archive ended up in the hands of investors and/or creditors that didn't care about that. You may be partially right - if Google hadn't bought them someone else might have (maybe Yahoo, AOL, Microsoft, or ...). I'm not sure about that (which is why the Google deal was good news at the time), but let's suppose you're right. All that would mean is that you would have ended up complaining about how some other buyer ran it into the ground. If you're going to make the case that Google got in the way of the Deja News archive's happy ending, you need a lot more than that.

fpgeek··on Never trust a corporation to do a library’s job
I really hope this comment was intended sarcastically. It disturbs me that I can't tell. It disturbs me even more that other commenters believe it wasn't.
fpgeek··on Never trust a corporation to do a library’s job
Kinda skipping over the part where they grabbed it at death's door, aren't you?

Suppose Google had done nothing. The alternative wouldn't have been a beautifully indexed, easily searchable completely up-to-date Deja News archive today. It would have been that archive rotting in a landfill or that equipment being wiped and reused.

Has Google's stewardship of the Deja News archive been disappointing at times? Of course. But the idea that Google has taken anything away from you or anyone else reflects an amazing sense of entitlement and an astonishing lack of perspective.

fpgeek··on Google says it fought gag orders in WikiLeaks investigation
Even granting your premise that a Google employee could leak the gag order undetectably (and I'm not confident about that, since the universe of people to investigate would be relatively small), there would still be serious repercussions to deal with.

At bottom, there's someone at Google in charge of overseeing the gag order. If the gag order leaks and they can't figure out who's responsible, I'm pretty sure they end up going to jail - if only because a court would have a hard time telling the difference between genuinely not being able to find the leaker and stonewalling / implementing a cover-up.

fpgeek··on 'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
Keeping the current system and not doing YouTube Music Key isn't very difficult - but there are more than a few reasons to think it is worth doing (all the people who block YouTube ads and/or use unauthorized downloaders, for example).

Doing YouTube Music Key and writing in special cases for independent artists while simultaneously making sure not to open any loopholes that would let, for example, Sony hold the service hostage later... that strikes me as very difficult, at best.

fpgeek··on 'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
Um, last I heard, unless you pay them, Github requires you to make any code you upload open-source and publicly available. In many ways that's even more far-reaching than what YouTube is asking, but that hasn't stopped programmers from flocking to them in droves.

That does, however, suggest to me an option (c) that Google isn't offering: Musicians pay Google to run Content Id on their behalf to simplify the takedown process. While I'm sure there are some win-wins they're missing by not offering that (possibly including Zoë Keating), I really can't fault them for that. I expect the PR and legal complications would dwarf the storm that's already here.

fpgeek··on 'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
I really don't understand the scandal here. This just confirms that Google is offering musicians the choice that's been suspected ever since YouTube Music Key just a rumor:

(a) Go all in on monetization (ads, Content Id, Music Key, etc.)

(b) Go all out on monetization (upload videos for free, no other commercial relationship).

They aren't offering this choice because it helps them kill puppies or whatever, but for what should be a blindlingly obvious reason: People who pay money for a service that gets rid of ads on music videos are going to be pretty ticked off if they still see ads on music videos.

You can call this evil, but you should be crystal-clear on what you're saying: Google trying to offer a service that lets people pay to get rid of YouTube ads (something lots of people say they want) is evil.

Personally, I think this isn't good or evil, but an example of the inevitable problems and complications that arise when you try to add subscriptions to a hugely popular ad-supported service with many different stakeholders. I suspect that this sort of thing is an underappreciated reason why Google is hesitant to offer paid subscriptions as an alternative to ads in other contexts.

fpgeek··on Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
> Spill resistant keyboards - Are most PC laptops outside of the toughbook market? I wouldn't have even thought about this.

Who cares if the keyboard is spill-resistant if they'll sell you accidental damage protection for a reasonable price? In that case, spill-resistance is more their problem than yours and it is often designed in. Lenovo, HP, Dell and others sell ADP as a warranty add-on. AFAIK, Apple doesn't - you'd have to go to a third party like Best Buy or SquareTrade (with the hassle of the extra company / moving parts that introduces).

fpgeek··on Google Nears $1 Billion Investment in SpaceX
Larry Page and Sergey Brin have majority voting control of Google. Tim Cook doesn't have the same at Apple. No matter how well-respected, he's answerable to shareholders in a way Page is not. Arguably we see some of this when Icahn pushes for Apple dividends and share buybacks.
fpgeek··on Apple Software Quality Questions
I'd say a fixed cadence, especially when combined with a relatively inflexible scope (pre-announced features, features tied to new hardware, etc.), is, at a minimum, a significant contributor to the problem. If there's an unexpected problem late in the development cycle, what's going to give?
fpgeek··on Apple, Your Developer Agreement Tramples on Free Speech and Innovation
Yes, it's a contract. It's a contract that moves the world in a direction the EFF thinks is bad. You may disagree with that, but they (obviously) don't.

What do you expect them to do? Ignore what they consider a serious problem just because many people choose to accept it? Might as well tell them to ignore the DMCA because it was (and, AFAICT, still is) overwhelmingly popular in Washington.

fpgeek··on Apple, Your Developer Agreement Tramples on Free Speech and Innovation
The tears may have been predictable (and maybe even planned), but they most certainly aren't crocodile tears.

These are issues the EFF and its membership deeply and sincerely care about. The whole point of the organization is to call attention to these issues and push for change. Complaining that they're working on their mission is pretty silly.

fpgeek··on FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility rules
People talk about regulating telecom like the power company, but the trend over the last 30 years has been to deregulate the power companies as much as possible.

And it's not like anything has happened since then that has made people rethink power company deregulation, too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_electricity_crisis

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →