HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fpgeek

6,372 karma · joined September 27, 2009

submissionscomments
fpgeek··on This Verbal Confrontation Shows Why Walmart Will Never Accept Apple Pay
As I understand it, retailers use loyalty cards to improve their customer-level data and as a way to act on that data (e.g. targeted coupons), but even the baseline they can extract without loyalty cards is very important to them.

In fact, even after last year's breach, Target clearly isn't happy offloading that nightmare. They're currently teting CurrentC: http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/business/2014/11/10/...

fpgeek··on This Verbal Confrontation Shows Why Walmart Will Never Accept Apple Pay
> But what's more, tokenization removes a huge storage burden from merchants, since they never see a person's actual credit card information and it never enters their POS system or online payment portal.

Yes, merchants think that getting additional customer-identifying information that forces them to run extra analyses on the mountains of transaction data they warehouse is a huge burden they'd like to be relieved of.

</sarcasm>

fpgeek··on A Closer Look at Android RunTime in Android L
That's because the original submitter wanted to highlight the garbage-collection discussion, not the whole article. Of course, now that the title has been changed...
fpgeek··on This Verbal Confrontation Shows Why Walmart Will Never Accept Apple Pay
According to this: http://www.quora.com/Is-Google-Wallet-considered-a-card-pres...

Google Wallet is card-present for the merchant, but card-not-present between Google and the consumer. I guess that means Google is eating the difference between the two rates (and/or has other tricks up their sleeve).

fpgeek··on The First Browser Dedicated to Developers Is Coming
There's a difference between inexplicable and an explanation you disagree with.
fpgeek··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
Who said a docile workforce is lucrative for the companies? There are many reasons they may not be. However, in most cases, "the company" doesn't make these decisions - managers do. And plenty of managers prefer a docile workforce whether or not it's good for the bottom line.
fpgeek··on Amazon Fire TV Stick
Why do you say that?

With the benefit of hindsight, we can see that Android phones didn't get AIV until it was clear the Fire Phone flopped. And unless you mess around with sideloading, it still isn't supported on Android tablets (non-cellular ones, at least). And, from what I've heard, Android TV (or at least ADT-1) doesn't support the Google TV app even though it probably works (or, at worst, can be trivially made to).

fpgeek··on Amazon Fire TV Stick
Is it sad my first thought was: There goes any chance for Amazon Instant Video on Chromecast and/or Android TV for the foreseeable future?
fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
They're also owned by Amazon. I don't have a problem with that, but I imagine someone trying to get away from Amazon would.
fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
Amazon doesn't want to push prices down for the sake of pushing prices down. They want to push prices to where their data says they'll make more money (and, assuming they get a cut of the total, to where everyone will make more). People make a lot out of Amazon not paying 70% for books priced above $9.99. Far fewer notice that they also don't pay 70% for books priced below $2.99.
fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
> once you've got that original library of books on your reading device on what app are you going to purchase additional books on?

My answer is: it depends. My wife and I have well over a thousand books on Kindle, but I've got a growing library of Kobo books (from taking advantage of some impressive discount coupons) and almost everything DRM-free I get outside a major ebookstore (e.g. books bought directly from publishers or authors) goes straight into Google Books (they're the best with uploads).

Yes, having books scattered across multiple apps isn't perfect, but it isn't that big a deal, either. Amazon has a significant edge (especially with customer service), but it is nowhere near insurmountable.

fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
Yes, but the Kindles on bedside cabinets are a rounding error compared to the smartphones and tablets in use today (let alone in a few years). I know there are people who prefer e-ink readers, but they're a small and shrinking slice of the market (at least if the pace of new e-reader releases is anything to go by).
fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
Unless you're talking about predatory VCs, comparing them to publishers is an insult.

Publishers routinely demand that authors submit their next book (or even everything you write in the same genre for years) to them first and even if they reject it they have the right to match any offer you get later.

How many VCs demand rights over your next N years of startups?

Or we could talk about high-discount clauses: Where publishers get a bigger percentage when your books are discounted below a threshold they claim is unlikely... Only to turn around and encourage retailers (including Amazon) to discount your book just below that threshold - where they make more per book and you make substantially less.

How often do VCs make more money by going behind your back to convince an acquirer to pay less?

Or we could talk about rights reversion games, shuffling sales through shell companies cut royalties and on and on and on.

I know VCs can be ruthless, underhanded and worse, but traditional publishers can make them look like kittens by comparison.

fpgeek··on Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
Disrupting editors does not mean eliminating them. Successful self-publishers pay for, among other things, their own editors. Readers are not stupid. Between descriptions, reviews, free samples and so on assessing quality (both abstractly and personally) isn't hard.
fpgeek··on Doctors Tell All, and It’s Bad
> I have no idea where this meme that free market health care looks like the US comes from.

India shouldn't be in a Canadian's comparison set with respect to health care systems. The resource differences are too great to learn anything useful about the impact of other dimensions. Can you name a developed country with a health care system as or more free market than the American one?

As for your experience in India... Consider how much wealthier you are than the average Indian. If you were that much wealthier than the average American, do you really think you'd have any complaints about the American health care system? Conversely, what do you think your experience would have been if your wealth relative to the average American has instead been your wealth relative to the average Indian?

fpgeek··on Google Play Game Services
Yes, but how hard is Apple going to chase those certs?

Unless someone is doing something big or strategic to Apple (and random app piracy doesn't qualify, IMO), I just don't see it. Chasing "rogue" enterprise certs is all cost (time, effort, energy, risk of angering legitimate enterprise customers) for little to no benefit.

fpgeek··on Nexus Player
I still glower, but I know of two loopholes:

1. You can get Amazon Instant Video on your cellular tablet if you use the Amazon Appstore directly. It's kinda vague on the distinction between a cellular tablet and a phone.

2. Amazon Instant Video works just fine if you sideload the Amazon for Phones and Amazon Instant Video apps.

fpgeek··on Decision to drop ext support from ChromeOS Files.app reversed due to outcry
While frustrating, the SD card situation is very different.

With SD cards, the "old way" had serious problems (security and robustness issues because apps could stomp on each other's data, all sorts of complexity and confusion on multi-user devices, orphaning private app data on the SD card when apps are uninstalled, no sensible backup possibilities for apps that depend on SD card data, apps not knowing whether data would be on internal or external storage because "/sdcard" means different things on different devices, etc.) that Google is trying to solve.

Google's solution required a compatibility break, but that doesn't mean they're just dropping all of the SD card use cases. KitKat introduced app-specific private data on external storage, apps can enable some simple sharing by the adding read permissions to their private data, the storage access framework can be used to support more complex structured sharing between and so on. Among other things, Google is even adding a new API in Android L that lets apps properly publish media (images, audio, video, etc.) from their private storage (including private SD card storage, which is when it is most useful) to the shared MediaStore.

Is this transition bumpy? Absolutely, especially for people who upgrade their OS or use an old SD card on a new device. Nevertheless, I don't think Google will go back no matter how loud the cries get. Google tried neglecting SD cards from Honeycomb through Jelly Bean (hoping they'd "wither away", I suspect). That failed. Now they have no choice but to do the hard work of putting external storage on a reasonable foundation.

fpgeek··on Amazon Must Be Stopped
Oh, please. This piece is silly. Amazon's ebook "monopoly" is incredibly fragile. Either Apple or Google could squash it without breaking a sweat. Microsoft, Facebook and others could too, they'd just probably sweat a bit.

None of them want to. That's not an accident. It's because Amazon isn't giving them an opening by abusing either customers or suppliers. Publishers can claim otherwise, but they're not putting their money where their mouths are. They're not walking away from Amazon, nor can they even demonstrate that they're getting clearly better terms from anyone else.

fpgeek··on Apple – Privacy – Government Information Requests
> A third is to move your servers to Switzerland, though then you get served with process from the Swiss authorities instead of FBIDHSDEAetc.

And, if you keep your headquarters in Cupertino, quite possibly from US authorities as well (see the currently in-progress Microsoft case about access to servers in Ireland).

fpgeek··on Apple – Privacy – Government Information Requests
My fundamental issue with Apple's privacy claims is they are pretending that they have a technological solution to what is, ultimately, a political problem. As the laws in the US (and I imagine some other countries stand), Apple can be compelled provide your data to appropriate governmental authorities, install back doors, not tell you and even lie to you and the world about it. As long as that's true, no assurance from any third-party service provider is worth a damn.

I can understand the marketing benefits Apple sees in making these disingenuous privacy claims. I'd be willing to call that "just business" except for one thing: Trying to persuade people they have a technological solution will necessarily get in the way of the absolutely vital political project of destroying the political and legal foundations of the surveillance state.

fpgeek··on Amazon releases new Kindle products
No, my paid videos also work. The only limitation (vs Amazon devices) I'm aware of is that you can't download videos to play later.

I've seen people claim that there are SD/HD issues, but I haven't noticed (though, to be fair, a lot of my usage has been watching an SD TV show, so...).

fpgeek··on Amazon releases new Kindle products
> I don't know, if Amazon Video were available on a real Android tablet I'd get that, but until then I'm using these Fire tablets.

It is. You just have to go to the Amazon Appstore and install the "phone" version of the Amazon app (the app is available in Google Play, but blocked for tablets there). Then that Amazon app can do the extra download of the Instant Video app/plugin and so on. It's working fine on my Nexus 7.

fpgeek··on Why it’s hard to find Android developers
I thought OP was very clear about the serious business reasons they see for US startups to make an earlier and more serious commitment to Android:

1. You will need Android support eventually (to go global, because users demand it, etc.).

2. If you try to add Android support later, you'll screw it up in ways that will be difficult to fix (e.g. porting iOS apps too slavishly, not taking advantage of Android-specific platform benefits, building a corporate culture that treats Android as second-class, etc.), especially since most of the best Android talent will want nothing to do with you.

fpgeek··on Apple Watch: Initial Thoughts and Observations
> i think it's fair to assume that the android wear manufacturers have shown their cards.

Um, the Android Wear manufacturers may not have any secret plans of their own, but... The Android Wear OS developer is practically jumping up and down in the corner saying "I have secret plans! I have secret plans!" See, for instance:

http://www.cnet.com/news/google-says-android-wear-about-to-g...

This shouldn't be surprising. The existing Android Wear hardware is unusually powerful (a 2010 smartphone or better?) for what it is currently doing. Given the importance of battery life, that's a strange choice - unless more is coming.

I'd also note that the GP commenter works for the previously mentioned OS developer, and the comment seems entirely consistent with someone who knows more is coming, but can't do much beyond hinting at that.

fpgeek··on Why Apple Pay could be the mobile-payment system you'll actually use
What sort of tracking are you worried about?

If you're worried about merchant-level tracking, I think tokenization makes little or no difference. Quoting from the article:

"Tokenization is typically handled by the payment network, which (in some implementations) encrypts the credit card number right when you swipe it, sends it back for the token, and then provides that to the merchant to keep for things like refunds or customer tracking."

The only potential merchant-level tracking difficulty I can see is that tokens can be merchant-specific, which might make unified customer tracking more difficult after a merger. And even if financial institutions didn't provide services like post-merger token-matching (something I wouldn't bet on), plenty of merchants have quite a bit of experience using other signals to approximate that kind of matching.

fpgeek··on Tim Cook on iMessage Security: It’s Encrypted, and We Don’t Have a Key
It's even worse that that. As of about a year ago, iMessage didn't do any certificate pinning: http://blog.quarkslab.com/imessage-privacy.html

Unless that's been fixed (I haven't come across any evidence one way or the other), you're not just worrying about Apple and the NSA: Your iMessages are vulnerable to anyone who can forge a certificate and MITM your connection to Apple's servers. I'd say that's a reasonably high bar except for one thing: I believe it covers the vast majority of corporate iPhones used on company-internal networks.

fpgeek··on Android One
As one of the many whose international 2013 Nexus 7 LTE mysteriously took three extra weeks (compared to the other Nexus devices) to get the 4.4.3 update and still hasn't gotten 4.4.4 (unless that fix was rolled into the late 4.4.3), I'm not that confident the Galaxy Nexus situation is unique.

It may just be a coincidence, but it's hard not to notice that OS updates were faster before the US Nexus 7 LTE was certified on Verizon. Hopefully, the Android L update will be better, but I worry.

fpgeek··on Android One
To be fair, Android One's "up to 2 years" is a huge improvement over the typical update policy in this price bracket: not in a million years.
fpgeek··on iPhone 6 and Android value
One the one hand, this argument sounds plausible.

On the other, we've seen this movie before. Remember Verizon? The iPhone 5 (LTE and a screen-size bump)? NTT DoCoMo and China Mobile?

These were all supposed to be game-changers. And while they all helped Apple sell plenty of phones, the Android/iPhone game didn't really change.

I'm sure the iPhone 6 and 6+ will be very successful. But I'm going to need to see something more before I believe that this time the game really will change.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →