it is qualitatively different
270 karma · joined January 12, 2022
it is qualitatively different
I'm baffled that you find the mechanics of human motivation hard to understand, (presumably ;) being a human yourself.
Studies have shown that people that know a certain piece of knowledge is stored somewhere, are less likely to remember said knowledge.
The sense (thrill?) of exploration and discovery can in fact be part of a person's motivation. The popularity of open-world games (often derided as 'walking simulators') are a testament to that. Do you really not see how that could be undermined by knowing that a problem that interests you is already solved?
there is a difference between "knowing" and "knowing about". "knowing" is having it deeply ingrained into one's intuition by working at a solution over years, often without progress in the immediate sense, and often without success in the absolute sense either.
Difficult problem -> Developing new branches of mathematics to solve said problem -> solving problem, or failing to do so, it doesn't matter -> aforementioned new branches of mathematics are used to solve practical, real-world problems that benefit industry and economy.
The point of solving the problem is not the prize. The point of solving the problem is not even solving the problem. It is developing new methods and deepening understanding to drive useful applications.
The societal rewards of the mathematical community's pursuit of answers to problems is not primarily in the answers themselves. It is in the practical problems that are eventually solved not by knowing the solution to the initial problem but by means of the new branches of mathematics that were invented to solve it.
Are you really unfamiliar with the concept that "the journey is the destination"? Read a book.
Unfortunately, though, it is what you said. And more or less what you
> If one wants to argue something, it's that the Nexus should not have been built.
Or that it is being built in a way that is causing forseeable problems, while making no effort to anticipate and solve or mitigate those problems.
And a lot of that building is of tangible things in the physical world, that I can literally feel the good of.
I liked the coding part.
> If AI solves all coding and software then we are not going to sit around talking
> it will be the time to sit down and do some very complex deep work that needs silence, concentration and understanding.
Have you worked at a big tech company?
Agreed. I understand what you are saying. You don't need capitalism for absurdly selfish behavior. However, I don't know that a capitalist system, in its current, relatively unregulated form, is making humans less selfish.
The form of capitalism now gnawing away at US society is essentially shouting "the virtue of selfishness" from the rooftops. People respond to leadership, including moral leadership. There are better forms of capitalism that involve regulation and fairer taxation, such as we have had in the past, but no longer have now.
For a lot of people criticizing capitalism, the goal is not socialism but rather better capitalism.
edit: lest this be misconstrued, it can become their problem if it is wildly unpopular and undesireable behavior is regulated away.
I advocate for this path.
I will miss coding, but I had a good run. Time to learn a trade. I don't begrudge this fate.
You are cherry-picking to come to that conclusion. Humans are constantly navigating the pull in either direction. On the one hand, they are pulled toward what benefits them, and on the other, to what benefits their group and to what gains them acceptance from said group. Often this means putting the group's needs on equal footing to the individuals.
You are correct that the pull towards the individuals' needs is not unique to capitalism. You are not correct that humans are "highly focused" on benefit for themselves at the expense of others.
I would say that some humans act as you say; but in the court of a king, your "group" reinforces behavior that is selfish on a societal level, so long as tribute is paid to the king.
Most people do not live in the court of a king. I live with a family. I put the needs of my family on equal footing with my own. I maintain that this arrangement is more common than not. For every ambitious individual there are countless thousands who want only to love and be loved.
That's an assertion often made without evidence. Humans are one of the most cooperative species in existence.
I think you do
> Of course this is best case scenario version where AI handles the real work and we can just enjoy the benefits of all this automation.
That's not a best case scenarlo. It's a claim that has no precedent in human history. The technology is unprecedented, sure, but that doesn't mean we can rewrite the rules of human behavior when predicting the future it'll bring.
The industrial revolution brought about the massive inequality of the Gilded Age, and those gains were not socialized but rather concentrated in the hands of the few. Perhaps you do not follow politics as closely as I do.
We are now seeing massive inequality again, due to corporations amassing wealth and political power. Part of what has driven that is the concentrations of wealth brought about by computer technology companies.
The burden of proof is on you to show that the people who profit from automating away all the jobs will change their minds about amassing wealth and power and decide to just start sharing all their stuff with the rest of us.
With that crucial term definition supplied, I agree. The technology that can do anything at all, and which is just around the corner, can in fact do anything at all.
This is a claim that is very contrary to the prevailing view. If you wish others to be persuaded by this claim, I recommend that you provide some evidence for it, because on their own your statements are unconvincing.
How are you sure it wasn't due to a spike in unemployment when a lot of people had to stay home from work?
What, exactly, has been lost here?
Suits look extremely hot and uncomfortable. I've never worn one. I wouldn't pay hundreds of dollars to have one tailor made to my proportions. I don't like the way they look. Why on earth would I wear a suit?
So do I, but when one attempts to push a square peg through a round hole (and sufficient force applied), the structural integrity of the square peg is compromised.
This is to say, if working against your inertia becomes traumatically painful, you may in reality be working against your nature rather than your inertia.
It requires a certain wisdom and a great deal of experience to distinguish between those aspects of oneself are immutable vs mutable. But I believe firmly that a loosely-held understanding of one's immutable nature is highly useful in living a happy life. I consider it equally important to what you are getting at: that some aspects which appear to be immutable are actually not, and the only way to know for sure is to stretch outside of one's comfort zone.
It takes skill and experience to tell the difference, but the effort is worth it.
I am in a small minority. My autistic colleagues do not struggle with this in the same way I do. While I may be a bit of an extreme outlier, I do exist. If I could be otherwise, I would. Throughout my life I have wanted nothing more than an accepting group of friends, and I have worked hard at trying to achieve that. I have never succeeded. At age 41 I have lost hope that I can be as you describe.
I do have wonderful experiences socializing with others 1:1. My group socialization is limited to that with my wife and two children (aged 4 and 2). I love people. I admire them. But there are some aspects of my nature which are so intractable that they cannot be changed no matter the effort expended or identity adopted (or jettisoned).
For context, the first 40 years of my life, I did not identify as autistic, nor did it occur to me as a possibility. I knew I had difficulty making friends, but I did not intentionally form an identity around that fact; to the contrary, I actively worked to change it (to deleterious effect).
I offer this in the hopes that it will loosen the "rules" around which your viewpoint is formed. It is not always as simple as your comment makes it out to be.
strange sense of humor on ya, but I like it
I don't dispute the utility of psychedelics. But I have observed (and this is anecdotal) that the fanatic devotees of the drugs tend to engage in magical thinking around the power/history/whatever of psychedelic substances, no matter their intelligence or accomplishment, or rigorous critical thinking in other areas.