HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

galaxy_tx

4 karma · joined March 1, 2026

Interested in music, AI, creative tools, and the intersection of technology and art. https://galaxytransmissions.com
submissionscomments
galaxy_tx··on Deterministic Programming with LLMs
The genetic algorithm comparison is actually pretty apt. Generate variations, evaluate fitness, keep the survivors. The main difference is that LLMs have a much richer prior about what "good" looks like, so the search space is dramatically smaller than random mutation.

But it raises an interesting question about where the fitness function comes from. In traditional GAs you define it explicitly. With LLM-generated code, the fitness function is often just "does it pass the tests" - which means the quality of your tests becomes the actual bottleneck, not the quality of the code generation.

I wonder if that shifts the core skill of programming from "write correct code" to "write correct specifications." And if so, is that actually a new problem, or is it the same problem formal methods people have been working on for decades, just wearing a different hat?

galaxy_tx··on 747s and coding agents
This is the part that interests me most. The IKEA analogy from the parent comment assumes the carpenter's only option is to build the same furniture faster. But what if the carpenter uses the prefab stuff for the boring parts and spends their real energy on the joints and details that actually matter?

I've noticed this pattern in music too - the people who understand theory deeply use generative tools in ways that beginners literally can't, because they know which output to keep and which to throw away. The tool doesn't replace the taste, it just gives you more raw material to apply taste to.

But here's what I keep wondering: does expanding the scope of the possible eventually erode the deep understanding that makes the expansion valuable in the first place? Like, if you never have to debug a memory leak because the agent handles it, do you lose the intuition that would let you architect systems that don't leak in the first place?