HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garblegarble

2,159 karma · joined August 4, 2011

Cloud and broadcast media
submissionscomments
garblegarble··on Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message
Good news! yt-dlp already has sponsorblock built-in :-) Have a look in the --help text output for the "sponsorblock-remove" arg.
garblegarble··on UK Address Oddities (2018)
I started writing a reply saying I couldn't imagine such a place (and that I assumed it was about dodging the Post Office's license fee), but it looks like you're right - in researching the reply I found an article[1] from back in 2006 stating that at that time in England only 60% of buildings had entries in the postcode file!

They cite the example of churches that don't receive post, I guess if somebody had a TV there & used it to watch live broadcast TV then the building would need a TV license. I do wonder when the TV Licensing door knockers would show up trying to gain entry... during a church service seems a little inappropriate!

1: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2006/jul/13/epublic.g...

garblegarble··on UK Address Oddities (2018)
>That has its own database of postcodes and addresses and I got to spend lots of time on the funny rules there.

How come the separate database vs the Postcode Address File? Sounds like you could write an interesting "Things programmers mistakenly believe about UK addresses" post very easily :-)

garblegarble··on John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate development of AGI
I'm afraid I don't remember how I found this paper, but it might be from following Dr Abeba Birhane[1], she's an anti-AI academic (which is why I followed her originally, to get reality checks / contrasting viewpoints), but she also posts and boosts a lot of interesting cognitive science (her field). I also follow Olivia Guest[2] for the same reason.

Many of the papers go over my head at times of course (despite my interest, I'm firmly a layman!)

More generally, I've had a lot of success with searching for meta-analysis papers on topics I'm interested in, since the authors have already done the hard work of researching the literature and presenting core takeaways (as well as providing terms for more searches).

1: https://bsky.app/profile/abeba.bsky.social or https://twitter.com/Abebab

2: https://bsky.app/profile/olivia.science or https://twitter.com/o_guest

garblegarble··on John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate development of AGI
>we know answers for the most of the problems but do not like the solution.

What an absolutely wonderful insight put extremely succinctly, thank you!

garblegarble··on John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate development of AGI
>I wondered the other day what the result would be if you strapped a microphone on a baby and every utterance that both the baby and mic heard was fed through speech-to-text and went toward training the baby's personal LLM.

I read about a paper[1] a while back, it was a rather unpleasant animal study in cats. Using two kittens, one was free to look around, but the other they immobilised in some way, and made it see what the other kitten saw as it looked around. They discovered the immobilised kitten's visual processing did not develop normally whereas the mobile kitten's did, suggesting that it's not just the sensory input, but it being feedback to some internal agency within the brain.

I suspect the same thing would be true for attempts to develop AGI by giving them an audio-visual copy of a human's environment growing up: that internal state driving (and getting feedback from) the action to investigate/interact with the world is key.

1: https://arxiv.org/abs/1604.03670 "Interactive Perception: Leveraging Action in Perception and Perception in Action"

garblegarble··on Ozempic linked to stomach paralysis, other gastrointestinal issues: UBC study
I agree with your general point, although (and it may not be the same everywhere, but is certainly true in the UK) Ozempic is supplied as a pre-filled pen injector that handles the dose for you, and is taken once a week - there are no markings for a half-dose (and the patient info sheet seems to suggest that a partial dose isn't possible)
garblegarble··on Why do cats love boxes so much?
Fascinating, thank you!
garblegarble··on Why do cats love boxes so much?
>I’m an MR tech and we sedate about 1 in 20 to get them into the scanner.

Another commenter has noted about the unpleasant sounds and ominous design, but I'm curious about your experience with other patient orientations - it occurred to me that a lot of the discomfort comes from going in head-first and on your back, that way you're losing any sort of autonomy.

I assume there are scans that require people be on their front and looking out from inside the machine (or otherwise able to see out of the machine directly rather than via mirror), do you find that patients for those procedures don't require sedation as often?

garblegarble··on macOS Containers v0.0.1
>For an isolated build worker - yeah, sure, I'll go ahead and disable SIP.

Isn't this especially dangerous on a build worker? All your source code goes in and you (presumably) use the binaries that come out across the rest of your infrastructure. Compromising a build worker in a persistent fashion due to lack of SIP seems like it could do some serious[1] harm...

1: https://wiki.c2.com/?TheKenThompsonHack

garblegarble··on BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year
>The UK being one of the worst countries for 5G deployment, with totally fake coverage (shows the 5G logo but connected to LTE).

I read the linked PDF and did some searching but I didn't see in what instances networks use a 5G Logo for LTE (although I do recall hearing about something like that in the past)... could you give some more detail?

garblegarble··on Intel Meteor Lake Architecture
Completely off-topic, but: I think the state of the art in castle design (pre modern explosives anyway) was a star/bastion[1], since that allowed defenders to have overlapping firezones, especially useful once an attacker reaches the walls. With a circular design like Apple's HQ, as attackers get closer to the walls fewer and fewer defensive positions can see them until you can only see them from right above.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bastion_fort

garblegarble··on EE is working with Qualcomm to add Wi-Fi 7 to consumer broadband hubs
Is that different from the landline service they offer directly from the ONT? My Openreach ONT has a telephone jack as well as the RJ45. I've never actually used the telephone jack, but I'd imagine I would get a voip-backed fake dial tone if I did?
garblegarble··on An analysis of the Google antitrust trial
Remember that the overwhelming majority of these cameras in London are privately owned and operated by shopkeepers and homeowners, it's not a massive state-operated surveillance network. They usually have extremely poor image quality and are hooked up to fixed local tape/hard drive recording rather than networked.

With that said, there are still a lot of state-operated cameras. Mostly to make money from traffic infraction fines, curiously that's one area where governments don't ever seem to cut police funding :-)

garblegarble··on Amazon Prime Video content to start including ads next year
I wonder are we thinking about the same thing - I assumed the original poster was referring to the pre-roll trailers that play ahead of an episode of a TV show or film. I tried this setting but unfortunately it doesn't seem to remove those... does it do that for you?
garblegarble··on Unix shells are generally not viable access control mechanisms any more
Yeah it was a useful approach, "disprove me with code"

>> Don't forget to disable sftp in your sshd_config >Doing `strace -fp $(pgrep sshd)` then `sftp userfoo@localhost` in another terminal, I see: [...] >execve("/tmp/custom-shell.sh", ["custom-shell.sh", "-c", "/usr/lib/ssh/sftp-server"]

If your sshd_config had "Subsystem sftp internal-sftp" as a shipped default, then I don't think it would have gone through the user's shell. Not a major issue, but there are just so many little points to be certain are locked down

>I'd love to see a `ssh/sftp userfoo@localhost` call that does something other than call cmd_foo, cmd_bar, or erring out.

The reference to LD_PRELOAD was to hint at that (since if the attacker can get a binary on the system -- e.g. in a git repo or config file) they could change what functions bash is invoking... I'm not a wiley enough attacker, but I bet if you put something valuable behind it and put out a public challenge you'd be impressed with the opensshd vulnerabilities and other interesting features of ssh/tty/environment variables.

As you probably guessed, my comment was just listing a few of the things (today) that you're playing whack-a-mole with when it comes to making sure everything is secure. I think your "disprove me with code" approach is a great basis for a discussion.

Writing their own 'ssh server and shell' program is a different set of tradeoffs vs trying to fully lock down programs that are intended to be general-purpose... to be perfectly honest I don't think I'd want to be involved in either route, the stakes are stressfully high... but there sure is a lot less code to audit and test in writing your own ssh+shell than there is trying to secure and keep up-to-date sshd, pam, bash, etc. (especially since they'll be adding features that you explicitly do not want for your purposes)

garblegarble··on Unix shells are generally not viable access control mechanisms any more
Don't forget to disable sftp in your sshd_config. and ssh port forwarding. and hopefully there's no sneaky way that an attacker can push an environment variable to break something like with LD_PRELOAD, and are you sure there are no directly/indirectly exploitable bugs/omissions in your script logic for invoking complex commands like git, and that your distributed filesystem works quickly across a few million home folders for your authorized_keys files, ...
garblegarble··on Facebook Messenger now limits WebP file attachments
I believe they are referring to CVE-2023-4863[1], see the fix commit[2] in libwebp.

I imagine the issue would also impact Electron, which might be the actual reason for blocking the format if they use that for some/all of their client apps (assuming the OP's claim is correct, I don't use it so can't check myself), because I'd like to think they could push out a back-end deployment quickly.

1: https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2023-4863

2: https://chromium.googlesource.com/webm/libwebp/+/902bc91

garblegarble··on The Death of Unity
Do you have evidence for that claim? My understanding is that Apple takes their cut after any refunds have been settled[1], and the same appears to be true for Steam[2].

1: https://www.revenuecat.com/blog/growth/does-apple-keep-its-c...

2: https://www.techradar.com/news/how-steam-refunds-are-a-bless...

garblegarble··on Apple’s first ‘carbon neutral’ products are a red herring
Exactly this - I think leathergoods are worthwhile because they last (and quality leather should last a very long time - and in that time you'll have run through several plastic versions of the product, and shed a vast amount of microplastics into the environment in the process) but Apple's simply don't anymore. Their leather loop watch bands were a key example - they laminated very thin layers of leather together with other materials, and the resulting product just fell apart after a year's use.
garblegarble··on UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, admits not 'feasible'
>It probably won't change till they get rid of the anachronistic monarchy.

It's nothing to do with the monarchy - indeed, if anything I think the consensus amongst pro-monarchy folks is that the monarch is a constitutional escape hatch in the event of a government getting out of control.

Both the Conservative and Labour parties have an authoritarian streak to them when in government, and a solid percentage of the population seem to trust that our institutions know what they're doing and can keep their databases secure (although I hope that's been shaken in the last month with a number of police and electoral register database leaks).

garblegarble··on Results of technical investigations for Storm-0558 key acquisition
>sshd runs as root, so the core dumps would be readable as root-only, no

Yes, although the article we're discussing shows that you can't rely on that, the dump could be subsequently moved to a developer machine for investigation, and unencrypted key material left in could be compromised that way... defense in depth would make sense here.

garblegarble··on Is this Duplo train track under too much tension?
That's quite neat! For anyone else who's interested, I found a video of this online[1]

1: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/iKs_zr6_qMg

garblegarble··on Results of technical investigations for Storm-0558 key acquisition
Interestingly, it looks like ssh-agent disables core dumps[1], but I don't see similar usage for sshd

1: https://github.com/openssh/openssh-portable/blob/694150ad927...

garblegarble··on The World’s First U2 Spy Plane Photo Shoot at the Edge of Space
No kidding - despite the fact that the images are all credited as "Photo by", I simply don't believe they are photos. They look more like videogame loading screen artwork (especially the images with engineers working on planes)
garblegarble··on Researchers have found that micro-spikes etched into titanium rupture microbes
It'll be a no-go for hiking given the extreme weight, but you might be interested anyway: a youtuber called Cody's Lab made himself a copper chainmail shirt[1], and did notice antimicrobial properties

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTXI3zGkGtI (pretty sure he talks about the antimicrobial properties in this video, if not here then it's a similar video)

garblegarble··on AI isn’t good enough
>The best use of LLMs that I've seen so far is as a boilerplate-producing autocomplete system. Considering that we have better ways to automate this (better programming languages that can abstract away the boilerplate), this is not very high praise.

I think it's in our nature as software people to look at their ability to work with code, but they're quite good when applied to general language tasks. I've been using them for summarisation and reading comprehension and they're quite effective. I've also been working with a teacher friend on seeing if they can generate well-scoring essays on highschool English essays (as always, the problem is prompting and context).

On code, GPT-3.5 (moreso GPT-4) seems to have a good ability to generate and translate smaller scale code problems (hundreds of lines in low-boilerplate languages) but yes, they're like an eternally junior engineer whose work you're constantly having to oversee for subtle bugs, and I don't know that it actually saves time.

I'm pretty sure people are working on different approaches to applying them to code, with better prompting+context from larger codebases, and multi-step processing (i.e. rather than just a single prompt->response, letting the model iterate through a few steps independently, possibly guided by other adversarial/supervisor agent instances, testcase generators, etc.)

>If you're going to include the whole animal on the human side, you need to include the whole supply chain on the LLM side. The cost of building all the fabs and doing all the R&D to develop and manufacture model training-specific computers (matrix multiplier hardware). Just like with crypto, these resources had to be diverted away from other things (e.g. causing the price of gamers' graphics cards to skyrocket). It's only fair to interrogate the ROI.

That's fair, although it gets complicated to work out numbers because we don't train many LLMs, whereas we're constantly training humans, each of whom cost the planet tons of CO2 emissions every year... and, of course, your point that LLMs just aren't very good yet. I fear that they're good enough (or appear to be to the layperson) that execs will replace customer support staff with them, even if the outcomes overall aren't as good.

garblegarble··on AI isn’t good enough
Seems that ~100W is regularly quoted as the average human energy output, so that'd be something like 18 MWh for 20 years (assuming 100% efficiency of food input). I suppose there's also the energy cost of all the training infrastructure (daycare, school teachers, homes, transportation, etc.), and also all the energy consumption of all humans that have come before and built those cities and knowledge infrastructure (although LLMs sit atop that anyway), and then the millions (billions?) of generations of creatures going back to the earliest organisms, who have been optimising how cells work to lower their energy cost.

For that setup cost, you get a single-threaded human, starting to specialise in a single field. They will work in that field for around 7.5 hours every weekday, with ~20 days of holiday a year, for around 45 years, and then retire.

Llama v2 70B cost 1,720,320 GPU-hours[1] at 400W, so 688MWh. Once trained, it can be run 24/7, and you can spin up as many instances as you want on much lower spec hardware. That model produces output faster than a human while consuming around ~30W on my Macbook Pro.

Now, I know we're in pretty shaky spherical cow territory here, comparing a human (albeit a highly educated one) to Llama v2 in logical reasoning... but consider that this is the state of the art in generally-available LLMs after a few decades of research into machine learning & we're using repurposed silicon to compute vs the amazing complexity and physics-leveraging approach of human neurons... and the training cost is only 1 order of magnitude off humans.

Again, I'm not disagreeing with the general point of the OP, I'm not saying that the models we're using right now are the best/right ones (or that the hardware they're running on are the most efficient way of executing them), but I don't think the energy efficiency gap is actually all that high considering

Edit: If you look at the total footprint (considering not just the efficiency of the neurons, but the whole animal) the figures are very close - the llama model card indicates that v2 70B caused the emission of ~300T of CO2, and an average human in the US emits 16T of CO2 a year, so a human would emit ~320T of CO2 in 20 years. I assume children don't have as high a CO2 output, but even so it seems like it's the same order of magnitude.

1: https://github.com/facebookresearch/llama/blob/main/MODEL_CA...

garblegarble··on AI isn’t good enough
At that point, the toddler's still run years of self-reinforced learning (as well as learning supported by parents, and observing other humans solving the problem) on controlling their muscles... and again, think of the computational power expended over that time (by a computational approach that's been highly-optimised over millions of years of trial-and-error recursive descent style). Our intellect and capabilities are the result of a truly vast amount of computation in the grand scheme of things.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not claiming that Machine Learning is as generally capable as animals/humans, and I don't entirely disagree with the OP (i.e. I don't know if our current approach has a chance of scaling to human-level capabilities). I just don't think computation-wise it compares that badly to animals, considering that it's the result of a few decades of work, largely on repurposed silicon

garblegarble··on AI isn’t good enough
>Live systems in nature seem to solve similar problems with way less compute available

Do they really? They're certainly more energy-efficient in business-as-usual mode, but a human brain has 86 billion neurons, 600+ trillion synapses(!), and each instance takes 15-20+ years to train to do complex logical tasks. Even if the per-cell work is tiny (and, is it? cells are amazingly complex), 86 billion (or 600+ trillion) times 20 years is a lot of computation.

← PreviousPage 5 of 18Next →