HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garmaine

2,787 karma · joined November 23, 2017

submissionscomments
garmaine··on Ask HN: How destructive to the environment are these “space tourism” trips?
No. It doesn’t release any more heat than burning that fuel in cars or airplanes would. Chemistry is chemistry. And a Falcon 9 consumes about as much fuel as 3 fully loaded 737s. While not trivial, it’s also negligible in the grand scheme of things. We could be launching hundreds of these every day before it has a noticeable impact on the global environment.
garmaine··on Ask HN: How destructive to the environment are these “space tourism” trips?
The development of space resources is the ONLY potential avenue of technological development that will lead to an abundance of material wealth while decreasing our impact on the environment. A handful of joyrides now is peanuts by comparison.
garmaine··on Ask HN: How destructive to the environment are these “space tourism” trips?
Notably SoaceX doesn’t use RP1 for Starship, and is aiming for a carbon neutral fuel source.
garmaine··on SHA-1 'fully and practically broken' by new collision (2020)
> Is it not possible to create a good cryptographic hashing algorithm that results in 128bit or 160bit hash?

No, it is provably not possible to do that. A N-bit hash function has maximum N/2-bits of collision resistance. So a 128-bit hash function (like MD5) has a maximum of 2^64 bits of security against a classical attacker, even if it wasn't broken in other ways (as MD5 is). A 160-bit hash function like SHA-1 would have 2^80 bits of security against collision attacks on a classical computer.

Both MD5 and SHA-1 are broken in other ways, but you could for example use SHA-2 or SHA-3 in truncated mode if you wanted a "secure" 128-bit or 160-bit hash output. Indeed there are standard operating modes for doing so, meant for when you need a drop-in replacement for MD5 or SHA-1.

But fundamentally, 64-bit or 80-bit security is too low for any except some highly specified use cases. And even then the extra bits of a stronger hash will rarely kill you, so why bother? Just use SHA-2 or SHA-3 and not worry about it.

In cases where you can demonstrate that you only care about preimage resistance and not collision resistance, then a 128-bit hash would be sufficient. However often collision attacks crop in in unexpected places or when your protocol is used in ways you didn't design for. Better to just double the hash size and not worry about it.

garmaine··on SHA-1 'fully and practically broken' by new collision (2020)
Well, they made 2.4994722 BTC directly by exploiting a smart contract on bitcoin that pays out to anyone demonstrating a SHA-1 collision.
garmaine··on SHA-1 'fully and practically broken' by new collision (2020)
Does GitHub support this?
garmaine··on SHA-1 'fully and practically broken' by new collision (2020)
It doesn't take any money or time. Google's break of SHA-1 was fully reusable. So long as committing a PDF to the repo counts, there's a script that will trivially concat two PDFs in such a way as that they each render to their original (different) contents, but both have the same SHA-1 hash. Put in a repo and `git add foo.pdf` and you're done.
garmaine··on Robots patrol Singapore streets for “anti-social behavior”
Disneyland with the death penalty…
garmaine··on Sony to join TSMC on new $7B chip plant in Japan
> There is a saying that if China were democratic, then they would have invaded Taiwan yesterday. In this sense the CCP are moderates.

That saying is propaganda. Here is a list of literally every war between democratic powers in the entirety of human civilization. It's a very short list, given the sheer number of wars that have been fought:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_between_democraci...

Democracies don't start wars with other democracies, outside of very unusual and exceptional circumstances. If China and Taiwan were both democratic, there wouldn't even be a thought of war.

garmaine··on Sony to join TSMC on new $7B chip plant in Japan
> It looks to me that Tibetan scripts and languages, Mongolian scripts and languages, etc are better preserved than over the border in India and Mongolia.

You've been drinking the koolaid. Tibetan as only been preserved through a heroic effort to smuggle books over the border to Nepal and India for preservation and duplication.

garmaine··on Windows Package Manager 1.1
Not sure why you’re being downvoted. He says in the article that Microsoft wanted to hire him to keep working on appget. He asked for an acqui-hire instead, and was told that’s not possible.

He wanted more than Microsoft was willing to give.

garmaine··on The US Is a Banana Republic: The 1% Own More Wealth Than the Entire Middle Class
These points largely don't hold true in the USA.

There is a gift tax exemption of $15k/yr, but with a lifetime cap and the total counts towards your estate taxes, so it ends up being paid in the end (assuming you die, and assuming your estate is rich enough to hit the limit, which is a fair assumption for this discussion).

In your other comment you mention how stock can be transferred "tax-free" in your jurisdiction. From your description I don't think it is actually tax-free, just tax-deferred. You still pay capital gains when you sell, no? But regardless this isn't true in the USA either. If I give appreciated stock to my kids, it is taxable by them as income at the current price.

There are trust funds and such that can be setup to gift the stock early before it appreciates and then pay it out later, but this is still a tax deferral scheme. The now-grown child still pays taxes when the fund matures and they access it.

garmaine··on The US Is a Banana Republic: The 1% Own More Wealth Than the Entire Middle Class
Facts:

https://www.thebalance.com/what-the-average-american-pays-in...

"According to the Tax Foundation's review of 2018 tax returns, the latest year for which data is available, the top 1% paid an average income tax rate of about 25.4%."

To pay an average income tax rate of 25.4% in 2018 would require an income of $165,000/yr. That would put you in the top 2%. And this is completely ignoring deductions, credits, etc. which proportionally help lower income tax brackets more due to cutoffs and phase outs.

98% of Americans have a lower average income tax rate than the top 1%, even under conservative assumptions.

-----

I suggest looking up facts and doing some fermi calculations yourself instead of blindly believing what you read in the news.

garmaine··on World food prices hit 10-year peak – FAO
It’s not how costs and prices work though.
garmaine··on The US Is a Banana Republic: The 1% Own More Wealth Than the Entire Middle Class
Tax deferral is not tax avoidance. If Elon Musk gets a loan backed by his Tesla shares to diversify his holdings, that isn't actually a "tax free" cash out. The tax is just deferred to if/when the bank margin calls the loan, or he dies, etc. But the taxes do get paid, eventually.

These Forbes articles and such conflate different issues and really confuse this point.

garmaine··on The US Is a Banana Republic: The 1% Own More Wealth Than the Entire Middle Class
Taxes are progressive, so they do pay more taxes than the 99%.
garmaine··on The US Is a Banana Republic: The 1% Own More Wealth Than the Entire Middle Class
It’s quite nice.
garmaine··on World food prices hit 10-year peak – FAO
They haven’t decreased in price. The feds instead say, essentially, “hybrid cars and airbags didn’t exist when this metric was invented, so to compare apples to apples we’ll guess at what a 1960’s car would cost if it were made today today” and then invents a number.
garmaine··on World food prices hit 10-year peak – FAO
Internet addiction has been a thing for a long time.
garmaine··on Ask HN: Western Pro-Sino Discussion Board?
I doubt you will find a place that is not run by CCP shills. Most English speaking people don’t hold China in high regard, and for good reasons.
garmaine··on Lunar samples returned by Chang’e-5 tell of recent volcanism
To a planetary scientist who is familiar with lunar geology, yes that is recent. It was widely believed after Apollo that the lunar core shut off and plate tectonics stopped soon after formation. 2Gya is a long time from now, but it is also almost equidistant from lunar formation. So the title here ought to be “the Moon was geologically active for almost 2 billion years after formation” which IS surprising.
garmaine··on M(57885161) verified as 48th Mersenne Prime
If it is useful enough that someone is willing to pay for it as a service, then it fundamentally changes the incentive model and voids the security it provides.
garmaine··on China blocks Wikimedia from entering World Intellectual Property Organization
It is not a polite fiction.
garmaine··on Waterfox Browser
Pretty much all jurisdictions. Even in Europe the copyright is extended if you alter a work.
garmaine··on Last year I started reading a physical newspaper
Why should I give two bits about who is famous?
garmaine··on Last year I started reading a physical newspaper
Newsweek is maybe a better comparison?
garmaine··on Waterfox Browser
That's not what copyright is for or how copyright works.

Copyright renewal is a real thing. Copyright years generally get refreshed whenever the content changes.

garmaine··on Crews are abandoned on ships in record numbers without pay, food or a way home
They definitely do have it in the RFID tag. Depending on your nationality, some have it printed in a larger QR-code like thing, I think. There’s an international standard, but I wouldn’t know where to find it.
garmaine··on Crews are abandoned on ships in record numbers without pay, food or a way home
Just FYI they do contain machine readable digital signatures from the passport issuer these days.
garmaine··on Crews are abandoned on ships in record numbers without pay, food or a way home
You’re thinking is incorrect. There are a LOT of governing regulations and oversight, not to mention unions and corporate policies.
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →