HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gatonegro

268 karma · joined February 2, 2022

submissionscomments
gatonegro··on Spotify was down
I got logged out from their website!
gatonegro··on Spotify was down
This is essentially what I've been doing. Spotify is usually decent enough when it comes to recommending new artists based on what I'm listening. When I find an artist whose work I plan on listening on a regular basis, I'll jump to Bandcamp or some other site where I can buy the song or album I'm interested in.

Sadly, the list of such sites seems to be shrinking with every passing year, and I've found many artists I'd like to support by buying their stuff, but they only offer streaming options. I've noticed it happens more frequently with artists that have been scooped up by a major label or one of its subsidiaries, unsurprisingly.

gatonegro··on Spotify was down
This is something else I forgot to mention, but it drives me absolutely mental. Music vanishing from my playlists, old TV shows I'm watching are suddenly not available. Paying for that kind of experience strikes me as a horrid proposition.
gatonegro··on Spotify was down
Because my access to it shouldn't depend on a third party's uptime. The fact that it's "a couple of hours once a year" doesn't make it any better.

We've been conditioned to just accepting that random outages and corporate decisions can take things away from us, but it is a ridiculous proposition that only benefits the bottom line of the service providers. I understand that the "convenience" angle might be attractive to some, but personally I don't think it's worth the trade-offs.

And this is not just about music, or movies. It applies to all forms of data that we have collectively agreed can just live in the cloud, because the cloud will always be there and we don't have to think about it. Until one morning you find that the cloud is unavailable, and so is all your data.

Physical media is inconvenient in a lot of ways, but to me is still an infinitely better proposition than trusting a bunch of random companies to provide me with access to digital media.

gatonegro··on Spotify was down
Sadly I don't have a proper record player setup here—only my CD Walkman, but I have plans for something else down the line. But I do have a healthy music library on my main PC.
gatonegro··on Spotify was down
And this is why I refuse to give up on owning media and relying on streaming. Discord seems to be gone, as well.
gatonegro··on macOS’s ancient problems still exist in 2022
Interesting! I don't think I noticed that before. I got used to just doing Cmd+Ctrl+F to do full screen, or manually resize windows. Probably not ideal, but it felt consistent at least.
gatonegro··on macOS’s ancient problems still exist in 2022
Thanks, I honestly was not aware that "adjust window to content" is (or used to be) the intended behaviour. I saw apps that did it over the years, but I remember it being inconsistent even from one Apple app to the next.

I also want to say that I remember Apple changing the green button to a maximise-like function, though I can't remember during which release that happened. Probably when they introduced virtual desktops and full screen apps.

Of course, UX guidelines can only do so much without developers following them. That explains why the green button is so unpredictable. You never know if it'll do full screen, resize the window, maximise, or just ignore you.

gatonegro··on Dear Epic Games, please don’t ruin Bandcamp
>Still, the download model is clearly headed toward obscurity. In 2020, revenue from downloads fell by 18% across the entire music industry according to the RIAA, and it accounted for just 6% of total recorded music revenue.

Considering the options to buy and download music keep disappearing every year, I am not at all surprised.

I love buying music. I'd buy more CDs if I could because I absolutely love physical media. But these days, when I find an artist I enjoy, odds are I simply am not able to buy their music. Most of the time you'll only find them on streaming services.

Having been burned many times before by streaming platforms that simply take away content I like overnight and without warning, being able to pay for an album and keep a copy of it under my control is infinitely better.

gatonegro··on macOS’s ancient problems still exist in 2022
> Window zoom not making sense to you doesn’t mean it doesn’t make sense to other people.

Could you explain it to me? macOS is not my favourite OS at all, but I can use it without much trouble if I need to and agree that many of these complaints boil down to the author not liking or understanding the macOS workflow. Window zoom, however, always struck me as wildly inconsistent and unpredictable.

For context, I started back in the days of Mac OS X Tiger, up to Catalina. Window zoom never made the slightest amount of sense to me.

gatonegro··on 'We are not part of this': NATO rejects Ukraine no-fly zone
(Disclaimer: geopolitics and IR are not my field, and I don't really know what I'm talking about.)

I was trying to picture a scenario where Putin "wins" this in a way that he considers an actual victory, and I couldn't come up with one. Sanctions are not going to stop any time soon, Ukraine is unlikely to give up, Russia can't hold Ukrainian territory long-term... I just can't see a win for Putin, no matter what happens.

What I can see happening is the Russian elites deciding that they've had enough of the old man, and they just want to go back to "normal". With him out of the picture, Russia has an "out" and I'd imagine the West would be willing to go down that road instead of prolonging the conflict.

The part that sucks is that, even if there is a regime change in Russia in the near future, millions of lives have already been turned upside down in Ukraine. Telling them to "hold on a little longer" is a slap in the face, but that seems to be the West's strategy right now.

gatonegro··on 'We are not part of this': NATO rejects Ukraine no-fly zone
It might escalate to that point, or it could escalate to something much worse that the current situation—a shooting war between NATO and Russia, for example. I don't imagine anyone in the West is eager to take that gamble.
gatonegro··on 'We are not part of this': NATO rejects Ukraine no-fly zone
> a no-fly zone could only be enforced by sending NATO planes to shoot down Russian ones, adding that the risk of escalation would be too big.

That's the thing that people seem to be missing when calling for a no-fly zone to be declared by NATO. A no-fly zone means nothing if you're unwilling to enforce it. NATO is not going to start shooting down Russian planes.

It's understandable that Ukraine is demanding extreme measures from any international body they can talk to, but no-fly zones would literally do no good to anyone.

gatonegro··on Write plain text files
> Every few years a new company says you should use their special format. You have to pay them a monthly fee to use it — or keep all of your documents in their care. [...] When you store your writing in one company’s unique format, then you need that program to access it. Then the economy takes a turn, they go out of business, and your work is trapped in an unusable format.

This is something I've been dealing with lately. I have over a decade's worth of important personal and work files in proprietary formats, since I used Windows and Adobe's stuff for a long time. These days I'm using Linux exclusively, so my only option to read many of those formats is to hope that things like GIMP and Inkscape are able to open them somewhat accurately. All the documents I created in InDesign are as good as gone. I still have the files, but they're locked behind proprietary software that I couldn't use even if I wanted to. Oh, well...

For creating documents I've been learning LaTeX, and for note-taking I quite like Vimwiki[1]. I don't do nearly as much graphics work as I used to, though I appreciate things like the fact that Inkscape uses plain SVG by default. I'd rather not be locked out of my own files again in the future.

[1] https://vimwiki.github.io/

gatonegro··on Why Does Windows Use Backslash as Path Separator? (2019)
> The ergonomics of non-US keyboards were naturally not considered, which caused the path separator to be ridiculously difficult to type on some national keyboards (e.g. German), perhaps as a perverse reminder that ergonomics do matter.

The more I've shifted towards a keyboard-centric workflow, the more I'm feeling this lack of consideration regarding non-US layouts. When using a Spanish keyboard, the placement of characters like forward slashes, backslashes, tildes, pipes, etc. can be physically painful after an extended typing session. I'm considering either getting a US keyboard, or doing some serious keyboard map tweaking.

It's somewhat amusing to think that my current ergonomic predicaments are essentially the result of operating system and keyboard design choices and conventions that are over half a century old at this point.

gatonegro··on TikTok expands max video length to 10 minutes
Why is it that social media platforms seem to invariably deviate from the thing that made them successful and different?(*) Micro-blogging platforms adding long-form posting features, long-form video platforms giving 10 second clips a go, short-form video platform increasing video length...

The lack of originality in this field is astounding.

* Money and market share, I know.

gatonegro··on Show HN: vimmer.io is an interactive course for Vim with a real embedded editor
Also, vimtutor. It'll show you everything you need to know to get started.
gatonegro··on Ask HN: Is Reddit Becoming Dumber?
I just checked the subscriber count of r/archlinux, out of curiosity. With over 200,000 users, I'm not sure it can be considered "niche".

The quality of submissions is also abysmal—for every interesting or thoughtful post I see, there are dozens of really basic troubleshooting questions. And I mean really basic stuff. You can only give thoughtful answers to "how do I connect to WiFi/install GPU drivers?" for so long. At some point you start copy/pasting links or just ignoring those threads.

gatonegro··on I love you, Hacker News, but you’re toxic
Yup, I do the same thing. I guess I'm lucky because I rarely have issues with my own gear and the services I use, so contacting support is not something I've needed to do frequently. But when I do, I spend a good amount of time doing research and making sure the issue actually merits bothering someone else and isn't something I can eventually fix on my own. Tier-1 support people are invariably caught by surprise :p
gatonegro··on I love you, Hacker News, but you’re toxic
> Honestly, the world would be a much more amazing place if it would be taught in schools that just "it doesn't work" does not convey any meaningful information.

Couldn't agree more. My first step when troubleshooting anything for someone else is to extract as much information as possible to understand what I'm dealing with. Having that information from the start would save me a lot of time.

>I can't say I perceive the dismissal from the quote alone.

True, the quote alone is not necessarily dismissive or arrogant, and your interpretation could very well be correct. I'm assuming it was dismissive because the author seems troubled by his own response, which he interprets as "I just told him that he's wrong and he doesn't know what he's doing". That's where my interpretation comes from.

gatonegro··on Against an increasingly user-hostile web (2017)
>Play the game of cat-and-mouse with an entire Internet's worth of bad actors trying to break your server? "No thanks," say most actual users.

I was listening to a podcast yesterday, and one of the hosts expressed this similar feeling, except he came from the opposite end of the spectrum—someone who has been deploying, maintaining, and working on Internet infrastructure for a while. Dealing with these headaches for an extended amount of time will probably nudge you to favour centralisation.

He argued in favour of moving the entire tech stack to the cloud and paying a fee, instead of deploying and maintaining anything on-premises, in no small part because of the cat-and-mouse game you describe. Paraphrasing, "I'm just paying for a service, if something breaks in the cloud it's not my problem to fix."

gatonegro··on I love you, Hacker News, but you’re toxic
I enjoy teaching people new things in general, but what I win specifically depends on the situation. With friends and family, it's the personal satisfaction of helping someone I care about.

With customers there's the added benefit of improving business relationships and building trust. If someone contacts me with a question, and I withhold the answer until they pay me, they're gonna feel cheated when they realise the answer was pretty straightforward. It doesn't matter if, technically, I'm providing a service and I'm within my rights to ask for compensation. That customer is going to hesitate to return in the future, because they now feel I just care about their money.

Being open, transparent, and helpful has the opposite effect, in my experience. The customer feels at ease with me, they trust my judgment, know that I'm looking out for them, and so are happy to return to me when they need something, and pay for the job.

gatonegro··on Google Search Is Dying
Not really what you're asking for, but I saw this[0] a while back and it's made me actually think about can openers a bit now. You might find it interesting, too.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_mLxyIXpSY

gatonegro··on I love you, Hacker News, but you’re toxic
The problem in those examples is not rejecting the premise, it's doing so in a dismissive, arrogant way.

I've had customers, friends, and family members tell me time and time again that they can't do some common, everyday thing on their computers because it's "not compatible", or it "won't let them", or it "doesn't work". If they're wrong, I show them where they're wrong, what they need to do to fix the problem and avoid similar ones in the future. No need to be dismissive, or berate them for not knowing something. It ends up being a nice "today I learned" situation for them, and we all win.

gatonegro··on MonoLisa – A font designed for developers
I'm pretty sure the default "monospace" font in KDE is mapped to Hack: https://sourcefoundry.org/hack/
gatonegro··on Adobe XD, where did it go wrong?
Those are all valid points, but software subscriptions still make me extremely uncomfortable. I'm not a fan of subscription services in general, but that's a little off-topic.

Paying a monthly fee to Adobe in particular strikes me as a horrible proposition: extortionate early termination fees, constant price increases, the inability to use the software whenever their servers or CC program throw a fit, finding that your programs were broken by an update you didn't ask for... And, of course, there's the fact that you're essentially locked out of your own files if you ever terminate your subscription, even if you were a paying customer for years.

I really miss the days where you could just pay for something and have it.

gatonegro··on Adobe XD, where did it go wrong?
> We're happy to pay for that.

Preferably once, not monthly.

gatonegro··on Is it even worth working on FOSS anymore?
I understand that, I was just pointing out a practical issue with the royalties model if it were to be applied to an open source project.
gatonegro··on Is it even worth working on FOSS anymore?
The key difference here is that for, say, a piece of music, you can very easily point to someone as the creator of said piece. Or a group of people, or a record label, or whoever owns the rights to it. How do you handle royalties for a FOSS project where dozens, or even hundreds of people have contributed various amounts of code over the years?
gatonegro··on Tim O’Reilly helped bring us Web 1.0 and 2.0. Here’s why he’s a Web3 skeptic
I think O'Reilly's take makes a lot of sense.

The "Web 2.0", as he says, was the natural evolution of the web after the dot-com bubble exploded. It was not a buzzword or marketing term, at least at the start. It turned into a dumb gimmick after a year or two, where every ridiculous and impractical idea was justified as "being Web 2.0", but the vast majority of those gimmicks went away on their own, simply because they didn't bring anything interesting or useful to the table.

The obsession with labelling things "Web3" and other buzzwords to justify absurd (and often predatory) schemes right now feels like little more than a bunch of carnies trying to sell us fancy new blockchain carts for horses that don't actually exist. It's a solution looking for problems to solve. And, at least from the common discourse around blockchains, it seems like those pushing Web3 solutions rarely understand what the problems are in the first place, beyond a very simplistic and superficial level.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →