HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gatsby

7,115 karma · joined October 4, 2010

About:

Chris Bakke

Co-Founder @ Laskie.com

3x exits to Indeed, Zillow, and Knotel

Email: chrisjbakke at gmail dot com

submissionscomments
gatsby··on The Utter Uselessness of Job Interviews
Laszlo Bock (former SVP of People at Google) did a great job summarizing decades of research around structured interviewing in his book 'Work Rules!'

For a quick reference, the two defining criteria for a structured interview are:

1.) They use one or several consistent set(s) of questions, and

2.) There are clear criteria for assessing responses

That second point is really important. You can't only ask candidates the same sets of questions and have a structured process: you need to understand what a "one-star" response vs. a "five-star" response actually looks or sounds like. Training and calibrating all of the interviewers in a large company around a similar rating system is nightmarish, so most companies don't bother.

The book also outlines that pairing a work sample with a structured interview is one of the most accurate methods of hiring.

If anyone is interested in some in-depth structured interview questions or work sample ideas, feel free to email me. I've spent the last few years working on a company in the interviewing space and would love to chat.

gatsby··on Airbnb gets into the property management business
Eh, sort of. In my state (and many US states), the first rule that dictates short-term is whether a transient/occupany tax is paid (which it generally is, by Airbnb for their hosts: https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/653/in-what-areas-is-occ...).

But many states are cracking down on what "short-term rentals" mean and who falls into this transient tax category. Here in CA, the DRE recently released the following:

>>>First, while the Code refers to “transient occupancies”, the language that is most often used with reference to such occupancies refers to “short term rentals” and “vacation rentals”. As mentioned above, the maximum time period of such rentals cannot exceed 30 days.

>>>Second, the exemption refers to those who handle transient occupancies as agents on behalf of “another or others”. It does not refer to what is commonly described as VRBOs or vacation rentals by owner (s).

Source: http://www.dre.ca.gov/files/pdf/adv/LicenseeAlert2016shortte...

And anytime you get local departments of real estate involved, they'll go down kicking and screaming and make it as difficult as possible for Airbnb, VRBO, etc.

gatsby··on Airbnb gets into the property management business
Not sure why you're being downvoted, but this is a very good point.

Companies like the National Multifamily Housing Council, National Apartment Association, National Association of Regional Property Managers, and various Realtor affiliated groups spend tens of millions of dollars each year lobbying to pass legislation that makes it incredibly difficult for non-property-owners and non-agents/brokers to do anything involving managing other people's property in many states.

Legitimately curious to know how Airbnb plans to get around this in the US (and several other countries with similar laws).

From the article, they're starting this as a pilot in Japan (and not sure about the laws there), so maybe the short-term only involves more loosely regulated housing markets.

gatsby··on Zenefits Loses Over Half of Its Value
Amazing that repricings like this are so rare that even investors like A16Z never / rarely see it:

>>“This is a unique situation, we’ve never seen it before and we don’t expect to see it again,” said a spokesperson for Andreessen Horowitz.

What's the advantage for the company?

The article makes it seem like this was David Sacks' decision and he's trying to coerce existing investors into signing off on this "new deal," making it even more strange.

gatsby··on Sam Altman's Bubble Talk Bet Is 1 Year Old
I was curious, so I looked up what the press has reported on each company's most recent valuation (and therefore, these numbers could be off, because they don't factor in reported write downs / markups from individual investors [i.e. Fidelity], financing rounds not reported by the press, huge gains/downturns in revenue over the last year, etc.)

1.) The top 6 companies mentioned are now valued at $146.5b.

2.) The 9 midstage YC companies mentioned in the article are valued at $15.43b.

gatsby··on New Bloomberg Terminal Keyboard
Exactly right. Bank of America alone spends $420m every year on Bloomberg terminal fees.

http://nypost.com/2016/01/14/bank-of-america-set-to-cash-on-...

gatsby··on More Than 40% of Student Borrowers Aren’t Making Payments
Full text if you don't want to deal with google/paywall workarounds:

More than 40% of Americans who borrowed from the government’s main student-loan program aren’t making payments or are behind on more than $200 billion owed, raising worries that millions of them may never repay.

The new figures represent the fallout of a decadelong borrowing boom as record numbers of students enrolled in trade schools, universities and graduate schools.

While most have since left school and entered the labor force, 43% of the roughly 22 million Americans with federal student loans weren’t making payments as of Jan. 1, according to a quarterly snapshot of the Education Department’s $1.2 trillion student-loan portfolio.

About 1 in 6 borrowers, or 3.6 million, were in default on $56 billion in student debt, meaning they had gone at least a year without making a payment. Three million more owing roughly $66 billion were at least a month behind.

Meantime, another three million owing almost $110 billion were in “forbearance” or “deferment,” meaning they had received permission to temporarily halt payments due to a financial emergency, such as unemployment.

The figures exclude borrowers still in school and those with government-guaranteed private loans.

The picture has improved slightly from a year earlier, when the nonpayment rate was 46%, but that progress largely reflected a surge in Americans entering a program for distressed borrowers to lower their payments. Enrollment in those plans, which slash monthly bills by tying them to a small percentage of borrowers’ incomes, jumped 48% over the year to 4.6 million borrowers as of Jan. 1.

The Obama administration—worried about taxpayer costs and the prospect of consumers damaging their credit by defaulting—has stepped up efforts to reach borrowers and offer options to enroll in the income-based repayment plans. In some cases, the government is garnishing wages and tax refunds of borrowers who refuse to pay.

But officials acknowledge that a large pool of borrowers have essentially fallen off the radar. Loan servicers—companies the government hires to collect debt—say they can’t reach such defaulted borrowers despite hundreds of attempts through phone calls, text messages and emails. The Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay.

“We obviously have not cracked that nut but we want to keep working on it,” said Ted Mitchell, the Education Department’s undersecretary. He said many defaulted borrowers dropped out of school and are underemployed.

Carlo Salerno, an economist who studies higher education and has consulted for the private student-lending industry, noted that the government imposes virtually no credit checks on borrowers, requires no cosigners and doesn’t screen people for their preparedness for college-level course work.

“On what planet does a financing vehicle with those kinds of terms and those kinds of performance metrics make sense,” he said.

Some borrowers aren’t repaying even when they can. Research from Navient Corp., which services loans for the government, shows that borrowers prioritize other bills—such as car loans, mortgages and heating bills—over student debt. A borrower who fails to pay down an auto loan might have her car repossessed; with student loans, there is no such threat.

Kristopher Mathews, 38 years old, is in deferment on about $11,900 in federal student loans. During the recession he earned a certificate at a Michigan-based for-profit college that teaches media arts, but he wasn’t able to find the well-paying job in radio that he hoped for.

Mr. Mathews now works as a logistical analyst for a U.S. auto company, making $46,000 annually. He says he devotes his income to caring for his family—he and his fiancée have three children—and then paying off two credit cards and a car loan. “With all the other necessities in life I just don’t have” funds to pay the student debt, Mr. Mathews said.

Once his deferment expires, he isn’t sure if he will feel obliged to pay down his loan. “They promised me everything,” he said of his for-profit college. “And I honestly have nothing to show for it except a piece of paper that doesn’t really do me any good.”

Most borrowers who have defaulted owe relatively little—a median $8,900, according to the Education Department.

Advocacy groups, some members of Congress and the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have faulted loan servicers for not doing enough to reach troubled borrowers to offer repayment options. But the picture is more complicated.

Navient, which also services private loans, says it attempts to reach each borrower on average 230 to 300 times—through letters, emails, calls and text messages—in the year leading up to his or her default. Ninety percent of those borrowers, which include federal borrowers as well as those who hold private loans, never respond and more than half never made a single payment before they defaulted, the company says.

The administration maintains that the student-loan program, as a whole, will generate a profit over the long term, but the risk is rising that the revenue won’t meet the administration’s projections.

Even many borrowers who are current on their loans are paying very little. More than a third of borrowers on an income-based repayment plan had monthly payments of zero because their incomes were so low, according to a Navient survey last year.

The Education Department, through private debt-collection agencies, garnished $176 million in Americans’ wages in the final three months of last year for student debt, federal data show.

The administration’s pursuit of troubled borrowers is drawing criticism from student advocates and their allies in Congress. Last week, the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Consumer Law Center sued the Education Department, accusing it of blocking public access to data on the agency’s debt-collection efforts. The groups suggested that the companies collecting debt for the department might be discriminating against black and Hispanic borrowers.

Dorie Nolt, a spokeswoman for Education Secretary John B. King Jr., said the agency is reviewing the groups’ public-information requests.

“The singular goal of our student loan program is to help all students get a degree that sets them up for success, and we take the treatment of our borrowers—particularly historically underserved students—very seriously,” Ms. Nolt said in an email.

gatsby··on First YC Fellowship Virtual Demo Day
Storefront - https://www.thestorefront.com/ - raised almost $10m for a similar idea, and just shut down last month after four years, so I wonder how/if Bulletin will approach the market differently.
gatsby··on Georgette Packaging (YC W16) Makes Custom Branded Boxes and Cups for Bakeries
This is a great idea.

A huge part of the success over the last 10 or 15 years in the cafe and coffee industry has been about branding and design.

Starbucks knows this: bright green straws, red holiday cups, etc. You can see a Starbucks cup from 100 feet away.

Why should Starbucks, Blue Bottle, Coffee Bean, and Dunkin all capitalize on this, while a lot of the mom n pop shops that make the best coffee are serving their brews in 16 oz paper cups that they buy in bulk from Costco?

gatsby··on Lever (YC S12) Raises $20M for Hiring Software at Netflix, Reddit and Lyft
Congrats to you and the team, Nate! We have several shared customers and they all speak very highly of Lever.
gatsby··on Common: Co-Living Startup from a General Assembly Founder
Congrats on the initial traction!

I feel like "co-living" is definitely a huge opportunity, and someone will get it right.

Curious what you're going to do differently than Campus and several other SF-based companies that had a similar model but couldn't scale beyond 15-20 locations: http://www.businessinsider.com/campus-co-living-san-francisc...

gatsby··on On Fake Instagram, a Chance to Be Real
This is really fascinating, and I've heard similar stories from my younger cousins about maintaining multiple accounts on FB, Instagram, etc.

"Real" social media = your fake life

"Fake" social media = your real life

edit:

Although, as I think about this, it's not much different from those of us who are a generation or two removed from the people in the story.

I was on a call with a salesperson from a large company last week, so I googled him to put a face to a name.

His linkedin featured a professional picture with a suit and tie, paragraphs written in the third person (like account executives have biographers?), and we had a dozen mutual connections in common. Connected with 500+ people.

His facebook profile told a very different story of vacations, beach voleyball, parties, family events, and life. Connected with 100 people.

gatsby··on Square Prices Its IPO at $9, giving it a $2.7B valuation
Yes, Square's private per share prices:

Series A: $0.21627

Series B: <$1

Series C: $5.79817

Series D: $11.014

Series E: $15.46345

IPO @ $9 is not great for lots of folks, but mostly late-stage employees (assuming D & E investors have a liquidation preference - though I don't know for sure).

gatsby··on Square Prices Its IPO at $9, giving it a $2.7B valuation
Wow, that's priced at ~2.8x 2015 revenue. So low.
gatsby··on Zenefits launches free payroll software for small businesses
We had an identical experience.

I just counted and I have two threads with Zenefits - one with sales and one with acct mgmt. The first thread with sales has 38 emails, and the account management thread has 16 emails. All of this to get set up as a new, tiny little company (4 employees at the time).

The craziest thing was that I didn't need to be "sold." I had used Zenefits previously, and filled out the form on their site to create an account, and got kicked into an incredibly long and painful manual onboarding process that took over five weeks, multiple calls, and 50+ emails.

Gusto got us set up in 20 min. with one automated workflow.

I understand that enrolling in healthcare is a more complex process than payroll, but it felt like I was working with a very traditional insurance broker.

Running a startup myself, I'm usually really empathetic toward startups with growth pains, but there were many things about the process where Gusto far exceeded expectations and Zenefits really underwhelmed me.

gatsby··on Zenefits launches free payroll software for small businesses
I would love to see this as well.

A salesperson from Gusto (fka Zenpayroll) who we use for payroll sent me multiple emails about switching to Gusto for benefits, so I emailed, "Hey - We're currently running everything through Zenefits. Are there any advantages to switching over?" and I never heard a response.

Could have been a mistake (i.e. forgot to respond), a bad salesperson, etc. but not having any differentiators makes the decision tough on my end.

gatsby··on Thoughts on Campus, a Failed Housing Startup
Great analysis. The author of this blog compares Campus to WeWork, but WeWork is actually doing a very similar concept to Campus called WeLive: https://www.bisnow.com/washington-dc/news/office/welive-and-...

With WeWork's massive success over the last six years, it should certainly be interesting to see if they can get the economics and experience right.

gatsby··on Welcome Jared
In addition to being one of our most helpful and thoughtful angels, Jared's just a genuinely nice guy.

When I read this, I immediately thought of Jared: http://paulgraham.com/safe.html

Big win for YC.

gatsby··on When Abacus Bank Was Accused of Fraud
Fascinating that despite years of "inflating or exaggerating [borrower] assets, incomes, and job titles” this bank maintained a delinquency rate less than a twentieth of the national average. In 2009, they had 4,399 mortgages and only 16 were in trouble.
gatsby··on McKinsey warns banks face wipeout in some financial services
Full article (because it's behind a paywall, then a survey):

The digital revolution sweeping through the banking sector is set to wipe out almost two-thirds of earnings on some financial products as new technology companies drive down prices and erode lenders’ profit margins.

This is one of the main predictions by the consultancy McKinsey in its global banking annual review to be published on Wednesday, portraying banks as facing “a high-stakes struggle” to defend their business model against digital disruption.

McKinsey said technological competition would reduce profits from non-mortgage retail lending, such as credit cards and car loans, by 60 per cent and revenues by 40 per cent over the next decade.

It predicted a smaller, but still significant, chunk of profits and revenues would be lost from payments processing, small and medium-sized enterprise lending, wealth management and mortgages. These would decline between 35 and 10 per cent, McKinsey said.

Philipp Härle, co-author of the report, said: “The most significant impact we see in price erosion, as technology companies allow delivery of financial services at a fraction of the cost, and this will mostly be transferred to the customer in lower prices.”

He said most technology companies were focused on picking off the most lucrative parts of banks’ relationships with their customers, leaving them as “dumb” providers of balance sheet capacity.

“Most of the attackers do not want to become a bank,” said Mr Härle. “They want to squeeze themselves in between the customer and the bank and skim the cream off.”

McKinsey said banks last year made $1.75tn of revenues from origination and sales activities, on which they earned a 22 per cent return on equity, while they made $2.1tn of revenue from balance-sheet provision at a return on equity of only 6 per cent.

The consultancy said the industry had two choices. “Either banks fight for the customer relationship, or they learn to live without it and become a lean provider of white-labelled balance sheet capacity,” it said. While predicting upheaval in the future, McKinsey said there was no evidence that digital disruption had started to eat into banks’ market share yet. Banks’ share of global credit provision has been constant over the past 15 years.

Mr Härle said one factor that could slow down the erosion of banks’ market share was if regulators decided to clamp down on the disrupters by imposing similar capital and compliance rules as those faced by banks.

McKinsey calculated that profits from all banks reached a record of $1tn last year, helped by rapid growth in Asia and particularly in China and as US lenders rebounded from the financial crisis. The average return on equity was stable at 9.5 per cent, as cost-cutting offset falling margins in the low interest rate climate.

Almost two-thirds of developed market banks and a third of those in emerging markets earned a return on equity below their cost of equity and were valued below their book value. “Many in the industry are waiting for an interest rate rise or some other structural lift to profits, but even if rates rise, that will be insufficient to fundamentally improve economics,” McKinsey said. “We expect margins to continue to fall through 2020, and the rate of decline may even accelerate.”

gatsby··on Oliver, a New Apartment-Finding App, Cuts Out the Middlemen
Right. This is part of it. Real estate is still the largest purchase most people make in their lifetime, and there are tons of things to deal with: inspections, title companies, escrow accounts, taxes, etc.

I'm overgeneralizing, but if you're selling a home and you're not wealthy, you are terrified to make a mistake that could wipe out a big chunk of your net worth if you screw up the sale, so you use a broker. If you're wealthy, you don't care about the 6% fee, and luxury brokers have already sold you on the value proposition of extra marketing and hand-holding from the days when you weren't as well off and buying your first home.

gatsby··on Oliver, a New Apartment-Finding App, Cuts Out the Middlemen
There is a nice opportunity if you can cut out rental brokers and apartment locators, but you really only see these types of brokers in a few markets: Boston, Chicago, Miami, NY, and some locators throughout the southern US.

People who live in these cities feel like the problem of rental brokers is worse than it actually is.

The big opportunity is to disrupt buy/sell-side brokers. Many, many companies have tried, and yet in 2004 when Zillow, Trulia, Redfin, etc. were getting off the ground, about 90% of people in the US used a broker to sell their home. In 2014, it was still 90%.

The internet has unchanged the position and power of brokers in the US for a variety of reasons - but a big one that all startups miss is the pain of getting accurate data.

In the last decade, the startups that have become ~$1b companies in real estate all support or augment brokers (Zillow, Trulia, Redfin, Costar, Loopnet, etc.) and companies that aim for massive disruption go out of business in a couple years.

Sometimes during a gold rush, you are better off selling pick axes to miners.

gatsby··on PickTrace (YC S15) Helps Farmers Manage Their Harvest
Congrats on the launch, guys!

PickTrace is solving one of those massive problems that I assumed was already solved by technology, until I spent a week on a family-owned farm a few summers ago.

The amount of labor to track the crop yield and the time-tracking/pay of your workforce is staggering. There are some really expensive solutions out there for huge farms, but the 400+ acre farm I visited used manual scales, clipboards, and a huge team of "counters" - essentially verifying and QAing the whole process.

gatsby··on Rental America: Why the poor pay $4,150 for a $1,500 sofa (2014)
Previous discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8471786

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8473541

gatsby··on On-demand pick up of your unwanted items. $5 a bag
Would be nice if they gave receipts for tax purposes, like the Shyp/Goodwill partnership did: http://blog.shyp.com/goodwill/
gatsby··on Cribspot (YC W15) is a search engine for college housing
Congrats on the launch!

Has it been challenging to get landlords to agree to a common rental application?

What's the plan to differentiate from companies like cozy.co in the application/leases/rent-payment space?

gatsby··on Show HN: SpendTree – A tool to analyze income properties
I still don't understand why you think RE investment is morally wrong.

Would also love to know how you came up with, "real estate investment...is THE major driving force for urban cost-of-living increases on both American coasts."

gatsby··on Show HN: SpendTree – A tool to analyze income properties
>If I could downvote the whole concept of this industry, I would.

So, are you the one that downvoted most of the comments in this thread?

>"income properties" and "real estate investment" are horrible things when it comes to residential real estate

Don't confuse flipping houses with actual real estate investment. There are 45m renters in the US, all living in "income properties." Why is this horrible?

gatsby··on Show HN: SpendTree – A tool to analyze income properties
This is really cool - congrats on the launch!

Does all of the property analysis currently happen in individual reports? As a RE investor, I'd love some comparison tools to comp out similar properties side by side.

Shoot me an email if you want to chat further. Love talking all things RE tech.

gatsby··on BuildScience (YC W15) Ties Hardware Systems Together in Big Office Buildings
Really cool, Ritesh!

How are you monetizing/planning to monetize?

Also, how are you approaching the space differently from http://buildingrobotics.com/ ?

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →