920 karma · joined February 11, 2010
That's what they said about WWI. Direct quote. My observation is that most populations are pretty readily swayed to support a war. And the invisible hand is no match for martial law in organizing resource commitment in a war footing. It's been decades since this happened on a large scale, so I think we've forgotten how truly terrifyingly effective a war footing can be for a major power.
I mean, can you imagine the kind of utter devastation that would result if the United States, as a society, really, and I mean really, decided that Islamic terrorism was an existential threat, and mobilized to fight it on the fully integrated national level comparable to WWII?
If the country were all-in -- spending at the level of the European powers during WWII -- this would mean an expenditure of perhaps $30 trillion per year for three or four years focused on that goal, an intensity which is almost beyond imagining. That's war mobilization in a modern economy. It's hard to conceive because it is, frankly, inconceivable. How would that even work? But possible? Oh, yes.
The proposed model makes no assumptions about the "average" teacher -- it proposes a simple metric applied to student performance. Under this metric, some teachers would get a positive score because their students' scores improved more than the average. Others would get a negative score because their students' scores improved less than the average.
> would this model prevent it?
I don't know, but the goal of the model is to prevent this, or even reverse it -- that is, the best teachers would want to work with the least advantaged kids, because arbitrage -- it should be easier to make a difference for kids starting at a low performance level, and harder to make a similar difference with kids starting at a higher level.
I don't know whether this works even a little bit in practice, but the thinking sounds promising.
One of the main premises is that the impact of societies on other societies ("ruling" in the vernacular of the book, as this impact has often been military and brutal in the time scale the book covers) has a lot to do with the kind of social organization they are able to use. There's amplifiers to this of course -- you can either mobilize a huge number of people to build a pyramid, or mobilize a huge number of people to invent cranes and bulldozers and let a few people build the pyramid. But the bottom line, according to Morris, is that this kind of social goal-oriented organization is a key metric of a society's impact.
Of course, in this case, the obstacles seem mostly about the name and not about the concept, so it's a strange situation...
Part of being Steve Jobs is knowing when you have a breakthrough and knowing when you've got an incremental improvement. He did plenty of the latter as well as the former.
What may be worth understanding, though, is that there are people who are equally willing to pay money for good vacuums, but whose judgment of "good vacuum" runs much more to "suction power and functional ability" rather than "build quality."
The idea that there is not a single axis of quality, and that different products can optimize for different axes, is not a new one, but it's one that many tech people in a post-Steve-Jobs era seem to have a hard time remembering.
It would take an extremely exceptional high schooler to navigate that all alone.
Or perhaps, if admissions offices are looking for exactly that story, all the consultants are just trying to produce exactly what they'd write naturally? :-)
It's based on the hilbert curve.
My reading of this 538 World Cup analysis is that the error bars are taken as being very large, and the relative numbers are mostly interesting as a means of comparing the impacts of various players and other factors in the model. Obviously there can still be major flaws in this method, chief among them being that the method tends to atomize the team's contributions. But that's not a horrible first pass, and still can yield some interesting insights.
If most people find the syntax any of {awkward, intimidating, unreadable, inscrutable, undesirable} then they won't use it unless they have to.
This means programming languages are path-dependent. Perhaps in a different world, lisp-type syntax is how people think about programming. Or maybe in a different world Haskell syntax is the norm. But we live in this world, and in this world, such syntax is pretty much all of the above. This makes it harder for people to read and understand programs written in those languages. Since that's ultimately the central point of a programming language -- to make programs readable to human beings -- syntax is the primary thing on which languages are evaluated.
Obviously there are other factors like available libraries, tools, platform support, and so forth, but syntax is an extremely important pillar.
Is this approach ever tried in these cases? It seems to me that the more convoluted and abstract the patent (which seems to be the point of many of these patents explicitly written to try and reach as broad as possible), the more juries will tend to identify with the expert saying "I can't make heads or tails of this thing" and invalidate bad patents as simply failing to adequately teach the construction of the infringement claim.
To rant a sec, how many times will the federal circuit need to be slapped upside the head on these issues before they get it through their skulls that their whole permissive approach to patent law is just fundamentally unconstitutional, and they need to adapt their philosophy, or the SC will continue to apply the boot to them? Is this a case of there just being a handful of particular incorrigible bad actors who we just have to wait to die?
Justice always relies on human discretion, for better or for worse, but it reflects on us all which cases we call which.
1. AIDS was a really important retrograde factor in this general story, and developing the commitment to research and deploy strategies for dealing with it was a major victory.
2. Alzheimers and similar illnesses are a huge factor in terms of healthcare for the elderly. A similar success there would yield tremendous results.
(And vice versa, of course.)
I'm suspicious that there are many projects that could be decomposed like this, or even into 10 minute blocks, but that it'd be really helpful to have tools that makes this more achievable -- ones that basically remind you of where you were and help with the what-do-I-do-next decision.
Does anyone have any experience with this kind of development process?
The tragedy of US politics is that we don't seem to hold people who made the worst foreign policy call in several decades accountable. Unreconsidered support for the Iraq war should just categorically disqualify one for a position either within national politics or as a commentator on them. Yet it doesn't. These people are either cynical liars, easy-to-dupe rubes, cynical spinsters that can't be trusted to say what they think, or vacillating receptacles. Perhaps several categories apply to some. The point is, any of these characteristics should be disqualifying for national leadership.