HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gcatalfamo

1,789 karma · joined January 30, 2013

www.linkedin.com/in/giuseppe-catalfamo
submissionscomments
gcatalfamo··on Netflix loses 1M users in Spain over password policing
You are also right, it is the scenario I hinted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35711055

Depending on the service/people sharing with, I personally witnessed both sharing costs of the single service and distributing full ownership among different services...

There are people who want to control all of them while absorbing costs, there are others who just want access.

gcatalfamo··on Netflix loses 1M users in Spain over password policing
I'll double down with another anecdote:

It is very common sense here to say "Ok, I'll cover Netflix, you'll cover Disney+/Spotify/other"

The moment when one of this services doesn't allow sharing anymore, this system will fall, and users will be incredibly more selective to what they will subscribe to.

gcatalfamo··on Netflix loses 1M users in Spain over password policing
Europe is culturally VERY different from US and Canada.

Although you may be right, I would never expect Netflix to admit my thesis, even if well known around here.

gcatalfamo··on Netflix loses 1M users in Spain over password policing
>> Do you think most sharers are contributing to the price?

All of them? Certainly not. Many? Yes.

>> There might be some friend groups who split the cost of an account between them, but I suspect far more common is that parents have an account that kids (who might be independent adults) use, couples who don’t live together sharing passwords

Yes, but although we don't have details on demographics, in Europe it is widely "accepted" (for lack a better word) that many friends, relative and even acquaintances share an account and its costs. I don't have number so consider it totally anecdotical, but it is honestly common sense, especially in southern and eastern Europe. (I am from Italy, FWIW)

edit: this is also true for Spotify Family accounts. Agains TOS? Sure. Do they do it anyway? Yes.

gcatalfamo··on Netflix loses 1M users in Spain over password policing
From the comments in this thread, many are not understanding that password borrowers are typically contributing to the account owner's monthly subscription, and many account owners, when faced to the full price of the subscription will eventually unsubscribe as well.

5€ month for what Netflix has to offer is one thing, 18€/month, for many, becomes an instant no-deal.

gcatalfamo··on Google Bard waitlist
chatgpt didn't have geographical limitations when it came out, greatly aiding its virality.
gcatalfamo··on Banning words won’t make the world more just
Farenheit 451.
gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
but telemetry HAS to do with my product, not you.
gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
> You can't use a blunt usage metric to tell whether a feature works or not. It only tells you that the feature is popular for some reason. That reason might be that it works, but often the reason people use a feature a lot is it's shoved down their throats.

I never said that was the only source of information, but indeed a useful one. Thinking a good PM only uses that one bit of info means you have known really bad PMs in your work.

gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
> Only 1% of mobile phone users need 911 regularly. Lets remove that feature.0

If this is the type of PM you are accustomed to, fire them. Because that's a dumb argument.

gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
That is usually information you already know from other sources

(e.g. is the 1% feature a feature that is pivotal to getting new users?) (e.g. is the 1% feature a feature that is key for a specific audience within my total addressable market?)

But you have know from somewhere that the 1% is, in fact, 1%...makes sense?

gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
As I said that is a "piece of information", not the whole story. Making an axing decision with ONLY that information would be outright idiotic.

Telemetry has to be designed as well, to piece as much as you can, and then you complete the full picture with other sources. Maybe not everybody does this, but I don't think that this practice should be "shocking" for anybody.

gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
As I said that is a "piece of information", not the whole story. Making an axing decision with ONLY that information would be outright idiotic.
gcatalfamo··on Telemetry required? Ask users first
> And it’s a malevolent spectre if you’re the 1% of users who actually use a niche feature in something, since developers will use that knowledge to take it away.

Yes, but also no. If my resources are not infinite, knowing that an "expensive-to-maintain" feature is used by just 1% of users, it is an incredibly important piece of information when I'm gonna have to decide where/how to recalibrate my (team's) effort.

Product managing is also this: I have to know what works and what doesn't. Maybe I will use that knowledge to understand how to increase the 1% to 5% with a specific business case. Maybe it won't make sense and I will have to decide if I can keep it or not.

I agree that vanity telemetry is bad for users, but killing ALL telemetry is bad for everybody.

gcatalfamo··on I Will Fucking Dropkick You If You Use That Spreadsheet
Can you make your blog subscribe-able?

Although I don't agree 100% with this entry specifically, it is particularly refreshing to read something unfiltered, witty written and yet unafraid to meet controversy. (which don't often go hand in hand lately)

gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: What habits have helped you achieve the greatest transformation in life?
Six months of daily is practice is a tolling amount of grinding before knowing if it works, for an ADD person...
gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: How to get good at analyzing and predicting technology/startup trends?
Is your answer giving any insight to OP on how they should do it?
gcatalfamo··on Tell HN: Can't turn off “grind mode”
** PLEASE READ **

You are not in grind mode. You are literally (mildly) depressed.

Every project you don't finish makes you feel increasingly unaccomplished, and tech is big on survivorship bias on great successes, while you are there, abandoning yet another github repo.

So you scramble to start building again, because you know you can do it, you HAVE TO do it. Because you feel that's the only moment when you feel you are doing the right thing. In reality, the relief you feel is due to an oxytocin/dopamine cocktail produced by the rush of making something, that makes that haunting hollow inside go to sleep.

But it is only sleeping, it's NOT going away.

The more desperate you become to get an idea, the less you feel you are getting "worthy" ideas to start with. And you keep feeling worse.

Another side effect: the more you'll keep at this, the sooner and sooner you will feel unaccomplished with your next projects, abandoning them sooner the before, until you will stop building cause you can't take it anymore.

Grinding is about always working, for a reason. You are not grinding.

You are trying to extinguish a fire with matchsticks.

The superficial advice would be "put your energy in a hobby", but honestly it doesn't work that way. Aside from seeking professional help, TRY to understand yourself better, WHY do you feel you have to build something great, why are you looking for success in the first place?

You know you are not really useless, but why do you feel useless? What is actually "useless and stagnant" (your words) that you are trying to get rid of?

The question might seem stupid or trivial ("duh, who wouldn't want success?") but it is not, and the answer is most likely NOT in your "work".

gcatalfamo··on Why is remote work seen as a gift?
I know it's not very HN-y to say "I agree", but I think your comment encapsulates wonderfully the general topic, in a concise and very well put paragraph.

edit: I am also commenting to retrieve it in the future.

gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: Why doesn't Apple bring continuity to the Music app?
I agree 100% but, if you wanted to change ecosystem as whole (not just for music), what alternatives are there, really?

They clearly get away with this because whatever you'd change it with you'd be far worse off.

gcatalfamo··on Show HN: Sketch – AI code-writing assistant that understands data content
Cool project, although the name kinda clashes with the well-known https://www.sketch.com/ in the UI/UX design space
gcatalfamo··on Robot is doing the work of an army of Renaissance sculptors, according to owner
CNCs are current manufacturing tech now more than ever, don't know what you mean by CNC peaking 50 years ago.

Anyway "tech" in the original post was clearly contextualised non-manufacturing tech which is the predominant context here.

gcatalfamo··on The AMD Ryzen 9 7900, Ryzen 7 7700, and Ryzen 5 5 7600 Review: Zen 4 at 65 Watts
Agree, but I honestly can't fathom the productivity/gaming benefits of the X models compared to such difference in power draw compared to the "regular" 7900
gcatalfamo··on Robot is doing the work of an army of Renaissance sculptors, according to owner
An incredibly broad, stupid and merciless generalization - which still applies here - is that while there are people in tech with very deep knowledge of the world (for personal curiosity and such) there are many, many people in tech with no knowledge whatsoever of the world outside tech.

And when those people see tech applied to a non tech-context, they think "wow, tech has done it again!"

Cynical morning, sorry

gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: Does anybody use the HN hide button?
Or maybe just give the opportunity to _undo_ it by re-clicking it shortly after if misclicked instead of hiding it in the void.
gcatalfamo··on How Wine works 101
I SO expected this to be about the basics of wine making (the beverage) and kind of let me down after opening the link.

Please somebody make wine-making 101

gcatalfamo··on How Wine works 101
Actually yes, a deep drill down of how wine (the beverage) works, catered to the typical HN audience, would be VERY HN
gcatalfamo··on Cloud desktops aren't as good as you'd think
I'd like that too, but can you give me a working example that is not based around using a VPN, or editing documents on the browser?

(which are both viable, but there is a different number of drawbacks to each)

gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: How to validate a startup idea whilst employed?
And when are you supposed to do it? During office hours when you should be working on your regular job, or after 6pm when no business will be open for your sales call?
gcatalfamo··on Ask HN: How to validate a startup idea whilst employed?
Not a bad place to start, but this hardly works in B2B where high touch selling is required on a normal basis
← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →