HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gcau

513 karma · joined November 9, 2021

submissionscomments
gcau··on Try Switching to Kagi
I just tried this, and google returned a variety of videos (guides for fixing), and various text/website tutorials (home depot, reddit etc), I had to scroll to the absolute bottom to see an ad for a plumber.
gcau··on Adobe deletes Bluesky posts after backlash
When I tried to cancel a regular monthly subscription, they tried to force me to pay a fee to be able to cancel the subscription, and they don't let you disconnect your payment methods. Luckily, I used paypal so I could unauthorise them on paypal. If this happened again to me I would be contacting the consumer rights organisation my country has.
gcau··on Intelligence Evolved at Least Twice in Vertebrate Animals
How does this theory show that birds didn't first become intelligent, and then started cheating because they're now intelligent enough to do it? The "sitting and watching" theory makes a lot more sense to me.
gcau··on Open-Source Is Just That
>And yes, Open-Source does mean "FOSS", always.

This does not align with reality, irregardless of what some private company says or how strongly you feel about software freedoms.

gcau··on Open-Source Is Just That
Free (as in freedom), open (like a book).
gcau··on Gumroad’s source is available
It's not a mistake because someone doesn't subscribe to the same definition as you. There are 2 widely competing definitions that are both perfectly valid, if you want to be more specific you can say "not OSI approved" to more accurately reflect what you're talking about, if you don't want to do that then you can understand how others feel.
gcau··on Show HN: Nue – Apps lighter than a React button
This is the "everyone who drinks water dies, therefore drinking water is deadly" argument. I'd also guess lesser known frameworks have a higher proportion of better developers - i.e people taking the time to research and try new technologies probably are more competent. You're also forgetting about the trillions of wordpress (and similar) websites that exist.
gcau··on Show HN: Nue – Apps lighter than a React button
>And to be just a tad pedantic: you have JS in production; your TS is only in dev.

This is not even pedantic, it's wrong. You have JS/TS in both dev and prod, with javascript being the actual runtime code in both, and typescript checking your code at build time in both. If you're running javascript compiled/checked by , and written in, typescript, it's not uncommon or unreasonable to call it typescript.

gcau··on Why Studio Ghibli movies can't be made with AI (2023)
As someone very active in both the programming and art communities, all logic and reasoning always goes out the window when it comes to artists discussing A.I.
gcau··on Docs – Open source alternative to Notion or Outline
>Bring projects, wikis, and teams together with AI. The AI workspace where you achieve more without losing control of your data

This is always a major red flag for me.

gcau··on Our interfaces have lost their senses
This is advice many modern designers need to know - I don't like seeing an icon and having no idea what it does without clicking it, and having to guess what the icon might mean, where a label could easily fit, or replace the icon, and be a vastly better UX, but "looking good" is more important to most designers.
gcau··on Our interfaces have lost their senses
It's hard to believe this is the interface for a page titled "our interfaces have lost their senses", and the author not being aware of the irony.
gcau··on Everything Is Chrome (2023)
Are these bugs in the website or in firefox?
gcau··on SEC Declares Memecoins Are Not Subject to Oversight
This is completely incorrect. There is a difference between:

(1) "PoopCoin" that is a copy paste of an existing cryptocurrency, repackaged with meme (!) marketing, and intentionally used for the creators to make quick money, and is bought ONLY for the purpose of flipping it for money.

(2) A serious cryptocurrency with a whitepaper, written by expert cryptographers, and serves a unique utility vs others, has a huge market cap, is used for real transactions.

gcau··on Jeff Bezos exerts more control of Washington Post opinion
You're misunderstanding or strawmanning. You don't need a business to be free, obviously, and no not everyone that's free has a business (???). But that's different from being forbidden from making one.
gcau··on Brazil justice orders ban of video platform Rumble
People have very differing and fluid definitions of fascism.
gcau··on Sunsetting Create React App
>So now you need a framework on top of React - itself a framework.

You definitely do not need any framework for react, you don't even need a build step. And react is not a framework. Not that it has objective meaning, but I think these frameworks are not abstraction layers on react, they are tools sitting along side it to make things easier or give more features. You still interface the same with writing the same old jsx.

gcau··on Sunsetting Create React App
React has never been a "framework", it's a "view library" that can be included in a framework. The benefit is you can pick your own pieces, like building your own computer. Also, React doesn't handle routing (I recommend wouter), and yes it does state management (I recommend zustand for additional state management). You seem pretty opinionated on something you don't know a whole lot about.
gcau··on Sunsetting Create React App
Vite is the replacement for CRA, I usually create new projects with their preact-ts template. Its very fast and just works. I would personally strongly advise against nextjs, but use whatever you prefer.
gcau··on Meta's memo to employees rolling back DEI programs
For those living in countries that don't have majority white people (eg asian or african countries), do they have any DEI programs to hire more white people and all that?
gcau··on Why Linux is not ready for the desktop, the final edition
Games happen to be software, that hundreds of millions use, especially younger tech-oriented people. So yes, it IS essential if you want to make a PC people will use.
gcau··on Why Linux is not ready for the desktop, the final edition
Everyone I know that uses linux for their PC, has constant, daily issues and complaints, and they all use a different distro that they promise is the best. Without even going into any of the other issues, that's enough to keep me away. Even as a nerdy programmer, I don't have the time, energy or any reason to use something that will make my life harder and impact my ability to do what I want to do. I can't see any conceivable path forward where linux becomes an actual viable and mainstream platform for regular PC users. It seems like people mainly use linux for ideological reasons, not because it's better - actually in spite of it being worse. In my personal experience, the vast 99% majority of professional programmers use windows/mac, and I see more than anything people switching to linux just for the novelty of it. Linux users can also be very dismissive "Photoshop? You don't need that. Use LibreGimp, but use X fork as it has essential bugfixes."
gcau··on Fun facts about SQLite
You are 100% correct. Open source has a common definition the vast majority of the world uses, a company can proclaim their own definition, but it doesn't magically change the language. Nobody is thinking about, or even aware of, the OSI, when using the term. The correct term people should be using is "OSI approved", or something similar, although that's no more meaningful or useful as a "bob approved" license, where bob is some random nobody.
gcau··on BYOJS (Bring your own JS)
This comes off as very naive and contrarian, and like the author just wanted a reason to create some more javascript libraries. The lack of types in your library makes it harder to use, more likely there will be bugs where its being used, and the library itself is probably buggy. The author commonly champions bad practices, that you should "just know" how js works and then none of this matters.

There's very strong reasons a vast amount of people are switching to typescript. It can very easily compile to clean javascript, you can commit that to git, and you are much better off.

gcau··on AI poetry is indistinguishable from human poetry and is rated more favorably
I don't understand the logic of calling superhero movies lesser/unserious like this, it's very snobby. Movies and music are made to be entertaining, the avengers is more entertaining than your "arthouse cinematic masterpiece that nobody likes but it's just because they aren't smart enough to understand it". It's also lazy and ignorant to ignore the sheer manpower that goes into making a movie like that.
gcau··on AI poetry is indistinguishable from human poetry and is rated more favorably
>This data really is awful because the subjects aren't interested in reading difficult poetry.

If the results were the opposite, would the data still be awful?

gcau··on Museum of Bad Art
Yes. Art exactly like what's shown in this museum is commonplace in serious art galleries or exhibits, and there is not really anything anyone can say or do, except just walk past it or use it as a palette cleanser.
gcau··on DOJ will push Google to sell off Chrome
My understanding is that google lets anyone freely use chromium, and chrome is just their flavour of chromium with google services integrated ontop of it. Microsoft took chromium and sprinkled ai-enhanced microsoft flavours on top to make edge, which doesn't look like a monopoly. Presumably, microsoft is able to use windows to push edge, and use edge to push bing. If chrome was sold and had the google integration removed I would switch to a vanilla chromium.

I see some argument for google paying firefox to be the default search engine, but is that worse than firefox not existing at all?

In terms of search engines, I think there's just a lack of good competition. The search engines I'm aware of are:

Google: Just works. The only problem is you need to add "reddit" to most searches to get actual real, human-written non-seospam text, but I doubt that's unique to just google.

Bing: I'm greeted with an uncomfortably flashy layout shift, a page full of american news and some popup about AI. They also cover up and censor for the CCP.

Kagi: Their website is literally broken right now and I can't even see the pricing or other pages. I tried safari, chrome, firefox and edge, the hamburger menu doesn't open. Ultimately though, nobody except the kind of audience on HN is going to pay for it. If I told anyone else about a search engine that costs $16/month to use, I'm sure they'd think i'm joking, irregardless of how good it may be.

Yandex: Good for the reverse image searching, but otherwise probably not good to use.

Most of this article is ads, and it's paywalled so I can only read the first couple sentences, so if this is addressed in it I apologise.

gcau··on It's legal for police to use deception in interrogations. Some want that to end
You were mentioning a boundary and line being drawn, I think what's trying to be said is that line is already drawn. No problem abruptly vanishes just because it becomes illegal. It doesn't help that your example is 30 years old, police and police oversight have gotten far better since then.
gcau··on It's legal for police to use deception in interrogations. Some want that to end
It's not terrible advice, it's the same advice you will hear from many lawyers. If a cop pulls you over because you were blatantly speeding - saying nothing, or admitting to it and apologising, are both reasonable things to do. Never talking to police is a safer blanket decision, but you can have some grey area.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →