HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on AI chemist could make oxygen on Mars
Dying of tetanus after a cut, or dying in childbirth is pretty natural - and electricity, computers and the internet are pretty unnatural. I'm glad I live in an "unnatural" time and place
ghufran_syed··on Six-hour time-restricted feeding inhibits lung cancer progression
that’s a strange qualification:

“no serious medical organisation endorses keto for the general population or cancer patients” - isn’t having it be effective for the obese and diabetics enough?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6566854/

as to using “medical organizations” endorsement as a sign of “truth” - it took over 10 years to go from the discovery that H Pylori caused stomach ulcers to GI medical organizations recommending antibiotic treatment, such endorsement is a lagging indicator. Or to take another example, almost every american medical organization supports widespread use of “gender-affirming care” for children, including hormonal treatment and surgery, while many european medical organizations have pulled back from their earlier enthusiastic support based on increasing data on harm. So are the european organizations correct, or are the american ones? or is human biology significantly different between europe and the united states? or to take another recent example, were the medical organizations correct when they endorsed the CDC view that “masks didn’t work” (because the cdc wanted to ensure mask supply for medical personnel), or were they correct when they then said they were effective…. until later research showed they made no discernible difference?

https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD...

ghufran_syed··on Mouse experiments reveal the brain-heart connections that cause fainting
The main thing is that if you feel like you're going to faint, get horizontal as soon as possible. Sitting on the ground is a lot better than sitting in a chair, but lying on the ground is even better and may avoid loss of consciousness - so even if your blood pressure is low for a few seconds, it's still enough to perfuse your brain if there's no hydrostatic gradient.

If someone passes out in a chair, try and gently lie them down on the ground (obviously assuming it's a safe place...) - I've had a few patients who passed out in an airplane seat, and they are often out for much longer with much slower recovery than those who just crumple to the ground and end up horizontal.

ghufran_syed··on Private equity is devouring the U.S. economy
Great, that "less competition" means higher prices... Which means someone setting up a new clinic can benefit from those higher prices - oh look, now you have competition again.
ghufran_syed··on Kidney stone procedure "has the potential to be game changing"
NASA saying there is a “research gap” and that it “needs mitigation” is very different from it being an “unacceptable risk” which implies that no mission can happen until it happens. if there was a ship ready to go with a hab and propellant for the return trip sitting on mars, I can guarantee they would take the very next transfer window, kidney stone risk notwithstanding- particularly if the chinese or russians were about to do so and might get there first!
ghufran_syed··on Shopify files lawsuit over DMCA abuse
Would you even have heard of those "top few percent" of musicians if there wasn't some way for them the capture some of the value they create, both for themselves, and to pay for marketing etc? Or would they just play for fun for a few friends? Why bother?
ghufran_syed··on United Airlines plans to board passengers with window seats first
Unless there is a penalty, some people will always try it - even if you get stopped, the worst case is your default boarding position. The only way to stop it is have a separate line ("sin bin"? :)) that the gate agent puts people in when they try to board early, so that they end up boarding last. Or force them check their bags. Humans respond to incentives...
ghufran_syed··on Raspberry Pi 5
I think the median works better in this situation because the huge population means that both the outliers and the skewness have much less effect than they do on the mean. The problem with using the mean “without outliers” is that you have to make arbitrary decisions about what data to exclude as an outlier, unlike with the median.
ghufran_syed··on How unions won a 30% raise for every fast food worker in California
Why only a 30% increase? If there are no negative effects, why not give them a 300% increase?
ghufran_syed··on SpaceX projected 20M Starlink users by 2022–it ended up with 1M
if the US is sending billions of dollars worth of stuff to ukraine, why would ukraine be paying for starlink? I agree that the US is providing some funding
ghufran_syed··on Councils in England in crisis as Birmingham ‘declares itself bankrupt’
When visiting england recently, the main problem seemed to be that both red labour and “blue labour” have essentially the same policies regarding regulation (more is better) and taxation (more is better), the only difference is deciding who pays the increased taxes, the poor or the rich. The idea of actually stimulating wealth creation, and then taxing it instead of taxing and regulating it into oblivion seems to have slipped everybody’s minds…
ghufran_syed··on Doctors on TikTok
Seems a little sexist?
ghufran_syed··on I’ll never be an astronaut
I think strictly speaking it was an aortic dissection that killed John Ritter, not an aneurysm. Aneurysms grow slowly, and like a balloon, the wall thickness goes down as the vessel circumference increases. So then it can suddenly leak. The aneurysm is chronic (though often asymptomatic), the leak is usually sudden and catastrophic. An aortic dissection is a sudden tear in a usually non-aneurysmal aorta, if the leak goes all the way through it's usually immediately lethal, but often the pressure of blood "dissects" (separates) the inner and outer walls of the aorta, leading to all sorts of weird symptoms, which is why it is often misdiagnosed (A vascular surgeon was once reported to have said about aortic dissection that the "the standard of care is to miss the diagnosis", because it so often mimics other conditions, both benign and dangerous. )
ghufran_syed··on Doctors on TikTok
what is a karen?
ghufran_syed··on If you have first-hand knowledge of the FDA’s torpor, get in touch
The government, through JCAHO, also helped create the opioid crisis, with their push for the healthcare system to treat pain as the "fifth vital sign". Note that while JCAHO is supposedly a non-profit, JCAHO accreditation is a requirement for receiving medicare and medicaid funding from the government, which makes it a pretty big stick to beat the healthcare system with. Of course, now that large amounts of patient harm are recognized as a result, the regulators and bureaucrats are extremely quick to dodge any responsibility, summarized well here with quotes from various JCAHO publications in the past:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6139759/

ghufran_syed··on Top suspect in 2015 Ashley Madison hack committed suicide in 2014
Do you feel there's any difference between "income" and "disposable" income? I would take it to mean income after paying taxes, and paying for housing, food, clothing, what definition are you using? I suspect the parent comment is using a similar definition to mine
ghufran_syed··on Learning needs to be effortful to be effective
Or as mathematician Paul Halmos said: "Don't just read it; fight it! Ask your own questions, look for your own examples, discover your own proofs. Is the hypothesis necessary? Is the converse true? What happens in the classical special case? What about the degenerate cases? Where does the proof use the hypothesis?"

https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Halmos/quo....

ghufran_syed··on CPR's true survival rate is lower than many people think
not quite - if you stopped breathing, but your heart is working, you have an excellent chance of recovery if someone keeps air going in and out - that’s often the case for children and young people . If your heart stops after trauma, it’s mostly due to something cpr doesn’t address, like severe blood loss, once your heart stops from blood loss, usually your brain is irreversibly damaged in a very short time. The other key group that benefits is people with a “heart that’s too good to die” - meaning a strong heart in a shockable rhythm, in which case cpr may keep your brain alive long enough for someone with a defibrillator to fix the rhythm problem. that’s about 20% of all deaths: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6020177/

So probably the optimal message is 1) learn how to do cpr and use it if you ever see someone collapse, but 2) if a doctor suggests that cpr would not be in your or your loved ones best interests, they’re usually right.

I do agree with the author about asking people if they want a “natural death” instead of asking if they want “cpr” or “resuscitation”

ghufran_syed··on Ban on Tenure for New Faculty Hires Passes Texas Senate
that makes sense - in my line of work, lawsuits are an occupational hazard, I imagine it should not be the case for teachers! But I also think both that it’s easy to overstate the risk of some of these things and it would completely suck to be on the receiving end

It’ll be interesting to see if the pay rate generally goes up for teachers in florida if they end up with many other teachers making that same decision

ghufran_syed··on Ban on Tenure for New Faculty Hires Passes Texas Senate
Thanks for the info - but this implies that following the state curriculum would be a pretty easy defence, wouldn't it? So if a teacher wanted to teach about "sexual orientation and gender identity", even outside of the "existing state standards", they could still do so as part of "reproductive health instruction that students can choose not to take" [1] [2].

The closest reference I can find for the legal stuff is here: https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2022/1557/BillText/er/...

Everything in that text talks about the parent taking legal action against the school district, not the teacher [3] - same as when citizens sue "the cops", they are usually suing the city that runs that police department, not the individual police officer. So if a teacher is following the rules laid down by their employer (which one assumes would be in accordance with state law), they would presumably be provided counsel by their employer in order to ensure that the employer can actually mount a legal defense? So it sounds no different to being a state employee in a lot of places. Or am I still missing something?

[1] "The rule change would ban lessons on sexual orientation and gender identity through 12th grade unless required by existing state standards or as part of reproductive health instruction that students can choose not to take"

[2] "Educators have said they don’t expect a major change in lesson plans given that teachers adhere to state education curriculums"

[3] "If a concern is not resolved by the school district, a 129 parent may: ... (I) [elided] (II) Bring an action against the school district to obtain a declaratory judgment that the school district procedure or practice violates this paragraph and seek injunctive relief. A court may award damages and shall award reasonable attorney fees and court costs to a parent who receives declaratory or injunctive relief. "

ghufran_syed··on Ban on Tenure for New Faculty Hires Passes Texas Senate
Can you help me understand what aspect of teaching biology in grades k through 3 would be against the provisions of the law in Florida? I studied biology to age 16 in England (“o-levels”) and don’t recall anything even up to that age that would be covered under this law?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_Parental_Rights_in_E...

ghufran_syed··on Study finds higher cancer rates among U.S. military airmen and ground crews
it’s funny you use the word “excuse” rather than “reason” or “cause” - it’s almost like you’ve already drawn a conclusion in the absence of any actual data…

The point is there is no excuse NOT to consider those important factors - they are part of every annual physical and certainly part of the extensive screening done during enlistment. So you’d only ignore them if you’re trying to create a particular narrative, IMO

ghufran_syed··on Study finds higher cancer rates among U.S. military airmen and ground crews
“ The Pentagon took pains to point out that the new study “does not imply that military service in air crew or ground crew occupations causes cancer, because there are multiple potential confounding factors that could not be controlled for in this analysis,” such as family histories of cancer, smoking behavior or alcohol use.”

so they didn’t control for the three biggest contributors to cancer risk - how is this useful? It’s like finding that strippers have higher risk of cancer than “the general population”, and implying that taking your clothes off is a risk factor for cancer…

Doing this kind of meaningless study doesn’t help anyone, including the service members and their families - if, for example, the major risk comes from higher rates of smoking among the military, then let’s focus on reducing that risk factor: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8489722/

ghufran_syed··on Students of BloomTech, FKA Lambda School, file class-action lawsuit
you don’t get a diploma if you don’t graduate… but you still have to pay back any loans
ghufran_syed··on Students of BloomTech, FKA Lambda School, file class-action lawsuit
“no” in the sense of paying more if you take longer to pay off the amount, but “yes” in the sense that IF you get a decently paying job, you’ll pay more. so it’s more like selling an option on your future income, then using the money to pay for your tuition. If the course helps you make a lot more money, it’s a win-win; if it makes not difference to your income, you lost time but you basically sold the option for a lot more than it was worth; the only time you really lose is if you would have increased your income significantly without the course, but instead you sold that option a lot cheaper than the true value based on your future potential, and then wasted the money on a course that made no difference to your future prospects.

I would be curious about the proportions of the three groups among the plaintiffs - if you did badly afterwards there’s no financial loss, if you did well financially afterwards, I think it’s hard to argue that the course didn’t help?

ghufran_syed··on T-Mobile Reaches Agreement to Acquire Mint Mobile for Up to $1.35B
fyi, they recently implemented wifi calling on iphone, maybe late last year? And IIRC I’ve been using hotspot on Fi for at least a year?
ghufran_syed··on After seven years of Brexit talks, Europe has emerged as the clear winner
is there such a thing as “liberal low-information voters” and if so, what bad policies were enacted as a result of such voters? Or is this just a high-brow way of saying “the people who disagree with us are stupid”?
ghufran_syed··on ERs are hiring fewer doctors to save money
because besides money, maybe some human doctors find it emotionally difficult to tell someone their family member died because we made the wrong diagnosis, or took too long to make the correct diagnosis?

By analogy, if you have home insurance, you don’t mind if your house burns down? Seems unlikely…

ghufran_syed··on ERs are hiring fewer doctors to save money
Right - and the risk is much greater seeing “unfiltered” emergency patients, compared to a patient who has had a full assessment in the ED, had surgical issues ruled out, etc and was then admitted to the internal medicine service.
ghufran_syed··on ERs are hiring fewer doctors to save money
Everyone in healthcare is overworked - but at least in the US people have the choice to move to a better-paying employer. I work in Northern california with a nurse who lives in Florida and flies out for a bunch of shifts, then takes a few weeks off. In the UK where I originally trained, the pay is shockingly low compared to the US, due to lack of competition IMO:

https://www.salary.com/research/salary/alternate/registered-... https://www.payscale.com/research/UK/Job=Registered_Nurse_(R...

← PreviousPage 5 of 29Next →