HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on Vets today are like doctors yesterday
"Even so, never stick the pads on someone who isn't actually in cardiac arrest because if it gets it wrong it probably would drop them into cardiac arrest."

MD here, I strongly disagree - the AED is designed for use by minimally trained people. And the chances of a shock being wrongly administered is many times lower than the chance of saving a life if they are in a shockable rhythm.

I think it's really hard to definitively diagnose cardiac arrest in the first few seconds to minutes, even for some medical personnel - even if you have no cardiac output, a person often still has some residual apparent breathing ("agonal breathing") which often leads people to delay CPR, and delay applying the AED/monitor+defibrillator.

Perhaps we can agree there is no point placing it on patients who can talk to you? :) But if as an untrained person you applied it to every person who lost consciousness in front of you, you would do a lot more good than harm, with almost zero absolute risk of harm.

ghufran_syed··on Vets today are like doctors yesterday
When doing these kind of comparisons, I feel we should separate out deaths from "excess" (drugs / alcohol / cigarettes) - or at least control for differing levels of use in the various countries. I suspect differing incidence of young people dying of drug overdoses makes a big difference to average lifespan, but it seems to me that's more reflective of a society's regulatory and legal environment than a reflection of healthcare
ghufran_syed··on US Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade [pdf]
Maybe some people believe women (and men) who are alive but haven’t been born yet have the right to control their bodies and not be killed, so they can exercise their autonomy one day. They would probably agree with you that “you don't leave rights up to the states. Rights are supposed to be guaranteed at all levels of government.”

Seems strange that most pro-abortion advocates would probably be in favor of tenants rights to protect them from being evicted from a rented house but are fine with a living human being lethally evicted from a womb as long as the “owner” says so.

In both cases there are two humans, both of which have rights and whose interests have to be balanced - I don’t think it’s helpful to pretend otherwise. One might also want to consider other situations where humans have decided other people are “not really” human in order to justify doing terrible things to them, including killing them. In every situation I can think of, that thinking was wrong - seems unlikely that abortion is an exception somehow.

ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: How to learn mathematical proofs from scratch?
This book has a creative commons license and is good for beginners:

https://www.people.vcu.edu/~rhammack/BookOfProof/

It’s important to get feedback on your proofs, so it’s worth learning to use Lyx which is a LaTeX editor - once you know some LaTeX, you can post questions on math.stackexchange.com and people are usually glad to help

ghufran_syed··on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?
I have been with mercury for around 3 years and very pleased with the service and the software.
ghufran_syed··on Brex is canceling customer accounts
I’ve been with mercury for 3 years now, I would recommend them
ghufran_syed··on Association between ADHD medication and depression: A 10-year follow-up
I disagree:

“ In this paper, we discuss candidate triggers of islet autoimmunity and factors thought to promote progression from autoimmunity to overt type 1 diabetes (figure 1). These factors seem to have their effect mainly in the genetically predisposed individuals.” [my emphasis]

ghufran_syed··on Must be this tall to write multi-threaded code (2015)
I have very little experience of writing concurrent code, but this seems relevant: https://clojure.org/about/concurrent_programming
ghufran_syed··on Nintendo's big piracy case is a sad story
Any reason to think being creative in general is somehow easier for people than before? Whatever solution you offer should also apply to the base case which is writing a story or a song, both of which are “cheap” in terms of required tools and yet extremely difficult for most people to do well. So maybe we don’t want to discourage the creators just yet?
ghufran_syed··on How I would start my next startup in Germany without a GmbH (2020)
And yet there is no successful German internet company on the scale of Amazon, Facebook, Netflix, Apple, Google. I claim the regulatory environment is a factor preventing such businesses being successful - why are are you so sure it couldn't be?
ghufran_syed··on How I would start my next startup in Germany without a GmbH (2020)
"looking for millions of VC money" = "I don't have money" How is that inconsistent with wanting to avoid paying money for regulatory requirements that get in the way of solving your customer's problem?

The point is not that startups shouldn't follow regulations, it's that startups are a uniquely weak type of venture, but with the potential to be tremendously valuable to society. So designing a set of regulations for startups that balances the benefits to society of the regulation with the benefits to society of the potential startups is likely to lead to better outcomes for society.

As an analogy - in the city I live in, no-one is allowed to do any digging around a tree without prior permission from the city tree specialist. That regulation is designed to prevent large construction companies from damaging old and valued trees in the community. But in theory, a child planting an apple seed or small tree without permission would be breaking the regulation - can you see how that might reduce the number of trees being planted? The answer is not to remove the regulation, but to have exemptions or light-weight versions of the regulations for those use cases, and then apply more stringent regulations as the company (or tree) grows and becomes more robust and healthy.

ghufran_syed··on Netflix cracks down on password sharing, but early efforts in Peru are a mess
same, it's way too expensive for just our household and the content available, but I'm ok paying that amount for a kind of "family plan", particularly for family in low-income countries. But removing that would actually take away the value proposition that currently makes it worth it.
ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: How to learn math from zero for adults?
I personally found that I would have to keep exposing my brain to the same mathematical concept many times over days or weeks by doing problems when I could and visualizing the math in my brain when I was doing other things. Over time it felt like my brain was gradually getting "imprinted" with the shape of the math ideas, but you had to be gentle and do it over a period of days to weeks, otherwise it's like the math shape would just squish your brain instead of letting your brain adapt to it :)
ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: How to learn math from zero for adults?
I did the same as you, literally starting with the number line and basic factorisation around 10 years ago, using this book: https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/engineering-mathematics-978135...

It's designed for self-study, and it together with "advanced engineering mathematics" by the same author covers all the math from the first two years of a 3 year UK engineering degree (they don't have any gen ed requirements so my sense is the material covered is equivalent to the math from a US engineering degree.

At some point, if you want to learn even more advanced math, you need to learn to do proofs, but you don't need a lot of mathematical knowledge to learn how to prove things, probably someone with a good high school math knowledge coupdnprsrn the basics, using a book like chartrand "mathematical proofs" which for the first five or six chapters only requires algebra knowledge.

I now have an MS in math and statistics -self-learning is great, but once you get to the "proofy" math, it's really helpful to get feedback on your proofs from someone who knows what they are doing. I took some summer math classes at berkeley, and then did my MS at cal state east bay, and found that the teaching was much better at cal state, which I would guess is because they mostly don't get paid to do research (small sample I know, but talking to many friends doing math classes at berkeley, my experience seemed representative). So that kind of school (cal state) might not be the best if you wanted to do a top tier PhD (though every year we have a couple of people getting admitted somewhere for a math PhD program), but for actually just learning and intellectual satisfaction, it was great!

I would second Khan academy, to quickly get an overview of a topic, it's great. But you don't really know something mathematical until you've done enough problems to be fluent in that area, which I think causes problems for some people who "understand" a topic but move on before they have "mastered" it IMO.

Feel free to contact me if you want to chat or have questions

ghufran_syed··on Philips dropped the ball in sleep apnea machine recall
can you not just buy a US one? I understand they are multi-voltage, so you would just need a travel plug to use in europe
ghufran_syed··on Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms (2015)
the article you quoted says: “Homicide figures may include justifiable homicides along with criminal homicides, depending upon jurisdiction and reporting standards”

Why don’t we talk separately about “murders” vs “suicide” vs “justifiable homicide”? Each of those terms is fairly clearly defined in most people’s minds (maybe the last one a little less so), and then we could focus on the different mitigation that might be needed for each. I feel conflating them doesn’t actually help move the discussion forward given how different they are. On a moral basis, I think the situation where a law enforcement officer killed the recent texas school shooter is very different from that of that shooter who murdered innocents. So when people conflate such very different things by using terms like “gun deaths”, it makes many gun owners like myself suspicious that people are not arguing in good faith. Or am I missing something? Is there some benefit to doing so that isn’t just political?

ghufran_syed··on California’s economy may seem healthy. Just wait for the next recession
the correct analogy would be that Iowa’s state budget would be in trouble if it were overly reliant on taxes on corn - is that the case?
ghufran_syed··on 5th Circuit Court Finds SEC Enforcement Unconstitutional [pdf]
There are only 15 cabinet secretaries, each if which heads an executive branch agency. If 15 such can manage and set priorities for such an agency, it should be much easier for 435 people to spread the load and oversee those agencies, including the relevant degree of delegation to agency or independent experts that might be appropriate to a particular issue
ghufran_syed··on My experience at community college
I’m pretty sure there is a guarantee that you can get admission at one of the UC campuses. That includes, for example, UC riverside or Merced which are very different from UCLA and UC berkeley
ghufran_syed··on Lessons learned from the recent job hunt
I applaud everyone who makes their experience and salary public, I think it's super helpful. Based on that info, I am shocked that a "senior developer" with 5-6 years experience would get around 100k gbp total compensation, while in the bay area I personally know at least two people with this level of experience making around $250k usd. Seems hard to believe that immigration law, reluctance to immigrate and / or time zone difficulties are that significant so as to allow such a differential to exist without getting arbitraged away. What am I missing? Even if you assume that the UK jobs get 6 weeks vacation and the US (sf bay area) jobs get 2 weeks, that still only justifies around an 8% difference. And one of those two friends have "unlimited" vacation
ghufran_syed··on Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
Consider a multitude of people who are going to buy food at a fast food place, and they all have $10 to spend. They all have the same opportunity to buy food there, but the outcomes (the actual items they buy) will likely be very different. If we then decide that "salads are good, meat is bad", then we can start to talk about "inequality of outcomes" with respect to salad eating. But is this really a problem? I would argue it's only a problem if we don't want humans exercising free will, and want to impose our "enlightened" views on them.
ghufran_syed··on Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
Yes, if we use "intelligence" as our metric when hiring, rather than using race. So why would we promote the latter instead of the former?
ghufran_syed··on Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
Why use historically marginalized groups - which almost always means racial groups as your target?

If you want to put more money into educational support for children where neither parent went to college or makes more then $x - I'm all in favor. But when you can easily measure those things, why then conflate it with race? If certain racial groups fall into those disdavtaged categories, they will automatically benefit. But maybe poor hard working white, or indian, or Chinese parents are dubious about giving additional benefit to the middle class or rich people who happen to be of a certain race? To take a specific example, why should a university prefer to accept one of president Obama's kids ahead of the child of a Chinese butcher or shopworker, all other things being equal?

ghufran_syed··on Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
Humans
ghufran_syed··on Russia's economy is back on its feet
Does that matter if it’s true? Or should we not consider the possible truth of it because we don’t listen to the “unbelievers”
ghufran_syed··on Nukes, nubs and coners: The unique social hierarchy aboard a nuclear submarine
Why would it be the job of the german military to try and prevent the war? Isn’t diplomacy the responsibility of the civilian government?
ghufran_syed··on Hiring discrimination: a problem for men in female-dominated occupations
I find it amazing that you think this kind of blatant racism is acceptable - what does being “white” have to do with his behavior or performance? or do you think certain skin colors are limited in their abilities and performance?
ghufran_syed··on Proposed bill would shorten California workweek to 32 hours
I agree - a related issue is that if indeed government should be using it's power, then it should be exercised at theost local level possible ie at the city or county level. That way you could see what happens when people have more of a choice about whether to live under those rules or not, before applying it in a way that is harder to avoid. Meaning it is easy to move cities or counties (in the US), harder to move state, almost impossible to change countries for most people's.

If it really is good for companies, then more will move there. If not, they will move out - better to do the experiment on a small scale first!

But the aim of a lot of federal or state level proposed legislation is so that people can't escape nirvana...

ghufran_syed··on My attempted cult recruitment
I think most people have too much caution when talking to strangers for the first time. I think one should be careful when taking things further - maybe meet in public for the first few meetings, so you can easily make excuses and walk away if things turn weird. This also makes recruitment much more expensive for these kind of sales / recruitment tactics,
ghufran_syed··on Developers spend most of their time figuring the system out
interesting that you equate “fragility” with the opposite of “morally superior” - “Fragile” seems like a fairly accurate description of the described phenomenon, you are the one who seems to be ascribing moral value on the basis of that description. Why is that? Why should we care if someone else describes us as “fragile”?
← PreviousPage 9 of 29Next →