HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gloob

2,069 karma · joined August 6, 2009

submissionscomments
gloob··on Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores
It is self-evidently true that removing visible comment scores mostly removes methods for trivially measuring "viewer sentiment". It is the contention of those in support of non-visible comment scores that trivial measurement of viewer sentiment harms, rather than aids, discussion. You have made no argument against that point.
gloob··on Russia's Crime of the Century
Your first sentence has been true for the better part of a century, now. And - while the American government is undoubtedly less corrupt and more liberal than the Russian one - I don't really see the odds of America using nukes being significantly lower than the odds of Russia using them.

(Also: I'm not entirely clear on what you mean by "out of control" - plenty of countries engage in extrajudicial killings: Russia, obviously, but also Israel, Syria, America...)

gloob··on Goodbye, IBM. Seriously.
every other sentence out of his mouth could be "I'm better than you" and people wouldn't flinch

To my understanding, that's pretty much what "charismatic" means. It's not a synonym for "friendly".

gloob··on The Origins of Altruism - Edward O. Wilson's Alternate Theory
Why the following: "the selection pressure at the individual level tends to outweigh the pressure at the group level".

Because "I had 1.8 viable offspring before I died" is more fit than "I had 1.5 viable offspring before I died", no matter how you slice it. Any trait that moves an individual from the former statement to the latter makes that individual less fit, even if it benefits the group, and since the individual is less fit, that trait is less likely to be passed on, resulting (asymptotically) in more fit individuals massively outnumbering less fit ones, irrespective of the impact those individuals have on group fitness.

gloob··on Pure python bitcoin miner to understand how it works
Could you describe how that makes it like a pyramid scheme?
gloob··on .XXX Goes Live in the Root Servers
So whether the porn industry wanted it, if the market wanted it, it would happen.

What do you mean by "if the market wanted it"? Unless people actually stopped paying for porn on non-.xxx domains, or they payed more for porn on .xxx domains, then there is no market force encouraging porn companies to change what they're already doing.

(Rant: The personification of "the market" to the point where it is capable of "wanting" things on its own initiative is a pet peeve of mine. It's not a person. It doesn't have desires. Market economics is a descriptive theory, not a theological statement.)

gloob··on .XXX Goes Live in the Root Servers
Forgive me if I'm being dense, but what motive would I have to pay X dollars a year for the privilege of being easy to block?

Edit: I mean, I've heard people argue that it would help the porn sites curry favor with parents, but I really have a tough time imagining that actually turning into more money for the porn sites (though I admit that I really know nothing about the industry).

gloob··on FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... domain names
Normally I wouldn't be this pedantic, but in a discussion about currency, it's worthwhile specifying whether you mean American dollars, $some_other_country's dollars, or the Platonic form of dollars.
gloob··on How to choose a domain name
I'm skeptical. I don't really see anything inherently less memorable about Blackwater, Microsoft, or Coca-Cola than Pepsi, Apple, or Dropbox.
gloob··on Why no company that values their data should ever "Go Google"
Then they should accept responsibility for the outcome of their decision when Google backing up their stuff isn't "backed up enough".
gloob··on Tim Berners-Lee: Web access is a human right
To quote myself from a few months ago:

"I am a citizen, you must hold (if you are the government) or fund (if you are a taxpayer) an election for me to vote in."

What's your feeling on that positive right? I've encountered people who argue against democracy, and I've encountered people who will re-word the right as stated above and then call it a negative right. I disagree with the former, and the latter only succeed in demonstrating that the difference between positive and negative rights is one of phrasing, and not of the right itself. Do you have a different take on the matter?

The idea of "negative" and "positive" rights is one way of looking at the matter, but it has flaws.

Edit: I don't mean to imply the parent post is making any argument one way or the other; I'm just commenting on the idea itself.

Edit 2: Other things (some completely outlandish, some more plausible) worth thinking about:

  - I own a square mile of land with a river running through
    it.  You own an adjacent square mile of land downriver
    of mine.  If I, entirely on my own property, divert the
    river such that it ceases to run through your property,
    have I aggressed against you?  Do you have the right to
    never have the value of your property decrease?
  - I am fantabulously wealthy and buy up all the food in
    the world.  Do I have the right to refuse to sell it?
    Have I aggressed against the other 7 billion by forcing
    the large majority of them to starve to death?
  - The local branch of the Nazis are hunting for members
    of unpopular minorities.  I am a gay black Jew.  Am I
    justified in trespassing on a stranger's property in
    order to hide and evade capture?
gloob··on RIM CEO terminates BBC Click interview
Fair enough, but the end result is still that the "security" of the system is rather different than what most people think it is. "Just your friends see BBM" versus "Just your friends, and RIM, and the government of India, and - oh hell, let's be honest - probably any other government that asks sufficiently impolitely as well, see BBM."
gloob··on RIM CEO terminates BBC Click interview
It's entirely possible I'm in the minority on this, but the following (theatrical, paraphrased, artistic-liberty-ized) conversation implies that there is a serious security issue with Blackberry devices:

  India: Give us access to your secure messaging service.
  RIM: Okay.
gloob··on Are You Following a Bot?
I haven't used this myself, but it looks like it might be something up your alley:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2004254

http://proxlet.com/

My understanding is that it's basically a proxy for Twitter that allows you to filter based on criteria you specify.

gloob··on Advanced programming languages
Though, in fairness, Erlang has a completely different emphasis than most other functional languages - instead of provability, experimenting with type systems, or state-phobia, my understanding is that it was pretty much engineered for making stable systems, and everything else is a secondary concern. (It was also put together by a telecom, rather than academics or hobbyists).
gloob··on The Rationality of One Star Reviews
I believe I'm in violent agreement with your second paragraph. A mismatch between the predictions of an economic theory and what happens in the real world demonstrates a predictive (and therefore descriptive) inadequacy of that theory, rather than a (moral) failure of the world.
gloob··on Ars Technica on GNOME3
You might disagree with the idea that "it simply doesn't matter", but I don't actually see any refuting of that idea in your post. Could you offer a reason why it does matter?
gloob··on Celebrating 20 Years of Linux
I might be misremembering, but wasn't Tivo also Linux-based?
gloob··on Steve Jobs Interview about the Blue Box Story
Brings a whole new meaning to "good artists copy, great artists steal".
gloob··on Show HN: my weekend project - sell files for bitcoins
In a pyramid scheme, the people at the top of the pyramid want to stay in the game for as long as they can, not cash out as soon as the opportunity arises. What you've described sounds closer to "pump'n'dump".
gloob··on Ask HN: How to stave off decline of HN?
He mostly did it manually. He had started to pull a system together to automate it, but (iirc) some people rather resented it, so he discontinued that.
gloob··on Osdev: a SubReddit devoted to operating system development
Because it's [dead], would be my first guess.

Now, if you are wondering why it is dead, I can't help you in the slightest.

gloob··on Cable-backed anti-muni broadband bill advances in North Carolina
I'd rather not have any facet of government in an easy position to monitor my internet traffic.

In fairness, it's a bit late for that:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nsa#AT.26T_Internet_monitoring

gloob··on Time-saving tips for Linux
Sorry - I accidentally downvoted you.
gloob··on Comodo attack appears to have originated from Iran
No it's not. Even if "most of the IPs involved in the attack came from Iran" constituted proof that the attacker was Iranian, it would not be proof that (1) the attacker was the Iranian government, or that (2) they intended to use the stolen SSL keys to spy on the citizenry of Iran.

It is, at best, evidence, not proof. Reasonably strong evidence, mind you.

gloob··on Detecting Certificate Authority compromises and web browser collusion
So the solution to "the CA system is not trustworthy" is "tell the public the CA system is trustworthy"?

Edit: I mean, I can see how it's in the browser's interests to convince people that the system is reliable. And I can see how it's in web companies' interests to convince people that the system is reliable. But trying to convince people that the system is reliable when it is known not to be reliable strikes me as ethically questionable, at best.

gloob··on 100,000 people pressure Apple to shut down 'Gay Cure' app
Freedom of expression does not exist in Apple's app store. That has consistently been my takeaway from previous discussions on this topic, at least.
gloob··on Cω
Without further qualification, "better" and "worse" are usually pretty meaningless words when discussing something like programming languages. I've only read the first few paragraphs on the page so far, but it seems reasonable to guess it is very unlike Python, at least.
gloob··on Superconductivity Near 20 Celsius
I'm not really certain about eastern Canada, but in Calgary the seasons are something like:

  Spring: Mid-March til Mid-May.  Snow goes away.  Then it
          comes back.  Then it goes away.  Then it comes
          back.  Then it goes away.
  Summer: Mid-May til early September (with luck) or late-
          August (without it).  Mostly warm, usually dry.
          Punctuated by hailstorms.  Once every few years
          punctuated with a smallish snow storm.
  Fall: Early September til late October.  Stuff cools down.
        Frost is common.  Occasional hail or freezing rain.
  Winter: Late October til mid-March.  October-til-Christmas
          swings back and forth between (very) cold streaks
          and stereotypically fall-ish weather.  January to
          March is mostly just cold and snowy and icy.
Bear in mind that the climate really only gets worse the further east you go, culminating in the maritimes - where winters of five-foot snow alternate with summers of hurricanes. :P
gloob··on Pornography Sites Will Be Allowed to Use .XXX Addresses
all-the-worlds-a-va.xxx
← PreviousPage 2 of 20Next →