HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gnarlouse

819 karma · joined October 20, 2022

HackerSmacker profile: https://www.hackersmacker.org/user/gnarlouse?hs=bIZAQUhrxLEi10YuTr
submissionscomments
gnarlouse··on Meta VR Glasses
Smoked Metas
gnarlouse··on Garry Tan wants US open-weight AI labs to 'distill' frontier models, too
you want smaller models with comparable capabilities. for resource efficiency, market efficiency, environmental conservation.
gnarlouse··on iPhone Duo
Hideous
gnarlouse··on Our decision on Cursor following its acquisition by SpaceX
At least capitalism isn't at the center of the most impactful technological revolution in human history.
gnarlouse··on Verschlimmbesserung: The Word Your Software Updates Need
Does that mean Verbesserschlimmung is "improving things for nothing" because the same can be said of AI.
gnarlouse··on AI;DR (AI; Didn't Read)
YO (AIDR)IAN!
gnarlouse··on Every Fucking Website (2020)
Why would you make this. I feel traumatized.
gnarlouse··on AI is removing the middle class of software engineering?
It's YOUR fault! I knew it had to be one of us. Now I know. At least you were honest about it.
gnarlouse··on AI is removing the middle class of software engineering?
If there's a real existential pressure on a certain group of engineers, those that escape with their employment will carry evolutionary DNA with them (along with a substantial helping of pure luck) in the form of experience. Those that don't will disappear.

Nothing else this article says matters much in my opinion. If you're concerned about something, do something about it.

AI is still just a tool.

gnarlouse··on AI is removing the middle class of software engineering?
> NEVER

with critical thought*

fixed that for you, only sith's (and unreasonable people) deal in absolutes; you almost did!

gnarlouse··on AI is removing the middle class of software engineering?
this might be the only comment on this post worth reading, much less the article...

seems like a petty easy construction, proof engagement kinda thing

gnarlouse··on Closing Canario Terminal source code
Isn't there a clause to opensource for "unmaintained, delivered as is?"
gnarlouse··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
It's a stupid word soup on second read, but hey, it works, and that's all that matters with "stochasty the parrot."

""" In this project, I require a socratically delivered line of conversation. Here's the typical structure to the conversation. I ask some question. You need to factor and reason about how to conduct and deliver a conversation. Best practices would be to limit terminology, or assess with the user whether they have a firm grasp on terminology before you use it. You must be very strict about this, it's unacceptable to just introduce a new concept, actor, phrase or other complication into the conversation without first labeling who what or why it exists for the conversation.

Conversation structure needs to be front-loaded with a brief interview for the user, "you understand X?", "whats your understanding of Y?".

Conversation structure then needs to proceed with single-sentence questions from the agent. User replies with an answer. Sometimes the agent needs to correct the user, but only ever do so with yet another question. """

^^ these are the instructions I have installed at the root of a "project".

Keep in mind, this is claude opus 5 low effort we're talking about, in the "projects" area of the mobile app. Here's the process I use to set up its knowledge:

1. I take screenshots of the textbook on my iPhone, and upload a chapter at a time.

2. I have it summarize the chapter into markdown by analyzing screenshots. You could probably achieve this simpler, if you just had the textbook in PDF.

3. I walk with my boy Clau-crates.

I've done this for a couple of weeks and haven't seen it revert back into its typical context-dumping behavior.

On second read, there's probably some clean up I could do. Thanks for making me pull it out and look at it. Things that could probably be improved:

- tell it to cross-check resources online to further ground itself

- use simple, short sentences (long sentences make the brain blur a bit)

- not be sycophantic (it seems like project mode has discarded with my root-level anti-sycophancy prompt)

gnarlouse··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
Sorta. If its response is grounded in actual material, and you're thorough, it's not so risky. As with all learning, trusting one source is a risk in itself. Hell, I didn't even trust my physics textbooks in college. Physics.
gnarlouse··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
I've had success using the socratic method. I give Claude some topic (say, how the intricacies of the bond market works, the content from which are screenshots of pages from a textbook), and then I go on a walk chatting with it in voice mode. Claude is the expert, I am the student. Claude asks me questions, leading me to an answer logically. I come back with questions, and we back and forth. LLMs arent like they were in '23-'25. I'm almost always skeptical its going to lie, and almost always wrong.

In particular:

- I limit it/encourage it to give me single sentence questions

- I sometimes will ask it to tell me a motivating, human-grounded story, when we're starting a new concept: claude responds "Maya is a bond portfolio manager, and her boss has asked her to quickly price in what happened if yields go down. She knows her bond's average duration, a measure in time, but she doesn't have a percentage, which is what her manager wants. How can she give him a percentage number with just a duration figure and the proposed new yield?"

- I'll often ask claude to let me work through it, to derive the thing myself, often resulting in a string of thoughts with "yes/no" trailers, to get the LLM to reply yes or no only, and avoid derailing my train of thought. If yes, my train of thought keeps going. If no, I've got something wrong.

- I'll sometimes stop and have it craft an artifact. I typically say "build me a Brilliant.org-style interactive demo of the topic", especially when we get into the realm of looking at the actual maths of a thing (for which prose and dialog is not optimal by itself AFAICT)

- I'll do this while I'm traveling, while I'm walking, while I'm doing chores.

It's so much fun.

gnarlouse··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
Why are you booing me I'm right
gnarlouse··on Proving a human wrote something
i do actually think the general thrust of the idea is good. i also think it's sort of inherently cursed, and has some amount of a predeterminable fate.

if it doesnt take off, it dies.

if it does take off and becomes a relevant currency of some sort, it will need improving. if it needs improving how far are we willing to go? does some alternative system fork off to handle severity of provenance concern?

what happens when AI action becomes indistinguishable from human action? what happens when sticking computers in your head becomes vogue?

if it takes off and fills a small niche, maybe thats the best future.

Like I said, cool idea, but seemingly very cursed from the get go.

gnarlouse··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
If the US AI market collapses, the entire US economy collapses.
gnarlouse··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
Anybody can ELI5?
gnarlouse··on Show HN: Juggler – an open-source GUI coding agent, by the creator of JUCE
Honestly even just a bookmarking system would go a long way to fix the problem, but getting "off-topic" in LLMs (3 years later and trillions of dollars of investment) still ruins my flow entirely. I end up playing an unwanted game of scrollbar warrior jumping back and forth between two points in chat. Could be that I'm studying a textbook and looking to enhance/check my understanding with Claude, or that I'm working on complicated tasks in my codebase. Side tangents always crop up. LLMs don't handle it well. Blows my mind that it doesn't bother anybody else, perhaps IATAH
gnarlouse··on Show HN: Juggler – an open-source GUI coding agent, by the creator of JUCE
The best example that comes to mind is orthogonal "thread pulling," and the fact that it's not immediately evident that you'd want to do it like this, makes me wonder if I'm the weirdo.

Say you're studying something: STEM topics, Liberal arts topics, a codebase, a textbook, etc XYZ. You're in the flow of discussing a main topic. Invariably, the main topic is built on top of atomic subelements. For example, discussions about Bonds invariably invoke discussions of Present Value, Yield to Maturity.

The branching is because you have a side query that is a potentially unbounded stack of "wait, but why this?" You highlight a segment of text in the current chat, click a button that pops a new conversation over to the right, and continue your "related but off-topic question." You have both context threads in view at once: the main topic & the side topic. You should be able to do this N layers deep.

The alternative is that you get to play scrollbar warrior in the current regime of LLM-designs. It's not really conducive to deep understanding.

This kind of conversation applies naturally to software development too: "wait, so we're working on feature X/refactor X/bugfix X, but that requires us to answer this subthread. And sure these days Claude Fable can probably do it all with the right harness, but does that mean you _understand_ what it just did?

gnarlouse··on Show HN: Juggler – an open-source GUI coding agent, by the creator of JUCE
@julesrms thank you for lending more credibility to the idea that agent conversations need to be natively branching. It's crazy that we're almost 3 years in on this LLM joyride and we still don't have the ability to do, like, reddit/slack-style "aside" convo threads.

~~edit~~

wait, are you doing that? Love JUCE btw

gnarlouse··on Proof of care in the age of AI
I've sort of been thinking about this in terms of software dev lifecycle & PRs/code review.

Maybe PRs these days need to "test" the human? "Explain how this code works, without AI, or it gets rejected."

gnarlouse··on Successful companies go blind
What the AI post
gnarlouse··on Show HN: I made Google Trends for Hacker News by indexing 18 years of comments
I'm still "trying to make 'fetch' happen" with the whole "billionaire alignment problem" thing. Maybe the phrase will catch on.
gnarlouse··on Iroh 1.0
Is the intent to replace the IP protocol ever?
gnarlouse··on macOS needs its grid back
We need a new social media platform purely for Apple product experiences. Stay with me. People post their experiences with various parts of all their products, from hardware button position to software design and behavior. Upvotes are "It's Genius", downvotes are "It's Shit" -- because Apple has completely shirked its much needed Jobsian specter.

The joke, of course, is that I imagine a good 75% of the reviews would be "it's shit."

gnarlouse··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
Superintelligence Alignment conversations are a misdirect.

Let's talk about Billionaire Alignment, Economic alignment, Human alignment.

Classware should be M.A.D. -- in that it shouldnt even happen.

gnarlouse··on The newest Instagram “exploit” is the goofiest I've seen
good lord
gnarlouse··on What color is your function? (2015)
> Spidermouth the Night Clown

Thanks for my next horror shortfilm plot. Twist: he's the protagonist

← PreviousPage 2 of 15Next →