HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gngeal

987 karma · joined March 2, 2013

submissionscomments
gngeal··on Appeals court rules journalists can’t keep their sources secret
Well, journalists will have to come up with a way of having people send them scoop without revealing who the scoop senders are.
gngeal··on The Forbidden Island
This was the best part:

"when an Indian Navy helicopter tried to recover them from the beach, the Sentinelese fought it off with bows and arrows"

Indian Navy should feel ashamed! :D

gngeal··on Email exchange between Edward Snowden and former GOP Senator Gordon Humphrey
Funny thing is, when he suggested splitting the key, I assumed that this is what he had in mind.
gngeal··on Linus on "acting professionally"
I don't buy that "people" need to swear any more than they need to lie, or that the result of swearing is somehow less damaging/more productive than lying.

Lying is dishonorable, counterproductive in context of multiple cooperating people, and a really bad idea overall, purely objectively. Swearing, linguistics-wise, is indeed a completely normal ("natural and ok") trait (present to some extent in individuals of all cultures, gender, professions etc., even in some higher animals) that is orthogonal to anyone's performance. How could you possibly equate these two is beyond me.

gngeal··on The Recomputation Manifesto
Emulating a Gameboy is fine, but emulating a large-scale scientific computation may be just a little bit more demanding, I'm afraid. :/
gngeal··on The Recomputation Manifesto
How are all these VMs going to react if people switch, say, to desktops with ARMv8, or whatever comes next?
gngeal··on Cello: Higher level programming in C
All? I'm sure Alan Kay would disagree. The problem with OpenDoc is that it emerged at an unfortunate time and asked you to work with vastly inferior languages than what you'd actually need to make this work without getting insane in the process.
gngeal··on Cello: Higher level programming in C
I would say the downside of this 'rich' environment is that your tools tend to become language dependent.

That does not necessarily have to be the case. Just like you have abstract collections capable of handling values of any type, I don't see why it should be impossible to have a model of versionable, editable code into which you could inject your own implementations for the particular language you're coding in right now.

I realized the other day how close persistent collections and tools like Git actually are. And given how most modern languages have programs that are essentially trees or groves, and given that said persistent collections tend to be trees...? Well, what do you think?

gngeal··on Cache-aware matrix multiplication – naive isn't that bad
I may be mistaken, but don't ATLAS, BLAS, LINPACK etc. only operate on single and double precision floats? What if the elements you're operating on are, say, rationals or polynomials? Somehow it seemed to me that linear algebra is a somewhat more abstract concept than what Fortran numerical libraries usually tend to implement.

Also, the drawback of anything written in this way is that it doesn't compose well. The individual operations may well have been optimized into oblivion, but their composition may not necessarily be what you'd like it to be. One can also say goodbye to higher-order functions. But I'm not exactly a Fortran person when it comes to code style, so I may be prejudiced against overly loopy code.

(BTW, am I the only one who thinks that the Sourceforge (http://sourceforge.net/projects/math-atlas/) comments are machine-generated? I mean, comments like "An essential Windows program." or "The best program that I've ever used." are hardly what I'd expect for a numerical library.)

gngeal··on Cache-aware matrix multiplication – naive isn't that bad
ATLAS and BLAS are

What you probably meant was that ATLAS and BLAS are implementations of the right way, not the way itself. Because the alternative would be really, really sad.

gngeal··on Sanskrit and Lisp (2011)
I've never had much success with Indo-Europeans

Did you compose this text with the help of Google Translate, then?

gngeal··on Sanskrit and Lisp (2011)
I think what he means is that what people actually spoke every day was as different from our bookish notions of what Sanskrit is as the language of a poor farmer or a slave in Ancient Rome was from the writings of Cicero. You really can't equate the two things.
gngeal··on Sanskrit and Lisp (2011)
English is not popular because it is "easy to copy" or any nonsense like that.

English may not be easy to copy but it's comparatively "bland". "Bland" in this case means "has a smaller number of marked features". For example, it has no tones. It's always easier for someone speaking a tonal language to learn a toneless language than the other way round. Sanskrit has a complex system of synthetic inflection, which is a rather marked feature, and all speakers of analytic languages would hate your guts for forcing it onto them if you tried to make them learn it. In many ways, Sanskrit is like Ancient Greek. You spend a year learning something that other languages can do without (and do so without muddling the meaning of the text), and even if you learn it, you'll still be doing mistakes quite a lot of the time. Such a language would never have a chance of spreading as an international medium of communication.

gngeal··on Sanskrit and Lisp (2011)
How come that "the theory that made up an imaginary language" correctly predicted the existence of laryngeal phonemes in the Hittite language before the Hittite language was even known to exist? Stroke of luck, that a group of unknown consonants from an "imaginary language" appeared in a real language in exactly the right place in the right words?

Also, the notion that the PIE reconstructions describe a "language" in the sense that we usually understand it (a vernacular tongue of a group of people in a single time and place) is a false one: even though the reconstructions with very high likelihood represent individual IE language features in an old form thereof, it would be a folly to try to slap them together and say "this is a language that someone spoke", for the same reason you can't reconstruct individual genes from the tree of mammals, slap them together and say "this was the first mammal". It doesn't work like that. What you get is a constrained probability function over possible languages, not a single solution with 100% probability.

gngeal··on Sanskrit and Lisp (2011)
To sum it up, the writer probably has the mentality of William Jones: sort of romantic, but essentially flawed.
gngeal··on How secure is Linux's random number generator?
Hmm. Haven't thought of that. Comparatively simple, yet also compact at the same time. Thanks, nice!
gngeal··on How secure is Linux's random number generator?
Too mechanical. I'm afraid I like my bubble idea more. Unless I get my hands on some suitable radioisotope, that is.
gngeal··on How secure is Linux's random number generator?
If you are super paranoid, you'll need to find a hardware random generator which you've built yourself --- and hopefully you are competent enough to actually build a real HWRNG, and not something which is sampling 60 Hz hum (or 50 Hz hum if you are in Europe :-), and mix that into the entropy pool as well.

What do you propose as a low cost solution? I've seen some interesting suggestions, such as having a small fish bowl or tube or tank, having air pumped into the bottom, and sampling the patterns of bubbles with some CV solution. Sounds geeky, would make for a nice decoration on one's table, but building it seems like quite a job.

gngeal··on New Scheme-Based GPU Programming Language
No. It makes it easier for parsers.

Not even that. It's about making thing easiest for metaprogrammers.

gngeal··on Crowd steps up to fund 'NSA-proof' app
Any reason why you're still only using AES-128?

What else would you suggest?

gngeal··on If correlation doesn’t imply causation, then what does? (2012)
I think it helps a lot if you have a plausible explanation for the chain of causes. For example, the correlation of dead people in houses with shitty stoves and furnaces in those houses is interesting, but once you discover that said stoves and furnaces leak carbon monoxide, AND that carbon monoxide binds to hemoglobin with much greater affinity than oxygen, AND that the affected people don't receive any specific warning symptoms when that happens, you suddenly have a reason to stop wondering whether or not they were committing suicide at a heightened rate because of poverty-related depression.
gngeal··on LINQ Ruined My Favorite Interview Question
In particular, a query like the one in the original blog post will evaluate multiple intermediate lists that then need to be thrown away.

Why not fuse the operations, if the values are immutable?

gngeal··on LINQ Ruined My Favorite Interview Question
Ironically, expressing this in something like SQL actually speaks to the expressivity of the language because the solution was produced entirely with syntactic forms.

What? Pure untyped lambda calculus does things "only with syntactic forms". Don't tell me that your solution wouldn't use some basic operators other than rudimentary syntax. Keep in mind that in Lisp-family languages, many things that are a part of syntax in other languages are actually simple functions - arithmetic operations being a case in point - so you really can't avoid using library functions.

I believe that the major point of Clojure etc. is that they provide concise basic operations that you can use everywhere to compose complex operations better than you can do with, say, C#.

gngeal··on Discovering Sketch
You should always be able to do non-destructive editing even when pretending to work destructively, by keeping around the original sources (which you keep around anyway in most cases) and the graph of operations applied (which isn't much data). Or rather, the software should be able to do that. I'm surprised that there don't seem to be any applications doing that.
gngeal··on Judge Orders U.S. to Release Aaron Swartz’s Secret Service File
the Secret Service hasn't really been ordered to release anything other than a stack of black pieces of paper.

Wouldn't that de facto qualify as a contempt of court?

gngeal··on What does it take to be an expert in computer programming?
If you're, for example, rewriting an obviously correct but slow piece of code X into a faster but not obvious code Y, how do you know if the two are functionally identical without at least some knowledge of program algebra?
gngeal··on Germany's Solar Industry Is Imploding
the mid to long term outcome will benefit the whole world anyway

Here, fixed that for you. (Pilot projects on a large scale are useful to all of us. Someone has to finally do it.)

gngeal··on Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans
We should see a obvious trend students heading to engineering majors.

Yes, especially people with childhood dreams of studying history or art will be turned on by the prospect of designing airliners and nuclear reactors.

gngeal··on Oh, My Hand: Complaints Medieval Monks Scribbled in the Margins of Manuscripts
Who's written anything worthy of that treatment?

Almost - not who but _why.

gngeal··on Bolivia says Morales' plane diverted, apparently over Snowden
I won't even try to guess what's the code for Peruvian or Colombian military planes is.
← PreviousPage 8 of 16Next →