HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

greygoo222

213 karma · joined August 26, 2025

submissionscomments
greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
mRNA cancer vaccines are the most exciting new treatment about to hit the clinic. Moderna's Phase 2b intismeran autogene randomized trial found a 49% (!!!) reduction in the risk recurrence or death for patients with high risk melanoma already on standard treatment. Several Phase 3 trials are underway. mRNA vaccines have the potential to work for a wide variety of tumors.

(95% confidence interval is 0.294-0.887, wide but not too wide, n=157, to be expected for phase 2).

How they work is also completely fucking insane. Intismeran autogene is personalized for every patient via sequencing their tumor DNA. That's sci-fi shit. If you're not impressed by that, you should be. Fast and scalable DNA sequencing, neoantigen identification, RNA synthesis, none of this is easy and all of it relies on recent innovations across multiple fields.

The first proofs of concept for personalized vaccines like this date back to 2017[1] or 2015[2]. The process for designing the vaccines requires a machine learning algorithm first published in 2020[3]. Details of the algorithm aren't available, but it validated against data published in 2019[4], and there have been many recent advancements in algorithms and datasets for biotech ML that it likely relied on. As you might already know, mRNA vaccines were first tested in humans around the 2010s[5].

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature22991 [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25837513/ [3] https://aacrjournals.org/cancerres/article/80/16_Supplement/... [4] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7138461/ [5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26082837/

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
You're incredibly wrong. You also cited my own comment at me.

The problem of high interstitial pressure (not blood pressure) interfering with drug delivery in tumors is basic cancer biology. If you don't believe me, here's:

A review published in a reputable oncology journal, with over 100 citations, entirely about targeting interstitial pressure, with an abstract leading with "Tumor interstitial pressure is a fundamental feature of cancer biology. Elevation in tumor pressure affects the efficacy of cancer treatment." https://aacrjournals.org/cancerres/article/74/10/2655/592612...

Another review, also a reputable oncology journal, 1000 citations, about tumor stroma more generally, which lists high interstitial pressure as a mechanism by which tumors limit drug access and includes a nice diagram (Figure 2a). https://www.nature.com/articles/s41571-018-0007-1

That's how basic this fact is. 1000 citation reviews in Nature have beautiful fucking diagrams of it. I'm pretty sure it was in the textbook of my undergraduate biology class.

If you don't know shit, don't talk shit. People will criticize LLMs for being overconfident while writing essays from their ass.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
They're not pointing out something the researchers missed, they're pointing out something the people in this thread confidently hyping the results are missing. I'm certain the researchers are familiar with the limitations of the models they used (is it bad that the incentives of science and science journalism leads to overoptimistic coverage that hint at groundbreaking implications without explaining to lay readers what the unknowns are? Probably, but that's not these researchers' faults).

The average person in this thread, however, would probably be better informed by asking an LLM for context. They'd be even better informed by taking a few weeks to work through a textbook on cancer biology, but realistically they won't.

My horse in the race is that I'm annoyed by overenthusiastic comments that display a lack of understanding of the history of cancer treatment, and I'm going to be even more annoyed in a few months when the rounds of "haven't we had 1000 cures to cancer posted to HN??? why aren't we using any of them???" start showing up again. I'd rather encourage informed, skeptical optimism.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
This is kind of true but misses the bigger picture. We have developed many drug options more targeted than traditional chemotherapy, famously Gleevec for example. The question isn't whether we've found one that could work at all, but how well does it work, what types of cancer it works for, and what the side effects are.
greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Both patient participation in clinical trials and compassionate use of experimental treatments are fairly common for cancer patients, with various accessibility barriers. (One issue with the latter, for example, is that the incentives aren't lined up for companies to provide unapproved drugs to dying patients, you're way more likely to get a horrible complication that leads to bad press than a miraculous recovery).

Here's an insightful blog series about Jake Seliger's experience participating in clinical trials. He was a regular HackerNews user who passed away in 2024: https://bessstillman.substack.com/p/please-be-dying-but-not-...

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
These are all correct observations about the limitations of xenografted mouse models.
greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Xenografted human tumors in mice != human cancer. The support structure of the tumor (tumor microenvironment) differs between model mice and humans, cells derived from human cancer that can be cultivated in a lab and xenografted differ from typical human cancer cells, and xenografting requires immunodeficient mice, just to name a few factors that affect treatment response.

Mice models of cancer are useful, but you should never be too surprised when something that works in mice doesn't work in the clinic, xenografting or no. Cancer is complicated.

greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
Your testicles, empirically, shrink when it gets cold. Do you think measuring their shadow is an acceptable substitute for a thermometer?
greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
Sigh. Sure, if you had a gun to your head and you knew nothing else, it would be better to guess that a given population (hunter-gatherers) with low rates of some illnesses (T2D, HBP) also had low rates of another illness (CRC) than the reverse. Okay. That's a slightly better-than-chance guess, not anywhere near a solid basis for speculation.

"Anyways, it makes sense that marathoners get CRC because hunter-gatherers probably don't run that much" is bongcloud lalaland tier guesswork.

greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
C'mon, I already said that, that was half of my comment!
greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
I won't bother checking or disputing the accuracy of your factual claims, because it does not matter.

Colorectal cancer is not the same thing as high blood pressure, or type 2 diabetes, or any other cancer that isn't colorectal cancer. Diseases are not a monolith and you cannot assume low risk of some diseases means low risk of others. That is wild guesswork passed off as logic, like measuring the shadow your testicles cast on the wall and announcing it is 24.1 degrees Celsius. Ultra-marathon runners also have low risk of type 2 diabetes!

Do you have specific evidence that modern hunter-gatherers have low rates of colorectal cancer that cannot be explained by survivorship bias, screening, genetic differences, and all other confounders, and that they are representative of historical hunter-gatherers? No? Then you cannot confidently conclude that hunter-gatherers didn't experience elevated rates of CRC.

greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
You shouldn't so offhandedly assume a hunter-gatherer lifestyle couldn't lead to issues like increased risk of CRC, or that activities which lead to increased risk of CRC couldn't be what hunter-gatherers did. Evolution is neither fast nor perfectly precise. Plenty of animal populations have common health problems that simply weren't harmful enough to reproduction to be selected out, much less something rare and late-onset like CRC.
greygoo222··on Overall, the colorectal cancer story is encouraging
This mostly can't explain the fact that mortality is also rising in under 50s. It is true mortality is rising less than incident, and that a small proportion instances of mortality could be deaths related to reasonable risks taken on from treatment side effects (to make up numbers, it makes sense to take a 5% chance of dying from treatment this year over a 80% chance of dying from cancer in 5 years), but this is probably not the whole effect. Something is causing more CRC in people under 50.
greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
Let me try this again. High fertility is the rule, not the exception, of human behavior. Human population has, give or take, consistently increased since the invention of agriculture. Modern trends of society-wide low fertility are an unusual phenomenon specific to a cultural context enabled by advanced technology and high global populations.

Imagine your prediction pans out until there are 10 million people worldwide, the size of a large city. It won't, because this entire premise is deeply ridiculous, but imagine. How is this society going to maintain the same culture we have now? Are all these people unable to recognize that low fertility is leading to extinction, despite the very obvious historical data, or do they just not care? How long do you think people will even have the capacity to keep producing and distributing birth control?

greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
I guarantee you I've spent more time thinking about this than you have.

Massive decreases in population change culture. The Western cultural context we have today won't just magically persist, converting new people, until we run out of people. At worst, we'll end up in a world where the majority of the population consists of the descendants of current high-fertility subcultures. Even that is extremely unlikely. Fertility rates only become a population-level problem a few generations down the line, at which point we are almost guaranteed to have artificial wombs and other technology that changes the dynamics of reproduction entirely.

Fertility is worth worrying about because it may cause fewer resources for the elderly, particularly in some acutely affected nations. It is not an extinction risk.

greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
I was wondering which pet issue you were a doomer about. Fertility is the most ridiculous of them all. There is no plausible mechanism by which low fertility rates could lead to extinction, and if you think there is you don't understand the issue at all.

Come on, just think about this for a minute. Is your model that we're just going to have fewer children, so that each generation becomes smaller, until we run out of people?

greygoo222··on Claims of disability are highest at elite universities
I am very aware of the history of amphetamine use in the US. I think widespread access to amphetamines was mostly good (and widespread access to benzos was mostly bad).
greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
It's crazy that you accuse the person you're replying to of being lucky, when your comment is the epitome of privilege. Since the year 2000, child mortality rates declined over 2x in Africa and Asia. That is millions of children who, in another era, wouldn't have had the opportunity to grow up.

I don't think your complaints about your life are true, see my other comment, but even if they were they make no impact in the big picture of "has the world gotten better or worse."

greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
This can't explain the data in the article, such as the fact that people underestimate the rate at which other survey responders will report being happy.
greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
There are many more undeniable mathematically-confirmable trends that bode well: life expectancy, poverty, homicide rates, etc. Most important things are getting better.
greygoo222··on Claims of disability are highest at elite universities
I find it more likely that we'll recognize the social benefits of widespread stimulant prescriptions, and make them easier to get.
greygoo222··on Most people are individually optimistic, but think the world is falling apart
You can most likely afford to buy a viable homestead in a rural area if you wanted to. Your problem isn't that you can't afford a house, it's that you can't afford a house in San Francisco.

I sincerely doubt that you can't find food better than your grandparents' by any objective measure. I suspect this is just nostalgia. I've lived and ate at rural family farms before, and while they often have better tomatoes than a typical supermarket and other tiny perks, if I had to pick between getting my food from the family farm and getting my food from a supermarket every day, I'd pick the supermarket without question. And I can always go to an upper-end market or a farmer's market if I really craved high-quality tomatoes.

I have never had any complaints about the quality of my clothes, including clothes bought at physical stores. I'm not sure why ordering clothes online is a downside.

greygoo222··on Can Ozempic Cure Addiction?
The trouble with the dementia prevention claim is that while the retrospective studies are promising, none of the RCTs really show results. You can argue this is because the RCTs don't dose enough nicotine early enough to matter, and that's likely true, but retrospective studies can turn up all sorts of phantom correlations. Right now I would say we don't know for sure, and I wouldn't recommend nicotine as a preventative measure.

I would recommend nicotine as a stimulant, though. It is a solid adjunct to caffeine.

greygoo222··on Can Ozempic Cure Addiction?
GLP-1s are the greatest medical innovation of the past decade. Top three, at least, mRNA might give them a run for their money.

There are known side effects, mostly gastrointestinal issues, and they don't work for everyone. That being said, I'd recommend you make your own risk assessment and consider getting on GLP-1s if you have the cash to spare. You might find that GLP-1s increase your quality of life so much that it's well-worth it (or that you get terrible nausea and immediately quit, and then you no longer need to wonder).

Potential risks have to be weighed against potential benefits. There are robust RCT results showing GLP-1s reduce all-cause mortality, major cardiovascular events, and stroke among patients with obesity or T2D by 13-14%, and suggestive evidence that some of these benefits apply to non-overweight people, though this hasn't been confirmed in RCTs and is likely smaller in magnitude.

"Cardiovascular and renal outcomes of glucagon-like peptide 1 receptor agonists among patients with and without type 2 diabetes mellitus: A meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials": https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266666772...

One reason to believe that cardiovascular benefits might apply to non-overweight people is that among the available evidence on overweight and obese people, weight loss doesn't seem to explain all benefits. See Figure 1 or the analysis section of the SELECT trial.

"Semaglutide and cardiovascular outcomes by baseline and changes in adiposity measurements: a prespecified analysis of the SELECT trial": https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

The main plausible long-term risk is thyroid cancer. Data from a meta-analysis of RCTs suggests a 55% (large error bars) increase in thyroid cancer risk.

"GLP-1 receptor agonists and the risk for cancer: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials": https://dom-pubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/do...

This is concerning, though it's worth noting that thyroid cancer is rare (1% lifetime incidence) and unlikely to kill you (98% 5-year survival, 99.9% when caught early). No studies have linked GLP-1s to a statistically significant increase in cancer-related mortality. I don't want to be too confident because RCTs have not yet shown this and I'm not an Eli Lilly shill, but cohort studies suggest GLP-1s are associated with reduced risk of other cancers. This is a good overview:

"Glucagon-like peptide-1 medicines and cancer": https://www.nature.com/articles/s43018-025-01110-1

greygoo222··on Can Ozempic Cure Addiction?
No it isn't. Every neurotransmitter is involved with every complex phenomenon.
greygoo222··on Can Ozempic Cure Addiction?
Nicotine pouches (or even vaping) are astronomically less harmful than cigarettes and still work as appetite suppressors. As a bonus they are more convenient to use in public. Smokers should consider considering switching instead of quitting nicotine entirely if it's easier.
greygoo222··on India's female workers watching hours of abusive content to train AI
I guarantee you approximately nothing on LiveLeak was consensual. Consensual cartel executions?

Men are more likely to be victims of violent crime than women. Adjust according to what?

greygoo222··on India's female workers watching hours of abusive content to train AI
Lots of people just aren't that bothered by gore videos and they are well-adjusted members of society, I dunno what to tell you.
greygoo222··on Bye Bye Humanity: The Potential AMOC Collapse
Livestock, staple crops, and pollinating insects cope pretty well over a wide variety of temperatures. Some specific crops don't, but that's not a problem as long as changes are predicted.
greygoo222··on India's female workers watching hours of abusive content to train AI
I feel like I'm taking crazy pills here. Am I just too old? What do you mean, people on this forum have no intuition about what watching gore videos online is like? About watching hours of ordinary porn (as the article also mentioned)?

That's more likely to be within the experience of a HackerNews user than serious manual labor.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →