HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

griffzhowl

1,116 karma · joined April 22, 2020

submissionscomments
griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
Yes, this is what tfa says, and it's a good point. But tfa also points out that the archaeologists/reconstructionists know that what they're producing differs from the original. The thing is the discipline of reconstruction means that they only use pigments that they have direct evidence of, and this is just the saturated underlayers. The problem is this is seldom explained when the reconstructions are presented to the public
griffzhowl··on AI is wiping out entry-level tech jobs, leaving graduates stranded
Thanks for the context, but there hasn't been a general tech sector crash since 2019, so I don't think the 2000-03 comparison is apt.

And while 2019 might have been third-highest year for investment in 2020, according to this it's been surpassed in 2021, 2022, and 2024

https://kpmg.com/xx/en/media/press-releases/2025/01/2024-glo...

So why have graduate hires continued to decline since 2023? It seems funds have been diverted from junior hiring into AI investments.

However, as others have remarked, this might be a case of "AI is not taking your jobs, AI investment is taking your jobs"

Junior hiring might pick up again once the spending spree is over

griffzhowl··on How geometry is fundamental for chess
He always has these brilliant ond original perspectives on even the simplest concepts.

He also has this series of talks beginning with the question "What is probability, what is randomness?"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJAQVletzdY&list=PLx5f8IelFR...

griffzhowl··on The World Happiness Report is beset with methodological problems
How much of the article did you read? The main substance of it is not that the UN rankings are flawed, but how the rankings change based on the broader analysis by Blanchflower and Bryson. That result can't so easily be read off from our cynical preconceptions
griffzhowl··on AI is wiping out entry-level tech jobs, leaving graduates stranded
The article refers to this article from May, which claims a 50% reduction in graduate tech hiring since pre-pandemic levels, 25% reduction since 2023

https://www.signalfire.com/blog/signalfire-state-of-talent-r...

griffzhowl··on Canada's Carney called out for 'utilizing' British spelling
It's just different meanings. "Utilize" means to put something to a use which doesn't normally have that use.
griffzhowl··on Thomas Piketty: 'The reality is the US is losing control of the world'
Yes, it's on the low end of estimates and corresponds most closely to the US military's Iraq war logs that were leaked by Wikileaks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Iraq_War#Tab...

Still, "over 100,000" is technically correct if it's more than 100,000. Since this subject isn't the main point of the article and the Iraq war is generally acknowledged to have been disastrous, I suppose he chose a safe figure so as not to derail the article with disputed estimates at the outset.

griffzhowl··on MIT Missing Semester 2026
Wasn't the SICP course a course in programming per se?
griffzhowl··on MIT Missing Semester 2026
Is the MOOC the same as the actual MIT course though? I went through one of the old Grimson Guttag Intro to CS courses on MIT OCW years ago, with zero programming background I found it a very gentle on-ramp with all the basics explained.

I think it was this one, unfortunately archived now. I don't know the new one

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/6-00-introduction-to-computer-sc...

griffzhowl··on Science Communications on YouTube
Yeah, those are huge... I haven't got round to them yet. I liked the one on electromagnetism as a gauge theory
griffzhowl··on Science Communications on YouTube
Yes, maybe, but for many maths or physics lectures you might have to imagine what's going on as you're listening to the squeaking of chalk on the blackboard:)
griffzhowl··on Science Communications on YouTube
I would say the main reason it's hard to follow abstract maths lectures by listening is not the difficulty of the concepts per se, but simply because it's so visual: it relies on notation and diagrams

But mathematicians can talk to each other about arbitrarily abstract concepts, as long as they have enough shared background, and they don't (always) need a blackboard to do it.

Conversely, you can have conceptually very simple things that are basically impossible to follow just by listening, like multiplying two nine-digit numbers or following one of Euclid's proofs in plane geometry. The difficulty isn't about abstraction, but how many things you have to hold in working memory

griffzhowl··on Science Communications on YouTube
For more in-depth physics, combining mathematical detail with excellent visualizations, the best channels I've found are

Richard Behiel, Physics Explained, Dr Jorge Diaz

For mathematics, I really appreciate the simpl but effective format of Richard Borcherds (Fields medalist)

https://www.youtube.com/@richarde.borcherds7998

griffzhowl··on Science Communications on YouTube
It's similar to the benefits of attending lectures (or watching them on yt): there are more informal asides and intuition-pumps, and maybe more detailed explanations of intermediate steps in calculations than you usually get in books.

And for videos specifically, it can obviously help understanding in many cases to have animated visualizations

griffzhowl··on If a Meta AI model can read a brain-wide signal, why wouldn't the brain?
Two main reactions:

The Meta paper, as well as other studies which have been interpreted as rudimentary "mind-reading" have measured activity in sensory cortex correlated with direct sensory inputs. There's a fairly close mapping between the initial layers of sensory cortex and patterns of activation in the sense organs. e.g. the optic nerve from each eye projects onto the initial layer of visual cortex in a way that closely preserves the geometry of the retinal image, so it's not that difficult to correlate information in the stimulus and these parts of cortex. Making sense of activity in deeper areas of cortex which isn't as closely correlated with immediate sensory stimulation is a much harder task.

Secondly, the idea seems to be that the brain could make use of a "lossy image" of its own overall functioning. This part seemed very handwavy to me. The brain already contains the information about its own functioning, by definition, so it's not clear to me what functions would be served by the brain's being able to "sense its own magnetic field". It's known that the brain integrates information from distant regions through the patterns of neuronal connectivity. It's not clear that something similar can be done with magnetic fields, because these would mostly affect very nearby areas of the brain, and long-distance effects would be scrambled with all the other activity going on in other parts of the brain.

The idea to look at the effects of the electromagnetic fields in brain functioning is interesting though. The general idea has been around for a long time[0]. The dificult part is making a detailed proposal for how it would actually work and finding experimental evidence for that.

[0] Burr, Northrop (1935) The Electro-Dynamic Theory of Life

https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/394488

griffzhowl··on Lean theorem prover mathlib
You could have a look at the job postings on the Lean zulip chat. They're mainly on the academic side, though

https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/284757-job-...

griffzhowl··on The Rise of Computer Games, Part I: Adventure
There was a Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy text adventure, with writing from Douglas Adams. It's entertaining, but insane what you have to figure out to get the babel fish...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker%27s_Guide_to_th...

griffzhowl··on Apple has locked my Apple ID, and I have no recourse. A plea for help
Yeah, the living in a basement comment was a strange rhetorical exaggeration, as if you have to be feeding and caring for your server 24/7, haha
griffzhowl··on String theory inspires a brilliant, baffling new math proof
I'm not sure what you're disagreeing with tbh. If you look up the thread, my point is that the reason string theory is untestable is not simply that high energies are experimentally inaccessible. Rather, string theory doesn't make any definite predictions for those high energies either. It seems you agree with that?
griffzhowl··on String theory inspires a brilliant, baffling new math proof
I guess I'm not being clear. I don't care about the word "theory". The point is string theory makes no predictions. It's not just inaccessible energies which make it untestable, but the fact that, as a framework, string theory is compatible with a huge range of possible universes.
griffzhowl··on String theory inspires a brilliant, baffling new math proof
Yes, that's what I meant: it's not a physical theory in the sense of making a well-defined set of predictions about the actual world.
griffzhowl··on How the Brain Parses Language
Not from the quanta article. By "story" I just meant the general story of the neural basis for language. What I mentioned in the comment is from the article I linked there
griffzhowl··on String theory inspires a brilliant, baffling new math proof
There's a more basic problem with string theory, which is that it's not a theory. It's a mathematical framework which is compatible with a very wide range of specific physical theories.

About tests of quantum gravity, there have been proposals for feasible tests using gravitationally-induced entanglement protocols:

https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.06036

griffzhowl··on How the Brain Parses Language
One disanalogy between human language use and LLMs is that language evolved to fit the human brain, which was already structured by millions of years of primate social life. This is more or less the reverse situation to a neural network trained on a large text corpus.
griffzhowl··on How the Brain Parses Language
One part of the story I found fascinating is the overlap in infants' brains of the areas involved in tool use and hierarchical syntax. These diverge and specialize in adults. The homologous brain region in primates is involved in motor planning.

It's an interesting hint at the deeper evolutionary origins of language in the ability to plan complex actions, providing a neural basis for the observation that language and action planning have this common structure of an overall goal that can be decomposed into a structure of subgoals, which we see formalized in computer programs too.

This is an older reference (1991) where I first heard about it. there are more recent studies reinforcing various aspects of it but I didn't find one that was as comprehensive

https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X00071235

griffzhowl··on Are We over the "Jaws Effect?"
> 47 unprovoked attacks last year

What about provoked attacks? And who's going out there provoking sharks?

I also like the implication that the provoked attacks are understandable and don't count

griffzhowl··on Are We over the "Jaws Effect?"
That's reminiscent of Livingstone's description of the time he was mauled by a lion:

"The shock produced a stupor similar to that which seems to be felt by a mouse after the first shake of the cat. It caused a sort of dreaminess, in which there was no sense of pain nor feeling of terror, though quite conscious of all that was happening."

https://historyweblog.com/2014/10/lion-attacks-livingstone/

griffzhowl··on Iceland declares ocean-current instability a national security risk
> the first calculations about the greenhouse effect where in 1896!

Even 1824 by Fourier

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_effect#History_of_d...

griffzhowl··on A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science
That sounds like the same circularity, since you'll have to assume numbers exist before proving any statements about them.

Physical objects aren't like that because you can discover that they exist by empirical investigation.

In mathematics the discoveries are about the logical implications of sets of axioms. Some of those axioms contain assertions of existence, like a number 0 in Peano arithmetic or the empty set in set theory, and then you can prove statements about these objects based on the axioms. It's circular to infer from these conclusions that the axioms are true.

What's interesting is why certain axiom systems are so useful and fruitful. Personally I think it's because they evolved that way from our investigations of the physical world, but that's another matter

griffzhowl··on A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science
You could say they exist as concepts, that are necessary to use for some reasoning processes, without having any kind of independent existence.

It's similar for the case of programs or algorithms. We can say that a sorting algorithm exists, or a chess-playing program or whatever, which means we know how to implement the logical process in some physical system, but it doesn't mean that they have some kind of existence which is independent of the physical systems. It's just a way of talking about patterns that can be common to many physical systems

← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →