HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grumbel

1,782 karma · joined April 16, 2015

submissionscomments
grumbel··on Trying to use Bluesky without getting burned again
Mastodon isn't true decentralization to begin with, it's just federation like email, where every user is attached to a server and the server operator holds all the power, while the user holds none. I find that approach a waste of time, as it's just replicating past mistakes verbatim.

On top of that, the whole Fediverse is extremely political. Email providers don't care much what you write or with whom you communicate outside of spam, so it works quite well. Meanwhile Fediverse is blocking people and servers left and right, it's completely unusable unless you follow the group-think on whatever server you are on.

Real decentralization is what Nostr is doing, where serves are just dumb relays, user-ids are public-key pairs and all the intelligence is in the client. BlueSky's AT-protocol should be capable of similar stuff, though in practice is still very much focused around the main BlueSky server.

grumbel··on Egui – An immediate mode GUI written in Rust
Desktop UIs only started adding that around 2000 or so (Gtk2?), it generally hadn't been possible before in the Windows/Linux world. Even today it still doesn't work as well as the Web, as the select ability is limited to a single widget, e.g. you can't copy&paste the complete text of the About box in Gimp in a single go and many other widget with text don't allow text selection at all.

That said, even on the Web it often feels like an afterthought. What text gets selected when you cross over multiple boxes in a layout often feels completely arbitrary, e.g. dragging the mouse to the left will select text at the top.

grumbel··on Why are cancer guidelines stuck in PDFs?
Same reason why datasheets are still PDFs. It's a reliable, long lasting and portable format. And while it's kind of ridiculous that we are basically emulating paper, no other format fills that niche.

It's the niche HTML should be able to fill, since that was its original purpose, but isn't, since all focus over the last 20 or so years has been on everything else, but making HTML a better format for information exchange.

Trivial things like bundling up a complex HTML document into a single file don't have standard solutions. Cookies stop working when you are dealing with file:// URLs and a lot of other really basic stuff just doesn't work or doesn't exist. Instead you get offshot formats like ePUB that are mostly HTML, but not actually supported by most browser.

grumbel··on Veo 2: Our video generation model
I am surprised that the top/right one still shows a cut and switch to a difference scene. I would assume that that's something that could be trivially filtered out of the training data, as those discontinuities don't seem to be useful for either these short 6sec video segments or for getting an understanding of the real world.
grumbel··on CADing and 3D printing like a software engineer
The Fusion360 free-tier has been getting ever more restrictive over time. At the moment it is at:

> users who generate less than $1,000 USD in annual revenue and use for home-based, non-commercial projects only.

Which already makes it unsuitable for any Open Source work. While one might still accept those restrictions for quick one-off projects, those projects are also the ones that FreeCAD can handle fine.

grumbel··on Android XR
Google Daydream is dead, no longer supported by modern phones, the store no longer works and they removed all Daydream specific features from their own apps. Getting a Lenovo Mirage Solo to work is possible, but requires a lot of workarounds, side loading and software downgrades.

The older Google Cardboard on the other side got open sourced and is still somewhat alive, works on modern phones and even the Youtube app still has support for it. It is however not getting any attention from developers, since everybody that cares about VR has long moved on to Quest or given up on VR. Cardboard due to not having controller and limited to 3DOF was a dead end.

grumbel··on The AI reporter that took my old job just got fired
The value in AI podcasts at the moment isn't in replacing human content, but in filling the niches that human content just doesn't cover. Doesn't matter if it's not the best podcast ever, when it's literally the only podcast on this planet discussing the topic you want to listen too.
grumbel··on Relativty: An open-source VR headset for $200
See "Pure IMU-based Positional Tracking is a No-go"[1], a position from an IMU starts to drift in a fraction of a second and than shoots off into infinity. Without an absolute reference there is nothing you can do to stop it and the errors will accumulate. It's not just a little bad, it's completely unusable.

A further complication is that the IMUs you find in phones, especially back when all this was new, weren't very good. So even a plain 3DoF experience would suffer from slow response and yaw-drift from lack of magnetometer, which is why GearVR had an extra IMU in the headset and why Daydream required new certified phones with better IMUs.

3DoF can still be good enough for VR180/360 movies, which don't allow movement to begin with. But as far as gaming is concerned, you really do need 6DoF, as even a bit of leaning forward in a chair will make it instantly obvious that the headset motion and the headset visuals are out of sync.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_q_8d0E3tDk

grumbel··on John Carmack on inlined code (2014)
That's not an improvement, as it screws up the code flow. The point of inline blocks is that you can read the code the same way as it is executed. No surprised that code might be called twice or that a function call could be missed or reordered. Adding real functions causes exactly the indirection that one wanted to avoid in the first place. If the block has no name you know that it will only be executed right where it is written.
grumbel··on Meta Movie Gen
klingai.com

lumalabs.ai

grumbel··on Meta Movie Gen
There are numerous tricks and LORAs to make realistic images without the overpolish you get by default:

* https://www.reddit.com/gallery/1fvs0e1

* https://old.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/1fak0jl/fi...

grumbel··on NixOS is a good server OS, except when it isn't
There is https://search.nixos.org/ and on the command line you can play around with:

$ nix repl

nix-repl> :l <nixpkgs>

nix-repl> {press tab for auto-complete}

grumbel··on Facebook scraped every Australian adult user's public posts to train AI
> then it will be sampled by a computer and instantly recreated at scale.

You don't need to train the AI on the work for that. You don't even need to show the AI the work itself. You can just give the AI a vague description of the work and it is able to replicate something very close to it.

That's something you can try today, hand Claude or ChatGPT an image, let them describe the image, put that description into your favorite image generator. The output is a clean-room-clone of the original. It won't be a photocopy, but it will contain all the significant features that made up the original, even with surprisingly short descriptions of just a 100 words.

Won't be long and you can hand the AI a movie trailer and the AI will build you the rest of the movie from it.

> Why would we embrace this now that a computer can do it

You can't stop it long term. That old "How To Draw an Owl"-meme is reality now. You give the AI some key points and it will fill in all the rest. The issue here isn't so much copyright, but that we'll be so flooded with content that it will be impossible for anybody to stand out. We might be heading towards the death of static content and heading into a world were everything is generated on the fly.

grumbel··on Why VR Games Still Haven't Taken Off
While comfort is an important issue with a lot of low-hanging-fruit solutions (top-straps!!!), it's a hole every serious VR user will mod themselves out of. There are numerous third party solution to make existing headsets more comfortable, be it complete strap replacement, facial interfaces or top straps. Even alternative headsets like the BigScreenBeyond or Xreal that are substantially lighter and smaller exist. The option are out there.

> It's impressive, but it starts to hurt after an hour or so.

The issue is that "impressive" wanes after a few weeks or months, while comfort tends to improve by additional adjustments and customization. What VR is missing is long-term content, the stuff you use VR for after the initial wow-factor has vanished, the stuff that takes advantage of the 360° 3D screen in front of your eyes and the 6DOF controls without just being gimmicky.

That's one issue I think Apple handled much better than Meta. On VisionPro you have full 2D app support, so most of the apps just work. It might sound boring, but VR needs to embrace that kind of boring when it wants to survive long term, since boring stuff is what people do with computers 24/7.

On Meta Quest things are much more of a mess. There is no clear vision for what's the headset is actually good for. You have a few lackluster games here, a few exercise apps there, a "Metaverse" that still feels woefully incomplete, basic 2D app support without Google Play Store, no easy way to watch movies and a whole lot of other half done ideas.

grumbel··on Why VR Games Still Haven't Taken Off
One thing I also miss is being able to just jump from the regular game on a monitor into VR and back. Star Wars: Squadrons is the only game I can think of that even has VR as an in-game option to toggle. Everything else requires a full restart of the game to switch to VR or even the purchase of a separate VR version of the game.

That's something that should have been handled much smoother, especially given the comfort issue that might force people to not play everything in VR. But alas, VR support in regular monitor games is extremely rare to begin with and that area of VR never really got much support.

grumbel··on Why VR Games Still Haven't Taken Off
I think it simply comes down to price and the fractured VR market. Be it Rift CV1, HTC Vive, Index, PSVR2, QuestPro or Quest3, they just straight up put the price too high for the average gamer. $500 or more just doesn't work with technology that is as unfinished as the current VR devices are. Quest2 is the one device that sold well, thanks to it's $300 price tag, though even there Meta couldn't hesitate to mess it up the momentum with a short lived price increase.

The other issue is just the amount of incompatible VR ecosystems out there, Cardboard, Daydream, PSVR1, PSVR2, Rift, Go, Quest are all separate system with little or no compatibility. That means you constantly end up with good content that only a fraction of the VR market can access, which is a huge problem when VR is already short on content.

Finally, VR never managed to integrate with the rest of the gaming world. Ports of regular games into VR were actively discouraged in the early days and only a few of them ever happened. That meant the whole promise of VR allowing you to "step into your games" fell flat very early on. None of your favorite games could be revisited in VR, instead you where stuck with a lot low budget indie tech demos. Lately that has been changing with UEVR, which allows to mod VR support into Unreal Engine games, but that still is just an unofficial hack, not a feature embraced by any of the VR companies.

There is of course also the big "motion sickness" bogeyman in the corner and while that can certainly be an issue, most people just get used to it. I think the efforts to mitigate the issue (don't port games to VR, make everything slow and boring) have done far more damage to VR than they helped, since it simply means we are stuck with a whole lot of games in VR that simply can't compete with what's available in the world of non-VR gaming. That's kind of a big problem when VR was always supposed to be the "next-level" of gaming and yet it feels like a step backwards.

grumbel··on Why VR Games Still Haven't Taken Off
Meta is working on that with their Codec Avatars[1], but since their focus is on affordable self contained VR headsets, and PCVR support is all but abandoned, they'll likely remain R&D experiments for quite a few more years. They just don't have enough compute in their current hardware offering.

Apple with their VisionPro is quite a bit further along and their Persona[2] are available to consumer, though the price tag of the device puts it out of reach for almost everybody.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDxMZ9zjqMs

[2] https://youtu.be/H3PB2zA6Q-c?si=E_OU1WeF4tsqhpTR&t=288

grumbel··on Interviewing Tim Sweeney and Neal Stephenson
What I find especially frustrating with all the Metaverse stuff is that everybody aims for the pie-in-sky solution (VR, realtime 3D worlds, etc.) instead of fixing the main problem with the Internet first: Computers can't talk to each other directly due to NAT.

That's the root of so many issue with the modern Internet, but every "solution" is just more cloud nonsense, instead of addressing the core connectivity issue.

I don't need virtual reality when even just the act of moving a file from one computer to another is already such a dysfunctional mess.

grumbel··on The semantic web is now widely adopted
I don't see how one can have any hope in a Semantic Web ever succeeding when we haven't even managed to get HTML tags for extremely common Internet things: pricetags, comments, units, avatars, usernames, advertisement and so on. Even things like pagination are generally just a bunch of links, not any kind of semantic thing holding multiple documents together (<link rel> exists, but I haven't seen browsers doing anything with it). Take your average website and look at all the <div>s and <span>s and there is a whole lot more low hanging fruit one could turn semantic, but there seems little interest in even trying to.
grumbel··on Magic Wormhole: get things from one computer to another, safely
> scp or rsync or sftp

All of them require an account on the other machine and aren't really suitable for quick transfer one-off file transfer from one computer to another that you don't own.

If I have a direct network connection I tend to go with:

    python3 -m http.server
or

    tar ...| nc
Neither of which is great, but at least you'll find them on many machines already preinstalled.
grumbel··on GIL Become Optional in Python 3.13
It would be nice to have typing in the core language/interpreter, including runtime type errors, instead of this weird add-on approach. I constantly run into situation where the code is fine and mypy complains or the code is broken and mypy says it's fine. It all just feels like one gigantic fragile workaround instead of a proper type system that you can depend on.
grumbel··on The effect of CRTs on pixel art
When it comes to CRT vs modern displays there is also a much simpler issue at play: Modern screens are twice the size of the CRTs we used to have. If a game looks too pixelated on a modern display, simply try shrinking the screen size. That fixes the majority of issue, all without going through the trouble of trying to emulate esoteric CRT artifacts. A SNES game running in 256x224 was never meant to be run on a 70" TV.
grumbel··on Large Enough
GPT4o already does that, for problems involving math it will write small Python programs to handle the calculations instead of doing it with the LLM itself.
grumbel··on AI's $600B Question
Just because it's impactful doesn't mean it's going to make much money. Take audiobooks for example, the market is valued at around $5 billion. In the very near future audiobooks will be created with AI. Does that mean anybody is making billions with those AI audiobooks? I don't think so. The value of audiobook will go towards $0 and audiobooks as a product category will completely disappear. Audiobooks will simply be the text2speech feature of your eBook reader.

Similar stuff will happen with a lot of other content, things that used to be costly will become very cheap. And then what? The amount of books people can consume doesn't scale into infinity. Their entertainment needs will be served by auto-generated AI content. Even the books themselves will be written by AI sooner or later.

Advertising industry might also start hurting badly, as while they will certainly try getting ads into AI content, users will have AI at home to filter it out. A lot of classic tricks and dark pattern to manipulate the user behavior will no longer work, since the user has a little AI helper to protect them from those tricks.

I don't doubt that the impact of AI will be gigantic, but a lot of AI produced content won't be worth anything, since it's so easy to create for everybody. And there isn't much of a moat either, since new models with better capabilities pop up all the time from different companies. Classic lock-in is also not really usable anymore, as AI can effortlessly translate between different APIs and user-interfaces.

grumbel··on Flags Are Not Languages
That's really the core of the issue. Language switching is such a common thing that it should be part of Web infrastructure itself, not the individual Website, and it sort of is. But most Websites ignore those preferences and browsers have those settings hidden so deep away that no user will even be aware of them.

Having a little icon in your browser, not the Website, to switch language would make this issue largely go away. What symbol you use in the end doesn't really matter, the issue is that every site does it a little differently.

grumbel··on John Carmack on Meta Horizon OS
Most of the games are just tech demos without any depths or length. Many of the goods ones aren't even on Quest, but on PC. There is also no steady stream of new high quality content, every year or two something interesting comes out and then nothing for months. Ports of existing 2D games or franchises into VR are extremely rare. 3D and VR movies are still largely ignored by Meta as well. The promised "Metaverse" is nowhere to be seen.

The whole thing is just a bit "meh". If you dig deep enough, you can find some interesting stuff, but it feels so far less interesting than it could be.

Just look back at all the stuff that happened back when Oculus was still in charge, we had Oculus Medium and Quill for content creation, we had Oculus Story Studios, we had numerous good games released in short order and so on. It felt like VR was expanding, the last few years in contrast it felt like the thing was just shrinking down. And a lot of that was not by accident, but Meta's conscious effort to turn VR into "Metaverse" and move away from games. Which in turn was a flop, so Quest is back doing games, but it all feels very half-hearted.

VR has been hyped up since the 90s and when you look at what Quest delivers today, 35 later, it just doesn't feel like it's actually delivering on the potential of VR.

grumbel··on John Carmack on Meta Horizon OS
It doesn't matter if it cost $0 when it just ends up collecting dust. Quest2 go for just $200, that's already plenty of cheap for pretty much everybody. It's the whole software and content landscape that still isn't very compelling. Worse yet, they even do a terrible job of highlighting all the good stuff you actually can do in VR. They also do a bad job at bringing content into VR that could easily take advantage of it, e.g. 3D movies, porting old games into VR, etc.

As for ads, so far the Quest is still ad free.

grumbel··on Zooming User Interface (ZUI)
It works with maps since they are fundamentally spatial, every country has its fixed position on the globe which doesn't change. With most other data there is no intuitive way to map the data into a 2D space and it gets even worse when that data frequently changes, completely changing whatever layout scheme you might have come up with.

A little bit of zooming can still work great when you have a very limited item count, e.g. Mission Control on MacOS to manage windows or thumbnail view of tabs in some browsers. But as core UI for the whole OS it gets quite confusing when you don't really have an intuitive understanding of where things should be.

grumbel··on AI consciousness is inevitable: A theoretical computer science perspective
The core of consciousness, building in internal model of the external world, is necessary if you want to do any kind of complex interaction with the world. Otherwise you wouldn't have any way to keep track of what's happening (e.g. no object permanence).

All the stuff related to the self is however optional, especially when it comes to AI where the self (bunch of GPUs in a datacenter) doesn't even exist in the problem space the AI is thinking about.

grumbel··on GNU Stow needs a co-maintainer
That's not right either. The --prefix needs to be /usr/local or /usr/local/stow/package-1.0, otherwise many packages won't find their own files. The prefix path will get compiled into the binary or configuration for a lot of packages, it's not just an install time thing.

Using --prefix=/usr/local/stow/package-1.0 is problematic whenever you have a package with plugins, themes or other stuff, as those go to /usr/local/share/package/... while the app is looking in /usr/local/stow/package-1.0/share/package/

Using DESTDIR and manually removing the usr/local from the directory tree is what I would consider the correct way, even if a bit annoying.

Either way, these days I would just recommend to use Nix instead, which is a much more complete solution for what stow tries to do.

← PreviousPage 7 of 22Next →