HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gruseom

30,328 karma · joined August 18, 2007

submissionscomments
gruseom··on Girls and Software
How do you get kids modding Minecraft? I suggested this a little while ago for a kid in my brother-in-law's Grade 8 class, but then regretted it because the tools for doing it seemed inaccessible to beginners.
gruseom··on Girls and Software
That seems uncharitable. "Born in childhood" is not a quality like the others. "A child's sense of play" might be.
gruseom··on Girls and Software
To say that a 12-year-old farm girl was in a "privileged position" with respect to computers strikes me as absurd.
gruseom··on Girls and Software
Seems to me the author vividly conveys what she means by "hacker" in the very paragraph you quoted:

  technologist
  addiction
  solving puzzles
  building things
  "victory!" moment
  impose will on electronics
These things are done and felt for their own sake and not as a means to an end, like a paycheck. Perhaps that's the main difference.
gruseom··on How I Hacked My Husband's Programming Addiction
If your goal is to pursue the truth and make correct decisions, you must not pay any heed whatsoever to the emotions

This presupposes that the emotions cannot be a source of true information.

gruseom··on The Rise of Worse is Better
I've never been able to make sense of the article either, and I've tried many times. I think it boils down to its title, which is just the right mix of vague and catchy to be optimal for getting repeated. The article itself is merely the title's host organism.
gruseom··on Silicon Valley's 'bro culture' locks out many minorities
One hears that argument, but I think it's shallow. People aren't cogs—some work better together than others. It isn't just about who you're comfortable around. Lou Reed and John Cale, for example, were not comfortable around each other. That's why I said "work well together": the work is what matters, not comfort.
gruseom··on Silicon Valley's 'bro culture' locks out many minorities
The word "culture" doesn't mean the same thing in "bro culture" vs. "culture fit".

To me, "culture fit" is another way of saying "chemistry". It means that people work well together, and is what you want if you are forming a band, say, or any other creative endeavour.

gruseom··on Imitate. We are imperfect mirrors
The "great artists steal" line comes not from Picasso but from T.S. Eliot. Lots of previous discussion about this:

https://hn.algolia.com/?q=picasso+eliot#!/comment/forever/0/... eliot

The line that elliots (not to be confused with T.S. Eliot!) quoted turns out to be authentic, though—or at least there's some evidence for it:

http://books.google.com/books?id=OJTKZeXaUvkC&lpg=PA53&dq=%2...

gruseom··on Ask HN: What do you think about our last HN Search update?
Impressive work in so short a time. I'm relieved that you guys are this responsive to the community. You've already addressed one of my personal concerns and hopefully the other (sort by date) soon. Here's some more feedback.

I think the defaults should be "all" (not story) and "forever" (not past week). I searched for something that I knew existed and when it didn't come up, my first thought was that the search was broken. Better to show everything at first and let the user decide how to narrow it down if they want to.

I think you'd be better off if the design looked like HN itself, especially the comment rendering. Not that what you've got is bad, but the user is almost always going to go from HN to search and back to HN. Any context switch is already a speed bump, and visual changes, which take time and mental energy to process, add to that jolt. Anything you can to do minimize these cognitive hurdles will serve the #1 goal, which is to get the reader the info they're looking for with minimum overhead. In this respect, the old HN Search is more usable, precisely for being unoriginal.

Thus, if I were you, I would drop the thumbnail pictures of the stories (it's cool that you can do it, but they don't really add anything and are distracting); would not include the story info with each coment (rather, I would do just like HN does and have a bit of text that says "| on: the-story-title-linked-here"), would make the text rendering look much like HN's, and would follow HN's lead in having a text- and information-density-centric design.

I'm not saying that HN's design is the global optimum (though it is better than most attempts to improve on it), but rather that HN search is an extension of HN and therefore not the place to innovate on its design. You're in a counterintuitive position for a startup with this project, since calling too much attention to yourself in this context is bad. You want to be unobtrusive and have the thing just work; the HN community is smart enough to figure out who you are from that and like you better for it. (That said, you shouldn't obliterate yourselves. For example, I like the visual cues that say "Page 1 of 10, got 237 results in 3 ms" and "1,244,896 stories and 5,289,181 comments indexed". They are unobtrusive and impressive.)

Lastly, a bug in Chrome: if I search for something, scroll to the bottom, click on "about", then hit the back button, the original results page freezes (i.e. refuses to scroll).

gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
IIRC, he deliberately wrote it to make it hard to read. Out of curiosity, why did you try to read it?
gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
There's no doubt that many of these books are standins for personal influence. It's sort of a convention for lists like that.
gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
That's a good observation. Seymour-Smith was (I seem to recall) a fan, and he certainly would have been around lots of people who were into that work. On the other hand, from Seymour-Smith's perspective, which was literary- and 20th century-centric, Gurdjieff may well belong on the list. He really did have a surprising influence on literary and artistic circles. His movement was fascinating and I don't think it has been properly studied or understood; all the good writing about it is by followers. But yes, surely nowhere near Marx or Mao.
gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
That was it! It was a magical place. Thank you.
gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
Well the site is just ripping off the list from one of Seymour-Smith's books, which would certainly have given reasons. I don't think respect for the original is a high priority there.
gruseom··on My Books of 2013
What are some of your notes about Marshall?
gruseom··on The Most Influential Books Ever Written (2010)
I noticed that this list was made by Martin Seymour-Smith. He was an English poet and critic whose masterpiece was called Guide to Modern World Literature. It is a monster of a book that covers hundreds (thousands?) of writers, a tour de force that is nearly impossible to believe was put together by one person. I used to spend hours poring over it in the reference section of the library. For such an encyclopedia, it's remarkable how idiosyncratic and addictive it is. He makes no attempt to be balanced or standard about anything; he just gives his personal views—for example he pooh-poohs Eliot and says that the greatest poet of the 20th century was César Vallejo. So, unlike most reference works, it's wonderfully intimate. It's like having an uncle who knows everything and will happily tell you all about anyone you name.

Sometimes it's even perverse, as he loves nothing better than to champion the obscure and take the famous and well-established down a peg. So I suppose it's fitting that basically no one has heard of his work.

I discovered him years ago on a long bus trip with a layover in Salt Lake City, where I went to a used bookstore. His book--actually an earlier one called "Who's Who in 20th Century Literature", smaller but still massive--was on a shelf in the basement of the store. I looked someone up in it and thought "this is interesting", sat on the floor and looked someone else up, and then another and so on. Hours later I woke up and realized that I was sitting on the basement floor of a bookstore in a strange city. I remember I had to run to the bus station and barely made it. That book, and then later the astonishing one I described above, became my companions for years, the sort of thing where the author is your mentor and friend and you feel vividly that you know him. Thank you Martin Seymour-Smith!

gruseom··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
You have a good point. I rewrote my comment to make fewer assumptions.
gruseom··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I fear I am dismissing it too quickly, probably because of gender troll dread syndrome.

If it works, it will be useful.

gruseom··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I thought it did from reading the blog post. Is that wrong? If so, I'll delete my comment.
gruseom··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
A play on words is ok, as long as it's not a running joke that keeps coming up. That's distracting.

The key to the Unix joke name genre is that the jokes are encoded laconically into the name and only the name (e.g. "less") and then have the good taste to immediately expire. They don't get old because they don't overstay their welcome.

Edit: I reworded this to be less judgmental.

gruseom··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I've often wished for something like this. Most of us learn by example.

I fear that the humor in it, much as I like humor, is a mistake. First, it comes across as a gender troll. Any technical attention the tool receives will be smothered by that avalanche. (Exhibit A: this thread.) More importantly, it impedes how the tool needs to work: get to the point immediately and cut everything else. Man pages may be Byzantine, but they do this well.

If I need examples for curl, examples for curl are all I want to see. They should be laid out readably and minimally (a nontrivial design problem). The last thing I want is a joke repeated everywhere. I'd say the same about the upvoting and downvoting stuff that appears in there: it's extraneous and distracting.

When I'm stuck on a shell command, it's usually because I have a specific task I'm trying to do. All I want is for the light bulb in my head to switch on so I can go "Oh I get it!" and go off to do the task. The best way is to see an example that's close enough to what I'm trying to do that it's like a magnet that attracts my specific task and snaps it in place. That's why I like the idea of this tool. It should focus on getting the user to that moment as quickly as possible.

gruseom··on HN Search Updated
I love how fast it is! Two things I rely on heavily with the old hnsearch are (a) restrict to stories or comments, and (b) sort by date (most recent first). Can you please do those? Especially the second one.
gruseom··on Lisp: More is less
Uh, I think maybe I'd better just quit while I'm behind.
gruseom··on San Francisco Is Eating Itself
Perhaps because there's such a clear symmetry with public transport.

Symbolism has its own logic, and the thing that becomes emblematic usually is not the most important one physically or rationally.

gruseom··on Lisp: More is less
Not sure what your point is? I'd be happy to be wrong here.
gruseom··on What Happens When the Poor Receive a Stipend?
the psychological and social difference between receiving money from a source which a population would consider to be 'theirs' cannot be overstated

It can be overstated; you've overstated it. In contrast to the careful research described in the article, you've just made a bunch of stuff up. Your rush to assume race as the dominant factor is another example.

gruseom··on Lisp: More is less
Pet peeve, sorry, but it irritates me that Clojure people act like this guilty-until-proven-innocent policy about macros is somehow original. It has been standard advice for decades. Chapter 8 of On Lisp (1994) is called "When to Use Macros" and its first section is "When Nothing Else Will Do":

By default we should use functions: it is inelegant to use a macro where a function would do. We should use macros only when they bring us some specific advantage.

I understand from a language marketing point of view why someone might say, "Oh, those other Lisps made wild and crazy use of macros. It was really bad! But we are enlightened and have restricted them." But it's a bogus way of playing to a bogus criticism. It would be better to just say that there's a tradition of how to use macros correctly.

gruseom··on Lisp: More is less
This post repeats two memes that float around the programming language space. One is: "it's so powerful that it's bad". The other is: "it's ok, but not for large projects". I don't think I've ever seen any evidence attached to either. (If the OP contains any, I missed it.) But they're the sort of things that sound plausible and have more gravitas than "Here are my current preferences", so they get repeated, and no doubt the more they get repeated, the more they get repeated.

When I say "evidence" I'm not asking for formal studies; that's too high a bar for our field. But one can at least ask to hear about specific real-world experience.

Of the two arguments, the "too-powerful" one has the disadvantage of being prima facie absurd, so I think the "large-project" one is more harmful. So, where are the large Clojure and Common Lisp projects that have been harmed by this alleged language weakness? Let's find some practitioners who actually ran into this.

For what it's worth, I haven't. Since the best thing for a large project is not to be so large in the first place, applying language constructs to make codebases smaller is a great strength when the language lets you do it—and Lisp lets you do it.

Edit: [deleted off-topic bit]

gruseom··on K, by Arthur Whitney (2005)
http://coding-is-like-cooking.info/2013/09/an-introduction-t....

Thanks, I enjoyed that article. It gives a vivid picture of the gap between the array languages niche and mainstream programming culture.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →