"This is a change so obviously sensible [...] that no other country has made it."
The Economist doesn't normally bust loose like that. (Edit: or so I thought.)
30,328 karma · joined August 18, 2007
"This is a change so obviously sensible [...] that no other country has made it."
The Economist doesn't normally bust loose like that. (Edit: or so I thought.)
The key concept here is that of partner. I like that word, but would like to know exactly what it means in such a structure. How, besides having high status, do partners differ from non-partners? How are they compensated? What sort of equity do they get?
The whole "distinguish hacker from cracker" thing has always seemed to me a classic effort to control language to suit an agenda. Such things are doomed to fail and rightly so. But I may be reading that wrong, as I've never looked into the history of it (correction is welcome).
Gandhi never said the "first they ignore you" thing. It's been traced back to a speech by a union activist in 1912 or so. Lots of previous discussion about this on HN.
People were upset about different things—instead of Google buses, lofts being converted into luxury condos and so on—but the emotions and the discourse were much the same. I remember a startup called Bigstep that got into hot water because they took over office space from a community org or something that couldn't afford the rent any more [2]. There was a lot of talk about the Latino community being displaced by dotcom types, about Marina yuppies taking over the nightlife—at places like Blowfish Sushi, plus a somehow slightly creepy experiment called Circadia [3] that Starbucks ran at Bryant and Mariposa, which was an emblem of dotcom excess. It's just an ordinary Starbucks now.
I haven't noticed any change in how "average" people feel about tech, except perhaps that its status has gone up.
One thing that actually has changed from the dotcom bubble to now is the massive shift of power away from VCs and MBAs towards founders and engineers. (Which is kind of ironic since it contradicts almost everything you say about the industry.) Investors have lost power relative to founders and managers have lost power relative to programmers. Both of those trends have been going on for a long time, but have been accelerating. They seem to me to be good trends, arguably even for the investors and managers.
Curiously, this shift is visible in the cultural ripples around the dotcoms then vs. the startups now. The dotcom bubble produced a lot of ersatz culture that matched its mostly ersatz startups. The parts of it that I saw were douchey and suity; a place like Circadia, which I mentioned above, was an expression of that. It was full of people who weren't actually working on anything. The decor was lavish, but the coffee and food (not that I could afford the food) were mediocre. Compare that to a place like Sightglass now, where the coffee is excellent and most people are working on stuff. Sure they're hipsters, but it's still a crowd I'd rather be around than the one that used to make me squirm back then; and I'm a dyed-in-the-wool programmer type who hasn't much changed.
[1] http://foundsf.org/index.php?title=Mission_Yuppie_Eradicatio.... Also http://www.uncanny.net/~wetzel/macchron.htm and http://www.wired.com/techbiz/media/news/2000/03/35154, and there's lots more where those came from.
[2] Googling this turned up http://blog.doubledutch.me/2012/03/the-rise-of-the-mission-s... which includes some details about anti-dotcom protests in from 1999-2000.
[3] https://www.salon.com/1999/01/21/feature_238/. I sometimes worked on my thesis there because they had internet. Most of their tech-oriented image was silly, though. The place was all pretense.
That directly contradicts how SICP teaches it:
Our computational model of a circuit will be composed of objects that correspond to the elementary components from which the circuit is constructed. (p. 273, 2nd ed.)
Elsewhere they say:
If we have been successful in our system organization, then to add a new feature or debug an old one we will have to work on only a localized part of the system. (p. 217)
... which sounds a lot like the benefits you deny. Do you really think SICP is wrong to teach this way? I don't.
I quoted a more general passage where they introduce object modeling here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6910292. But it seems striking that you would have brought up circuit simulation as when not to do object modeling, as it is the very domain they use to illustrate the strength of the approach.
I hear this from time to time—it seems bizarre. Representing real-world things as objects is a fine design approach for many problems and is well worth teaching. Where on earth did the idea that it isn't get started?
SICP, a classic of programming pedagogy if ever there was one, has this to say:
One powerful design strategy, which is particularly appropriate to the construction of programs for modeling physical systems, is to base the structure of our programs on the structure of the system being modeled. For each object in the system, we construct a corresponding computational object. For each system action, we define a symbolic operation in our computational model. (p. 217, 2nd ed.)
It's true that by "object" they mean something more general than OO. But that doesn't change the basic design approach.
It's also true that they are careful to teach more primitive concepts first, so what they do is compatible with the OP's point. But there's a reason why the above passage on real-world representations appears immediately after they mention modularity.
Edit: I'm afraid the "historical perspective" you supply is not very historical. The decline of Freudianism began long before the 1980s, and pharmaceutical psychiatry has a much longer history than you imply. The antipsychotics that Steingard writes about were discovered about 60 years ago—something you might have learned from the fifth paragraph of her article. It is highly unlikely that she was trained as a Freudian; she says she spent 20 years routinely prescribing antipsychotics.
Your other objection has a simple answer too: as Westerners it behooves us to get our own house in order. Suppose I told you "Our house is a mess, let's clean it up," and you became indignant and said, "Where are all the pithy insights about the neighbor down the street? Their living room is a pig sty!" That would be an absurd misdirection.
It's true that Klein obliged the Toronto stereotype of the redneck Albertan (and, shrewd politician that he was, used it to score points with his base). That's one reason it's so poetically fitting that you all elected Rush Limbaugh crossed with Marion Barry.
But why the WSJ? Maybe it's a better way to troll Canadians to get an article like this in the US press?
I live in what is arguably the most Americany of Canadian cities, and even here this idea isn't even a fringe position. I vaguely remember hearing years ago that some people had once proposed it, but it wasn't considered polite to mention who they were. If it ever turned into a political movement in Canada it would meet with overwhelming resistance. It's an identity thing.
I fear that many arguments about incentive and disincentive are just morality tales anyway, based on beliefs about human nature. It's easy to imagine opposite stories. Maybe there will be a social incentive to work. Maybe there won't be enough jobs for everyone anyway. Maybe the disincentive to work will make wages go high enough that they become an incentive to work again. Maybe the disincentive to do menial jobs will free up incentive to do creative things, a net win for society.
It's easy to make these things up, and everyone mostly does it based on whether they already like or dislike an idea. (I rather like this one. Megan Mcardle presumably doesn't.) But do we have a good way to decide between them?
But if you means-test it to control the cost, or try to tax most of the benefits back for people who aren’t low-income, you rapidly lose the efficiency gains and start creating some pretty powerful disincentives to work.
Why? I can see how "means-test" might imply bureaucracy and thus inefficiency, but what's wrong with using tax policy for this? It seems like an obvious way to ensure that people who don't need the money don't get it, and no more inefficient as everyone has to fill out their taxes anyway.
Come to think of it, isn't that so obvious that the debate ought to start there, rather than end there? Otherwise the objections start to seem rather straw-man.
In a worst-case scenario for the high-tech industry, if the Supreme Court upholds the ruling it could invalidate many existing software patents or at least make them more difficult to defend in lawsuits.
One wishes there was not such ignorance at the Associated Press.