HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gtsop

917 karma · joined March 26, 2020

submissionscomments
gtsop··on Is software abstraction killing civilization? (2021)
Which points do you think the author has missed?
gtsop··on Is software abstraction killing civilization? (2021)
It is unfortunate that someone needs to pick apart a flawed thesis in such detail (as the author did with Blow). The pure empiricist is equaly as detached from reality as the pure theorist, and as such Blow is making up arguments just because they fit his experience, cherry picking examples that fit his rants and promoting the exception to be the rule.
gtsop··on 'Capitalism is dead. Now we have something much worse (2023)
Ok so the answer to my question of where you got all that is: Zizek?

You are reading marxism through the distorting eye of a middleman. Marxism, as you said, is a wider context than diamat, but not a different one. As you said, dialectical meterialism is the philosophy, the world view, which informs the subsequent aspects of marxism, that is socialism/communism and all the political aspects around it. To say that marxism has a static view on anything IS to say that diamat has a static view on anything because diamat is the "algorithm" of marxism.

> Under Marxism, if you were born as a a worker proletariat you remain a proletariat, everything else is structured around this overdetermination.

Where did you get this? Zizek? It is a different thing to say that "chances are you will remain a proletariat" than to say "it is impossible to change class, therefore you will remain a proletariat". The fist is true, the latter is false.

gtsop··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45 (1955)
The purpose of a protest in general should not be to affect the people in power, it should be for enpowering and bonding the people to further enact post-protest. A moralle boost, a conversation starter, an ignition to call more people to action. Having sayd that, a very successfull protest does affect the upper ones, only temprorarily and tactically. A policy maker will still want to make X move, but ever so slightly delay it or figure out a differnt narrative to bring it back some time later.
gtsop··on America desperately needs more air traffic controllers
Of course there is a way to make it less burdensome, exactly everything you listed. It's just that it is cheaper to take the risk to crash a few people here and there than do all that.
gtsop··on America desperately needs more air traffic controllers
> The fact that some people have an irrational fear of flying does not justify that irrational fear dictating policy

Go tell that to the casualties. Oh wait, you can't. Which part of them being dead is irrational exactly?

gtsop··on America desperately needs more air traffic controllers
If you don't have air traffic controllers, the air traffic won't be controlled... who knew?
gtsop··on Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”
I don't buy the switch speculation. Since we have zero info it sounds too arbitrary.
gtsop··on Our channel on YouTube has been deleted due to “spam and deceptive policies”
Why hire and pay actual humans to moderate and review false takedowns when you can have the free labor of other community platforms (like twitter, hn, reddit) organically raise only the high impact support tickets for you? It is literally jira, but free, IQ 1000
gtsop··on 'Capitalism is dead. Now we have something much worse (2023)
> The marxist perspective for example based in isolation and collectivism, with the assumptions of the static unchanging individual.

Maybe i'm reading the synatx wrong here, but if you are implying that marxism has a static unchaning view of the individual then this is the complete opposite of marxism. Dialectial materialsim (marxism) has the never ending change (movement) of everything in it's very core of it's philosophical understanding. There is literally nothing more distilled for a marxist that everything in the universe changes, let alone the individual.

Not sure how you arrived at that rationale.

gtsop··on 'Capitalism is dead. Now we have something much worse (2023)
> and believing communism is a better system are not mutually exclusive. Are they?

Mathematically speaking, no they are not. Politically speaking, yes they are. It is a different thing to have made such an analysis and it is a different thing to use it as your main political argument for reform. But this discussion buys into the argument that he is even pro-communist (which is what he sells) when he clearly isn't if you look at his concrete political actions. Especially when he was a prime minister.

gtsop··on 'Capitalism is dead. Now we have something much worse (2023)
It is subtextual, but also emergent in his overall political stance. His argument is that there has been a negative shift in the economy because capitalism died and technofeudalism took it's place. It is inherent in that stance that one sees the old state of afairs as better. Varoufakis will never state this outloud as clear as i state it here, but you can read his political party programme (mera25) to validate yourself that his polotical proposals are very clearly implemented witihin the capitalist economy without even hint of socialism or communism.

> One can observe a transition without taking sides, can they?

One can, he cant. He was a prime minister and has been a party leader with concrete political views and policies for many years

gtsop··on 'Capitalism is dead. Now we have something much worse (2023)
Varoufakis: The master of muddying waters. On day 1 he says he is a communist, on day 2 he seds tears because we now live in the age of technofeudalism, poor proper capitalism has been sidelined. He wants to relive the good old days of proper capitalism (lol?). He is a marxist, he is a postmarxist, he is a soscialist, he is a democrat, he is a communist, he is an anarchist, he is a pro-capitalist, he is an anti-capitalist, he is a pro-anti-anti-pro-capitalist and anti-pro-anti-communist, he is a reformist, he is a revolutionary, and when you are everything, then you are really nothing, or much better, you are trully a clown
gtsop··on Doom running on Apple Lightning to HDMI dongle [video]
i don't get it
gtsop··on DeepSeek-R1: Incentivizing Reasoning Capability in LLMs via RL
Meanwhile, everytime I try to deeply interact with an LLM as a side companion to my projects I always end up in a toxic conversation triggered by the fact that they simply can't follow instructions after a point. I don't even care if they don't have thr answer, i would much rather get an "sorry i don't know" than a haluciation or an irrelevant wall of text. For me, the progress will be there, in following my thought process, not knowing more.
gtsop··on The State of Vim
I still use a bloated version of vim for my day job, since it involves huge react+ts apps. But i slowly build up a clean vimrc while writting my pet projects
gtsop··on The State of Vim
I went back and forth quite a lot until i decided to stick to vim. The reason being that I want to gain deep knowledge of my editor instead of depending on a gazillion plugins that occasionally break. Now, I understand this is something you can do with both vim and neovim, however the documentation of neovim is littered with both the vim docs and the new lua docs, and there is a vibe of "you already know all of vim, here is the lua equivalent", which made it very inaccessible to me. I decided I'll spend the time in the more simple editor of the two and maybe reevaluate this decision again in 3-4 years
gtsop··on Bunster: Compile bash scripts to self contained executables
It is a very interesting technical feat to be able to do that... but should you do it?

My gut feeling says no. Unless I am missing something.

gtsop··on 0-click deanonymization attack targeting Signal, Discord, other platforms
I find genius being 15 and being in a state to find this issue and write this report. For my understanding there is a ton of context and knowledge packed in this write-up which i can't possibly imagine myself being able to grasp it at the age of 15. That is not to say it's not possible, but it goes to say it is very hard, that's why i characterise it as genius
gtsop··on 0-click deanonymization attack targeting Signal, Discord, other platforms
Interesting you touched on his age. I got extremely curious, why did the OP did such a flex?(assumming they are telling the truth). The first sentence is such a weird brag that it felt suspicious. The report is highly technical and extremely well written. We're either dealing with a pure genious or a fraud. But why would a genious flex? Doesn't make sense.
gtsop··on 0-click deanonymization attack targeting Signal, Discord, other platforms
I believe most people (me included) dismiss the OP's claimed severity, as if it is being oversold. I see a balance of opinions saying "great find, but not as critical as claimed" so they don't seem dismissive. It is important to correctly classify the severity of issues. Proof of whereabouts is not deanonymization, especially when the abouts are so loose
gtsop··on Thoughts on a month with Devin
I'm using it to orient me when tackling something new. For instance, the other day i was making a web driver client in shell and i asked it something apong the lines of "is there an http endpoint to the webdriver to get the class name of an element?"

These are the sort of questions i mostly do. "What is the best practice to read output from a device file in C", "Is there a cli tool to find dead typescript interface fields?"

gtsop··on Thoughts on a Month with Devin
o1 is way to slow to keep up with my flow of thinking in order to be of any help in the scenario i am describing
gtsop··on Thoughts on a Month with Devin
Exactly this. At first started verbally abusing it untill it conformed, but i quickly realised that after the context gets very long it simply discards former instructions and abusing. So i get frustrated, toxic AND don't get my job done
gtsop··on Thoughts on a month with Devin
Honestly, i have been bitten so many times by LLM hallucinations when I work in parallel with the LLM, I wouldn't trust it autonomously running anything at all. If you have tried to use imaginary APIs, imaginary configuration and imaginary cli arguments, you know what I mean
gtsop··on WordPress Is in Trouble
This argument can't hold, how do you know rails isn't going to flip, how do you know linux won't flip. How do you know vim won't flip? I'm sure you have tens if nit hundreds of technologies in your stack that are open source and you never imagined they were going to flip. I have rearly used wp for clients, but i was never under the impression it could go sideways just like most stable software i use.
gtsop··on WordPress Is in Trouble
Hugo is by no stretch of the imagination a drop in replacement for wordpress in my understanding. I understand the average joe uses wordpress for the UI and huge ecosystem, rather than it's technical capabilities (there are a million cms). Yes, technically speaking there is nothing preventing you from reimplementing everything in hugo, nothing except many months of labor

Said differently, the person who will successfully and painlessly migrate wordpress to hugo is not an average case, but a minority.

gtsop··on Fascists and Rakes (2014)
Significantly smoothening the definition of fascist.
gtsop··on Ask HN: Was GitHub responsible for today's high Skill Obsolescence Rate?
No, it's not Github's fault.

If you grasp the root force that is driving this constant release of new tech and new libraries you will be able to escape the hustle of keeping up with it.

Parameter 1: Software and web development is historically very young. In this context it is very natural that humanity has to do some trial amd error to figure it out. For instance, operating systems programming has matured more since it has had many nore decades to grow than web app development.

Parameter 2: Web development has grown to be very highly abstracted. Abstraction, by definition, hides lower level knowledge. When a developer learns to code using the highest level of abstractions available (eg react, next) then they haven't grasped the basics of the platform. This means that 1) they do not trully grasp what problem react or Next actually solve 2) when a technical problem arises, they only think of the solution only within the context of that abstraction (releasing even more abstracted sister libraries)

Parameter 3: Libraries are built to solve problem based on some assumptions. As technology progresses, these assumptions keep changing. This leads to akward evolution in some libraries to address yhe changing assumptions or the creation of new libraries that leverage the new assumptions. For instance check how vite has been built on top of a modern javascript stack that didn't exist when webpack came out.

Put all these together and you have an exploding coctail of change as you described it. What should you do?

Basics - Basics - Basics

The more you try to understand the base platform, the more you will understand it's progress, the reason libraries exist, you will judge them better on whether they do a good job or not. Then, "knowing" a new library will be a matter of reading it's docs and saying to your employer "Yeah, it's fine, I have played with it, not super experiemced but i can handle it and will learn it pretty quick". I always learn new libs on the job, never in my free time.

In my free time (and i suggest it for you) read the rfcs. Read http rfc, read html spec, read C, read the js apis, etc, etc

gtsop··on MAGA opponents of Elon Musk claim he stripped them of their X badges
"Free-speech absolutist" supporting far-right in German elections [1], suppressing (specific) far-right arguments in his own country [2].

I guess he is an "absolutist" as long as you absolutely agree with his political interests.

[1] https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1869986946031988780

[2] https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1872860577057448306

← PreviousPage 5 of 18Next →