917 karma · joined March 26, 2020
You are reading marxism through the distorting eye of a middleman. Marxism, as you said, is a wider context than diamat, but not a different one. As you said, dialectical meterialism is the philosophy, the world view, which informs the subsequent aspects of marxism, that is socialism/communism and all the political aspects around it. To say that marxism has a static view on anything IS to say that diamat has a static view on anything because diamat is the "algorithm" of marxism.
> Under Marxism, if you were born as a a worker proletariat you remain a proletariat, everything else is structured around this overdetermination.
Where did you get this? Zizek? It is a different thing to say that "chances are you will remain a proletariat" than to say "it is impossible to change class, therefore you will remain a proletariat". The fist is true, the latter is false.
Go tell that to the casualties. Oh wait, you can't. Which part of them being dead is irrational exactly?
Maybe i'm reading the synatx wrong here, but if you are implying that marxism has a static unchaning view of the individual then this is the complete opposite of marxism. Dialectial materialsim (marxism) has the never ending change (movement) of everything in it's very core of it's philosophical understanding. There is literally nothing more distilled for a marxist that everything in the universe changes, let alone the individual.
Not sure how you arrived at that rationale.
Mathematically speaking, no they are not. Politically speaking, yes they are. It is a different thing to have made such an analysis and it is a different thing to use it as your main political argument for reform. But this discussion buys into the argument that he is even pro-communist (which is what he sells) when he clearly isn't if you look at his concrete political actions. Especially when he was a prime minister.
> One can observe a transition without taking sides, can they?
One can, he cant. He was a prime minister and has been a party leader with concrete political views and policies for many years
My gut feeling says no. Unless I am missing something.
These are the sort of questions i mostly do. "What is the best practice to read output from a device file in C", "Is there a cli tool to find dead typescript interface fields?"
Said differently, the person who will successfully and painlessly migrate wordpress to hugo is not an average case, but a minority.
If you grasp the root force that is driving this constant release of new tech and new libraries you will be able to escape the hustle of keeping up with it.
Parameter 1: Software and web development is historically very young. In this context it is very natural that humanity has to do some trial amd error to figure it out. For instance, operating systems programming has matured more since it has had many nore decades to grow than web app development.
Parameter 2: Web development has grown to be very highly abstracted. Abstraction, by definition, hides lower level knowledge. When a developer learns to code using the highest level of abstractions available (eg react, next) then they haven't grasped the basics of the platform. This means that 1) they do not trully grasp what problem react or Next actually solve 2) when a technical problem arises, they only think of the solution only within the context of that abstraction (releasing even more abstracted sister libraries)
Parameter 3: Libraries are built to solve problem based on some assumptions. As technology progresses, these assumptions keep changing. This leads to akward evolution in some libraries to address yhe changing assumptions or the creation of new libraries that leverage the new assumptions. For instance check how vite has been built on top of a modern javascript stack that didn't exist when webpack came out.
Put all these together and you have an exploding coctail of change as you described it. What should you do?
Basics - Basics - Basics
The more you try to understand the base platform, the more you will understand it's progress, the reason libraries exist, you will judge them better on whether they do a good job or not. Then, "knowing" a new library will be a matter of reading it's docs and saying to your employer "Yeah, it's fine, I have played with it, not super experiemced but i can handle it and will learn it pretty quick". I always learn new libs on the job, never in my free time.
In my free time (and i suggest it for you) read the rfcs. Read http rfc, read html spec, read C, read the js apis, etc, etc
I guess he is an "absolutist" as long as you absolutely agree with his political interests.