HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gumby

65,359 karma · joined June 19, 2010

Currently working on removing excess methane from the atmosphere.

Previous lives:

gnu hacker (e.g. co-founder of Cygnus back in '89) Pharma developer (Talima) Distributed solar thermal systems (Terrajoule) MIT AI Lab/PARC/MCC/Rodin consumer tabletop AR (CastAR) Etc...

remove-everything-up-through-last-dash-gumby@brachiate.org

submissionscomments
gumby··on Valve New Employee Handbook (2012) [pdf]
The reasulting reality of the managerless approach hasn’t been good. As the they say, “if you don’t have any managers you have politics”.

I have several friends who used to work at Valve none of them hate the place, they still have friends there, etc. But they tell similar stories as to why things that normal companies do successfully are impossible at Valve. Perhaps it’s best summed up by something one friend said about her year and a half at Valve: “I first learned who my boss was on the day she fired me.”

Google tried this, notoriously dense grating and then firing basically all the managers at an all-hands. That didn’t work out well at all... And now they have over-steered in the opposite direction!

gumby··on Study explains why laws are written in an incomprehensible style
> Just as "magic spells" use special rhymes and archaic terms to signal their power, the convoluted language of legalese acts to convey a sense of authority, they conclude.

This is definitely the case. I've modified NDAs (from our lawyers or other parties') and have written plenty of business contracts and I find some people are uncomfortable with them unless you wrap them in a "whereas" preamble and put some pointless nonsense like "The parties agree that time is of the essence in this agreement". What a pointless waste of time.

gumby··on No "Hello", No "Quick Call", and No Meetings Without an Agenda
Normally: no agenda, no need to attend. But since our team is currently small, we have a deliberately agendaless meeting every morning. We talk about anything: somebody's daughter got engage, an upcoming vacation, that gnarly engineering problem that never got resolved yesterday. It's an anti-standup, and it's designed to take the place of those transient "water cooler" convos.

It's incredibly valuable, but sure doesn't scale.

gumby··on There aren't that many uses for blockchains (2022)
Yeah, we only need a distributed chain at the edge, and even there there aren’t “competing” changes in the sense there could be in an implementation of a currency. But it’s a block chain like any other Merkel tree.

But it’s to prove chain of custody / lack of tampering since revenue ultimately depends on the data.

gumby··on Ukraine attacks Moscow in one of largest ever drone strikes on Russian capital
Every war zone is a testing/advertising zone for weapons manufacturers. Think of the infamous (and hilarious, if it hadn’t meant loss of life) Exocet ad in Jane’s after the Falklands War.

And NATO’s role in the war is crucial, of course, as a supplier of materiel, but not as deep as the conspiracy theorists like to think. They did not launch this war and do not direct it.

Also, despite my comment being voted down, it’s not a joke that NATO was shocked by how Ukraine has fough, not just how well. Its influence is openly discussed in the US and a European press and can be seen, for example, in the rush to embrace low cost disposable drones.

But it’s more than that: Ukraine has been more nimble and creative than the stogy western militaries who stopped taking Russia’s military that seriously in the early 1990s. Russia has underperformed, but not by a lot. But Ukraine has taken a weak hand and, without a navy, bottled up the Russians in the Black Sea. They demonstrated and used a flexibility far from the capabilities of any of the western militaries at scale. NATO needs not just to embrace that (which will likely take a generation) but also be ready to fight an adversary that has a similar attitude.

gumby··on I'm tired of fixing customers' AI generated code
Yeah, I moved the paragraphs around and pasted the quote in where it belonged, forgetting that it had been pasted at the top. Too late to edit, though.
gumby··on I'm tired of fixing customers' AI generated code
> Helping a customer solve challenges is often super rewarding, but only when I can remove roadblocks for customers who can do most of the work themselves.

One thing I loved about doing technical enterprise sales is that I’d meet people doing something I knew little or nothing about and who didn’t really understand what we offered but had a problem they could explain and our offering could help with.

They’d have deep technical knowledge of their domain and we had the same in ours, and there was just enough shared knowledge at the interface between the two that we could have fun and useful discussions. Lots of mutual respect. I’ve always enjoyed working with smart people even when I don’t really understand what they do.

Of course there were also idiots, but generally they weren’t interested in paying what we charged, so that was OK.

> Helping a customer solve challenges is often super rewarding, but only when I can remove roadblocks for customers who can do most of the work themselves.

So I feel a lot of sympathy for the author — that would be terribly soul sucking.

I guess generative grammars have increased the number of “I have a great idea for a technical business, I just need a technical co founder” who think that an idea is 90% of it and have no idea what technical work actually is.

gumby··on MIT leaders describe the experience of not renewing Elsevier contract
Unfortunately apple autocorrect doesn't know this and I didn't notice until it was too late to edit.
gumby··on Ukraine attacks Moscow in one of largest ever drone strikes on Russian capital
NATO is learning a lot from the AFU. When Ukraine eventually joins NATO (or even just after the war ends) their veterans will be eagerly sought out so the AF of other states can learn from them!

Note: I am not Ukranian, or even in any way European, though I have lived in western Europe.

gumby··on Eli Lilly's weight loss drug slashes the risk of diabetes in long-term trial
I believe this class of drug also suppress glycogen emission from the liver when exercising or eating.
gumby··on Show HN: A simple and powerful RSS reader for the web
Looks like a nice start!

What I miss is good filtering and search within the feeds. Some readers make "smart folders". But usually the searches are pretty primitive: not searching metadata (like starred or read/unread, in or out of another named search, etc), lacking regular expressions etc). Also no way to apply changes (e.g. read/unread) to multiple selections, etc.

I'll look in from time to time -- might be worth a switch.

gumby··on There aren't that many uses for blockchains (2022)
My company actually does have a use case where a blockchain makes sense, and we are proceeding that with it. Unfortunately we have a buzzword trifecta of "blockchain", "AI", and "cloud" so we are careful about the words we use when we talk about it publicly.

We never utter the work blockchain because if you say "a blockchain" most people hear ** THE blockchain!! ** and either think we're a yet another bunch of scammers or worse, get tremendously excited thinking we're doing web3 or some other scam they want in on. Instead we say "we protect the data using Merkel trees."

We have the other buzzword problem too: we use some machine vision (for some safety matters) and use RNNs to determine some local operating parameters and to crunch data for some lab experiments. Even though we have two former AI research scientists on the team, none of us want to be lumped in with the big langage model folks, since that's not what we do (and the hype is insane).

The blockchain application: we have a shitload of sensors monitoring equipment we'll be deploying all over the world. Our revenue depends on the performance of this equipment. So every sensor is built into a little box that signs and timestamps its data. The data are aggregated by the equipment and streamed up to our servers (cough "the cloud"). Connectivity can be intermittent, so machines can offload data to topologically nearby installations.

It's actually pretty nice to be outside the hype bubbles. We just concentrate on our work instead, and mostly the prospective customers don't understand any of the tech, much less what those buzzwords mean.

gumby··on On Being a Senior Engineer (2012)
> A bit of a cynical take (on Hacker News no less) but after being in the industry for a while, my view is that the best definition of “level” is self-referential: it corresponds to the ability of a person to convince others that they are at that level.

This is of course not just in "the industry" -- for an extreme example there are a lot of elections arund the world in 2024 and almost all of them have at least one candidate trying to convince the hiring team (i.e. the voters) that they are qualified to do a job they've never done before.

gumby··on The Discovery of the Celendrical Date Line
> Interestingly, the date line wasn't always where it is now.

Different empires defined their own prime meridians (and thus implicitly their date line 180 degrees away) from the ~16th-19th century. Eventually in the late 1800s a conference was organized to pick one and since Britain was the center of commercial shipping (with all the concomitant infrastructure like Lloyds, project finance, Admiralty law etc) there was little dissent.

gumby··on MIT leaders describe the experience of not renewing Elsevier contract
However there is also the loss of prestige for Elsevier.

MIT is one the the preeminent universities in the world, perhaps the preeminent one.* The loss of MIT gives permission to other institutions who may be more concerned about reputation to do the same (they don’t want to generate whispers of “did they do this because they are having money troubles?”). It may also cause authors to submit other prestigious journals before elsevier ones.

* really any change in the top 10 ranked schools from year to year are just a kind of browning motion. They are as a group equally prestigious.

gumby··on Switzerland offers cash prize to get munitions out of lakes
Just what can be decteded from the air, in shallow water. But could be a good start.

Unlike me they may have access to some capability to actually do it.

gumby··on Mike Mageek is dead
The fate of journals wax and wane, and for me the apex of el Reg was in the era of Andrew Orlowski and (RIP) Lester Haines (they overlapped). Orlowski knows his computing history and writes really well. Haines wrote not just knowledgeably but with a carefree humour that made you feel like he was smiling with you as you read his work. His loss was a real blow.

I still read it regularly, but some of the spirit has gone. But you never know -- someone new could show up and revive that joi deivivre je ne sais quoi. Haines definitely did that when he joined.

gumby··on Switzerland offers cash prize to get munitions out of lakes
Just doing the analysis for a plausible plan for a robot company would be expensive. My idea is at the "some guy in a pub" level :-).
gumby··on Increasing Retention Without Increasing Study Time [pdf]
20 years ago my kid still had to learn up to 12x20. The 12s are pretty handy for a bunch of reasons, and especially if you live in the USA. Using base 10 for the metric system was a mistake.
gumby··on Increasing Retention Without Increasing Study Time [pdf]
They still teach them in Germany, though I think maybe only up to 10x10 these days.

In the US AFAIK they are called "times tables"; in Germany "one times one" („Einmaleins‟). It's funny what people emphasize for the same thing.

gumby··on Switzerland offers cash prize to get munitions out of lakes
Prize seems rather low. I imagine a waterproof robotic dog with a huge snorkel, a magnetometer, and a big grapple to hoist (not drag) munitions to shore. Different sizes for aircraft bombs and grenades (from a picture in the article -- I wouldn't have thought of that case).

SFR 50K would be a rounding error in developing that.

gumby··on Surgeons Cut a Giant Tumor Out of My Head. Is There a Better Way?
You mean the bonesaw-through-the-chest scene in Reanimator was not accurate?
gumby··on Dasel: Select, put and delete data from JSON, TOML, YAML, XML and CSV
> It sort of raises the question of, could there be 1 universal language to query relational databases, text file storage (json, csv, etc), and anything else.

Sure there could be -- any turing-complete language (which SQL is) can query anything.

But the reason we have different programming languages* is because they have different affordances and make it easy to express certain things at the cost of being less convenient for other things. Thus APL/Prolog/Lisp/C/Python can all coexist.

SQL is great for relational databases, but it's like commuting to work in a tank when it comes to key-value stores.

* and of course because programmers love building tools, and a language is the ultimate tool.

gumby··on Toothpaste Null-Terminator
But the association could just as well be to cinnamon, or spearmint, or blueberry. US toothpaste aisles have little variation, especially when compared to other countries without the mint obsession.

Then again the flavor choices in US potato chips is extremely constrained too. Never seen the notorious "hedgehog flavoured" in the US!

gumby··on Toothpaste Null-Terminator
The idea that a "minty fresh" mouth (or the idea that "mint" implies "fresh" at all) was the product of an ad campaign in the 1930s. It's not some sort of human universal.
gumby··on Zngur: A C++/Rust interop tool
You are arguing a distinction without a difference. If socially one could not muster the will to do something then it will never happen -- it cannot be done.

We certainly could reduce the use of fossil fuels by over 90% in a few months -- global nuclear war would probably work -- but I hope nobody has the will to make that happen. Conversely we could reduce them by that much over a 30 year span, but currently lack the will. So in that case the distinction would make sense.

But few are willing to "replace this working thing for a small gain" (and you can argue about rust but when something works and the downside is a statistical risk demonstrably of low probability* ) it will be hard to find many people willing to invest in it.

Eventually these old programs will be replaced but they won't be replaced with functional equivalents, any more than, say, wired home phones were replaced with fibre optic connections. They will be replaced with something de novo instead.

* nerds like us may say the risk is significant but the level of uproar in security breaches is negligible in practice and the actual incidence of bugs due to things like use-after-free is likewise tiny.

gumby··on How does it feel to test a compiler?
Honestly, mostly they were vanilla misunderstanding of the language being compiled.

Some people would rather blame the compiler than their own code.

Others were shocked that a compiler could have a bug at all. Because most code is not corner cases, this isn’t a bad default assumption, really, but bugs do happen.

gumby··on Why won't some people pay for news? (2022)
> Part of this was Zuckerberg outright lying to everyone about video's impact.

Perhaps I'm missing some important aspect, but what would be the benefit of lying about this? How would serving video that didn't promote engagement help FB at all? Just more storage and bandwidth without increased opportunity to serve an ad -- backwards from how I understand FB's model.

People do say something false for a believed gain all the time. But usually when I hear something false it's a misunderstanding or misspeaking. So based on my (relatively naïve) model of how FB works as a business, "lying" doesn't seem like the right word here.

gumby··on VCs don't care if you're nice, they want founders who take risks
This is a long winded way to say that Black-Scholes applies to startup investments too. Greater volatility has a higher expected value.
gumby··on Reticulum Is Unstoppable Networks for the People
What’s wrong with it? It just means network.
← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →