HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gurkendoktor

3,602 karma · joined August 11, 2011

submissionscomments
gurkendoktor··on Elementary OS is imploding
I have played around with elementary OS for a bit, and even though it was "coding like at work", it was really refreshing to see how much elementary's tiny team has already achieved. At the MegaCorp day job, every new button requires a meeting marathon only to fail in unforeseen ways.

Martinis on a beach and hobby coding are also compatible.

gurkendoktor··on Elementary OS is imploding
elementary is already moving in the right direction by trying to combine flatpak and AppCenter (=payments) -> https://blog.elementary.io/elementary-appcenter-flatpak/

From there it's not a huge jump to allow flatpaks that are closed source and/or not written with GTK, certainly more realistic than with non-sandboxed DEBs.

But as a former elementary user and micro-contributor, I also think that the App Store model has been a disaster for elementary OS. It means that developers who are perfectly capable of fixing the buggy stock apps are incentivized to instead start their own app and (fail to, presumably) get paid for it. Random example from a very prolific developer in the golden age of eOS 5:

https://appcenter.elementary.io/com.github.artemanufrij.play...

Now this app has been abandoned, and instead of taking over this developer's personal app, the next person who wants to write a music player will start another one. And so on.

gurkendoktor··on Apple Event March 8, 2022
I have an iPhone 12 mini, and sometimes when I drag down to enter the search field, it feels like I'm waiting for an HDD to spin up (stuck for a second or two).

It's probably not a hack, but just the towering complexity of all the different software systems developed under tight deadlines.

gurkendoktor··on iMac G4 to M1 conversion process
It's not that connecting speakers is hard with the new iMac (2021, sorry not 2020), but that having anything permanently plugged in will look silly:

https://9to5mac.com/2021/04/20/m1-imac-relocates-the-headpho...

I guess it's only meant for headphones in a pinch, and you are supposed to buy Bluetooth speakers/headphones anyway? But Apple also discontinued the big HomePod that would give the iMac some oomph.

(I often suspect that the new iMac is that primarily meant as cashier machine in clinics, boutiques etc. In that context the design is probably fantastic, but then what is the successor to the iMac G4 line? Maybe everyone just uses laptops for family computers?)

gurkendoktor··on iMac G4 to M1 conversion process
Little room for imagination? The iMacs that came after the G4 are not even height adjustable.

They also didn't just cut down on useless material. Power supplies are still large, but Apple has moved them out of the iMac in 2020.

The recent iMac redesign also makes it extremely awkward to connect external speakers using a cable, but the built-in speakers have received mixed reviews. Even that seems like a step back from the iMac G4.

gurkendoktor··on Ask HN: Why is there no small Android phone?
> presumably the demand isn't really there

I loved the 4" iPhone form factor (5, 5S, 5C, 2016 SE), and was really looking forward to the iPhone 12 mini.

But the reason I like small phones is because I don't use mine all day, and when I do, I want to do it with one hand. The iPhone mini line is too large for that, and costs almost twice as much as the 2020 iPhone SE. I think the mini series is simply a bad deal.

(And that's before I get into my rant about the terrible PWM flicker on OLED iPhones.)

gurkendoktor··on Ask HN: Disillusioned with the direction of society and technology
I guess it refers to this?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics)

gurkendoktor··on Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates
It's hard to prove any of this, but I feel that I see a lot more astroturfing on Twitter than on FB.
gurkendoktor··on KDE: A Nice Tiling Environment and a Surprisingly Awesome DE
Not bad, but right at 9:10 in the video, you have white text on a bright translucent background with terrible contrast (in the widget list). This is not an issue with this particular theme... Building a theme that looks great across the operating system, including common third-party apps, is an endless game of whack-a-mole that requires a dedicated team.

I guess I wish Ubuntu had picked KDE as its replacement DE, I really liked their theme around 20.04, and they put a lot of work in the details (like just getting desktop icons back).

gurkendoktor··on KDE: A Nice Tiling Environment and a Surprisingly Awesome DE
I don't mind the K per se. It's great branding! But the specific apps shown on kde.org are Krita, Kdenlive (needs a pronunciation guide), Kontact (looks painfully asymmetric), Kdevelop, GCompris (needs an explanation, a pronunciation guide, and looks like GNOME branding).

We don't have the same opinion on what looks good and what doesn't. That's fine - but I wish someone from "my side" had tried to build a KDE-based distro. I've found some KDE distros with alternative theming, but nothing that leans towards the elementary/Apple style.

gurkendoktor··on Apple in 2021
> It’s about being more than ….

I would understand that objection if people could only own a single computing device. But us who want the iPad to be a dumb consumption device probably own a proper computer for creation. In fact, having an iPad that is supported by all the big companies (native apps, DRM, ...) makes it easier to use a main operating system that runs none of the SV junk.

From my POV, it is really the opposite. People who want the iPad to be a universal computing device are the problem, because they'd be willing to move to a locked-down platform if only it had Xcode or whatever.

gurkendoktor··on Apple in 2021
> Human beings are more than vessels for SV douches to make billions they don’t need.

If I buy an iPad to read PDFs or books, many of which are free, I am hardly making SV douches more money than when I buy a "Pro" device for productivity.

Ironically, the idea that people shouldn't read or listen (consume), and instead just build build build, also strikes me as a very Silicon Valley idea.

I really don't know what it is about the iPad that makes it the target of this discussion. I have never heard anyone say the same things about e-book readers, or headphones that don't come with a mic for content creation.

gurkendoktor··on KDE: A Nice Tiling Environment and a Surprisingly Awesome DE
I've been meaning to try KDE several times, but I can never get over its look, or the silly names for everything, like "Kontact" and "Kdenlive".

I wish there was a project like elementary OS, which takes the tech of GNOME and applies its own theme, naming etc., but for KDE/Qt. (I know, I know, elementary is doing way more than just that.)

If something like this exists, I'd love to try it out.

gurkendoktor··on Apple in 2021
> I was a pretty staunch opponent of the iPad for a very long time. Tablets were clearly a consumption device

I have no doubt that the iPad is great at the things you list in your post, and I wish I had any skills that would justify buying an Apple Pencil.

However, I don't understand why Apple and we on HN are so focused on making the iPad "more" than a consumption device. What's wrong with consumption?

If I were to buy another iPad, it'd be for reading PDFs (terrible on e-book readers), for listening to podcasts and audiobooks, or to let my children play an educational game sometimes. But Apple keeps investing in productivity features while their Books app seems moribund at times (widget please?), their Podcasts app is an ongoing disaster, and they still don't have a read-only guest mode for children or friends. iPadOS has gotten so "pro" that buying an iPad for grandparents is not the no-brainer it used to be, either.

For all the derision that iPads get for being couch potato devices, I wish they were better at being that.

gurkendoktor··on Thank You, Valve
> Unless you run flatpak...

Well yes, sandboxing should be the goal! Installing Steam from Flathub is a good first step on desktop machines. But as long as games require anti-cheat software at the kernel level, I'll keep a Windows partition around to sandbox the gaming world as a whole.

gurkendoktor··on Thank You, Valve
"...other humans that you don't trust"

I often care about online multiplayer, but only with my friends (who I trust not to cheat). I don't want to install a rootkit for that.

gurkendoktor··on In the end, you're treated like a spy, says MIT scientist
Hard to pick a neutral source about this, how about this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Students_for_Fair_Admissions_v...

> According to his testimony, if an Asian-American applicant with certain characteristics (like scores, GPAs, and extracurricular activities, family background) would result in a 25% statistical likelihood of admission, the same applicant, if white, will have a 36% likelihood of admission.

(And that is with standardized testing in the mix, it stands to reason that the gap will grow with further emphasis on "personality".)

I don't have data to prove that these statistics apply to Chinese-Americans specifically, that's an assumption on my side. Whether this is morally wrong is up for debate, but I thought it was relevant in the context of national competitiveness.

gurkendoktor··on In the end, you're treated like a spy, says MIT scientist
No disagreement about ethics, but:

> This is a basic truth of economics.

Is this basic truth backed up by anything tangible? Ethnic Chinese already face unfair hurdles by the current push against standardized testing. But one more obstacle would suddenly make the US unable to compete? With whom, anyway - the only worthy competitor I can think of is hardly egalitarian.

It seems like dangerously wishful thinking to me that liberal ethics, or just basic fairness, automatically translates into economic strength.

gurkendoktor··on Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
Yet, when people make jokes about dongles it's also misogynist, because sexuality at the workplace makes women feel uneasy.

From a European standpoint, the simpler explanation (in this particular case) is that the US tech scene is incredibly, fascinatingly prude. It feels like even HN users would rather post their DNA and a list of illegal drugs that helped them pass an exam before they'd talk about their sex lives, for better or for worse.

gurkendoktor··on Why does the "chart increasing" emoji show in red?
This is a recent development. When gay marriage was less popular among voters a couple decades ago, "conservative" meant "neoconservatism", which was exactly the same as neoliberalism, but without the LGBT+.

(I hope that I have now successfully offended every political ideology that claims to have centuries of philosophical backing behind it.)

gurkendoktor··on Last Windows 11 update changed all default browser settings to Edge
I doubt it, given that Microsoft now actually owns the Candy Crush IP.
gurkendoktor··on Best practices as code using RuboCop
Going through the Rubocop configuration ordeal is probably a good investment of time if you have a large codebase where every developer has a different style, and you don't want everyone's code to look completely different.

But most of my Ruby projects are tiny tools with a bus factor of 1. I find "rufo" as a minimal formatter quite nice for those (there are VS Code plugins). For the most part it normalizes '' to "" in code that I might have copied from somewhere else, but doesn't go on to lecture me that "if not" must be written as "unless", and all the other things that the Rails community cares about.

gurkendoktor··on Microsoft to Acquire Activision Blizzard
> You don't have to render identically. A 720p phone and a 4k TV are quite different.

Yes, but that's kind of the problem. The 720p phone has a lot of horsepower per pixel, but is crippled by touch controls. The Apple TV is _slower_ on a larger screen, with yet another frustrating input situation because Apple didn't put a gamepad in the package. (They don't even make gamepads! The MFi ones I bought were pure junk.) I can't imagine a more hostile environment to develop AAA games for.

gurkendoktor··on Microsoft to Acquire Activision Blizzard
No matter how much money you throw at the current Apple Arcade, most people will play the game on a 5" touch screen. If you want to target living room gamers with a gamepad, the same game has to work on an Apple TV that struggles to render 3D scenes at 4K (probably until an M2 version comes out?). I think it's just going to be a baseline of games for people/families who have Apple One, like how Solitaire and Minesweeper came with Windows.

If Apple goes all-in on VR, the whole VR market will benefit from greater public acceptance. But at the very best I predict it'll be like the Nintendo Wii: a few games that are extremely popular, and then it gets old.

Which is a shame because I agree that Apple is in a great position to enter the gaming market. Imagine what Nintendo could do with powerful hardware in so many hands! But by the same logic, Apple should have crushed Spotify long ago, given its mile-wide lead with the iTunes Store, and yet the nicest thing I have heard about Apple Music is that it works with other Apple stuff. I honestly don't think Apple's management understands entertainment.

gurkendoktor··on Show HN: Life calendar – use the concept of Memento mori to embrace every week
Thanks, I didn't know kurzgesagt had them on their shop as well. I've ordered mine from the waitbutwhy shop after reading the blog post, which was pretty silly for a piece of paper to be sent to Germany. Oh well.

Then I got stuck filling it out: Is week #1 (the square in the top left corner) the first calendar week of my birth year? Or is it the first week of my life? The latter makes more sense, but then it gets really tedious to translate timestamps for university graduation etc. (OP takes the birthday into account and offers month markers. Good idea.)

The life calendar is now posted next to my desk, still empty half a year later. Once/if I get to filling it out, I should mark this long period of time where I have it but don't use it. Time flies.

gurkendoktor··on Microsoft to Acquire Activision Blizzard
Apple Arcade is for casual games that have to work on all of Apple's form factors (minus the watch, thankfully). I've tried it out twice. It is, with very few exceptions, in a completely different category from PC gaming because most people access it through a touchscreen. It's like comparing a PS5 and a Switch, except that Apple Arcade is not nearly as polished as the Switch.

My impression is also that Apple Arcade is already pushing the limits of how much Apple's management wants to touch gaming.

gurkendoktor··on Hello Mac OS X Tiger
Mh, I don't know. Some of the changes that people complain the most about (from Leopard's 3D dock to Safari 15 tabs) were undone by Apple. And for some changes that haven't been undone, like monochrome icons everywhere, I still mis-click things so often that I doubt it's just nostalgia.

If you'd let people mix and match elements from different eras of macOS, I'm sure you'd see some patterns regardless of when people got into Macs; similar to how people have lots of abstract opinions about architecture, but somehow the tourist buses always stop at the same cozy-looking old towns. Beauty and usability are not entirely subjective.

gurkendoktor··on Hello Mac OS X Tiger
I actually liked Exposé a lot more in Tiger and Leopard than in Snow Leopard, where all windows were resized to a grid, and you lost relative window sizes as a visual cue. Thankfully, there was a hack to get Leopard Exposé in Snow Leopard, by overwriting a binary with one from a beta! https://superuser.com/a/212717

There were hacks for absolutely everything. Simpler times...

gurkendoktor··on Hello Mac OS X Tiger
Thanks! I think I've used that, and a SIMBL bundle for Finder when it became necessary.
gurkendoktor··on Exploring System76's New Rust Based Desktop Environment
Well, what about Vala? Obviously C, Python, and especially JavaScript are infinitely more popular programming languages. Yet the number of developers building GTK apps with any of them seems to be in the same ballpark.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →