HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

h0p3

181 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
h0p3··on Mental Models: The Best Way to Make Intelligent Decisions
I agree with much of your excellent argument. I aim to strengthen it.

It's very expensive to fittingly defend any conceptions of //real// and //knowledge// in my experience. It's hard to put into words, but I take representations (including what may seem as menial as mental models) made explicit to at least sometimes be necessary though insufficient (and not epiphenomenal) for being a good thinking thing like us. I am worried that some circles do not appreciate the anti-codificationist intuitions about virtue (of a practice) that you are speaking about. At the very least, some rails, footholds, rules-of-thumb, and oversimplified models can provide an accelerated ladder for us, and that may continue even for experts in at least some cases. Without denying the radical value of immersive experience in developing tacit knowledge (nor the necessity of fast emotion for slow cognition), I think there's plenty of room to debate about even the value of crutch-models, compressions, explicitly exploring, story-telling, and codifying instrumental reasoning for even the virtuoso (including with other virtuosos).

h0p3··on Google proposed Web Bundles could threaten the Web as we know it
We might not disagree much. IDK. I think there's something right about what you saying, but I seek clarification. I ask for your patience in thinking outloud with me (and my schizoposting); I'm someone who isn't as skilled as you are with computers. Despite my ignorance, I am a person deeply concerned with p2p-ness. I'm delighted to see your argument, and I appreciate your perhaps contrarian perspective here.

Google is evil, and if we need to wrestle about that, I will. I'd like to see your red-team skepticism about their intentions and your attempt to consider how this may be a trojan horse or a false-compromise. Google is famous for making moves that look neutral or even good from many angles that are ultimately centralizing power in the hands of capitalists. With good reason, we should doubt why they are doing this. It does appear that the core intuition (if I understand correctly) in WebBundles //can// be used to improve decentralization of information power, but I suggest we should paranoically imagine how it may be exploitable by Google (that is our duty here).

I have some limited experience and a ton of skin in the game on this one. For several years, my wiki has had some of the properties of a prototype of a WebBundle, including an attempt at enabling cryptographic verification (https://philosopher.life/#Cryptographic%20Verification). My goal is to emit one huge all-inclusive html file with the signature wrapped around it (I sign and push/sync up to every minute). This enables me to distribute my wiki across many networks, even sneakernets, without losing one of the fundamental keys to my voice. I'm a second-class citizen on the internet compared to a large corporation, and I have to be able to effortlessly abandon or accept the losses of rented end-points (I really don't own my domain, access-point, or server...they are merely rented: I do own my private key though). In some sense, I have the opportunity to agnostically treat the methods of distribution as a lame middlemen pipeline (what we always hoped the internet infrastructure would really be). I give up my ability to control how my wiki is distributed in some sense as I enable anyone to pass around the signed wiki as a proxy. I happily lose the ability to check whether or not I want to send my signed wiki to any individual in many cases, and I lack interactive control of a session; it feels like I become a far more passive participant of the web, being incentivized to provide the read-only information valuable to ML and disincentived from relying upon dynamic real-time exchanges. I appreciate being able to prevent people from putting words in my mouth while also enabling users of my wiki to acquire and run the site offline, as they see fit, with maximum privacy and anonymity.

There's the context I have. From what I can tell, from a grassroots p2p practice, the reason that the signature "works" is because a user has maintained an old copy of the wiki or even just the public key that they do trust. They've chosen by hand to trust it's me that signed it. I'm not convinced that Google intends to maximize the automation and decentralization value of that kind of verification. It seems an incidental possibility at best (perhaps there's their quasi plausible deniability in seeking a monopoly).

They aim to be more than merely a very large peer, and I'm begging you to question that more openly with me. This feels like a disruptive feint only seeking decentrality in name. Perhaps their move weakens the powers of many web infrastructures that would otherwise continue to centralize, but I think they will continue to attempt to take over whatever power vacuums arise in that space (I assume they can see how to make money off this far better than I can too). When I see, for example, Dat become a first-class citizen of Chrome and when I see them empower client-side archiving, search, and moderation to users of their infrastructure (while taking Firefox and web standards off the leash), I'll begin to believe they intend to enable a p2p web. For now, I see them building an AMPed blackhole walled-garden where they aim to be the root server of trust and authority on what is salient while allowing the highest paying bidders to have degrees of access or control over our data, minds, and lives.

h0p3··on Show HN: Vigyaa Anonymous – A safe place to write and read anonymously
That seems to be more about intention, and I'll agree that even style can be intentionally selected, my dude. Perhaps there are larger leftover pieces, gaps, or other footholds to consider here. I'll agree you might not even need a machine, but I am concerned about unjustifiable ML-empowered humans sifting even more effectively for justified dissidence through style, sentiment, and semantic analysis. Do you think this is an arms race that is won by hand?

I'm not saying I disagree with you. I want to know more about what you think.

h0p3··on Moving from YouTube to PeerTube
I agree that GPT-3 is impressive (https://philosopher.life/#Aispondence).

You might agree: "thought and discussion termination isn’t cool," right? I hope you aim to live up to your own principles. Maybe you meant to say something else to the human being on the other end of the line.

h0p3··on Moving from YouTube to PeerTube
Oh, some people say I'm an insatiable monster. I appreciate that you have taken the time to reply. If you are really here for a discussion, I'll have one. I do care about what you say and don't say (and I'll prove it to you). I do ask quite a bit of those in power (https://philosopher.life/#Power).
h0p3··on Ask HN: Parents, what are you doing for school this fall?
Hello Manisha, that is very kind of you, and I admire your work. I will agree I am the most motivated and accountable person in their lives.
h0p3··on Ask HN: Parents, what are you doing for school this fall?
Among other things, trying to teach my offspring reminds me of how profoundly unqualified I am to be a father. It feels like I've thrown everything plus the kitchen sink at the wall to see what sticks. I do not claim to do a good job. They've maintained wikis for a while with us, and that has been something I hold in high regard. Feel free to HMU, https://philosopher.life/, if you want to talk.
h0p3··on Ask HN: What’s your daily/weekly routine?
https://philosopher.life/#.tmpl:.tmpl%20.tdl%20.plan

Mostly insanity, chaos, and absurdity though.

h0p3··on Ask HN: What do you think will be “the next big thing”?
Before I respond any further, I'd like to offer you the chance to speak with me more privately. HMU, https://philosopher.life.
h0p3··on Ask HN: What do you think will be “the next big thing”?
I appreciate your willingness to reason carefully about this problem. I may not understand your point, so please walk me through it, if you have the time and energy to teach a young man. At the very least, would you agree it is possible to have a context where anyone can say what they want (perhaps something we all infrastructurally support and protect) while also having other contexts in which each user controls who their moderators and search/feed signalers will be? Isn't it worthwhile to work for both?
h0p3··on Ask HN: Hour of reading articles in HN vs. 1 hour of reading books?
I cannot speak to your context well enough. If I only get to choose one, I choose HN (or even carefully curated Plebbit). While there are radical dark patterns in the attention economy with which to concern ourselves (and I'm happy to talk shit about the nature and states of discourse available to people), there are also many salient voices to hear within a recent and brief timeframe that aren't usually as easy to find elsewhere (at least not with as much signal-to-noise ratio).
h0p3··on The FBI is secretly using Sabre as a global travel surveillance tool
That is a very charitable reply. Thank you. Even in possible disagreement, I admire why we might disagree.

If you ever drive south a few hours, and would be up for meeting for dinner, coffee, a beer, whatever, let me know. It would be my honor to meet you offline too.

I would like to know your dreams, your wild speculations, and your gut feelings about what the post-scarcity world should look like and how it might come to be.

h0p3··on The FBI is secretly using Sabre as a global travel surveillance tool
It was my honor to read your argument. Thank you. Please feel free to not respond.

I suggest the only justified criterion of authority and rule of law emerges from a high-performance liquid democracy built on infrastructures owned by the people. Those in power have little egoistic reason to enable that thing to evolve. Spontaneous mass cooperation that radically leverages webs of epistemic trust toward maximizing the utility of the those at the bottom appears to be our only hope; I do not predict it.

h0p3··on OpenAI's GPT-3 may be the biggest thing since Bitcoin
No pressure: feel free to ignore me, please. Would you mind elaborating? I'm interested in what you have to say (and, of course, feel free to say it privately if you prefer). I would like to even hear your dreams, wild speculations, or gut feelings about the matter.
h0p3··on Why You Need a Community: Opportunity Exposure and the Internet Echo Chamber
Maybe I have misunderstood your claim here. If you ever change your mind, it would be my honor to get to know you.
h0p3··on US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China
Hello. I am h0p3. I would love to hear more. I can prove I'm not a spook (though I am a crazy person). HMU if you ever need a friend to speak with.
h0p3··on Do not remain nameless to yourself (1966)
I like to write letters with people. HMU.
h0p3··on Microsoft: Rust Is the Industry’s ‘Best Chance’ at Safe Systems Programming
If you ever need a penpal, hit me up.
h0p3··on The May jobs report had “misclassification error,” underreported by 3 points
I appreciate the way you think. If you are ever interested in having a penpal, hit me up.
h0p3··on Ask HN: What is your personal knowledge management system?
I use Tiddlywiki. https://philosopher.life/
h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
Aww, thank you. I spend a lot of time inside it, so I'm glad to have something I enjoy looking at. I hope to be meticulous.
h0p3··on Ask HN: What is the cheapest way to make a website?
I think it's fair to call it a personal site and a public self-model, though I cannot say it merits popularity. Unfortunately, I don't have a short and clean answer for what it is about (though I spend significant energy trying to answer that question). It's a place to think, a conduit to communicate with myself and others, and it's where I do philosophy. Each member of my immediate family writes in a wiki every day. We autonomously tell the stories of our lives with these devices. Some kinds of relationships and conversations require 10,000 hours, and we aim to make art of our lives together. It is my honor to speak with others through my wiki.
h0p3··on Ask HN: What is the cheapest way to make a website?
Github + Tiddlywiki. That's what I do for https://philosopher.life/. It's free (unless you rent a domain name), flexible, and easy to distribute over many kinds of channels.
h0p3··on Stop Taking Regular Notes; Use a Zettelkasten Instead
Related, https://philosopher.life/ and https://sphygm.us/ may be worth checking out too.
h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
That is an excellent concern. I've not generated my initial analysis of the concept of rhetoric yet, but it is a common topic in the wiki (it's a word I have wielded hundreds of times in it so far). I have a lot to say about it, but I don't want to flood you. So, I'll hedged-conservatively ack in our dialectic here. I suggest that whatever is normatively valuable about rhetoric can be analyzed in terms of rightness or beauty. When rhetoric is used wisely, it is a justified beautiful hack in expression.
h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
Thank you, that is very high praise. I've worked hard on it, and I'm glad it's useful. If you ever get the chance, I would like to see what you build. I think wikis are a great opportunity to share ourselves represented in hypertext with others. You should check out https://sphygm.us/.

I suppose this is neither here nor there, but for the giggles, I've been trying to reach out to the cast of Stranger Things (they aren't easy to reach) to see if they would make wikis too; I'd like to get to know them (or their characters) through their own self-modeling.

h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
Blog is perhaps too weak a term; it is far more than that. I'm sorry that it's not intuitive or polished. It really isn't everyone's cup of tea. In a way, it is difficult to navigate because it's huge (much larger than most people would predict). There are currently +12,000 different pages inside the html file. Even the questions of what I think is Good, what is good in the wiki, and what it is good for, are core problems I wrestle with quite a bit inside it. I suggest that if it were to be useful to you, it would be in virtue of your patience and curiosity. I'm not trying to be obscure here, and it's not a mere game. I just don't know how to say it any better. I recommend wandering the entrance.
h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
That's very kind of you. Thank you. I appreciate when people reach out to let me know. I've been trying to do the same for others lately. Feel free to HMU too; it's always my honor to speak with people over my wiki.
h0p3··on Ask HN: How Do You Blog?
I don't know if my situation fits yours. I'm a crazy person.

My wiki (https://philosopher.life) started out as a non-linear letter. That seed grew into a vine and then a garden. I write every day, even when I don't want to. I talk to myself and those who matter to me (even those I've not yet met or never will). I write because the stories we tell and retell ourselves and others are objectively valuable. I consider it my moral obligation and vocation to read, think, and write.

h0p3··on GPT-3: Language Models Are Few-Shot Learners
If you ever want a random friend to penpal with (or VC or whatever), HMU. Seriously. I would be lucky to hear your thoughts.
← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →